![]() |
|
S4A - update - Printable Version +- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk) +-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3) +--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4) +--- Thread: S4A - update (/showthread.php?tid=20035) |
S4A - update - RonnieWallwork - 07-31-2021 Fellow Albion fans. S4A members happy for me to share this with the wider fan base. Again, nothing more, nothing less. We’re all Albion! Dear Member We wanted to provide you with an initial update on last night's meeting: We are very grateful to you all for your support. Both at the meeting and your email messages over the last few weeks. We counted over 60 shareholders attending last night and judging by your messages, we would have comfortably passed 100, were it not for the holiday season and other prior commitments that many of you had. We confirm that both of the resolutions as stated in the notice of meeting you will all have received (i.e. to commission the full and independent investigation needed regarding the loan and to take all steps to seek re-payment of the loan) were defeated, as Holdings voted against them with their 87.8% shareholding. This came as a disappointment but not as a surprise to us. Quite why they refuse to consider this, remains a mystery! Ken did confirm, however, that the directors of Club and Group would be taking steps to pay off loan by the end of 2021. Unfortunately, this will be after a dividend has been declared to all shareholders (i.e. money leaving the Club first to re-pay an overdue loan debt due to it). Those present made it clear that this was not a welcome course of action and strong feelings were expressed. Unfortunately, if the Club can satisfy the legal pre-requisites for declaring a dividend in due course, there is not anything we can do to stop this. To avoid repetition, please see the attached press statement for further details. Ken also confirmed that the directors of Club and Group would be prepared to carry out the partial review (which we had already rejected). The partial review proposed was not accepted by the shareholders present. Leigh firmly demonstrated why this is practically and legally flawed. If we agreed to this, it would not take us any further forward. It would also effectively take away legal avenues which we are still able to exercise, if we need to. We will continue to work with Ken to convince him that the meaningful and independent investigation is carried out. It is important and very pleasing to confirm that Ken allowed a full and free discussion regarding the issues and was very open with those present. He received a round of applause for this from the shareholders at the end at the end and then spent time chatting informally to shareholders. We also know how well this was received from speaking to many of you afterwards. In spite of the outcomes, we do feel that progress is being made on a number of fronts, including the further improvement of the relationship between Ken and the shareholders and supporters. This is for the benefit of Albion, which is what we all want. As mentioned in a previous statement, the Committee now needs to meet to review before we can provide more comment on the above matters and further detail on matters discussed at the meeting (for those not present), for legal reasons. There may be a delay in meeting due to various prior commitments. Thank you for your patience there. David made the following address at the end of last night's meeting: The result of tonight’s ballot is disappointing but hardly surprising, due to the previous resistance from the club on this matter over the last few years. It is clear the majority shareholder has no appetite to commission a thorough investigation into events involving the loan of the football club's money to the previous owner of WBA Holdings. Why continues to remain a mystery, on many levels. A cause for concern even. We have clearly demonstrated why an investigation is required and the strength of feeling amongst shareholders and the club’s loyal supporters is evident. I do thank Ken for allowing a free and open discussion on the matters, This is in stark contrast to what has gone before. We may not have achieved all of our objectives this evening, but S4A will continue the fight to protect the interests of minority shareholders, investors in WBA group and our great football club. We are not going away. Given last night's outcomes and due to press interest and contact since, we felt it important that we make a statement to the press as soon as possible. We are also concerned that some supporters will have the misconceived perception that this is all about us receiving a dividend. Each shareholder to their own views, but we suggest that the vast majority of shareholders do not wish to receive a dividend! David Baker (Chairman) and Leigh Kent (Vice Chair) Also S4A statement below: Statement We are disappointed with West Bromwich Albion Holdings Limited's ('Holdings') vote against the resolutions proposed at the General Meeting on 29 July 2021. The failure to commission the required full and independent investigation into the matters raised, to establish whether or not there has been any wrongdoing, is perplexing and an ongoing cause for concern. We had clearly demonstrated the overwhelming need for such an investigation. We remain open-minded as to whether or not there has been any wrongdoing. It is noted that the sole director of Holdings, Mr P Y Li, was not present at the meeting. Mr Li had instructed a proxy to vote against the resolutions on his behalf, without considering the contents of last night's meeting. We remain of the view and have demonstrated that the directors of West Bromwich Albion Football Club Limited ('Club') and West Bromwich Albion Group Limited ('Group') are under legal duties to commission the required investigation, irrespective on one shareholder's view. Neither Group nor Club are wholly owned subsidiaries of Holdings. Whilst Xu Ke (Ken) has indicated that the directors of Club and Group will carry out a (partial) review of the matter (essentially, a review of historic club files only), this is practically and legally flawed. In our view, it does not take us any further forward. Ken has indicated that the directors of Club and Group intend to secure re-payment of the loan before the end of 2021, but only after a dividend has been declared to the shareholders of Group (i.e. Holdings and minority shareholders) to provide the funds for Holdings to do this. Whilst it is welcome news that the loan (a long overdue debt due to the Club) is finally to be paid off, the vast majority of our members and Albion supporters will be disappointed that this is being facilitated by way of the prior declaration of a dividend to shareholders of Group. The shareholders present last night made their strong feelings clear. Those present confirmed that: 1. The partial review proposed was not acceptable; and 2. They did not wish to receive a dividend and feel that is wholly inappropriate for Group to declare a dividend at this time, given that football club should be focused on becoming a competitive Premier League club. Many have already confirmed that, if a dividend is declared, they would seek to re-invest the money into the club at the earliest available opportunity. First and foremost: we are loyal and fanatical supporters of Albion. The cost of a full investigation required was also raised as an issue by Ken. Whilst it is not accepted that this should be a material matter of concern, the minority shareholders present (seemingly) unanimously voted by show of hands to facilitate payment of this either by: i. (Given that re-payment of the loan is to be facilitated by dividend from Group (of which Club is the wholly owned subsidiary)) An agreed reduction from the loan amount due from Holdings to Club in lieu i.e. no net cost to the football club in paying for the investigation; or ii. Willing minority shareholders will pay for this using their dividends which they do not seek or want. Again, there would be no net cost to the football club. We are grateful to Ken for holding the meeting at the Hawthorns (rather than London) and allowing a full and free discussion on relevant matters. This is in stark contrast to previous practice and was very well received by all of those present. Our initial preference, of course, is to continue to work with Ken, to try and achieve the investigation required, via agreement. In the absence of agreement, there remain various avenues open to us. Due to legal reasons, we cannot comment further at this time. We will meet as a Committee and consult with our members in due course, before deciding on the next steps. We will continue to do what is necessary to protect the interests of our great club, on behalf of its supporters and shareholders. Finally, we note Jeremy Peace’s comments in The Times article ‘Ex-West Brom owner Peace ‘welcomes’ loan investigation’ on 21 July 2021, with interest. Due to legal reasons, we cannot comment on many of Jeremy Peace's comments at this time. We can confirm that we are not aware of any shareholders who engage in 'grumbling'. We instead act in the best interests of Albion and its supporters and shareholders, at all times. We will continue to do so. It should also be noted that in excess of 200 minority shareholders signed the notices to originally request this meeting and support the resolutions for the required investigation and overdue repayment of the loan, with many other minority shareholders subsequently confirming unequivocal support to us. The vast majority of these being loyal Albion supporters. David Baker (Chairman) and Leigh Kent (Vice Chair) of Shareholders for Albion RE: S4A - update - baggiebloke - 07-31-2021 Cheers Ronnie RE: S4A - update - Derek Hardballs - 07-31-2021 Forgive me for asking but what is all this wrangling hoping to achieve? RE: S4A - update - RonnieWallwork - 07-31-2021 (07-31-2021, 06:27 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Forgive me for asking but what is all this wrangling hoping to achieve? 1million interest (last count) coming to an end! RE: S4A - update - Derek Hardballs - 07-31-2021 (07-31-2021, 06:51 PM)RonnieWallwork Wrote:(07-31-2021, 06:27 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Forgive me for asking but what is all this wrangling hoping to achieve? I think the situation needs a summary for people who haven’t been following the story closely. RE: S4A - update - RonnieWallwork - 07-31-2021 (07-31-2021, 07:00 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:https://www.expressandstar.com/sport/football/west-bromwich-albion/2021/07/30/west-brom-shareholders-to-battle-on-after-bid-for-jeremy-peace-loan-investigation-fails/(07-31-2021, 06:51 PM)RonnieWallwork Wrote:(07-31-2021, 06:27 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Forgive me for asking but what is all this wrangling hoping to achieve? RE: S4A - update - Fulham Fallout - 07-31-2021 As I mentioned earlier. They should have raised the question about a proposed theft of an asset which, as shareholders would have impacted them with the proposed Pereira back hander deal to China. Never mind the loan, worry about unlawful accounting. RE: S4A - update - Kit Kat Chunky - 07-31-2021 (07-31-2021, 06:51 PM)RonnieWallwork Wrote:(07-31-2021, 06:27 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Forgive me for asking but what is all this wrangling hoping to achieve? But who is the interest payable by, and to whom Ron? Its a circular position. This isn't money leaving the club structure to a third party. |