WBAUnofficial
This transfer window, it seems there is one mind making the decisions... - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: This transfer window, it seems there is one mind making the decisions... (/showthread.php?tid=15386)



This transfer window, it seems there is one mind making the decisions... - Squid - 02-01-2021

...As opposed to Dowling and Slav squabbling and producing a mess between them.

In summer it was like Slav was clutching a list saying:

1) Keep the nice lads together
2)Get players whose surnames end in -ic
3)Grant.

Whereas Dowling's was:

1)Get any player we can sell for a profit later.

Unsurprisingly, we ended up with a really unbalanced team and missed a prime opportunity to move on some players who weren't going to be good enough for the PL. We spent money, but not at all wisely.

Under Sam, it seems like we are actually *gasp* bringing players in areas in which we are short.


RE: This transfer window, it seems there is one mind making the decisions... - Lurker#3 - 02-01-2021

I actually lay very little blame at Dowlings door. His mandate will be set by the owners who will want saleable assets. Teh manager will haver the biggest input into the positions and types of player he wants.

As you quite rightly point out, Slav wanted his pals it seems, and "nice guys". As a result we have lacked any real bite and no real ambition from the players. You need a certain degree of arrogance, and this is what Pereira brings which sets him aside from the others.


RE: This transfer window, it seems there is one mind making the decisions... - Lillwall's left foot - 02-01-2021

Reminds me of when SGM came into the club. It was obvious to everyone that we were weak at CB and had zero fbs so he just went out and bought in Butler, Lyttle and Clem.....simple and job done. Major weaknesses addressed and team starting to take shape. Next job....bring in fight and leadership etc.

No doubt BS is setting the agenda, even if he won't get everything he has demanded.


RE: This transfer window, it seems there is one mind making the decisions... - HugeHons - 02-01-2021

I wonder if we make a fist of it ( although I think it’s too late) and improve over the rest of the season whether Sam will give it a go next season?


RE: This transfer window, it seems there is one mind making the decisions... - ColliersWoodBaggie - 02-01-2021

Allardyce is contracted until June 2022. Tbf I'd back him on bringing us back up first go.


RE: This transfer window, it seems there is one mind making the decisions... - Baggeridgebaggy - 02-01-2021

(02-01-2021, 02:44 PM)Rob Lurker#3 Wrote: I actually lay very little blame at Dowlings door. His mandate will be set by the owners who will want saleable assets. Teh manager will haver the biggest input into the positions and types of player he wants.

As you quite rightly point out, Slav wanted his pals it seems, and "nice guys". As a result we have lacked any real bite and no real ambition from the players. You need a certain degree of arrogance, and this is what Pereira brings which sets him aside from the others.

From what I see the owner allows the club to run itself & those in charge to spend 100% of the money it generates in whatever way they want. Downing is or should be involved in all transfers & certainty in the context of getting balance in the squad 

Sorry, but on that basis it’s frankly perverse to suggest Downing (Sporting & Technical Director) should take no responsibility (or blame) for the misguided & at times incompetent recruitment policy 

We’ve seen some of the worse displays in the clubs history (and certainty in living memory) and to try to give him a free pass isn't logical and if he has allowed Bilic his own way he needs to be sacked


RE: This transfer window, it seems there is one mind making the decisions... - CA Baggie - 02-01-2021

Dowling should be setting the remit in terms of style of play and the recruitment of managers and players to provide that, that's the only way to get any sense on continuity. The change in approach by the managers employed leaves the squad all over the place and unbalanced.

The joy of management is managing the short term aims whilst sticking to the longer term plan, we seem to be lurching from one style to another and this was happening before Dowlng turned up and hasn't really changed.

It's why Kyle Bartley ended up attempting to play out from the back like Cryuff. If you want a manager and team to play that way don't go out and sign Bartley.


RE: This transfer window, it seems there is one mind making the decisions... - wbamitch - 02-01-2021

I do find the criticism of Dowling a bit OTT sometimes. It’s easy to look back on transfers with hindsight, hes working with a very small budget and he’s got some right and some wrong. Last season our transfers were largely a success, not many expected us to go up and we did. You won’t find many fans who weren’t excited about Grady joining, nobody expected him to struggle as much as he has. Yes there’s holes in the squad and for that he is partly to blame but what can you do if your manager is publicly insistent on signing Krovinovic over a DM, insisted on signing Grant over any other option.


RE: This transfer window, it seems there is one mind making the decisions... - Tom Joad - 02-01-2021

Squid Wrote:...As opposed to Dowling and Slav squabbling and producing a mess between them.

In summer it was like Slav was clutching a list saying:

1) Keep the nice lads together
2)Get players whose surnames end in -ic
3)Grant.

Whereas Dowling's was:

1)Get any player we can sell for a profit later.

Unsurprisingly, we ended up with a really unbalanced team and missed a prime opportunity to move on some players who weren't going to be good enough for the PL. We spent money, but not at all wisely.

Under Sam, it seems like we are actually *gasp* bringing players in areas in which we are short.

Good post. Sam clearly the driving force. As for blame, I would start with whoever thought we would be OK without a proper no.9.


RE: This transfer window, it seems there is one mind making the decisions... - Baggie_Nick - 02-01-2021

(02-01-2021, 02:40 PM)Squid Wrote: ...As opposed to Dowling and Slav squabbling and producing a mess between them.

In summer it was like Slav was clutching a list saying:

1) Keep the nice lads together
2)Get players whose surnames end in -ic
3)Grant.

Whereas Dowling's was:

1)Get any player we can sell for a profit later.

Unsurprisingly, we ended up with a really unbalanced team and missed a prime opportunity to move on some players who weren't going to be good enough for the PL. We spent money, but not at all wisely.

Under Sam, it seems like we are actually *gasp* bringing players in areas in which we are short.

Now way Sam would come and listen to that dickhead Dowling about matters of football.

This bloke should get the sack very soon.