WBAUnofficial
VAR - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: VAR (/showthread.php?tid=15742)

Pages: 1 2


VAR - Wednesburybaggie - 02-20-2021

Fucking ruining this great game. I know that it helps us, but how can the Bartley handball not be given? If that was not given for us I would be beyond furious.


RE: VAR - chasetownbaggie - 02-20-2021

I'm a supporter of VAR but it doesn't help itself does it? Or more to the point, those manning it.

Am I the only one who thought Ajayi's handball a bit harsh? His arm was swinging in a running motion for me. In real time, I don't think he had a chance to stop it.


RE: VAR - baggie_ray - 02-20-2021

Re : Ajayi, like most if not all fouls, it is down to the ref's interpretation. Having taken a closer look at the incident the ref decides it was deliberate by Ajayi (as does the VAR ref). Looked like an instinctive motion to the ball to me, meaning it was deliberate.

The Bartley one, exactly the same as Furlong's at Man U for me. Have the rules changed again?

Personally I wouldn't have given it bearing in mind the conditions. It didn't look deliberate to me, just a high bounce of the ball.


RE: VAR - Lightnin - 02-20-2021

The ball comes off Bartley before it hits its hand so it can’t be handball.


RE: VAR - CA Baggie - 02-20-2021

(02-20-2021, 05:24 PM)Lightnin Wrote: The ball comes off Bartley before it hits its hand so it can’t be handball.

Did the ball not come off Ajayi’s thigh?

I actually think Ajayi does deliberately bring his arm up, problem with VAR is the slow-mo makes it look much worse.  I think it was handball but I cannot we that it was a clear goal scoring opportunity.

The Bartley one I’m not sure.  No intention imo (although that doesn’t seem to matter these days), but I’m not sure you can say his arm is in a natural position.

Just think Villa v Southampton and then neither are handball...


RE: VAR - Tom Joad - 02-20-2021

It's crap. Ok, Ajayi handled it but this was in the centre circle. Dean originally didn't think it worthy of a foul but like anything, you look for something over and over, eventually you see it. In real time it's maybe handball, maybe he gets the benefit of the doubt but either way, a sending off is very harsh.


RE: VAR - Cuzer - 02-20-2021

(02-20-2021, 04:58 PM)chasetownbaggie Wrote: I'm a supporter of VAR but it doesn't help itself does it? Or more to the point, those manning it.

Am I the only one who thought Ajayi's handball a bit harsh? His arm was swinging in a running motion for me. In real time, I don't think he had a chance to stop it.

How are you a supporter  of VAR chase?

What, how and why does it improve our game?

It’s a fucking car crash

Cuzer


RE: VAR - woodman - 02-20-2021

VAR is an unmitigated disaster. Was brought in to overturn the obviois errors and now creates more obvious errors than it solves.

Add to it a lack of communication, not hearing those Stockley Park wankers or the ref, the monitor by the side of the pitch farce, rules changing every other week.

It's a complete shitshow and should be canned


RE: VAR - YorkieDan - 02-20-2021

As a defender now, in Semis situation, You have to just let the striker go and hope your keeper can bail you out and you can get back. Its a split second reaction but You just will not get away with it.

The Bartley one is absolutely nailed on and if it was in the other box we'd be raging and calling Mike Dean every name under the sun.

Weve had so many go against us that weve been well overdue one or two in our favour... but VAR was supposed to bring consistancy and it doesnt seem to be doing that ATM.

That said, i had 3 friends on my news feed arguing over the Maguire pen/offside all of who are qualified officials at some level albeit junior and semi pro. Im guessing there is still some ambiguity and confusion with the mid season rule changes.


RE: VAR - Tom Joad - 02-20-2021

woodman Wrote:VAR is an unmitigated disaster. Was brought in to overturn the obviois errors and now creates more obvious errors than it solves.

Add to it a lack of communication, not hearing those Stockley Park wankers or the ref, the monitor by the side of the pitch farce, rules changing every other week.

It's a complete shitshow and should be canned

Word for word a great post. It should be printed in foot high capital letters outside Stockley Park.