WBAUnofficial
Time to ditch 5 at the back ? - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: Time to ditch 5 at the back ? (/showthread.php?tid=14074)

Pages: 1 2


Time to ditch 5 at the back ? - Shabby Russian - 12-07-2020

Question mark is crucial here as i don't know the answer.

Just have a feeling that this formation is not helping us at all.

I wonder if it has been introduced to give us greater defensive stability, but if this is the case it is not working at all . We give so many chances to the opposition . Only a combination of great goalkeeping and poor finishing stopped Man U and Sheff U scoring as many as Palace did.

My biggest complaint against it is that it weakens us in midfield and means we do not get good enough possession of the ball in our opponents half . The wing backs are supposed to supplement the midfield, but that;s not happening enough and in the second half hardly happens at all . It's a reason why we are scoring so few goals.

Personally i think i would prefer a 433 formation, with Perreria being one of the front 3 . I wouldn't quibble too much with 4312, with Perreria being the one. But i'm not totlally convinced that this would improve us.l


RE: Time to ditch 5 at the back ? - Dumbo - 12-07-2020

The problem for me with ditching 5 at the back is we don’t have fullbacks anywhere near good enough to play a back 4. (Except for maybe Townsend)

You make some good points though. We have no control in the middle.


RE: Time to ditch 5 at the back ? - Midget In A Pinstripe Suit - 12-07-2020

I'd go 4231.

SJ
O'shea Ivanovic Semi Gibbs/Townsend
Sawyers Gallagher
Diangana Perreria Krov
Grant


RE: Time to ditch 5 at the back ? - Shabby Russian - 12-07-2020

(12-07-2020, 10:32 AM)Dumbo Wrote: The problem for me with ditching 5 at the back is we don’t have fullbacks anywhere near good enough to play a back 4. (Except for maybe Townsend)

You make some good points though. We have no control in the middle.

I'm not sure we have good enough wing backs either.


RE: Time to ditch 5 at the back ? - Dumbo - 12-07-2020

Johnstone
Furlong Ivanovic Ajai Townsend
Livermore Gallagher Krovi
Periera Robinson Grady

(12-07-2020, 10:35 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote:
(12-07-2020, 10:32 AM)Dumbo Wrote: The problem for me with ditching 5 at the back is we don’t have fullbacks anywhere near good enough to play a back 4. (Except for maybe Townsend)

You make some good points though. We have no control in the middle.

I'm not sure we have good enough wing backs either.

Before the sending off yesterday they were the best part of our game. Townsend and Furlong have been two of our better performers this season. The debate is still up ‘if they’re good enough’.


RE: Time to ditch 5 at the back ? - Cunninghamismagic - 12-07-2020

(12-07-2020, 10:34 AM)Midget In A Pinstripe Suit Wrote: I'd go 4231.

                      SJ
O'shea  Ivanovic Semi Gibbs/Townsend
            Sawyers Gallagher 
      Diangana  Perreria Krov
                    Grant

Personally I wouldn't have Sawyers anywhere near the side.
When fit I would play Field. He's the one player we have who can play the Yacob role and shield the defence.


RE: Time to ditch 5 at the back ? - strawman - 12-07-2020

(12-07-2020, 10:34 AM)Midget In A Pinstripe Suit Wrote: I'd go 4231.

                      SJ
O'shea  Ivanovic Semi Gibbs/Townsend
            Sawyers Gallagher 
      Diangana  Perreria Krov
                    Grant

Grant over Robinson - madness - can't hold the ball up, doesn't press the defence, does nowt except may be a scorer in the box but we don't get that kind of ball in there. Utter waste of a player


RE: Time to ditch 5 at the back ? - MrFizz - 12-07-2020

To be perfectly honest i dont think it makes the slightest difference. 541, 352, 433, 631........

If you dont have enough players capable of playing at this level, you will concede goals and lose football matches.


RE: Time to ditch 5 at the back ? - Sliced - 12-07-2020

No, it's the best chance we have to accommodate defenders that aren't good enough. We need Gibbs in asap rather than Phillips.

Also our next match is probably against Man City so the only way we should be ditching 5 at the back is by adding another 3 defenders on top of that


RE: Time to ditch 5 at the back ? - strawman - 12-07-2020

(12-07-2020, 10:55 AM)Sliced Wrote: No, it's the best chance we have to accommodate defenders that aren't good enough. We need Gibbs in asap rather than Phillips.

Also our next match is probably against Man City so the only way we should be ditching 5 at the back is by adding another 3 defenders on top of that

3 more opportunities for VAR to give penalties against us  Big Grin