![]() |
|
Karlan Grant - Printable Version +- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk) +-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3) +--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4) +--- Thread: Karlan Grant (/showthread.php?tid=21457) |
Karlan Grant - petty sniper - 09-20-2021 I really think that Grant gets judged by our fans on what we paid for him and a general concensus that hes crap because we think he is crap. So far this season I think he has been good apart from maybe the millwall game and first half against Derby when he was hooked. When he came on yesterday he created 2 great chances, one for hugil and then a cross that ajay didnt quite reach. He is the one that comes deep and moves the ball positivly through midfield. Yet when folks on here give ratings for saturday he is panned. And our fans at the game on saturday were shocking. Some no marks next to me spent the game slagging off most of the players, the manager and the tactics to the point where I was sick of it and questioning my attendance. We are 2 points off top, anyone can see that the manager and tactics are evolving game by game, we may be a stiker short but in no way is that the fault of the manager or the players, or even anyone in the country. The fault lies with someone who aint really that bothered that we are bothered so moaning about it achieves nowt. RE: Karlan Grant - Cheshire East Baggie - 09-20-2021 I'm always amazed how dogmatic fans and posters on here can be, how black and white they see things. Most players do a good enough job, it's small percentage differences in ability, application, attitude etc that mark out the match winners. Whilst goalies and defenders can lose games with bad errors, it's not generally unforced errors that determine results. Unless it's a Bilic/Allardyce Albion side, of course. Going back many years, Paul Groves never scored higher than 2/10 in the old Baggies newspaper. He was underwhelming, but not 4 points short of everyone else. RE: Karlan Grant - Sliced - 09-20-2021 (09-20-2021, 09:26 AM)petty sniper Wrote: I really think that Grant gets judged by our fans on what we paid for him and a general concensus that hes crap because we think he is crap. So far this season I think he has been good apart from maybe the millwall game and first half against Derby when he was hooked. When he came on yesterday he created 2 great chances, one for hugil and then a cross that ajay didnt quite reach. He is the one that comes deep and moves the ball positivly through midfield. Yet when folks on here give ratings for saturday he is panned. Absolutely. The fact that most people had a higher rating for Robinson than Grant on the ratings thread highlights the bias RE: Karlan Grant - Birdman1811 - 09-20-2021 I feel for Grant, he gets some horrendous abuse from fans, unnecessarily. He works really, really hard. He didn't have much of a summer holiday this year, he got himself super fit, feeling that was where he struggled last season, that's how he impressed Val so much early on. He can't help his price tag, and overall this season he's done well, but fans want him to fail now, it's sad to see. RE: Karlan Grant - CA Baggie - 09-20-2021 He's clearly got a price tag to live up to, which isn't his fault and it's creates an unfair expectation. That coupled with Bilic misusing him as a central striker last season and the emergence of the alternate option (Toney) doing well has created the initial disappointment and now comparison to beat him with. I don't believe anyone wants him to fail, but I for one think his performances don't warrant Diangana being pushed to the right wing at this point. I think there was an expectation that as we're back in the Championship he'd look the part and be amongst the goals. It hasn't really happened, albeit the all round performances have been better. He wasn't what we needed last season and he isn't really what we need for this one either. CR and Diangana cover the left wing attacking options perfectly well without an expensive 3rd choice. RE: Karlan Grant - Shabby Russian - 09-20-2021 I was hoping that Grant would provide the goals this season, a hope based on the season he had with Huddersfield at this level. It would help if he could play the central role of the front 3. It's a real area of weakness for us. Seeing how Diangana played against Derby , I think he needs to be the first choice left side front player. RE: Karlan Grant - Cuzer - 09-20-2021 I think Grady has shown flashes of what we had come to expect these past few games, I would certainly make sure he's starting on the left of the three for the forseeable future Cuzer RE: Karlan Grant - Baggeridgebaggy - 09-20-2021 I suspect Grant will define a time for the club that could well result in a prolonged spell in the Championship and be part of the clubs demise to mid table or worse The club have a £20m plus commitment and I honestly believe Carlos Edwards would have been a better & more effective substitute on Sat Glimmer of hope was his Blackburn performance, where he did look like a player, but since then back to what we saw last season And I'm not saying he was the only poor performer on Sat- no one did very well He's the most expensive striker in the clubs history (whether fee is paid over one year or 6) and it's a struggle to see what he brings to the table Can't head a ball, doesn't go past anyone easily, not a good crosser, doesn't hold the ball up well We already have one very expensive, faltering left winger (and had Robinson (and Edwards) so why bring him in on a 6 year contract? Currently has very limited resale value & is heading towards the biggest financial mistake in the clubs history (Diangana is trying hard to compete for that title, but at least play him in the position he did so well for us & the reason why we brought him). RE: Karlan Grant - Madness - 09-20-2021 Needs a rocket up his arse. He can be excellent in the Championship and has the ability to be RE: Karlan Grant - Cheshire East Baggie - 09-20-2021 (09-20-2021, 11:52 AM)Baggeridgebaggy Wrote: I suspect Grant will define a time for the club that could well result in a prolonged spell in the Championship and be part of the clubs demise to mid table or worse I think that kind of confirms what PS was saying in the OP. Grant is judged harshly because of his fee. You've expressed dogmatic opinions which are way over the top. Leaves you in a position where he has to continue failing to make you feel good about your opinion. Lose lose situation if you ask me. Not sure why people do this to themselves. |