![]() |
|
If we’d beaten Villa last year in play offs... - Printable Version +- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk) +-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3) +--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4) +--- Thread: If we’d beaten Villa last year in play offs... (/showthread.php?tid=12397) |
If we’d beaten Villa last year in play offs... - Belfastbaggie - 09-05-2020 ...what do you think we’d have achieved in the PL...? Would we have attracted the kind of talent that we seem to have in the past 12 months...was our management team in May 2019 good enough...or to put it another way, are we better prepared for the PL now compared to what the position may have been in May 2019...? RE: If we’d beaten Villa last year in play offs... - albion_pigeon - 09-05-2020 Difficult to say, if Slav was our manager even with the squad I think we'd have done better than Villa. We ended the season with Shan so it purely would have been down to who we appointed. RE: If we’d beaten Villa last year in play offs... - Supamart - 09-06-2020 Obviously we will never know, however my hunch is that it worked out for the best. RE: If we’d beaten Villa last year in play offs... - Johnnykayeengland - 09-06-2020 (09-06-2020, 05:55 AM)Supamart Wrote: Obviously we will never know, however my hunch is that it worked out for the best.My guess is that it was a blessing in disguise we didn't go up. Would have been hard to sack Shan, and then I guess he'd have struggled in the prem. We were no better than a poor Villa, who spent far more than we could/ can and still struggled.. On the plus side we'd have kept JRod, and maybe bought Gayle. But he'd have then presumably been injured most of the season...! And we wouldn't have had the terrific season we've just seen, but one more Norwich- like.. But it's just guess work. RE: If we’d beaten Villa last year in play offs... - baggiebloke - 09-06-2020 (09-05-2020, 09:05 PM)Belfastbaggie Wrote: ...what do you think we’d have achieved in the PL...? Would we have attracted the kind of talent that we seem to have in the past 12 months...was our management team in May 2019 good enough...or to put it another way, are we better prepared for the PL now compared to what the position may have been in May 2019...? Good question. It looks like we are a far more cohesive Club again and the extra year in div 2 brought about no damage of note financially. Just a shame that the seals fluked staying up. RE: If we’d beaten Villa last year in play offs... - SW4Baggie - 09-06-2020 (09-06-2020, 06:32 AM)Johnnykayeengland Wrote:(09-06-2020, 05:55 AM)Supamart Wrote: Obviously we will never know, however my hunch is that it worked out for the best.My guess is that it was a blessing in disguise we didn't go up. Agree. Ousting Shan would have been incredibly harsh, and so I imagine we’d have bumbled our way into the PL and just made up the numbers. We’d have ended up still with players like JRod, Dawson, Gayle another year older, and doubt we’d have seen the likes of Ferguson, O’Shea and Edwards getting opps. Whilst losing to Villa was galling, I do think it was the better long term strategy! RE: If we’d beaten Villa last year in play offs... - MrFizz - 09-06-2020 A blessing in disguise for me. We may well have kept Jimmy and been forced to sack him before Christmas. Would have kept an aging Dawson. JRod would have stayed and been worth less now, Gayle would have stayed and been injury prone. Maybe no Pereira, Krov, Ajayi, Sawyers. No breakthrough for F****e, O'Shea. No Slav. Cant help but think it was for the best. RE: If we’d beaten Villa last year in play offs... - Johnnykayeengland - 09-06-2020 (09-06-2020, 10:13 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote:Ah ! A cunning plan!(09-06-2020, 06:32 AM)Johnnykayeengland Wrote:(09-06-2020, 05:55 AM)Supamart Wrote: Obviously we will never know, however my hunch is that it worked out for the best.My guess is that it was a blessing in disguise we didn't go up. If only I'd known leaving the stadium after the penalty shootout...
RE: If we’d beaten Villa last year in play offs... - MassDebater - 09-06-2020 I think we needed a steady season with Moore / Shan, and going up with them would have resulted in epic failure, that possibly could have made Derby's record be taken. As others said, i think that things worked out for the best long term. Just a shame about that Hawkeye feck up as that would have been the icing on top, but hey ho. RE: If we’d beaten Villa last year in play offs... - igorbalis - 09-06-2020 no one knows - but always thought it would take two seasons to turn things around, Moore should take a lot of credit, and was sorry he wasn't given 'tll the end of that season. hopefully we kick on and become established in the first division (EPL for all you yo ung uns )
|