WBAUnofficial
Small Claims - Advice required - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: Small Claims - Advice required (/showthread.php?tid=14309)

Pages: 1 2 3


Small Claims - Advice required - Duffers - 12-16-2020

Has anyone got any experience of going through them?

Long story short, I bought a car from a dealer last year. Five years old and about 33k on the clock. 8 months and 2k miles later the clutch and gearbox both go and need replacing. I paid a grand at the point of purchase for a 3 year warranty, the warranty company sent an “independent advisor” to assess and determined that the issues were “natural wear and tear” and that the warranty company didn’t have to pay. Ended up costing me £1,750 to fix. While the mechanics were there they identified another £1,500’s worth of issues that need fixing. Quite how a car of relatively low age and mileage can have so many issues through “natural wear and tear” is unbelievable to say the least.

I have been hassling both the warranty company and the dealer to recover the costs I’ve paid out so far to get the car repaired and to get a refund on a warranty that was clearly mis-sold. The dealer said the car had a “thorough inspection” before it was sold yet cannot produce any evidence of this inspection. They offered me £470 as a “goodwill gesture” which I’m pretty sure legally amounts to an acceptance of liability, but they refuse to offer anything more.

Thinking of going to small claims to try and get my money back, anyone been through anything similar?

Cheers


RE: Small Claims - Advice required - Duffers - 12-16-2020

Back page bump.


RE: Small Claims - Advice required - baggiebloke - 12-16-2020

(12-16-2020, 10:05 PM)Duffers Wrote: Has anyone got any experience of going through them?

Long story short, I bought a car from a dealer last year. Five years old and about 33k on the clock. 8 months and 2k miles later the clutch and gearbox both go and need replacing. I paid a grand at the point of purchase for a 3 year warranty, the warranty company sent an “independent advisor” to assess and determined that the issues were “natural wear and tear” and that the warranty company didn’t have to pay. Ended up costing me £1,750 to fix. While the mechanics were there they identified another £1,500’s worth of issues that need fixing. Quite how a car of relatively low age and mileage can have so many issues through “natural wear and tear” is unbelievable to say the least.

I have been hassling both the warranty company and the dealer to recover the costs I’ve paid out so far to get the car repaired and to get a refund on a warranty that was clearly mis-sold. The dealer said the car had a “thorough inspection” before it was sold yet cannot produce any evidence of this inspection. They offered me £470 as a “goodwill gesture” which I’m pretty sure legally amounts to an acceptance of liability, but they refuse to offer anything more.

Thinking of going to small claims to try and get my money back, anyone been through anything similar?

Cheers

Was there any sort of finance used in the purchase?


RE: Small Claims - Advice required - Duffers - 12-16-2020

(12-16-2020, 10:11 PM)baggiebloke Wrote:
(12-16-2020, 10:05 PM)Duffers Wrote: Has anyone got any experience of going through them?

Long story short, I bought a car from a dealer last year. Five years old and about 33k on the clock. 8 months and 2k miles later the clutch and gearbox both go and need replacing. I paid a grand at the point of purchase for a 3 year warranty, the warranty company sent an “independent advisor” to assess and determined that the issues were “natural wear and tear” and that the warranty company didn’t have to pay. Ended up costing me £1,750 to fix. While the mechanics were there they identified another £1,500’s worth of issues that need fixing. Quite how a car of relatively low age and mileage can have so many issues through “natural wear and tear” is unbelievable to say the least.

I have been hassling both the warranty company and the dealer to recover the costs I’ve paid out so far to get the car repaired and to get a refund on a warranty that was clearly mis-sold. The dealer said the car had a “thorough inspection” before it was sold yet cannot produce any evidence of this inspection. They offered me £470 as a “goodwill gesture” which I’m pretty sure legally amounts to an acceptance of liability, but they refuse to offer anything more.

Thinking of going to small claims to try and get my money back, anyone been through anything similar?

Cheers

Was there any sort of finance used in the purchase?

Private bank loan. Not financed through the dealer.


RE: Small Claims - Advice required - Beachboysbaggie - 12-16-2020

I’ve used small claims online twice Duffers, both very successfully. One claim was against TUI who just ignored me until one day they got the summons delivered. Then funnily enough they became helpful. Even big companies like that don’t need a court judgment on their records.


RE: Small Claims - Advice required - Fido - 12-16-2020

The only time I used it I was successful against an estate agent who "took over" our contract when the old one had scarpered with everyone's deposits. If they are willing to put in an offer even more of a reason to get all the evidence together and put it through.


RE: Small Claims - Advice required - MassDebater - 12-16-2020

Might be worth contacting Citizens advice or something... See if they think you have a chance.

Warranties are always dodgy. Clutch going seems unfair, and you'd expect them to last more than 35k miles, see what the manufacturer says about how long it expects a clutch to last? if it's 5 years then it'll be tricky to claim against, otherwise you should be in a stronger position to get more, if not the whole amount.

I bought a Focus in 2004, clutch had gone when I got it, was only my second car so the salesman fobbed me off saying i just wasn't used to it and maybe the cable needed tightening. Driving to Brighton it fully went whilst on the M40, that was bloody scary and half, middle lane, 70mph, wham no clutch...RAC came out and when I said what the salesman had said he laughed and went it's hydraulic there's no cable to tighten. Got to Brighton and had a right go at the dealer, they were offering me small amounts, but I then explained that the salesman had basically lied, and all of a sudden they were footing the bill. Sometimes saying the right things to the dealer can yield results, e.g. I've contacted a solicitor and they say I have a strong case sort of thing may get something in your favour?


RE: Small Claims - Advice required - HawkingsHalfpint - 12-16-2020

Did they fix the car? And was the additional work paid for? Sounds expensive!

Quite often a lot of warranties and after-care policies really aren’t worth a lot (how else would so many lemons be bought and sold otherwise, and it isn’t a new car being bought). Without being able to read this, it’s difficult to say. Many dealers know this, and that it’s a ball ache to pursue.

But it’s not THAT much ballache nor cost to pursue online, and the fact he’s offered goodwill is an acknowledgement of some responsibility. If you are confident that this isn’t wear and tear (maybe difficult to prove given the car’s age), it maybe worth sending a Letter Before Action and seeing what becomes of it. He’ll have 14 days to respond, but I guess it’s how it all hypothetically appears in front of a magistrate/process (that would encourage mediation first); hence the importance of the warranty wording.

Hopefully someone like Manc can offer better advice than me. But if I were you, given the small court cost relative to the outlay endured, I’d give it a go. It’s the price of an away day and less than an afternoon’s work to do properly, and the LBA not even that.


RE: Small Claims - Advice required - Kit Kat Chunky - 12-16-2020

(12-16-2020, 10:16 PM)Duffers Wrote:
(12-16-2020, 10:11 PM)baggiebloke Wrote:
(12-16-2020, 10:05 PM)Duffers Wrote: Has anyone got any experience of going through them?

Long story short, I bought a car from a dealer last year. Five years old and about 33k on the clock. 8 months and 2k miles later the clutch and gearbox both go and need replacing. I paid a grand at the point of purchase for a 3 year warranty, the warranty company sent an “independent advisor” to assess and determined that the issues were “natural wear and tear” and that the warranty company didn’t have to pay. Ended up costing me £1,750 to fix. While the mechanics were there they identified another £1,500’s worth of issues that need fixing. Quite how a car of relatively low age and mileage can have so many issues through “natural wear and tear” is unbelievable to say the least.

I have been hassling both the warranty company and the dealer to recover the costs I’ve paid out so far to get the car repaired and to get a refund on a warranty that was clearly mis-sold. The dealer said the car had a “thorough inspection” before it was sold yet cannot produce any evidence of this inspection. They offered me £470 as a “goodwill gesture” which I’m pretty sure legally amounts to an acceptance of liability, but they refuse to offer anything more.

Thinking of going to small claims to try and get my money back, anyone been through anything similar?

Cheers

Was there any sort of finance used in the purchase?

Private bank loan. Not financed through the dealer.

That means you don't have the protection of CCA.

Did you pay for any part of it on Credit Card Duffs, such as the deposit? Doesn't have to be the complete Balance. If so, you may have a claim against the credit card issuer.

Have you tried Trading Standards? They are usually good. Also I take it this wasn't a national franchise, or a main dealer?

Did you (or they) do an HPI check? This is normally good for verifying mileage? Also have you checked previous MOT records online, or the service book to see if this throws anything out on mileage? If you can prove it has been clocked you have been mis-sold.

Small claims might be tricky, because you can't quantify at the moment what you are claiming for. That's why I would try some of the stuff above.


RE: Small Claims - Advice required - sickParrot - 12-16-2020

As the problems arose after 6 months, the onus is upon you to prove that the problems were present when the vehicle was sold to you. 2000 miles is fuck all and a clutch and gearbox should last more than 6 years at 35,000 miles.

The independent report will be key.

Keep a copy of all correspondence and notes with times/dates of all calls.