WBAUnofficial
Having EU Cake & Eating It - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: Politics (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=5)
+--- Thread: Having EU Cake & Eating It (/showthread.php?tid=14951)

Pages: 1 2 3


Having EU Cake & Eating It - Protheroe - 01-12-2021

EU member states signed a legally binding agreement that ONLY the EU could deal with vaccine manufacturers on their behalf.

I seem to recall there was some debate about that on here when the UK decided not to participate.

It now transpires that Germany has broken ranks from this legally binding agreement and bought 75 million extra doses for itself.

Frederique Ries, a Belgian MEP on the European Parliament's Public Health Committee said Germany showed a "total lack of solidarity".

Proving once again that member states only respect the rules of the EU when it suits them, yet the EU wanted a sovereign nation to sign a ratchet clause to secure a trade agreement. What an appalling lot they are.


RE: Having EU Cake & Eating It - Borin' Baggie - 01-12-2021

As you have been repeatedly told, third countries do not get the same level of flexibility with the EU as members. Now we are not a member we no longer have that flexibility.


RE: Having EU Cake & Eating It - Protheroe - 01-12-2021

EU are priceless. "Let's ignore our own legally binding agreements, but by George if the British do it they're toast"

Flexibility? Howling.


RE: Having EU Cake & Eating It - Borin' Baggie - 01-12-2021

Yes, and if we were still members we'd have that flexibility as we have used in the past. It's also yet another example as to how being a member of the EU doesn't inhibit a nations sovereignty.

We are no longer members, the UK can't have it's cake and eat it. If we want flexibility with the EU we could always rejoin.


RE: Having EU Cake & Eating It - baggy1 - 01-12-2021

From my memory of this we were asked if we wanted to participate in the EU procurement of vaccines but that didn't require exclusivity, we could have also bought through our own procurement (as Germany have), is this a non-story?


RE: Having EU Cake & Eating It - Borin' Baggie - 01-12-2021

(01-12-2021, 01:42 PM)baggy1 Wrote: From my memory of this we were asked if we wanted to participate in the EU procurement of vaccines but that didn't require exclusivity, we could have also bought through our own procurement (as Germany have), is this a non-story?

Pretty much.

Germany have secured an agreement for additional vaccines outside of the procurement agreement and have also bought unclaimed stock within the procurement agreement, the latter is technically in violation of the joint procurement agreement as it should be done by population but if countries aren't claiming that stock then there's no problem and the additional purchase is for vaccines that will be delivered after the supply to the Commission. There's a reason why the other member states don't seem to care. The purchase agreement Proth is referring to was made in September and has been public since then, yet is being dragged up now.

Typical europhobic nonsense being pedaled by people clutching at straws and trying to justify the fact that I and many others have been tied up in new red tape for over a week and therefore have projects on hold.


RE: Having EU Cake & Eating It - Protheroe - 01-12-2021

(01-12-2021, 01:51 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(01-12-2021, 01:42 PM)baggy1 Wrote: From my memory of this we were asked if we wanted to participate in the EU procurement of vaccines but that didn't require exclusivity, we could have also bought through our own procurement (as Germany have), is this a non-story?

Pretty much.

Germany have secured an agreement for additional vaccines outside of the procurement agreement and have also bought unclaimed stock within the procurement agreement, the latter is technically in violation of the joint procurement agreement as it should be done by population but if countries aren't claiming that stock then there's no problem and the additional purchase is for vaccines that will be delivered after the supply to the Commission. There's a reason why the other member states don't seem to care. The purchase agreement Proth is referring to was made in September and has been public since then, yet is being dragged up now.

Typical europhobic nonsense being pedaled by people clutching at straws and trying to justify the fact that I and many others have been tied up in new red tape for over a week and therefore have projects on hold.

"The only framework we are negotiating in is as 27. We do this together, and no member state on this legal-binding basis is allowed to negotiate in parallel or to have a contract in parallel," the president of the EU executive, Germany's Ursula von der Leyen, told reporters on Friday (8 January).

Europhobic? Or an observation?

It's EUphiles clutching at straws pretending Germany's behaviour is less than a breach of the the letter and spirit of the Agreement. You just can't admit it, can you?


RE: Having EU Cake & Eating It - baggy1 - 01-12-2021

But what have they breached, are you saying that the amounts should have been distributed on a population basis even if some countries didn't want them? Not being awkward here but have Germany actually denied another country getting the vaccines?


RE: Having EU Cake & Eating It - Protheroe - 01-12-2021

(01-12-2021, 02:05 PM)baggy1 Wrote: But what have they breached, are you saying that the amounts should have been distributed on a population basis even if some countries didn't want them? Not being awkward here but have Germany actually denied another country getting the vaccines?

They have breached the Agreement they signed. You can weasel all you like about the nuances, but the fact remains that the 27 signed a legally binding Agrement and Germany breached it.

There will, of course, be no consequences for doing so. Like there are no cosequences for France in breaching the Stability Pact.

You'd be all over the UK for any minor breach of the WA or Trade Agreement. Double standards n'est pas?

"Rules" are so easily bent or broken in the EU and more often than not it's by Germany & France. Greece? Not so much. It's almost colonial. Thank goodness we're out.


RE: Having EU Cake & Eating It - Borin' Baggie - 01-12-2021

(01-12-2021, 02:02 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(01-12-2021, 01:51 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(01-12-2021, 01:42 PM)baggy1 Wrote: From my memory of this we were asked if we wanted to participate in the EU procurement of vaccines but that didn't require exclusivity, we could have also bought through our own procurement (as Germany have), is this a non-story?

Pretty much.

Germany have secured an agreement for additional vaccines outside of the procurement agreement and have also bought unclaimed stock within the procurement agreement, the latter is technically in violation of the joint procurement agreement as it should be done by population but if countries aren't claiming that stock then there's no problem and the additional purchase is for vaccines that will be delivered after the supply to the Commission. There's a reason why the other member states don't seem to care. The purchase agreement Proth is referring to was made in September and has been public since then, yet is being dragged up now.

Typical europhobic nonsense being pedaled by people clutching at straws and trying to justify the fact that I and many others have been tied up in new red tape for over a week and therefore have projects on hold.

"The only framework we are negotiating in is as 27. We do this together, and no member state on this legal-binding basis is allowed to negotiate in parallel or to have a contract in parallel," the president of the EU executive, Germany's Ursula von der Leyen, told reporters on Friday (8 January).

Europhobic? Or an observation?

It's EUphiles clutching at straws pretending Germany's behaviour is less than a breach of the the letter and spirit of the Agreement. You just can't admit it, can you?

It's in breach of the written technicalities of the framework agreement, it is not in breach of the spirit of the agreement as the Commission gets priority on delivery of vaccines and members signed up to the framework aren't given reduced allocations. Therefore, EU vaccine supplies to member states isn't inhibited in any way.

There's a reason why the Commission is upset and the member states are shrugging their shoulders, to latch onto this is clutching at straws. If the EU member states don't care, which they don't, the EU will be flexible with Germany. As I mentioned, the deal between Germany and BioNTech was made in September, why are you bringing it up now?