![]() |
|
The Case for the Defence - Printable Version +- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk) +-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3) +--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4) +--- Thread: The Case for the Defence (/showthread.php?tid=17907) Pages:
1
2
|
The Case for the Defence - chasetownbaggie - 05-23-2021 As sad as I am that we're going back down again (despite my expectation we would), I found the season a bit odd in some ways. Particularly in that, though the team as a whole sucked, the individual parts weren't too bad. None more so than in defence... Johnstone - quite rightly pilloried for his lack of command of his box in the Chanpionship, this season he seemed to get over that. Numerous brilliant save adhered to his usual sound kicking, he was my POTS. Furlong - after an average Championship season where he struggled to hold down a first team place, Darnell established himself at RB and got better as the season went by, showing great energy and tenacity and even being a threat in the opposition penalty area. Bartley - composed, great passer and seemed to enjoy wearing the captain's armband. Ajayi - excellent in the air and pace to burn, I thought he looked quality at times Townsend - I thought he'd be found out at this level but so glad to say he proved me wrong. What a revelation, played like a seasoned veteran. In the running for POTS, IMO. O'Shea - still young and the experience will serve him well As pleased as I was with them, I think they all (some more than others) were guilty of making mistakes (arguably losing concentration). Should the defence take responsibility for letting in 70+ goals - or was it a team failure? And if it was the defence, should we replace some of them or is it just coaching? RE: The Case for the Defence - Cuzer - 05-23-2021 I'd say Ajayi was the biggest dissapointment, had high hopes when we came up but at times this season has been extremely error prone, will learn from the experience and if we go back up and he's part of the side that achieves that he will learn from this season in the Prem Cuzer RE: The Case for the Defence - HLS - 05-24-2021 Ajayi seemed to be better earlier in the season than later but was fairly colossal for us last season so no problems him being a starter next. I agree with this post. If we can keep all of them, then we have a good start. Midfield is the key area of strengthening. Minimum of 2 signings. RE: The Case for the Defence - Cheshire East Baggie - 05-24-2021 In a season where we conceded 70 goals, it's complacent to suggest that the defence was OK. Furlong, Townsend and Bartley have improved tremendously under Sam's coaching. These players will be key for next season (failing any ridiculous bids forcing us to cash in). I wonder if O'Shea has been found wanting at Premier level. Surprising Sam overlooked him in the latter stages. Is it his (relative) lack of height or pace? I think he needs to play a full season in one position at some level and see how he develops. Ajayi is a nightmare. Poor positioning, poor concentration, poor judgement. He will concede a goal most matches, also put pressure on his team mates to make them look bad. He's not a young player, I don't expect him to improve. Controversially, I'll suggest that Johnstone hasn't been the complete ticket, his communication is poor and he is hesitant at times when he needs to be decisive and commanding. It may be that a less talented keeper is easier to play in front of. I think we desperately need one good solid centre back to go with Bartley. Unless of course Kipre turns out to be a gem, even though neither Sam nor Slav fancied him at all. RE: The Case for the Defence - GunsOfNavarone - 05-24-2021 (05-24-2021, 07:04 AM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: In a season where we conceded 70 goals, it's complacent to suggest that the defence was OK. Furlong, Townsend and Bartley have improved tremendously under Sam's coaching. These players will be key for next season (failing any ridiculous bids forcing us to cash in). I wonder if O'Shea has been found wanting at Premier level. Surprising Sam overlooked him in the latter stages. Is it his (relative) lack of height or pace? I think he needs to play a full season in one position at some level and see how he develops. Ajayi is a nightmare. Poor positioning, poor concentration, poor judgement. He will concede a goal most matches, also put pressure on his team mates to make them look bad. He's not a young player, I don't expect him to improve. I'm more aligned to this post than the opening one. RE: The Case for the Defence - Loanee - 05-24-2021 Ajayi was fantastic in the championship, Bartley less so. Both have had highs and (many) lows this season. Both will be ok next season RE: The Case for the Defence - Duffers - 05-24-2021 Call me an optimist, but I’m of the view that all of our defenders will come back from their horror experience in the Championship stronger and be better players for it. They have all demonstrated, either with us or at other clubs, that they can be good Championship players. The squad needs work over the summer and realistically we won’t be able to replace everyone, need to forgive and forget this season for a few players. RE: The Case for the Defence - Brentbaggie - 05-24-2021 (05-24-2021, 07:42 AM)Duffers Wrote: Call me an optimist, but I’m of the view that all of our defenders will come back from their horror experience in the Championship stronger and be better players for it. They have all demonstrated, either with us or at other clubs, that they can be good Championship players. Is this you foretelling the future? RE: The Case for the Defence - Duffers - 05-24-2021 (05-24-2021, 08:21 AM)Brentbaggie Wrote:(05-24-2021, 07:42 AM)Duffers Wrote: Call me an optimist, but I’m of the view that all of our defenders will come back from their horror experience in the Championship stronger and be better players for it. They have all demonstrated, either with us or at other clubs, that they can be good Championship players. They’ll all be great in League One. RE: The Case for the Defence - baggy1 - 05-24-2021 (05-23-2021, 11:33 PM)Cuzer Wrote: I'd say Ajayi was the biggest dissapointment, had high hopes when we came up but at times this season has been extremely error prone, will learn from the experience and if we go back up and he's part of the side that achieves that he will learn from this season in the Prem I was going to post something similar, he seems to have gone backwards this year but maybe that can be put down to learning at the sharp end, the prem probably came a year too early for him. He probably needs to look at Bartley alongside him and go back to basics which is what Barts has done before moving onto the next level. |