WBAUnofficial
The free kick - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: The free kick (/showthread.php?tid=15859)

Pages: 1 2


The free kick - cornishbaggie - 02-28-2021

As has been said, there is no actual rule to say the defending team has to be given time to be ready, but what has always happened, as it did yesterday, a defending player stands in front of the kicker until the ref confirms, on his whistle, coupled, with the ref spraying a line on the pitch, it is accepted, that the defending team have time to sort themselves out, so to suddenly blow your whistle while the defending side are sorting out their wall, is a least unsporting and players can't trust officials, Mason knows he ballsed up and tried to rectify it, as for all the pundits saying he spotted Johnstone by his post and realised he wasn't ready, have completely ignored, two players in our wall had their backs to the kicker, clearly still getting instructions from Johnstone, so either Mason just fucked up or he was being very sly.


RE: The free kick - Logic1 - 02-28-2021

(02-28-2021, 09:58 AM)cornishbaggie Wrote: As has been said, there is no actual rule to say the defending team has to be given time to be ready, but what has always happened, as it did yesterday, a defending player stands in front of the kicker until the ref confirms, on his whistle, coupled, with the ref spraying a line on the pitch, it is accepted, that the defending team have time to sort themselves out, so to suddenly blow your whistle while the defending side are sorting out their wall, is a least unsporting and players can't trust officials, Mason knows he ballsed up and tried to rectify it, as for all the pundits saying he spotted Johnstone by his post and realised he wasn't ready, have completely ignored, two players in our wall had their backs to the kicker, clearly still getting instructions from Johnstone, so either Mason just fucked up or he was being very sly.
Exactly that. 99.999% of the time that is what happens and is an informal rule if you like that is fair to everyone. Dunk is playing on that informal rule and taking advantage of it. He did it against Liverpool last season.

They need to change the rules on this.

1) you have the option to take a quick free kick, the referee determines whether this is an option depending on the context.

2) if you choose not to take a quick free kick the referee uses the spray (if needed) and allows the opposition to get set.

That would be fair to both teams.


RE: The free kick - tiptontown - 02-28-2021

Exactly what I was thinking regarding being unsporting...Pissed off with the pundits saying how Dunk was right it should have stood when clearly our lot as per normal were arranging the defence of the free kick.....It really does leave the game open to corruption if a ref allows that kind of thing to happen and another time doesn't.


RE: The free kick - SW4Baggie - 02-28-2021

The whole free kick thing is being blown out of proportion

VAR’s role is to determine whether or not a goal should stand. In this instance, before the ball crosses the line Lee Mason blows his whistle. The reason why he blew his whistle is immaterial, whether he saw SJ wasn’t ready, whether he realises he made a balls up of the whole event, or whether he believed there was pushing and it needed retaking, the only thing that matters is there is a clear and audible whistle before that ball crosses the line which means the game is halted when the ball crosses the line and subsequently the goal does not stand.

Dunk was well within his right to take that freekick. He asks Mason if he can take it quickly, he says yes and blows his whistle. Mason blows again - now according to Bartley - because he saw pushing in the wall. The goal is therefore ruled out.

What confuses the situation is Mason bizarrely deciding to give the goal only for VAR to correctly then rescind it. Mason should be demoted for his total mishandling of the event, but in terms of the decision that the goal doesn’t stand, VAR got it entirely right. Unsporting doesn’t really matter once the ref has given permission to take the freekick... there’s no law saying the defending team has to be given time to arrange their shape. If the goal had stood would have been far more unfair as we could rightly argue SJ heard the whistle and didn’t dive...

Also worth looking at what followed the incident. The freekick returned to Brighton to retake suggesting it was handbags in the wall.


RE: The free kick - SussexBaggie - 02-28-2021

In future, the wall must stand at 5 yards to prevent the ref from being confused, until everyone is in position, then slow march backwards?


RE: The free kick - Peachy - 02-28-2021

I said it yesterday. How often do you ever see a quick free kick being allowed 20 yards out with an empty net? Never ever have I seen it before. If that was the case then they are setting a very dangerous precedent going forwards.

Fair enough in the middle of the pitch to keep the game flowing etc but not when your keeper is lining up the wall and your players still have their back to the play....


RE: The free kick - Spandaubaggie - 02-28-2021

Very incisive debate on it on MOTD I thought. Must say how much I rate Jermaine Jenas- excellent pundit. Can see both sides of the argument and a truly bizarre incident.


RE: The free kick - clem4england - 02-28-2021

Ungentlemanly for me too. If this was done regularly, fine, but it isn't so unfair if we weren't given the benefit.


RE: The free kick - Atomic - 02-28-2021

There's no way Mason has blown up for pushing in the wall, there were only our players in it.


RE: The free kick - CA Baggie - 02-28-2021

The kicker has the option to take a quick free kick, but once the referee has marked out a wall etc then that option has naturally lapsed and you wait for everyone to be ready.

Mason made the mistake of blowing his whistle too soon to allow the kick and then quickly blew to halt it. What’s scary is the idea that it only got disallowed because he blew for a second time before the ball crossed the line.

The Brighton player that jumped out of the way off the ball as it was going into the net was also offside.

Why Mason suddenly thought he had to give the goal is the second mistake. The simple answer to Brighton’s protests was no and to retake it.

The idea of allowing the referee to spray the wall distance and then whilst the team makes the wall to take a quick free kick is surely ungentlemanly conduct. Take a quick free kick or wait.

I notice the TV made very little of the fact it was a great tackle from Townsend and never a penalty, focusing completely on Brighton’s hard luck story.