WBAUnofficial
Ratings - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: Ratings (/showthread.php?tid=11324)

Pages: 1 2


Ratings - Cuzer - 07-14-2020

I would have taken a point pre kick off to keep it in our hands and if we can't beat Udd's away and QPR at home then maybe we don't deserve automatic but I back us to get the job done from here

SJ 7 One good punch from corner, tipped one round the post which was going wide but again from set pieces glued to his line and keystone cops defending in front of him

O Shea 7 Solid, supported the attack as he does, no complaints

Townsend 7 Tidy, good use of the ball as always, up against two tricky wingers but only founding wanting once when he conceeded a dangerous free kick

Hegazi 8* Big call from Slav but the right one, great reading of the game and excellent passing

Ajayi 7 Seems to be playing a little nervously but soild enough tonight, one big chance from a corner he saw late

Sawyers 7 Fine tonight in the end, good use of the ball, still 2-3 times he shirked his responsibilities which left us open to the counter but I guess that's always going to be him

Livermore 7 Excellent energy, was always going to get booked, seemed fired up and put in plenty of challenges, sure he'll galvanise the lads to get them over the line

Pereira 7 Struggled to stamp his authority on the game due to the excellent Harrison Reed also seemed to tweak his hamstring in the first half and did seem to play at half pace at times, still a class act though and hope he's 100% for Friday

Diangana 7 Always looked lively but end product was lacking, unlucky with chance but should have scored

Krosicki 7 Surprised he was hooked, we were all off the pace first half yet he still put the best ball in the box for us and is always an outlet

Austin 6 As always can't fault effort, one good cross for Pereira, seemed slow to react to two great crosses in 2nd half. Time for HRK at Udds for me

Subs

Phillips 6 Took a while to get going but contributed more as the 2nd half wore on

HRK 7 Better tonight I thouhgt, some good link up play and only a great challenge from Reed denied him a goal scoring oppportunity, fair to say a sharp number 9 may have buried it, we've not had one all season

Robinson 6 Struggled to make an impact since lockdown for me, decent at Sheff Wed but poor apart

Krovonivic - only a couple of minutes

In our hands, they know what they need to do, can't see QPR doing Brentford too many favours so all on to Friday and Slav is bang on why we have to play earlier than the others, SKY hoping to get a promotion party, wankers!

Cuzer


RE: Ratings - Cuzer - 07-14-2020

Hmmm fair point re Krosicki, but Diangana, Pereira and Austin all struggled first half, he also put in a peach of a cross which Austin was nowhere near

Tough being hooked and I thought it took Phillips 15 minutes to get up to the pace of the game

Cuzer


RE: Ratings - Mark E Smith - 07-14-2020

Agree with that apart from Austin. He offers fuck all IMHO. We'd have been up by now with Gayle.


RE: Ratings - Sliced - 07-14-2020

Think you're being quite generous on Grosicki, Sawyers and Townsend there.

Townsend struggled but had absolutely no protection from Grosicki, who was very very poor other than one cross. Grosicki was worth closer to a 4 than a 7 for me; absolutely no way he played better than Austin.


RE: Ratings - MancBaggie - 07-14-2020

Good write up as usual Cuz and largely agree. 

As Slice says, Gros was v poor but I do agree that Slav might have given him 10 mins 2 half before hooking him


RE: Ratings - MassDebater - 07-14-2020

7 all round. Nobody really stood out...maybe 7.5 for Hegazi and O'Shea


RE: Ratings - Tom Joad - 07-14-2020

Grosicky is a winger and every now and again, it doesn't happen for them. A 5.5 or 6 I'd say, it wasn't like he wasn't trying. Good to see Phillips getting up to the pace of the game. Could be a real threat for the last 2. Robinson a disappointment again but in his defence, it must be difficult just getting bits here and there.
Huge positives, O Shea (again!), Hegazi, Livermore and have to say, Townsend.


RE: Ratings - Fido - 07-14-2020

(07-14-2020, 06:59 PM)Tom Joad Wrote: Grosicky is a winger and every now and again, it doesn't happen for them. A 5.5 or 6 I'd say, it wasn't like he wasn't trying. Good to see Phillips getting up to the pace of the game. Could be a real threat for the last 2. Robinson a disappointment again but in his defence, it must be difficult just getting bits here and there.
Huge positives, O Shea (again!), Hegazi, Livermore and have to say, Townsend.

It doesn’t help a winger when he doesn’t get quick ball and there wasn’t much of that first half.


RE: Ratings - Hopalong - 07-14-2020

(07-14-2020, 06:28 PM)Cuzer Wrote: I would have taken a point pre kick off to keep it in our hands and if we can't beat Udd's away and QPR at home then maybe we don't deserve automatic but I back us to get the job done from here

SJ 7 One good punch from corner, tipped one round the post which was going wide but again from set pieces glued to his line and keystone cops defending in front of him

O Shea 7 Solid, supported the attack as he does, no complaints

Townsend 7 Tidy, good use of the ball as always, up against two tricky wingers but only founding wanting once when he conceeded a dangerous free kick

Hegazi 8* Big call from Slav but the right one, great reading of the game and excellent passing

Ajayi 7 Seems to be playing a little nervously but soild enough tonight, one big chance from a corner he saw late

Sawyers 7 Fine tonight in the end, good use of the ball, still 2-3 times he shirked his responsibilities which left us open to the counter but I guess that's always going to be him

Livermore 7 Excellent energy, was always going to get booked, seemed fired up and put in plenty of challenges, sure he'll galvanise the lads to get them over the line

Pereira 7 Struggled to stamp his authority on the game due to the excellent Harrison Reed also seemed to tweak his hamstring in the first half and did seem to play at half pace at times, still a class act though and hope he's 100% for Friday

Diangana 7 Always looked lively but end product was lacking, unlucky with chance but should have scored

Krosicki 7 Surprised he was hooked, we were all off the pace first half yet he still put the best ball in the box for us and is always an outlet

Austin 6 As always can't fault effort, one good cross for Pereira, seemed slow to react to two great crosses in 2nd half. Time for HRK at Udds for me

Subs

Phillips 6 Took a while to get going but contributed more as the 2nd half wore on

HRK 7 Better tonight I thouhgt, some good link up play and only a great challenge from Reed denied him a goal scoring oppportunity, fair to say a sharp number 9 may have buried it, we've not had one all season

Robinson 6 Struggled to make an impact since lockdown for me, decent at Sheff Wed but poor apart

Krovonivic - only a couple of minutes

In our hands, they know what they need to do, can't see QPR doing Brentford too many favours so all on to Friday and Slav is bang on why we have to play earlier than the others, SKY hoping to get a promotion party, wankers!

Cuzer

Criminal that Zohore and Krovinovic are not starting.  Zohore would have scored that chance HRK had because he's quicker and stronger.   And what was Austin doing ducking when that brilliant cross came in from Pereira?  Awful.  

Krov knits our play together with neat triangles and supports other players.   Sawyers and Livermore don't.  Our lone striker is stranded and the wide players isolated when they get the ball, having to beat a man and usually losing possession/getting crowded out because other players are not getting forward to support.


RE: Ratings - Lurker#3 - 07-14-2020

Johnstone: 7 - Good showing by SJ. Solid punched clearances, and did well to judge some wicked set pieces for most of the game.

O'Shea: 8 - Superb again. Loves defending, and rarely loses the ball.
Ajayi: 6 - Solid but his pace gets him out of trouble at times. Will be some defender when he learns his craft a bit more. Loses a mark for that miss.
Hegazi: 8 - Man mountain again.
Townsend: 8 - Solid as a rock today, an extra mark covering for the pathetic Grosiki.

Sawyers: 6 - not bad, just not effective. He let to ball bounce too much and got caught.
Livermore: 9 - Real captains showing. Won tackles, tracked back, got forward. At his best tonight. MoTM.

Diangana: 6 - not quite at it, bar that lovely piece of skill which draw a good save.
Perreria: 6 - Looked tired, almost gave him a 5 for the embarrassing play acting. Makes greasy look like Roy Keane when he does that.
Grosiki: 3 - Not a fan, think he is a better Cal Mac. Doesn't graft anywhere near enough. And today he was awful.

Austin: 6 - Good shift again. Never got into the game enough.

Subs:

Phillips: 7 - Made a huge difference defensively and gave us better balance. Should start against Hudds.
HRK: No impact, shit dive.
Others: not enough time.

Slav: did enough to gee us up and got us the result that keeps it in our hands.

We have to stay calm now and do our jobs.