![]() |
|
Continued debate with B1 - Printable Version +- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk) +-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3) +--- Forum: Politics (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=5) +--- Thread: Continued debate with B1 (/showthread.php?tid=20887) |
Continued debate with B1 - JOK - 08-28-2021 Sorry B1, I couldn’t waste all my research (thanks to some cack handed Mod . Yes there are far worse things Mayo.)Here is my answer to your claim that one of the major benefits of the EU was cheaper food. (Monetary union and EU army I’ll do later, perhaps) Thank you, by the way, for engaging in debate rather than ignoring valid points or resorting to dismissive, obfuscatory and / or personal attack. There are tariffs applied. “It is not a flat rate: instead, there's a fee per kilo and a percentage of the value. And the more it is butchered and processed, the higher the tariff on entering the European Union. Why so high? Because the European Union has acted as a fortress to protect its farmers ...against cheap imports. New Zealand, for instance, produces more efficiently in bigger farm units, with bigger flocks and blessed with better quality pasture.” https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-scotland-55209329 “The EU quietly increased eight tariffs on imported oranges from third party countries from 3.2% to 16.0% – a staggering fivefold increase.” (2016) “the world’s fifth largest producer of citrus fruits, Spain, had taken very badly to the removing of import tariffs on citrus fruits from South Africa.” Processed coffee imports that compete with EU processors attracts tariffs of, up to 11.5%. iea.org.uk/the-eus-thousands-of-senseless-tariffs-punish-the-poor/ “The EU’s external tariffs for agricultural produce are high and lowering these would make a difference. An area of interest would be citrus fruit, grapes and top fruit, with South Africa an obvious trade partner, but also the USA and parts of South America. Some of the highest tariffs are beef and dairy products, for which Australia and New Zealand could be future sources. We don’t anticipate this replacing UK dairy and meat, rather offering an alternative to imports from the EU”. (British Retail Consortium) https://publications.parliament.uk/pa/ld201719/ldselect/ldeucom/129/12908.htm “…tariffs placed on food imports as a result of the Common Agricultural Policy of the EU increases food prices for UK consumers. As part of this, it cited a paper written by Halligan & Lyons for Policy Exchange which calculated that food prices in the UK are approximately 17 per cent more expensive as a result of the common external tariff.” “This figure is corroborated by Dr Kristian Niemietz of the Institute of Economic Affairs who found that food prices inside the EEA were 17 per cent higher than the market price.[2] Furthermore, an examination of the data provided by the World Trade Organisation reveals that there are high tariffs placed on certain food products which are imported from outside of the EEA. These tariffs, combined with farming subsidies, and the EU’s food standard regulations, increase food prices for UK consumers substantially”. [1] Halligan, L., & Lyons, G., Clean Brexit, January 2017. [2] Niemietz, K., Abolish the CAP, let food prices tumble, January 2013. [3] WTO, Tariff Profiles: European Union, http://stat.wto.org/TariffProfiles/E28_e.htm. “The Out campaign blamed the Common Market, which through the Common Agricultural Policy, forced Britain to buy food from other member states and, to give one much quoted example, banned the import of cheap butter from New Zealand. "The price of butter has to be almost doubled by 1978 if we stay in," warned the Out campaign in its leaflet. In fact, the price of butter quadrupled by 1978, although debate continued to rage about whether the Common Market was entirely to blame for that. “Surpluses of food being sold off at knockdown prices by the EEC itself. Subsidies to farmers had produced "butter mountains," "beef mountains" and "wine lakes". The surplus food was, as the Out campaign pointed out, being destroyed or sold off to Russia "at prices well below what the housewife in the Common Market has to pay". (BBC 2016] RE: Continued debate with B1 - Borin' Baggie - 08-28-2021 You've not once mentioned tariff free quotas, as an example specific to New Zealand all it's pertinent at the moment , such as the fact that all NZ lamb is imported into the EU duty free therefore any trade deal on that will have zero benefit. You've also not factored in things like trade agreements with developing nations, particularly in North Africa, that mean all agricultural produce enters with zero duty applied. Food will not get cheaper, it's already amongst the cheapest in the world as a percentage of income and that's while we were members. RE: Continued debate with B1 - JOK - 08-30-2021 There is a limit to Tariff free imports from New Zealand and Australia. The volume of lamb imports into the EU prior to Brexit, available within the tariff-free quota, was 228,254 tonnes, 19,000 tonnes respectively. Any lamb imports outside that quota or from countries not covered by it, are subject to ad valorem tariffs of 12.8%, plus a fixed amount ranging from €902 to €3118 per tonne, depending on the cut. In many cases, this would be equivalent to an ad valorem tariff of 50 per cent or more, which seriously impacts on the ability of imported sheep meat to compete with EU meat. The cost relevant to our standard of living compared to 196 independent states is irrelevant, I think, to the argument of whether we ‘enjoyed’ cheap food as a result of our membership of the EU. Edit: I've just noticed I did mention 'tariff free' imports on meat. "There are tariffs applied. “It is not a flat rate: instead, there's a fee per kilo and a percentage of the value. And the more it is butchered and processed, the higher the tariff on entering the European Union." RE: Continued debate with B1 - Borin' Baggie - 08-30-2021 When was the last time the limit for NZ lamb exceeded the quota? Last I checked, all NZ lamb imported to the EU was tariff-free, so any of the additional levys that you talk about are completely irrelevant. So NZ lamb won't get cheaper. And, again, you didn't mention tariff-free imports. You talk about an increased levy on processed meats, so whole cuts of pork are levied (outside of quotas) at a lower rate than sausages. That isn't what I was bringing up. RE: Continued debate with B1 - JOK - 09-01-2021 You are correct, the line didn’t refer to the tariff free quota. I apologise. 2011 was the last time full quotas were used. (According to The British Meat Processing Association) How can the fact that the tariffs exist be irrelevant? The fact there were not enough lifeboats on the Titanic was irrelevant, until they were needed. However, let’s ignore two reports and another source which all suggest being in the CAP keeps food prices artificially high by c17% and just concentrate on one example. Nothing on the quadrupling of the price of butter within a few years of Joining the EEC? Is there No rebuttal on the oranges or processed coffee examples? No comment of the fact that it is only in the last few years that the EU has given any consideration to the struggles of farmers in developing countries? RE: Continued debate with B1 - Borin' Baggie - 09-01-2021 They're irrelevant as they've not applied in a decade, and that's with a country that the EU only has a partnership with and not a FTA. What impact will removing tariffs on NZ lamb have given that they don't apply now? And I don't care about oranges or coffee, do you know why? Because they were only four comparable nations that had a lower cost of living for food worldwide than the UK: Germany, the Netherlands, the US and Canada. Two of those are in the EU, and incidentally the two EU members are lower than the US and Canada. Therefore, food prices aren't going to get meaningfully lower outside the EU's tariff regime (even ignoring our own tariff regime being in line with the EU's) Final point on this, red tape contributes double the price increase on goods (including food) than tariffs. You know, the thing we added a load of onto imports from EU and EFTA nations, the government are so worried by the impact that they've kicked the can on a lot of it but we can't do that indefinitely without the WTO kicking up a stink. |