WBAUnofficial
Ratings v Man U - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: Ratings v Man U (/showthread.php?tid=15659)



Ratings v Man U - chasetownbaggie - 02-15-2021

Hugely encouraging performance but, as most would agree, too little too late. Nonetheless, credit where it's due, fair result but we had chances to win. Only disappointment was the hoofball - our best spells came when we tried to pass it around.

Sam - a couple of excellent saves in the second half saved us a point. A shoe-in for PotS. 7

Peltier - dogged, if unspectacular, performed above expectation. 6.5
Ajayi - at times looks class, but prone to the odd error. Still can't work out why VAR said he didn't foul Maguire (though we had offside in our back pocket). 6
Bartley - arguably our most improved player this season. Still capable of clangers but since he's been back in the side, I think he's done well. 7
Townsend - performing way above my expectation and better than Gibbs. Very good today. 7.5

Snodgrass - WHam fans said he puts in a shift and he truly does. RM deffo his best position. 7
Okay - the type of player I was crying out for back in August. Pity he didn't turn up a month ago. Not just a destroyer though, he can play.  7
Gallagher - high energy performance we've come to expect. 7
Pereira - hard going for him today against quality opponent but without a doubt when he gets on the ball, he can make things happen. Some poor set pieces though. 6.5
AMN - hmmm, did alright but, for me, could have done more to prevent ManU's equaliser. IMO - then there was that terrible pass when we were 2 on 1 in the second half. 5.5

Diange - MAF but with goals. Should/could have got a hat-trick but still my MotM. 8

Subs:
Furlong - 7.5 great when he came on, goal line clearance and put in dangerous crosses
Livermore - 6 contributed to a battling performance, let down by that pass in the last minute.
Phillips - 6 supported RB well.


RE: Ratings v Man U - Dumbo - 02-15-2021

SJ - 8

Peltier - 6
Ajai - 7
Bartley - 7
Townsend - 7.5

Okay - 7.5
AMN - 7
Gallagher - 7.5

Periera - 7
Snodgrass - 7

Diagne - 8 (MOTM)

———————-
Furlong - 7.5
Livermore - 5.5
Phillips n/a


RE: Ratings v Man U - Cunninghamismagic - 02-15-2021

SJ - 8

Peltier - 6.5
Ajayi - 7
Bartley - 8
Townsend - 7

Okay - 7.5
AMN - 6
Gallagher - 8

Periera - 7
Snodgrass - 8

Diagne - 8 

———————-
Furlong - 8
Livermore - 6
Phillips n/a


RE: Ratings v Man U - Lurker#3 - 02-15-2021

SJ - 7 - Truth be told he had little to do. But the twice we needed him, he made 2 saves. 1 routine, 1 outstanding.

Peltier - 6 - Defensively fantastic, awful on posession and one of the main reasons we are so poor in transition.
Ajayi - 7 - Either brilliant or clumsy. Will continue to develop I have no doubt and will be a solid PL defender as he approaches his best years (29-33).
Bartley - 7 - Sound in all areas.
Townsend - 7 - See Bartley. After a difficult firs 20 mins, MP got a roasting and started helping him out.

Snoddy - 7 - Puts an almighty shift in. Top Pro. Much better when furlong came on to do his attacking running though.
Gallagher - 7 - Back to his early season best in the first half for me. Tired second and lost his influence in the game. A young player who has had an understandable dip in form.
Okay - 8 - would have been MOTM if he would have lasted 90 minutes. Looks a proper midfielder.
AMN - 5 - Rak Harper mkII. Same languid style, occasional flashes of quality, but far too often does not stamp his authority in the game. Not holding out much hope, but had the talent to improve. At 23 he's no youth player now though.
Pereria - 8 - MOTM. Thought he got through a mountain of work after the first 15/20 mins or so, is our only truly PL quality player, we are very lucky to have him.
Diange - 7 - Bullied their defenders well. Especially for his goal. Held it up well too. But I have to take a mark off him for that miss. On another day he could have had 3 and been a hero.


RE: Ratings v Man U - ElbowGrease1973 - 02-15-2021

(02-15-2021, 08:36 AM)Cunninghamismagic Wrote: SJ - 8

Peltier - 6.5
Ajayi - 7
Bartley - 8
Townsend - 7

Okay - 7.5
AMN - 6
Gallagher - 8

Periera - 7
Snodgrass - 8

Diagne - 8 

———————-
Furlong - 8
Livermore - 6
Phillips n/a

I would have marked exactly the same as you CIM, with Gallagher just shading the MOM, due to his all action performance for the whole 90 minutes. I'd start him in that position for the rest of the season, as even if he's not playing well, his energy and endeavour is just what's needed.


RE: Ratings v Man U - Hopalong - 02-16-2021

(02-15-2021, 01:16 AM)chasetownbaggie Wrote: Hugely encouraging performance but, as most would agree, too little too late. Nonetheless, credit where it's due, fair result but we had chances to win. Only disappointment was the hoofball - our best spells came when we tried to pass it around.

Sam - a couple of excellent saves in the second half saved us a point. A shoe-in for PotS. 7

Peltier - dogged, if unspectacular, performed above expectation. 6.5
Ajayi - at times looks class, but prone to the odd error. Still can't work out why VAR said he didn't foul Maguire (though we had offside in our back pocket). 6
Bartley - arguably our most improved player this season. Still capable of clangers but since he's been back in the side, I think he's done well. 7
Townsend - performing way above my expectation and better than Gibbs. Very good today. 7.5

Snodgrass - WHam fans said he puts in a shift and he truly does. RM deffo his best position. 7
Okay - the type of player I was crying out for back in August. Pity he didn't turn up a month ago. Not just a destroyer though, he can play.  7
Gallagher - high energy performance we've come to expect. 7
Pereira - hard going for him today against quality opponent but without a doubt when he gets on the ball, he can make things happen. Some poor set pieces though. 6.5
AMN - hmmm, did alright but, for me, could have done more to prevent ManU's equaliser. IMO - then there was that terrible pass when we were 2 on 1 in the second half. 5.5

Diange - MAF but with goals. Should/could have got a hat-trick but still my MotM. 8

Subs:
Furlong - 7.5 great when he came on, goal line clearance and put in dangerous crosses
Livermore - 6 contributed to a battling performance, let down by that pass in the last minute.
Phillips - 6 supported RB well.

When we were linked with Diagne I posted a video on here which was supposed to be his highlights but certainly for the first half it just showed him missing chance after chance - just like yesterday!  

There's a reason he's at WBA.   A contact who lives in Istanbul and supports Galatasaray was delighted we'd signed him and was fairly critical but to be fair he's worked really hard and put himself about.  He wants to play in the Prem so if we go down someone else may sign him.  Either way it's a win:win for us but probably too little too late.


RE: Ratings v Man U - SW4Baggie - 02-16-2021

(02-16-2021, 12:04 AM)Hopalong Wrote:
(02-15-2021, 01:16 AM)chasetownbaggie Wrote: Hugely encouraging performance but, as most would agree, too little too late. Nonetheless, credit where it's due, fair result but we had chances to win. Only disappointment was the hoofball - our best spells came when we tried to pass it around.

Sam - a couple of excellent saves in the second half saved us a point. A shoe-in for PotS. 7

Peltier - dogged, if unspectacular, performed above expectation. 6.5
Ajayi - at times looks class, but prone to the odd error. Still can't work out why VAR said he didn't foul Maguire (though we had offside in our back pocket). 6
Bartley - arguably our most improved player this season. Still capable of clangers but since he's been back in the side, I think he's done well. 7
Townsend - performing way above my expectation and better than Gibbs. Very good today. 7.5

Snodgrass - WHam fans said he puts in a shift and he truly does. RM deffo his best position. 7
Okay - the type of player I was crying out for back in August. Pity he didn't turn up a month ago. Not just a destroyer though, he can play.  7
Gallagher - high energy performance we've come to expect. 7
Pereira - hard going for him today against quality opponent but without a doubt when he gets on the ball, he can make things happen. Some poor set pieces though. 6.5
AMN - hmmm, did alright but, for me, could have done more to prevent ManU's equaliser. IMO - then there was that terrible pass when we were 2 on 1 in the second half. 5.5

Diange - MAF but with goals. Should/could have got a hat-trick but still my MotM. 8

Subs:
Furlong - 7.5 great when he came on, goal line clearance and put in dangerous crosses
Livermore - 6 contributed to a battling performance, let down by that pass in the last minute.
Phillips - 6 supported RB well.

When we were linked with Diagne I posted a video on here which was supposed to be his highlights but certainly for the first half it just showed him missing chance after chance - just like yesterday!  

There's a reason he's at WBA.   A contact who lives in Istanbul and supports Galatasaray was delighted we'd signed him and was fairly critical but to be fair he's worked really hard and put himself about.  He wants to play in the Prem so if we go down someone else may sign him.  Either way it's a win:win for us but probably too little too late.

I think the video you posted was the one Gala fans created taking the piss out of all his misses Wink

Diagne’s goal scoring ratio proves he knows where the net is but as we’ve seen in his appearances so far, he’s far from clinical. 

He is however putting in bag loads of effort and I’d rather we had a striker creating opportunities, finding space and missing chances than just being Karlan Grant.

At £4-5m there’ll be PL takers this summer. He’d be ideal for Brighton.


RE: Ratings v Man U - B36baggie - 02-16-2021

Much higher marks from most for Pereira, six at best for me.


RE: Ratings v Man U - Baggy Bruin - 02-16-2021

If Diagne is going to miss 2 out of 3 chances, then we just need to create more chances for him.

Create six, he will score 2.

Create nine, he will score 3

We need to be more attack minded. Been our problem all season. But now? With Diagne? It's essential we create more chances. He will take them.