![]() |
|
VAR again i am afraid - Printable Version +- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk) +-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3) +--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4) +--- Thread: VAR again i am afraid (/showthread.php?tid=15291) |
VAR again i am afraid - Shabby Russian - 01-29-2021 I have no love of Liverpool, but the use of VAR last night to disallow their goal really troubled me, because when you think about it, it made no sense, and what was troubling for me was no one else seemed to be bothered by it. Dier and Firmino were tussling at the half way line, Dier seemed to be fouling Firmino, the ball inadvertently hit Dier's arm and then inadvetently hit Firmino's, who gained possession from which Liverpool scored. I don't have a problem the goal was disallowed, rules clearly state any handball deliberate or not in the build up to a goal means that the goal cannot stand, but why do Tottenham get the free kick. In the space of a second two players inadvertently handle the ball on the halfway line and its only the last handball that is penalised . I know technically an inadvertent handball by a defender is not a foul, but it is by an attacker. But this incident took place on the halfway line, who is to say who was the attacker or the defender at the time of the incident. It shows the craziness of the current interpretation of handball, an interpretation which is only in place to facilitate VAR. Where VAR is concerned we have allowed the tail to wag the dog. RE: VAR again i am afraid - TartanRug - 01-29-2021 (01-29-2021, 09:56 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote: I have no love of Liverpool, but the use of VAR last night to disallow their goal really troubled me, because when you think about it, it made no sense, and what was troubling for me was no one else seemed to be bothered by it. I agree it's crazy. So if Dier had won the ball in that tussle and Spurs then scored from it the goal would be ruled out and Liverpool get a free kick for exactly the same starting situation. They're having to make these stupid rules up to accommodate VAR which is an awful system as it is IMO. RE: VAR again i am afraid - CA Baggie - 01-29-2021 I thought inadvertent handball by an attacker had been scrapped? If not why was the Chelsea equaliser allowed to stand at our place? It was looked at by VAR. I succinctly express my views on VAR below. They'll never scrap it but I'd love them to do so, although I could accept offside decisions provided it was done so with clear rules around when a linesman is and isn't supposed to flag... RE: VAR again i am afraid - ferencpuskas - 01-29-2021 I know and admit that I'm ode school, but the game I played and now watch, has been ruined and imo, VAR is an abomination ! I said it at it's introduction, and nothing will change my opinion! Further more, if the rules regarding when a linesman, sorry linesperson, sorry referee's assistant, waves his/her flag are filtered down to junior/sunday football, and fat blokes waving grubby towels, are involved, the A&Es, at the hospitals will be overloaded with folks who've been fighting on the on the touch lines, at kid's football matches
RE: VAR again i am afraid - Brentbaggie - 01-29-2021 (01-29-2021, 10:33 AM)ferencpuskas Wrote: I know and admit that I'm ode school, but the game I played and now watch, has been ruined and imo, VAR is an abomination ! I said it at it's introduction, and nothing will change my opinion! Further more, if the rules regarding when a linesman, sorry linesperson, sorry referee's assistant, waves his/her flag are filtered down to junior/sunday football, and fat blokes waving grubby towels, are involved, the A&Es, at the hospitals will be overloaded with folks who've been fighting on the on the touch lines, at kid's football matches What more than they do now - or at least did before lockdown?
RE: VAR again i am afraid - Sliced - 01-29-2021 It's just rubbish. They're literally having to change the rules of football to fit in with VAR. If it was capable of serving a purpose then it would be the other way around. It's shit RE: VAR again i am afraid - Psalm23 - 01-29-2021 I thought the Son offside call, for Tottinghams goal early on was a load of bollox aswell, about half a millimeter in it, after they'd drawn about six lines aots. Just ruining the game, needs fucking off asap. RE: VAR again i am afraid - MrFizz - 01-29-2021 The technology is here to stay now unfortunately. I think it should be used differently, with responsibility on the match officials to use it. If the officials on the pitch think there may be a reason not to award a goal, the referee makes the 'TV' gesture and then consults a pitchside monitor. If they don't see anything, goal is given. If they see a handball, push, offside etc then they give a free kick. No lines, just anything obviously missed is looked for. I would also introduce a coaches challenge. One per half, to be used to review a goal if a manager believes something has been missed. Again the ref consults a monitor and decides one way or the other. If they stick with their decision the manager loses their one challenge. If the decision is changed then they still have their challenge available. Referees can also consult a monitor if an assistant sees something off the ball that may be violent conduct. All of these put the matter in the hands of those on the pitch, which is where it should be. RE: VAR again i am afraid - Tom Joad - 01-29-2021 TBH, I don't see them admitting their mistake when challenged by a coach. I'm like many on here and have been dead against it from the start (namely that cup game when they examined everything we did against Liverpool). VAR started badly and has got worse. it seems now that the powers that be can interpret whatever they want from the rules. I don't even need to site any examples, we have all seen them. In all the complaints I heard about our game at Old Trafford, the sagest was "I don't know if all those decisions were eventually correct, I only know they would all have gone the other way for Man Utd". RE: VAR again i am afraid - Everything Zin - 01-29-2021 If Ajayi had scored in the first minute against City, VAR would have ruled it out. In the scramble up to the chance, the ball struck a city defender on the arm ( clearly unintentional and not a penalty) but then bounced up onto Livermore’s arm - again clearly unintentional but in the bonkers VAR world enough to chalk off the goal for exactly the same ‘offense’ as the defender. Utterly absurd. |