![]() |
|
Penalties - Printable Version +- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk) +-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3) +--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4) +--- Thread: Penalties (/showthread.php?tid=16112) |
Penalties - chasetownbaggie - 03-15-2021 I'm still stewing over Saturday's result. We all know that in football, you often don't get what you deserved, but it makes it a bit better if you were undone by a piece of quality/excellence. Ok, on Saturday, we didn't deserve to win but neither did we deserve to lose - especially to a penalty awarded for a handball from a nothing cross which was cleared. Which brings me onto my pet hate - penalties. I've said it on here before but if there was one rule that I would love to see changed, it is penalties. The Palace game was the latest in a very long list of instances where a football team is awarded a free shot from 12 yards for an offence committed in a situation where a goal scoring opportunity was almost certainly not denied. It's wholly unsatisfying IMO. Fumin'. RE: Penalties - Cheshire East Baggie - 03-15-2021 It's Pelanty FFS sake! RE: Penalties - Beachboysbaggie - 03-15-2021 (03-15-2021, 09:10 AM)chasetownbaggie Wrote: I'm still stewing over Saturday's result. We all know that in football, you often don't get what you deserved, but it makes it a bit better if you were undone by a piece of quality/excellence. Ok, on Saturday, we didn't deserve to win but neither did we deserve to lose - especially to a penalty awarded for a handball from a nothing cross which was cleared. Which brings me onto my pet hate - penalties.You make some good points. Maybe a solution would be to reduce the size of the penalty area? Start it from a yard either side of the posts RE: Penalties - HugeHons - 03-15-2021 Remember Jason Robert (s) getting one for Blackburn on his return to the hawthorns. It was facing away from goal , near the edge of the area when his shirt was tugged, I don’t think he was even running, just shielding the ball. Penalty. Ridiculous RE: Penalties - TartanRug - 03-15-2021 (03-15-2021, 09:10 AM)chasetownbaggie Wrote: I'm still stewing over Saturday's result. We all know that in football, you often don't get what you deserved, but it makes it a bit better if you were undone by a piece of quality/excellence. Ok, on Saturday, we didn't deserve to win but neither did we deserve to lose - especially to a penalty awarded for a handball from a nothing cross which was cleared. Which brings me onto my pet hate - penalties. Maybe you could have a free kick from wherever the offence took place when it's not a goal scoring opp that is denied. I agree a penalty is far too great a errr.. penalty in a lot of cases. RE: Penalties - Squid - 03-15-2021 In the Championship it doesn't matter so much. You'll get decisions that go for and against you. In the PL, where things seem to be increasingly about a wider narrative as opposed to what is actually happening on the pitch it all becomes more dubious. It's clear now that VAR and particularly penalties are getting more attention than actually playing football. Therefore the powers that be will amp up these events, because they think they are giving the public what it wants. But by public, they mean armchair glory-hunters on Twitter aka the last people who should be influencing how football is played. RE: Penalties - chasetownbaggie - 03-15-2021 (03-15-2021, 12:57 PM)HugeHons Wrote: Remember Jason Robert (s) getting one for Blackburn on his return to the hawthorns. It was facing away from goal , near the edge of the area when his shirt was tugged, I don’t think he was even running, just shielding the ball. Penalty. Ridiculous It was an incident similar to that which first convinced me they were absurd. A home fame v PNE and Hughesy was chasing a ball that was heading out to the touchline and a defender accidentally clipped his heels. Ball was outside the area, Hughesy was inside: penalty.IIRC, it was the decisive moment of the game. I don't have a solution. I'd always thought the same as TartanRug but I like Beachboys idea. Of course, it will never change. |