WBAUnofficial
The board's record on appointments - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: The board's record on appointments (/showthread.php?tid=14332)



The board's record on appointments - Offside - 12-17-2020

Just been looking at the Wiki list of managers I have known since Vic Buckingham, who was in charge when I first entered the Hawthorns.  I am reassured that the board are as stupid now as they were for most of the past 60 years that I have been a fan.   I had the same feeling yesterday, as I had when previous neanderthal / legends in their own shaving mirror managers were appointed.

It’s surprising how your mind thinks they some managers were OK and then you look at their win ratio. For example, Jimmy Hagan’s win ratio of 38.81% is not as good as I thought it was, but is bolstered by a league cup win.  That was a great night against West Ham. Only to be fucked up by QPR at Wembley.

Don Howe arrived full of hope and managed a win ratio of 31.52%.  I had lost the will to live by the time he finished destroying my love for the game. 

Atkinson the first time managed 44% which is very  good and we nearly won the league,  and would have if the weather had not stopped us in our tracks for six weeks.  His second stint achieved a win ratio of just 28.3%. Another stupid appointment by the board.

When Ron Wylie was appointed I could have cried. He was obvious to everyone other than the board that he was bloody useless and managed 35% , only to be surpassed by the dark days of Ron Saunders on 21.88%.   Wylie and Saunders in particular were abysmal appointments.  

Bryan Talbot was nearly as bad as I remember on 29.82%.  And a couple of years later, just to prove that the board were still morons, they appointed Bobby fucking Gould who managed 33.33%.   Was that when the coffin appeared?  Great stuff. 

Ossie managed a win ratio of 54.5% but we would have been slaughtered in the Premier league playing his sort of football, as he proved at Spurs a few weeks later.  Never forgiven him for that.  He should have hung around for another year at least.

Burkinshaw was past his sell-by date and managed 23.44%.

Buckley. Words fail me. 118 games and a win ratio of 33.05%.  I am surprised it was that good. 

Ray Harford picked things up in his brief stay.  47.5%.

Denis Smith managed to return to Buckley days at 29%. 

And then we move into the exclusive sub 20% league starting with Brian Little at 19.51%.  I’m surprised it was that high.

Then Sir Gary Megson arrives at 42.53% and fair play to him,  he stuck around to have a go in the greed league and laid the foundation for the last 20 years.

Similar to yesterday, my heart sank when Alecan was appointed.  He had achieved nothing as a manager other than a reputation for drinking and building a pub team. But yet again the board fell for the style and reputation rather than the evidence of his managerial ability.

Mowbray managed 48.78% which is good considering his performance in the Premier League.

Matteo managed 49%  which reflects how well we won the championship.  His luck changed that night at Blackpool when the baby ref fucked it all up.  We never recovered from that.

Roy managed 37% which is respectable given the circumstances.  Clarke 32% which is better than I remember and Pepe Mel 17.65% which is on a par with what I recall. Yet another inspired appointment by the board.

Alan fucking Irvine and his watch surprisingly managed to stay out of the sub 20% club at 22.73%.   It seemed a lot worse than that.

Pulis managed 27.75% in 121 games.  It seemed like 1121 games at the time.  His draw ratio is also 27.5% which probably tells a story.

Pardew was as bad as we thought at 14.3% in 21 tortuous games.  I take my hat off to the board for that appointment.  How they had not worked out that the man was a complete tosser by the time they interviewed him, is beyond me.

Darren managed a very creditable 47.92% in 48 games.   What he would have gone on to achieve will never be known.  But I look at him as a person in comparison with the avaricious piece of shit we appointed yesterday, and despair at what the game has become.

Slav managed 40% from 65 games. But the writing was on the wall when it took Brentford blowing a gasket, to get us over the promotion line.  If Watkins had scored two absolute sitters against Stoke and I think it was Barnsley,  we would still be in the Championship. Let's hope he is as bad for Villa. 

As for Sam,  he will probably get us organised (needs doing) keep us up,  and take the money and run.  


I hope it’s more fun than watching a Ron Wylie,  Ron Saunders, Tony Pulis or Bobby Gould side.  But he's from the same neanderthal school of football.


RE: The board's record on appointments - Johnnykayeengland - 12-17-2020

You're not pleased with the appointment then?


RE: The board's record on appointments - Hopalong - 12-17-2020

(12-17-2020, 12:19 PM)Offside Wrote: Just been looking at the Wiki list of managers I have known since Vic Buckingham, who was in charge when I first entered the Hawthorns.  I am reassured that the board are as stupid now as they were for most of the past 60 years that I have been a fan.   I had the same feeling yesterday, as I had when previous neanderthal / legends in their own shaving mirror managers were appointed.

It’s surprising how your mind thinks they some managers were OK and then you look at their win ratio. For example, Jimmy Hagan’s win ratio of 38.81% is not as good as I thought it was, but is bolstered by a league cup win.  That was a great night against West Ham. Only to be fucked up by QPR at Wembley.

Don Howe arrived full of hope and managed a win ratio of 31.52%.  I had lost the will to live by the time he finished destroying my love for the game. 

Atkinson the first time managed 44% which is very  good and we nearly won the league,  and would have if the weather had not stopped us in our tracks for six weeks.  His second stint achieved a win ratio of just 28.3%. Another stupid appointment by the board.

When Ron Wylie was appointed I could have cried. He was obvious to everyone other than the board that he was bloody useless and managed 35% , only to be surpassed by the dark days of Ron Saunders on 21.88%.   Wylie and Saunders in particular were abysmal appointments.  

Bryan Talbot was nearly as bad as I remember on 29.82%.  And a couple of years later, just to prove that the board were still morons, they appointed Bobby fucking Gould who managed 33.33%.   Was that when the coffin appeared?  Great stuff. 

Ossie managed a win ratio of 54.5% but we would have been slaughtered in the Premier league playing his sort of football, as he proved at Spurs a few weeks later.  Never forgiven him for that.  He should have hung around for another year at least.

Burkinshaw was past his sell-by date and managed 23.44%.

Buckley. Words fail me. 118 games and a win ratio of 33.05%.  I am surprised it was that good. 

Ray Harford picked things up in his brief stay.  47.5%.

Denis Smith managed to return to Buckley days at 29%. 

And then we move into the exclusive sub 20% league starting with Brian Little at 19.51%.  I’m surprised it was that high.

Then Sir Gary Megson arrives at 42.53% and fair play to him,  he stuck around to have a go in the greed league and laid the foundation for the last 20 years.

Similar to yesterday, my heart sank when Alecan was appointed.  He had achieved nothing as a manager other than a reputation for drinking and building a pub team. But yet again the board fell for the style and reputation rather than the evidence of his managerial ability.

Mowbray managed 48.78% which is good considering his performance in the Premier League.

Matteo managed 49%  which reflects how well we won the championship.  His luck changed that night at Blackpool when the baby ref fucked it all up.  We never recovered from that.

Roy managed 37% which is respectable given the circumstances.  Clarke 32% which is better than I remember and Pepe Mel 17.65% which is on a par with what I recall. Yet another inspired appointment by the board.

Alan fucking Irvine and his watch surprisingly managed to stay out of the sub 20% club at 22.73%.   It seemed a lot worse than that.

Pulis managed 27.75% in 121 games.  It seemed like 1121 games at the time.  His draw ratio is also 27.5% which probably tells a story.

Pardew was as bad as we thought at 14.3% in 21 tortuous games.  I take my hat off to the board for that appointment.  How they had not worked out that the man was a complete tosser by the time they interviewed him, is beyond me.

Darren managed a very creditable 47.92% in 48 games.   What he would have gone on to achieve will never be known.  But I look at him as a person in comparison with the avaricious piece of shit we appointed yesterday, and despair at what the game has become.

Slav managed 40% from 65 games. But the writing was on the wall when it took Brentford blowing a gasket, to get us over the promotion line.  If Watkins had scored two absolute sitters against Stoke and I think it was Barnsley,  we would still be in the Championship. Let's hope he is as bad for Villa. 

As for Sam,  he will probably get us organised (needs doing) keep us up,  and take the money and run.  


I hope it’s more fun than watching a Ron Wylie,  Ron Saunders, Tony Pulis or Bobby Gould side.  But he's from the same neanderthal school of football.

Little to disagree with you there apart from the last sentence and brings back some great memories - you must be a joy to live with  Big Grin.


RE: The board's record on appointments - Baggiejacko - 12-17-2020

All this just reiterates what a difficult task it has always been to get big name quality managers here. Different eras, different boards and different divisions but always the same. It's the same in general with players.