WBAUnofficial
What makes you British - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: Politics (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=5)
+--- Thread: What makes you British (/showthread.php?tid=19735)



What makes you British - Shabby Russian - 07-19-2021

I ask this after reading a news story in the Guardian..might be in other media outlets.

It was about a 44 year old woman who was born in Spain, but who came to this country when she was 11 months old and has never left it. And as never had a UK or Spanish passport. Her employer asked for proof that she was entitled to work in this country, which she couldn't do. Before Brexit she didn't need to . She hadn't thought to apply for the EU citizens right to remain in this country, presumably because she didn't  think she needed to, after living in this country all her life except for the first 11 months.

So i suppose my question why isn't she considered British by the state. She has lived almost her life here, was educated here, worked here , paid tax and ni here. He has no knowledge of living in any other country.

And why does the state seem to go out of its way to find legal loopholes to crush the lives of individuals. We have seen this before with the Windrush saga and the recent deportation of criminals to Jamaica...some of the latter group were very dodgy and smacked more of the desire to fill a plane rather than deport dangerous foreign criminals.


RE: What makes you British - Birdman1811 - 07-19-2021

I'm a proponent of globalised one world myself. Very anti borders and suchlike.

Personally as far as I'm concerned, that person is British, they've spent most of their life here, educated here, worked here. To deport such a person is purely moronic and nation-state crap.

There is no inherent genetic difference that makes a Spanish person a different type of human to someone who was born in Britain.

One race, one planet. Don't get the desire to build walls between everyone and everywhere.


RE: What makes you British - Borin' Baggie - 07-19-2021

The fact that this has happened to her in spite of her finalising the paperwork and submitting it within the deadline is embarrassing.

I have a mate who was born here and lived here all his life but as both of his parents are Italian he's not entitled to citizenship. Thankfully he's got permanent residence but if he wants to apply for citizenship he has to pay a grand, imagine paying a grand to get the citizenship of the country you were born in and lived all your life in.


RE: What makes you British - Protheroe - 07-19-2021

"She had been aware that she might need to apply for EU settled status, having seen government advertisements, but was unsure about how to apply because she had no passport; she has previously sought legal advice from immigration solicitors, but was quoted fees of £2,000 and could not afford it."

So she did nothing.

5.1 million people (just to remind you that's 1.5 million more EU ciitizens than Remainers claimed were in the UK) managed to sort themselves out.

This is an unfortunate personal issue, but given she was obviously aware of her status I'm not sure you can blame anyone else but her for her predicament. The state hasn't sought out loopholes to "crush" her life - the state provided the means to apply and she couldn't be arsed.

(07-19-2021, 10:46 AM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: The fact that this has happened to her in spite of her finalising the paperwork and submitting it within the deadline is embarrassing.


She submitted it on the last day of the deadline. It's hardly surprising she has a wait.


RE: What makes you British - Borin' Baggie - 07-19-2021

(07-19-2021, 10:55 AM)Protheroe Wrote:
(07-19-2021, 10:46 AM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: The fact that this has happened to her in spite of her finalising the paperwork and submitting it within the deadline is embarrassing.


She submitted it on the last day of the deadline. It's hardly surprising she has a wait.

So she submitted before the deadline. If you can't accommodate for people submitting before the deadline you set then that's not their fault.

Also, side note, that 5.1 million people includes everyone entitled no matter their age, working status or whether they even live in the UK currently. That "1.5m" (now that I recall I'm pretty sure it was 2.2m EU citizens in work according to the ONS, not 1.5m) was people in work. Apples and oranges.


RE: What makes you British - Shabby Russian - 07-19-2021

My point is that there are a significant number of people in this country who might assume they are British and citizens of the UK who it turns out, are not.

Her case is an interesting one on paper, because she will have no memory of living anywhere else, but the UK. If she isn't British, what nationality is she?

To be honest I am not specifically interested in her case which I am sure will be resolved satisfactorily, but the more general principles of nationality and citizenship, and how the state interacts with that.


RE: What makes you British - Squid - 07-19-2021

It's very simple.

Most countries either determine citizenship by blood/heritage (jus sanguinis) or place of birth (jus solis). The UK has been the former since the British Nationality Act 1981.

However, I agree that lots of people are shockingly ignorant of the law (the mistaken belief in the concept of common-law wife a common one) and this really should be covered in schools. Wills are another area with high levels of costly ignorance.

Spain also has jus sanguinis, so the woman in the OP is Spanish.