WBAUnofficial
Tonight - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: Tonight (/showthread.php?tid=21583)

Pages: 1 2 3


Tonight - Cuzer - 09-24-2021

Well, what to make of that? 

I thought pre game the selection was wrong, shame we saw Townsend at CH again and what had Grant done to get the nod over Robinson? 

Shocking start and QPR set up with 1 striker, 2 behind and happy to go direct and squeeze the pitch, obviously learning from our last 3 opponents so to give a side with that mentality a goal head start was always going to be difficult to claw back

First half wasn’t great, we huffed and puffed but the general lack of quality in key areas was hurting us, Reach should have scored, Grady went close but the first half was ended with audible boos

2nd half you expected is to come out al, guns blazing, we didn’t really but we’re still in the ascendancy, we played a higher risk of football, Townsend joined in the attacks more, overloading down the left, Mowatt entered beast mode and covered every blade of grass and was driving forward joining the attacks. The Subs? Grady was very unfortunate to be hooked, Grant was having a shocker

The equaliser was very fortunate but as expected it galvanized us, QPR defended even more and the winning goal was a great move, finished off by the hapless Grant who went from villan to hero in the space of fifteen second half minutes 

Mark’s

SJ 6 In no mans land for goal me his ‘sweeper keeper’ work clearly needs work, so many balls running through for him to pick up and he comes out of his area and boots it into touch

Furlong 6 Again getting in threatening positions but final ball lacking the quality needed

Reach 6 Better 2nd half but lacks pace to go past his man and crossing not been as good as it can be, sooner Townsend back there the better

Semi 4 Shocker, his touch and passing has become terrible, he’s like a rabbit in the headlights currently, lacking confidence 

Bartley 5 Had a mad spell on the first half when the groans from the crowd seemed to get to him and he was panicking, couldn’t clear his lines etc. Did improve 2nd half

Townsend 6 Got forward we’ll 2nd half, found wanting in the air 1st half and is always targeted by the opposition as long as he plays this position 

Livermore 6 Usual energy, drive and commitment with little quality on the ball unfortunately 

Mowatt 7* Inspired 2nd half, seemed to have more energy than anybody on the pitch, exactly what we need from him

Grady 6 Lively again for me and unlucky to be hooked, some good half chances he has to improve on but signs he’s getting close to really firing

Phillips 5 Sloppy, wayward passes and didn’t link play as well as required, hooked and rightly so

Grant 6 Papering over the Grand Canyon with the late winner, was piss poor for 75 minutes but let’s hope this boosts his confidence and he can kick on now

Subs

Hugill 6 As he always seems to be full of effort, endeavor and commitment, works tirelessly and puts himself about, should be used as an impact player in matches like this IMO

Robbo 7 Hiws he not starting? Plays slightly deeper, finds space, creates, carries a goal threat, works his socks off? One for Big Val

Bryan 6 Nice little cameo to see the game out 

We’re not patient as fans but we have to try to be, we will improve, hopefully in January we’ll get a proper number 9 in, an improvement on Hugill and Ken, maybe a bit more quality in midfield and with Clarke to return and the players getting better under Vals methods the football will hopefully improve and the chances were creating we will stick in the net

Cuzer


RE: Tonight - richbaggie - 09-25-2021

Good summary Cuz. Think the mark for Conor is harsh, I thought he was excellent, especially 2nd half. He was my man of match. I liked the cameo of Bryan too. Looked confident, organised and assured.


RE: Tonight - boingingjim - 09-25-2021

Fair assesment as always, though Livermore I thought was fantastic. It's his press that wins the ball for the winner and he was also way more box to box tonight. Was my MOM (he always seems to play well against QPR for some reason).


RE: Tonight - ElbowGrease1973 - 09-25-2021

A little harsh on Semi IMO. He had a poor spell in the first half, but improved and brought the ball out well to start some of our attacks.

Totally agree with regards to Robinson. He should be starting.

I thought we tried to play a bit more football last night, and it wasn't just kick and hope. The winner was very well worked. Hopefully we can build on this and move away from the kick and hope tactics.


RE: Tonight - Shabby Russian - 09-25-2021

Normally I think you are usually on the money, but not with these comments, generally far too negative, and the Ajayi mark is a nonsense.

Defensively we were, apart from the goal , solid. Very little of the game was played in our defensive third, even though QPR were prepared to play long. Our defence were able to stop their attacks before they became dangerous. And in the first half he found either Furlong and Diangana in really good positions, with passes played on behind their wing back, who had a difficult first half.


RE: Tonight - Everything Zin - 09-25-2021

Just watched it some 8 hours after the match not knowing the score. Think your marks on the defence are too low as after the first minute we never looked like conceding and all 3 at the back looked totally in control. Little sign of the hoofball we’ve sometimes been guilty of, but little cutting edge in the first half. Also our set pieces seemed less effective than usual.
2nd half much better tempo and a deserved win.


RE: Tonight - Lurker#3 - 09-25-2021

I kept away from here last night after the first 15 as frankly I was embarrassed about what I was reading by and large from swathes of our fanbase.

I respectfully disagree largely with your marks and assessment bud. I thought we had obviously changed the way we were set up in posession and noticeably pressed less really high up the pitch to try and encourage them to play on to us. We were trying to show more composure, but afterb3 months of having it beat into them to press and play at pace this is going to be tough to switch to.

First half we dominated, we had 2 really good chances and and again 1 or2 really good aattacking situations we couldn't quite capitalise on.

Second half we stepped it up even more after a really slow first 15, which it seemed our tactical changes at HT took a while to settle in.

Over all, as most other games this year we had more chances, better attacking possession, more threat and thankfully we got the goals to see the game through.

Ratings:

SJ - 5 - had bugger all to do, but made a right cock up ffor their goal.

Ajayi - 7 - Tought he played much better, came out of defence a few times and plays come cute passes over the top for furlong. Much more promising.
Bartley - 6 - Defends fantastically, but frantic in posessikn and some sloppy headers.
Townsend - 6 - 5 first , half 7 second. Got done in behind for their goal and was really sloppy both in and out of posession. Second half, everything good came through him and Reach.

Furlong - 7.5 - Never stopped, defended fantastically and gave us a constant outlet. Deluvery was better to. Back to his better form.
Livermore - 7 - Grafted, tackled, chased, led by example, gets an honorary assist for the press which led to our winner. But blimey
Mowatt - 8 - MOTM - Superb, done the lot. Much more akin to the first games.
Reach - 7 - as furlong, never stopped, has quality in delivery and passing. Seems to be settling in. Could turn out to be a decent player for us.

Diangana - 7 - looked really threatening, was going past people but looks so short on confidence when it comes to the end product. Was wishing for the long effort to fly in for him. Surprised he was pulled, but it turned out to be the right decision.
Phillips - 4 - Might as well have been sat in our caravan next to windermere with me and the missus . From the first minute it just didn't happen for him.
Grant - 8 - Must have run a marathon, makes very clever runs outs himself into the right positions just needs to affect the game like he did last night. Reminds me of Jesus for City, no real standout attributes, but seems to be involved in alot of our good stuff.

Subs:

Hugill - 7 - Made us better... held it up, bullied their defenders and aged a vital role in the winner.
Robinson - 6.5 - Busy, got between the lines and played a good pass for the goal. But bottled so many 50/50s, didn't threaten the spaces behind enough and was sloppy at times.
Bryan - Not on long enough, but a couple of good clearances when we were under pressure.

Val - 8 - I was delighted to see us play more passes, even though it didn't always come off, made decisive changes, although I didnt agree with taking Grady off as the time it was justified in the end with Hugill Robbo and Grant all involved in the win. In these circumstances you have to give the coach the credit.

If we can sort our passing from deep, and become as efficient as we are playing 'vertical football', we will be the complete team and nearly impossible to play at this level.


RE: Tonight - 11amstart - 09-25-2021

We played poorly for the entire first half, but improved slightly after, especially with the introduction of the lads from the bench, but we still looked far from champions on that performance (or our last three games). However, we still won! Isn’t that the sign of a good team?


RE: Tonight - Wotty - 09-25-2021

(09-25-2021, 08:21 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote: I kept away from here last night after the first 15 as frankly  I was embarrassed about what I was reading by and large from swathes of our fanbase.

I respectfully disagree largely with your marks and assessment bud. I thought we had obviously changed the way we were set up in posession and noticeably pressed less really high up the pitch to try and encourage them to play on to us. We were trying to show more composure, but afterb3 months of having it beat into them to press and play at pace this is going to be tough to switch to.

First half we dominated, we had 2 really good chances and and again 1 or2  really good aattacking situations we couldn't quite capitalise on.

Second half we stepped it up even more after a really slow  first 15, which it seemed our tactical changes at HT took a while to settle in.

Over all, as most other games this year  we had more chances, better attacking possession, more threat and thankfully we got the goals to see the game through.

Ratings:

SJ - 5 - had bugger all to do, but made a right cock up ffor their goal.

Ajayi - 7 - Tought he played much better, came out of defence a few times and plays come cute passes over the top for furlong. Much more promising.
Bartley - 6 - Defends fantastically, but frantic in posessikn and some sloppy headers.
Townsend - 6 - 5 first , half 7 second. Got done in behind for their goal and was really sloppy both in and out of posession. Second half, everything good came through him and Reach.

Furlong - 7.5 - Never stopped, defended fantastically and gave us a constant outlet. Deluvery was better to. Back to his better form.
Livermore - 7 - Grafted, tackled, chased, led by example, gets an honorary assist for the press which led to our winner. But blimey
Mowatt - 8 - MOTM - Superb, done the lot. Much more akin to the first games.
Reach - 7 - as furlong, never stopped, has quality in delivery and passing. Seems to be settling in. Could turn out to be a decent player for us.

Diangana - 7 - looked really threatening, was going past people but looks so short on confidence when it comes to the end product. Was wishing for the long effort to fly in for him. Surprised he was pulled, but it turned out to be the right decision.
Phillips - 4 - Might as well have been sat in our caravan next to windermere with me and the missus . From the first minute it just didn't happen for him.
Grant - 8 - Must have run a marathon, makes very clever runs  outs himself into the right positions  just needs to affect the game like he did last night. Reminds me of Jesus for City, no real standout attributes, but seems to be involved in alot of our good stuff.

Subs:

Hugill - 7 - Made us better... held it up, bullied their defenders and aged a vital role in the winner.
Robinson - 6.5 - Busy, got between the lines and played a good pass for the goal. But bottled so many 50/50s, didn't threaten the spaces behind enough and was sloppy at times.
Bryan - Not on long enough, but a couple of good clearances when we were under pressure.

Val - 8 - I was delighted to see us play more passes, even though it didn't always come off, made decisive changes, although I didnt agree with taking Grady off as the time it was justified in the end with Hugill  Robbo and Grant all involved in the win. In these circumstances you have to give the coach the credit.

If we can sort our passing from deep, and become as efficient as we are playing 'vertical football', we will be the complete team and nearly impossible to play at this level.

Made me smile. You said you were embarrassed by some of the comments and then score Grant an 8 and Sam a 5 ?

Sam was caught out of position by another Bartley error. He is told to position himself there.
He never got chance to set himself properly for the one on one. Not his fault. I agree his kicking wasn’t as good but he ay to blame for the goal.

I think Grant is a good lad and his attitude is spot on it seems. But . . .


RE: Tonight - Cuzer - 09-25-2021

Interesting feedback as always and the beauty of football, we all see it differently

Few comments from me

Firstly re Townsend, thought he had a great 2nd half and we can clearly see he’s at his best getting forward and joining the attack, not playing bloody centre half, he really struggled first half for me though, was losing way too many headers as he was targeted by the opposition, as is the way, hopefully with Clarke close and Bryan up to speed as harsh as it may seem on Reach he has to go back to LWB

Watched 2nd half when On catch up after the golf last night and Livermore was excellent 2nd half, really high up the pitch so maybe more of a 7 than a 6

Semi, Can’t agree with the comments really, he’s kicked half a dozen balls into touch under no pressure, he’s brought he ball out and passed to QPR players when trying to build attacks, not sure what’s happened to his confidence he’s just become extremely panicky when in possession
Defensively he did fine, his pace as always helping our high line, Bartley as I said was fine, barring that mad 5 period in the first half when he made about 4 errors in the space of as many minutes

Most important thing of course is the result, and we got that

Cuzer