WBAUnofficial
Do we take a long-term view? - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: Do we take a long-term view? (/showthread.php?tid=11720)

Pages: 1 2 3


Do we take a long-term view? - Pragmatist - 07-25-2020

Our recruitment policy over the coming week is going to shape the club for the next 5 years.  Let’s be realistic - we are odds on to be relegated next season.  No - I’m not waving a white flag already, but what we need to ensure is that we are in great shape to bounce back even stronger because that’s when we should be in a far better position to consolidate in the Premier League.

Our squad at present, partly through necessity, is a hotpotch of players including several who aren’t good enough for the Premier League and who are the wrong side of 30 which makes it very hard to ship them out. We need to be far smarter going forwards.  What does that mean?

Firstly, with the odd exception (we need some experienced leaders on the pitch) we need to be signing young, hungry, talented players with a very good chance of a resale value.  Our Academy has produced Ferguson and O’Shea, and Tulloch and Morton are emerging.  There are others too.  We simply have to ensure that we are better at keeping the outstanding ones than we have been in the last couple of years.  That requires good judgement - they clearly won’t all make it.

Secondly, we need to spot those young, hungry players in the Championship and below who have what it takes to step up.  There are plenty of them around.  No good waiting until they are already worth £10m because the risks are then far too high.  We need to be buying them before they get far into their 20s at around £3m and below. 

Thirdly, and perhaps most importantly, we have to spot great value abroad.  Pereira, Krovinovic, Hegazi all prime examples.  They exist - we need to keep finding them.

Fourthly, good use of the domestic loan market is vital. Players like Diangana, Brewster, Gallagher, Reed are the sort of quality that we need. All with a big point to prove. 

Finally, older players with a lot to offer who are in their last year of their contracts with clubs who can no longer afford them. Grosicki springs to mind - £800k.

That strategy leaves money available for the quality of striker who can bag 15+ goals a season in the Premier League, whether from abroad or domestic (Mitrovic for example).

If that strategy is successful then we will be regularly faced with losing players to the bigger Premier League clubs for large sums, enabling us to keep reinvesting in similar high calibre players.  For a club of our size it’s really the only way.

Dowling and his team have done well over the past 18 months.  Let’s hope they can continue over the next 6 weeks, but we need a 5-year strategy, not a 6-week one.


RE: Do we take a long-term view? - HLS - 07-25-2020

Ah, so get good players that are keen to play and improve, have re-sale value with lower wages and good value, whilst also signing older experienced players on the downward trend but can improve the team as well as using loans and the foreign market where possible.

You've done a very good job of describing how a transfer market works. Very pragmatic. <winky smiley thing>


RE: Do we take a long-term view? - baggiebloke - 07-25-2020

(07-25-2020, 07:15 AM)Pragmatist Wrote: Our recruitment policy over the coming week is going to shape the club for the next 5 years.  Let’s be realistic - we are odds on to be relegated next season.  No - I’m not waving a white flag already, but what we need to ensure is that we are in great shape to bounce back even stronger because that’s when we should be in a far better position to consolidate in the Premier League.

Our squad at present, partly through necessity, is a hotpotch of players including several who aren’t good enough for the Premier League and who are the wrong side of 30 which makes it very hard to ship them out. We need to be far smarter going forwards.  What does that mean?

Firstly, with the odd exception (we need some experienced leaders on the pitch) we need to be signing young, hungry, talented players with a very good chance of a resale value.  Our Academy has produced Ferguson and O’Shea, and Tulloch and Morton are emerging.  There are others too.  We simply have to ensure that we are better at keeping the outstanding ones than we have been in the last couple of years.  That requires good judgement - they clearly won’t all make it.

Secondly, we need to spot those young, hungry players in the Championship and below who have what it takes to step up.  There are plenty of them around.  No good waiting until they are already worth £10m because the risks are then far too high.  We need to be buying them before they get far into their 20s at around £3m and below. 

Thirdly, and perhaps most importantly, we have to spot great value abroad.  Pereira, Krovinovic, Hegazi all prime examples.  They exist - we need to keep finding them.

Fourthly, good use of the domestic loan market is vital. Players like Diangana, Brewster, Gallagher, Reed are the sort of quality that we need. All with a big point to prove. 

Finally, older players with a lot to offer who are in their last year of their contracts with clubs who can no longer afford them. Grosicki springs to mind - £800k.

That strategy leaves money available for the quality of striker who can bag 15+ goals a season in the Premier League, whether from abroad or domestic (Mitrovic for example).

If that strategy is successful then we will be regularly faced with losing players to the bigger Premier League clubs for large sums, enabling us to keep reinvesting in similar high calibre players.  For a club of our size it’s really the only way.

Dowling and his team have done well over the past 18 months.  Let’s hope they can continue over the next 6 weeks, but we need a 5-year strategy, not a 6-week one.

A Pragmatic view.

Good stuff.


RE: Do we take a long-term view? - ChamonixBaggie - 07-25-2020

It is a bit 'captain obvious' tbh Wink but I agree with the sentiment that I'd prefer to build a team that has lots of room to improve and can storm the Championship next season or that one after, rather than buying in desperation to stay up this time.


RE: Do we take a long-term view? - HLS - 07-25-2020

Something that I'd add though is that the scouting is likely already done. They'll already know which players they want and will make an offer to. The next step is waiting for the market/waiting for players to become available. Of course there will be a meeting with Bilic who will have only had thoughts in the back of his mind but the scouting process of looking for players will be 95% done. It's now over to Bilic to say what/who he wants/needs and then the negotiation team to make it happen.


RE: Do we take a long-term view? - Cheshire East Baggie - 07-25-2020

(07-25-2020, 07:15 AM)Pragmatist Wrote: Our recruitment policy over the coming week is going to shape the club for the next 5 years.  Let’s be realistic - we are odds on to be relegated next season.  No - I’m not waving a white flag already, but what we need to ensure is that we are in great shape to bounce back even stronger because that’s when we should be in a far better position to consolidate in the Premier League.

That's where failure starts. You've wound the clock back to 2002. I think we're back in 2010, ready and able to stay for the long haul. Truth is we were relegated because Peace was selling and went against his own instincts in appointing Pulis. Peace also recommended the new chairman, John Williams, who was completely incapable of dealing with the self-serving wiles of the shifty Pulis. And Williams appointed Pardew. So our demise was less to do with the football or financial structure of the club, more to do with internal club politics and board level decision making. With the right signings, there is no reason whatsoever to regard relegation as inevitable next season.


RE: Do we take a long-term view? - HLS - 07-25-2020

(07-25-2020, 08:06 AM)ChamonixBaggie Wrote: It is a bit 'captain obvious' tbh Wink but I agree with the sentiment that I'd prefer to build a team that has lots of room to improve and can storm the Championship next season or that one after, rather than buying in desperation to stay up this time.

Yes +1. My OP was a bit sarc but I do agree that it's a good idea to think about using the market to retain a solid team should we go down. Such as 08/09. Who did we actually lose then? Robbo and Greening? Both important players at the time but I don't think anyone was too bothered aside from the sentimental value.

Edit: I could add Valero, but then he never really left. Is he coming back next season?

(07-25-2020, 08:09 AM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: That's where failure starts. You've wound the clock back to 2002. I think we're back in 2010, ready and able to stay for the long haul. Truth is we were relegated because Peace was selling and went against his own instincts in appointing Pulis. Peace also recommended the new chairman, John Williams, who was completely incapable of dealing with the self-serving wiles of the shifty Pulis. And Williams appointed Pardew. So our demise was less to do with the football or financial structure of the club, more to do with internal club politics and board level decision making. With the right signings, there is no reason whatsoever to regard relegation as inevitable next season.

Aye, but expect the worst hope for the best at least removes some of the disappointment of going down, should we have made a good fist of the transfer market.


RE: Do we take a long-term view? - Derek Hardballs - 07-25-2020

(07-25-2020, 08:09 AM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote:
(07-25-2020, 07:15 AM)Pragmatist Wrote: Our recruitment policy over the coming week is going to shape the club for the next 5 years.  Let’s be realistic - we are odds on to be relegated next season.  No - I’m not waving a white flag already, but what we need to ensure is that we are in great shape to bounce back even stronger because that’s when we should be in a far better position to consolidate in the Premier League.

That's where failure starts. You've wound the clock back to 2002. I think we're back in 2010, ready and able to stay for the long haul. Truth is we were relegated because Peace was selling and went against his own instincts in appointing Pulis. Peace also recommended the new chairman, John Williams, who was completely incapable of dealing with the self-serving wiles of the shifty Pulis. And Williams appointed Pardew. So our demise was less to do with the football or financial structure of the club, more to do with internal club politics and board level decision making. With the right signings, there is no reason whatsoever to regard relegation as inevitable next season.

Whoah let’s not rewrite history we appointed Burton and Irvine, recruited appallingly in the Summer having lost half a squad for next to nothing. The players we brought in were well below the standard required and I don’t think one of those players had any resale value. We were hovering just above the relegation zone, with a deeply unpopular (or more accurately figure of fun) ‘Head Coach’ who was out of his depth until we appointed Pulis. The problems with the ‘football department’ were there long before Pulis arrived which isn’t fashionable on here to say but is a fact.

We should be looking to stay up, the idea we can build for the future is lovely but in reality most of our best players would be picked off by Prem clubs if we get relegated and we shall be left with the good for the Champ not good enough for the Prem players and start all over again. The reason we stayed up last time was because we found a bargain goal scorer in Odenwingie, had two or three players who made the step up and a certain Mr Roy Hodgson fall in our lap.


RE: Do we take a long-term view? - HeavyWoollenBaggie - 07-25-2020

Presuming that player valuations outside of the PL fall dramatically, which seems a given, will be we see more chances being given to those players vs overseas players ? There are obviously notable exceptions but the number of players making the step up from the lower divisions (particularly L1/L2) has slowed down to a trickle.

Consider our 78/79 team: 2 signed from non-league (!) Godden, Regis; 2 from Div 3 (Batson, Wile); 2 from Div 2 (A Brown, Cunningham); the rest from the youth set up (Statham, Ally Rob, Cantello, Robson, Bomber). All clubs were the same-Toshack and Keegan from Div 2/4; Coppell from Div 4, etc etc. Oh and the manager was from Div 3 as well, which definitely wouldn't happen, though it would make more sense than hiring the head coach of another PL team's Academy...

The reasons for this are numerous of course; I just wonder whether there is that quality lurking down there still and whether at more reasonable prices more chances will be taken ?


RE: Do we take a long-term view? - Pragmatist - 07-25-2020

(07-25-2020, 08:03 AM)HLS Wrote: Ah, so get good players that are keen to play and improve, have re-sale value with lower wages and good value, whilst also signing older experienced players on the downward trend but can improve the team as well as using loans and the foreign market where possible.

You've done a very good job of describing how a transfer market works. Very pragmatic. <winky smiley thing>

Yes, but we’ve ignored such a strategy by just using sticking plasters as temporary solutions.