WBAUnofficial
President has Afgone ... - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: President has Afgone ... (/showthread.php?tid=20539)

Pages: 1 2


President has Afgone ... - Lurker#3 - 08-15-2021

Not looking good for the Afghans sadly.


RE: President has Afgone ... - TETLEY74 - 08-15-2021

All to predicable i'm afraid. Get our people out and let them get on with it. If the many factions there  are backward and mad  enough to want to slaughter thousands of their own citizens just because they dont happen to belong to this or that ideology let them get on with it ,otherwise if we move in again to stop it we will be there for evermore with no way out without it descending into chaos again, sad, selfish and cruel i know but can't see any other way unfortunately.


RE: President has Afgone ... - Lurker#3 - 08-15-2021

The only suitable solution however is mass migration like from Syria.

We have stuck our noses in, and we should be there to follow through on the promise of freedom to those sections of the Afghani population who were craving it.


RE: President has Afgone ... - Borin' Baggie - 08-15-2021

Really do worry for those who supported western forces and the government.


RE: President has Afgone ... - SW4Baggie - 08-15-2021

(08-15-2021, 03:28 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: Really do worry for those who supported western forces and the government.

 Completely. These people helped make things safe for our citizens and supported them whilst they were out there and now we are completely abandoning them to a barbaric group of ideological nut jobs.


RE: President has Afgone ... - Ministry Of Silly Signings - 08-15-2021

Parallels with Vietnam are readily apparent. Don't, at least yet, think we will see helicopters landing on roofs etc, you would like to think lessons were learnt, the Taliban seem to think it's best to let the airport operate, get westerners etc out. God knows what will happen to those left behind.
Afghanistan is, and always will be corrupt, the 200, 000 man army probably had half that number, the others were 'ghosts', made up so officials could take their pay, another echo of Vietnam. A situation where America and the west didn't learn.
A western democracy probably should never get involved in these countries as public opinion will not tolerate years of casualties etc.


RE: President has Afgone ... - Tom Joad - 08-15-2021

(08-15-2021, 03:49 PM)Ministry Of Silly Signings Wrote: Parallels with Vietnam are readily apparent. Don't, at least yet, think we will see helicopters landing on roofs etc, you would like to think lessons were learnt, the Taliban seem to think it's best to let the airport operate, get westerners etc out. God knows what will happen to those left behind.
Afghanistan is, and always will be corrupt, the 200, 000 man army probably had half that number, the others were 'ghosts', made up so officials could take their pay, another echo of Vietnam. A situation where America and the west didn't learn.
A western democracy probably should never get involved  in these countries  as public opinion will not tolerate years of casualties etc.

True. But with  regards to the last paragraph,  the peoples of these countries also will not tolerate years of being occupied. The damage was done years ago, it is now a total no win. The UN needs to pull it's weight here.


RE: President has Afgone ... - Kit Kat Chunky - 08-15-2021

Didn't the West first get involved due to the Soviet threat decades ago?


RE: President has Afgone ... - HugeHons - 08-15-2021

Many of the Taliban would have been young children or not even born when they were overthrown 20 years ago. Freedom has no chance there.


RE: President has Afgone ... - Derek Hardballs - 08-15-2021

We have a responsibility to those who helped our armed forces and political leaders, not to mention the women and children who will now have their freedom taken away from them. We have already cancelled scholarships for bright young people who had been offered places at our universities.

The Times report today said that the government are concerned that it won’t play well with their supporters if we offer those aforementioned safety in the U.K. Sadly that’s where we are now as a country.

We should never have gone to Afghanistan in the first place, it was a war we could never win, unless we stayed for decades but as we did, we have a responsibility to those who helped us and embraced democracy, which was part of the reason we were there.