WBAUnofficial
First half yesterday - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: First half yesterday (/showthread.php?tid=15366)

Pages: 1 2


First half yesterday - Cheshire East Baggie - 01-31-2021

It was a very rare thing to see, a tactical change so early. What's the view of posters on here, what was Sam trying to do and why wasn't it working? I'm not interested in the "he's got no idea what he's doing" level of analysis, because I don't believe that's the case.

I'm sure I saw someone on here state with authority "it was supposed to be a 4-5-1, the players were't doing what he wanted". Is that the case? Was Ajayi supposed to be in midfield? Or was it that the whole back five were too deep and he had to get another forward player on if they weren't prepared to press higher up the pitch?

In the second half, they did press higher up the pitch. So why did they need that half time talk before they did what must have been the instruction from the start? It wasn't just the introduction of Diagne that made it possible, they could have put themselves about a bit more any time.

Someone else likened it to the last days of Pulis. I think it smells more like the Pardew days. Anyone remember that interview with three of the players (Brunt and Field were two of them) after training. They were asked how training went. A barely suppressed snort of derision, shrug of the shoulders told the whole tale. Yet the same players went on a brilliant run for Big Dave.


RE: First half yesterday - HugeHons - 01-31-2021

Sam said afterwards he changed from three at the back to 4-1-4-1. I assume he thought we would be ok with 3 centre halves with one picking up Mitrovic and the two wing backs bombing on and supporting the attack.However we just seem to be pegged back from the off and Robinson 30 yards away on his own.It was horrendous to watch.


RE: First half yesterday - Wotty - 01-31-2021

Going a goal down was obviously a big factor but I think having extra subs enabled him to change it so soon.


RE: First half yesterday - Tom Joad - 01-31-2021

HugeHons Wrote:Sam said afterwards he changed from three at the back to 4-1-4-1. I assume he thought we would be ok with 3 centre  halves with one picking up Mitrovic and the two wing backs bombing on and supporting the attack.However we just seem to be pegged back from the off and Robinson 30 yards away on his own.It was horrendous to watch.

Is correct. Only thing I disagree with was O'Shea being sacrificed. Gibbs should have gone IMO, with a shuffle around of the others.


RE: First half yesterday - cornishbaggie - 01-31-2021

(01-31-2021, 05:21 PM)Wotty Wrote: Going a goal down was obviously a big factor but I think having extra subs enabled him to change it so soon.

What extra subs ?


RE: First half yesterday - MancBaggie - 01-31-2021

(01-31-2021, 05:14 PM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: It was a very rare thing to see, a tactical change so early. What's the view of posters on here, what was Sam trying to do and why wasn't it working? I'm not interested in the "he's got no idea what he's doing" level of analysis, because I don't believe that's the case.

I'm sure I saw someone on here state with authority "it was supposed to be a 4-5-1, the players were't doing what he wanted". Is that the case? Was Ajayi supposed to be in midfield? Or was it that the whole back five were too deep and he had to get another forward player on if they weren't prepared to press higher up the pitch?

In the second half, they did press higher up the pitch. So why did they need that half time talk before they did what must have been the instruction from the start? It wasn't just the introduction of Diagne that made it possible, they could have put themselves about a bit more any time.

Someone else likened it to the last days of Pulis. I think it smells more like the Pardew days. Anyone remember that interview with three of the players (Brunt and Field were two of them) after training. They were asked how training went. A barely suppressed snort of derision, shrug of the shoulders told the whole tale. Yet the same players went on a brilliant run for Big Dave.
 
I likened it to Pardew v Hudds at home Chesh. There is busy incompetence and then there are players going through the motions


RE: First half yesterday - Derek Hardballs - 01-31-2021

(01-31-2021, 05:14 PM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: It was a very rare thing to see, a tactical change so early. What's the view of posters on here, what was Sam trying to do and why wasn't it working? I'm not interested in the "he's got no idea what he's doing" level of analysis, because I don't believe that's the case.

I'm sure I saw someone on here state with authority "it was supposed to be a 4-5-1, the players were't doing what he wanted". Is that the case? Was Ajayi supposed to be in midfield? Or was it that the whole back five were too deep and he had to get another forward player on if they weren't prepared to press higher up the pitch?

In the second half, they did press higher up the pitch. So why did they need that half time talk before they did what must have been the instruction from the start? It wasn't just the introduction of Diagne that made it possible, they could have put themselves about a bit more any time.

Someone else likened it to the last days of Pulis. I think it smells more like the Pardew days. Anyone remember that interview with three of the players (Brunt and Field were two of them) after training. They were asked how training went. A barely suppressed snort of derision, shrug of the shoulders told the whole tale. Yet the same players went on a brilliant run for Big Dave.

We couldn’t play in their half because without a target man you can’t play the ball long and make it stick. In the second half Diange was clearly told to stay up the pitch and offer that outlet. It gave our players a chance to join the attack, play in their half and get bodies forward / into the box. I imagine going 4141 was to try and cut out the straight balls, offer a shield to the ball being played between our lines. 

First half our midfield allowed Fulham to play straight balls into their forwards / behind our defence and it cut our defence to shreds. It also completely nullified our midfield who were playing in very rigid lines. As soon as the ball was played straight our players had to turn and chase. How many times did we see Livermore, Gallagher etc chasing back or just watching statically as the ball was pinged between the lines?


RE: First half yesterday - diagne_west - 01-31-2021

Hello friends. I am new here, just joined. This season I support West Broomwich and I fallow its games. I hope this team stays in the premier league at the end of the season. Good luck. Best wishes.


RE: First half yesterday - Baggeridgebaggy - 01-31-2021

Started with 3 CB's which invariably means 5 defenders given its Gibbs & OShea so its 5 3 1 1

But were being overrun in midfield & wasn't even as if the 5 defenders were making us tight defensively

Changed to back 4 with extra midfield player - Grant went left & got 4 across the middle, plus Pereira to go 4 4 1 1


RE: First half yesterday - MozzasRocket - 01-31-2021

(01-31-2021, 06:53 PM)diagne_west Wrote: Hello friends. I am new here, just joined. This season I support West Broomwich and I fallow its games. I hope this team stays in the premier league at the end of the season. Good luck. Best wishes.

Hi mate! Welcome. I'm new here too, i enjoy it. Hopefully people don't get smarmy towards you when you have a different opinion to them.. oh & i hope you don't get the 'new poster' rubbish thrown at you as well.

BOING BOING