WBAUnofficial
This ere Covid app - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: This ere Covid app (/showthread.php?tid=13444)



This ere Covid app - coxy134 - 10-28-2020

Not sure if you lot have it or had much dealings with covid app?

I was at work a few weeks ago (16th), 2 lads came in canteen been working together all day quite closely as often you do in our line of work. I got up and kept a safe distance and left shortly after.

Got a text from worker 1 telling me on the Monday after that he tested positive on saturday 17th . His app still not telling him to isolate until 7 days later when on the 26th 10 days later worker 2 gets a text to his app to self isolate.

In that 7 days (no message to his covid app) worker 2 had attended a retirement do at work for one of our team! Now another lad is off waiting for a test.

You can see why it is spreading when the app is not working correctly/slow and people are not taking special precautions when they MAY have been in contact with a confirmed case.

In the meantime we have 3 in our team isolating while I rush around like a numpty.


RE: This ere Covid app - baggiebloke - 10-28-2020

Got the app.

Scan the QRs.

Fuck knows what it actually does.


RE: This ere Covid app - MassDebater - 10-28-2020

I installed it. My understanding would be in your scenario that worker 1 should have told the app that he tested positive...If he never told the app then the app wouldn't know, hence it couldn't go into the central database and notify others to isolate.

There's a section in the app to allow you to tell it the test results.

no system will work very well if people don't use it correctly.

I had two notifications flash up the other day, but when i went into the app nothing showed, so I'm not totally sure what they were saying!


RE: This ere Covid app - coxy134 - 10-28-2020

(10-28-2020, 09:56 PM)MassDebater Wrote: I installed it. My understanding would be in your scenario that worker 1 should have told the app that he tested positive...If he never told the app then the app wouldn't know, hence it couldn't go into the central database and notify others to isolate.

There's a section in the app to allow you to tell it the test results.

no system will work very well if people don't use it correctly.

I had two notifications flash up the other day, but when i went into the app nothing showed, so I'm not totally sure what they were saying!

He did tell the app via a code he aint daft but the app never gave him a countdown or tell him to isolate. He obviously did and told anyone with 48 hrs of his test. It took 8 days for it to start working hence why worker 2 only got his app 9 days later!


The indications you got were just to remind you the app is working


RE: This ere Covid app - MassDebater - 10-28-2020

(10-28-2020, 10:02 PM)coxy134 Wrote:
(10-28-2020, 09:56 PM)MassDebater Wrote: I installed it. My understanding would be in your scenario that worker 1 should have told the app that he tested positive...If he never told the app then the app wouldn't know, hence it couldn't go into the central database and notify others to isolate.

There's a section in the app to allow you to tell it the test results.

no system will work very well if people don't use it correctly.

I had two notifications flash up the other day, but when i went into the app nothing showed, so I'm not totally sure what they were saying!

He did tell the app via a code he aint daft but the app never gave him a countdown or tell him to isolate. He obviously did and told anyone with 48 hrs of his test. It took 8 days for it to start working hence why worker 2 only got his app 9 days later!


The indications you got were just to remind you the app is working

In that case it sounds like it is a pile of wank. The thing is, looking at the front end there is pretty much fuck all to it.

Sure, it must be processing millions of data, but that's what the powerful servers are for. The phones are supposed to be doing the distance tracking thing using stuff provided by Google and Apple, in all cases it's largely just ID 1 is near ID2 and ID3 and ID5 and ID10 etc..., do any of them have a positive result, yes then notify them, no do fuck all. Admittedly it's the sort of thing that would be almost impossible to test until it had been rolled out to millions of people. (they could even simplify the positives by just storing their IDs and only comparing for notifications with them... then as positive IDs get added then they can crunch the numbers and send out the isolation notifications to anyone whose been the same places etc..)

Also, if the app tells you to isolate you can't get the isolation payment that you can get if the phone calls tell you to.


RE: This ere Covid app - Tom Joad - 10-29-2020

Well, you don't get much for £12 Billion.....There really should be some held to account.


RE: This ere Covid app - MassDebater - 10-29-2020

(10-29-2020, 08:29 AM)Tom Joad Wrote: Well, you don't get much for £12 Billion.....There really should be some held to account.

Damn right.


RE: This ere Covid app - Stevel Knievel - 10-29-2020

(10-28-2020, 09:42 PM)coxy134 Wrote: Not sure if you lot have it or had much dealings with covid app?

I was at work a few weeks ago (16th), 2 lads came in canteen been working together all day quite closely as often you do in our line of work. I got up and kept a safe distance and left shortly after.

Got a text from worker 1 telling me on the Monday after that he tested positive on saturday 17th . His app still not telling him to isolate until 7 days later when on the 26th 10 days later worker 2 gets a text to his app to self isolate.

In that 7 days (no message to his covid app) worker 2 had attended a retirement do at work for one of our team! Now another lad is off waiting for a test.

You can see why it is spreading when the app is not working correctly/slow and people are not taking special precautions when they MAY have been in contact with a confirmed case.

In the meantime we have 3 in our team isolating while I rush around like a numpty.

WHAT?!!!!! You mean the Tories gave their mates at Serco £12 BILLION for an app that doesn’t work? Never


RE: This ere Covid app - BurleyBaggie - 10-29-2020

This is the problem with technology and people.

OUTCRY - the app will track me, know my data, government yada. Hysteria yada.

Government reverts to anonymised apple / google Framework that collects and stored no data centrally and has the minimum viable functionality for the purpose (GDPR) - which is to collect anonymised data on close persistent contacts and advise through these contacts if you need to isolate. That is the purpose of the app. If you enter your COVID status it then tells close persistent contacts to isolate. It doesn’t tell you to isolate as that information is given to you with your test result.

NEW OUTCRY: The app is useless it doesn’t do anything it doesn’t tell me enough.

I just don’t get it. Yes I work in tech but it serves a purpose and that purpose is limited by privacy and the use case it is designed for

The government has been shambolic but I’d rather vent in the right places.


RE: This ere Covid app - baggy1 - 10-29-2020

(10-29-2020, 10:57 AM)BurleyBaggie Wrote: This is the problem with technology and people.

OUTCRY - the app will track me, know my data, government yada. Hysteria yada.

Government reverts to anonymised apple / google Framework that collects and stored no data centrally and has the minimum viable functionality for the purpose (GDPR) - which is to collect anonymised data on close persistent contacts and advise through these contacts if you need to isolate. That is the purpose of the app. If you enter your COVID status it then tells close persistent contacts to isolate. It doesn’t tell you to isolate as that information is given to you with your test result.

NEW OUTCRY: The app is useless it doesn’t do anything it doesn’t tell me enough.

I just don’t get it. Yes I work in tech but it serves a purpose and that purpose is limited by privacy and the use case it is designed for

The government has been shambolic but I’d rather vent in the right places.

If you're venting in the right areas then use the right terminology - GDPR gives the 'nasty europeans have done this angle', the UK law that is equivalent and basically the same is the DPA 2018. 

Also GDPR / DPA 2018 doesn't mean that you cannot collect data on individuals and doesn't have to be anonymised, it just means that you have to be transparent what you will use that data for. If it was for the obvious reasons - contacting people only in relation to covid, then there's no issue; if they wanted to collate the data and sell to their mates then that might be the reason they do have an issue. GDPR doesn't impact on right and proper use of data.

And yes I do work in Data Protection  Big Grin