![]() |
|
5 across the back - Printable Version +- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk) +-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3) +--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4) +--- Thread: 5 across the back (/showthread.php?tid=12571) Pages:
1
2
|
5 across the back - Cheshire East Baggie - 09-13-2020 I've always said that if your players aren't good enough to play in a back four, adding a fifth not-good-enough player won't help, in fact it can make things worse. I would have said that Gibbs and O'Shea looked our best defenders, until they got tangled up and gifted an unchallenged header for the first goal - then O'Shea gave away a needless penalty. Everyone had lost the plot by then, but it's not compulsory to join in the panic. I don't think there is a functional pairing to be found between Ajayi, Bartley and Hegazi. The short term answer may be one of them with someone else, but I'm worried about Ivanovic's age. With a functional midfield in front of them they wouldn't be exposed so often. It's not just the individuals, it's the fact the Slav won't waste a place on a purely defensive midfielder. Oh for a Yacob or Scharner type! Bilic's dedication to his two-man "engine room" and his belief in Sawyers may cost us a lot of points. RE: 5 across the back - Cunninghamismagic - 09-13-2020 Yacob was great for us in the Prem when we were largely against superior sides. Sat back and broke up the play. Watching Leicester players time after time drift past a static Sawyers was painful. Sawyers looks decent when he can get on the ball and we are on the front foot. He won't get much of a chance of that in the Premier League though. I'd like to see Field start. Seems only Meggo is the only manager who was willing to play him though. RE: 5 across the back - Hopalong - 09-14-2020 We have to settle on a single defensive midfielder in my view with legs in front. RE: 5 across the back - Super_Slav - 09-14-2020 I know I will get shot down on here but it was like watching a Pulis swivelling back 5 in our 17-18 season. I hope we go back to a 4 going forward. We had zero identity on Sunday. RE: 5 across the back - backsidebaggie - 09-14-2020 (09-14-2020, 11:47 AM)Super_Slav Wrote: I know I will get shot down on here but it was like watching a Pulis swivelling back 5 in our 17-18 season. +1 RE: 5 across the back - Squid - 09-14-2020 (09-14-2020, 01:07 PM)Pickle Rick Wrote: It worked ok for us at the start of the game, but Leicester once in their stride were not bothered by it and maybe we should have switched earlier. The lack of confidence touched on by others was worrying - our 'flair' players never got going. On the subject of Pulis mentioned above, the coverage I watched from CNN/Peacock or whatever they are mentioned our attacking players and scoffed how West Brom were not well known for such things - I'm afraid the taint of TP and his style will stick with us, another legacy of his as well as relegation. I hope we can find some confidence to attack more and release this flair and be less afraid, as Leeds were at Liverpool, but time will tell. Annoying that commentators and pundits are so little interested in clubs they do not regard as 'big' that their knowledge of clubs is so ill researched and short term, but that's the Prem era for you. Hopefully Bilic can rewrite the script a bit this season, though the second half yesterday won't. In what other area of sports commentary could you get away with such lazy ignorance? We are now into our third season post-Pulis. RE: 5 across the back - Anew - 09-14-2020 Slav completely bottled it employing a back five(something I can't recall him doing in his first 12 months at the club)it was evident after half an hour we weren't playing to our strengths and worrying way too much about the opposition .we can all talk about how strong Leicester are but they were shite towards the end of last season and I was thinking maybe a great time to play them but Bilic bottled it big time! RE: 5 across the back - Cheshire East Baggie - 09-14-2020 I don't suppose Ivanovic has turned up yet (unless I've missed an announcement), but here's my theory. The 523/343 line up is to accommodate big Bran, loads of class but maybe lacking a bit of pace. If his nous gets us wins and draws against bottom half teams, we're well on the way to Pulis heaven = 40 points. If it works. I'd rather see a properly functional back four with a central midfield anchor man shielding them. I'm pretty sure that isn't what Slav intends to do. RE: 5 across the back - baggiebloke - 09-15-2020 10 across the back may work best. RE: 5 across the back - Shabby Russian - 09-15-2020 Not sure it started as a back 5. For the first 30 minutes i would suggest Furlong played a wide midfield role, and Ajayi covered the left back position. Gibbs never got as forward as Furlong did. The theory behind this is that it would allow Perreria to be more flexible and come inside. The more Leicester came into the game, the further back Furlong played, so by the second half it was very much a flat back 5 - which clearly didn't work. |