WBAUnofficial
Ratings - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: Ratings (/showthread.php?tid=10961)



Ratings - Cuzer - 06-26-2020

SJ 7 Good handling and kicking, little to do but one of the few he’s come back strong

Furlong 6 Poor touch tonight, great energy and good in the air but not good enough tonight

Gibbs 6 Tidy first half but not getting forward nothing like enough

Semi 5 Poor tonight, should have done better with goal and sloppy in possession 

Hegazi 8* Was excellent throughout, also played well v Blues, solid with good distribution 

Sawyers 4 All our problems tonight, way too labored in possession, no forward passes and Brentford crowded him out perfectly, also offers nothing when we don’t have the ball, too lazy. My MOM v Blues but way off tonight

Livermore 4 Also very poor, doesn’t look fit and looks to me like he’s bulked up too much again

Pereira 7 Still our most likely but guilty of over complicating things at times

Diangana 6 Rusty, some flashes but not up to speed yet

Phillips 4 Good work rate but offered no threat tonight, surely has to sit out Sheff Wed 

HRK 4 Poor again but in his defense totally isolated first half, Pereira nowhere near him

Subs

Krovinovic 5 Quiet and didn’t enjoy playing so wide

Zahore 6 Started well but then slipped back into slumber mode

Harper 4 Worked hard but nothing worked for him

Robinson 4 No impact

Edwards no time 

Slav got some work to do with them after this

Cuzer


RE: Ratings - igorbalis - 06-26-2020

(06-26-2020, 09:10 PM)Cuzer Wrote: SJ 7 Good handling and kicking, little to do but one of the few he’s come back strong

Furlong 6 Poor touch tonight, great energy and good in the air but not good enough tonight

Gibbs 6 Tidy first half but not getting forward nothing like enough

Semi 5 Poor tonight, should have done better with goal and sloppy in possession 

Hegazi 8* Was excellent throughout, also played well v Blues, solid with good distribution 

Sawyers 4 All our problems tonight, way too labored in possession, no forward passes and Brentford crowded him out perfectly, also offers nothing when we don’t have the ball, too lazy. My MOM v Blues but way off tonight

Livermore 4 Also very poor, doesn’t look fit and looks to me like he’s bulked up too much again

Pereira 7 Still our most likely but guilty of over complicating things at times

Diangana 6 Rusty, some flashes but not up to speed yet

Phillips 4 Good work rate but offered no threat tonight, surely has to sit out Sheff Wed 

HRK 4 Poor again but in his defense totally isolated first half, Pereira nowhere near him

Subs

Krovinovic 5 Quiet and didn’t enjoy playing so wide

Zahore 6 Started well but then slipped back into slumber mode

Harper 4 Worked hard but nothing worked for him

Robinson 4 No impact

Edwards no time 

Slav got some work to do with them after this

Cuzer
you can say that again - simply not good enough against a good Brentford side - I don't like to single out players so I'll give the whole team 5 

Thought Hegazi should have done better for the goal - we had one shot I can remember zahore who hit the bar apart from that did we create anything of note? 

lack of creativity - Krov apart from one shit corner (our only one iirc?) did seem to inject a bit of life after he came on Pereira had his worst game for a while and as for diang - miles off the pace - did philips touch the ball?


RE: Ratings - fbaggy - 06-27-2020

(06-26-2020, 09:10 PM)Cuzer Wrote: SJ 7 Good handling and kicking, little to do but one of the few he’s come back strong

Furlong 6 Poor touch tonight, great energy and good in the air but not good enough tonight

Gibbs 6 Tidy first half but not getting forward nothing like enough

Semi 5 Poor tonight, should have done better with goal and sloppy in possession 

Hegazi 8* Was excellent throughout, also played well v Blues, solid with good distribution 

Sawyers 4 All our problems tonight, way too labored in possession, no forward passes and Brentford crowded him out perfectly, also offers nothing when we don’t have the ball, too lazy. My MOM v Blues but way off tonight

Livermore 4 Also very poor, doesn’t look fit and looks to me like he’s bulked up too much again

Pereira 7 Still our most likely but guilty of over complicating things at times

Diangana 6 Rusty, some flashes but not up to speed yet

Phillips 4 Good work rate but offered no threat tonight, surely has to sit out Sheff Wed 

HRK 4 Poor again but in his defense totally isolated first half, Pereira nowhere near him

Subs

Krovinovic 5 Quiet and didn’t enjoy playing so wide

Zahore 6 Started well but then slipped back into slumber mode

Harper 4 Worked hard but nothing worked for him

Robinson 4 No impact

Edwards no time 

Slav got some work to do with them after this

Cuzer

Agree with those Cuzer in the main, Sawyers was very poor tonight and I don't mind players having an off night but he doesn't put the effort in, at one point seemed more concerned about having lost his gum than what was happening on the pitch.


RE: Ratings - Fulham Fallout - 06-27-2020

(06-26-2020, 09:33 PM)igorbalis Wrote:
(06-26-2020, 09:10 PM)Cuzer Wrote: SJ 7 Good handling and kicking, little to do but one of the few he’s come back strong

Furlong 6 Poor touch tonight, great energy and good in the air but not good enough tonight

Gibbs 6 Tidy first half but not getting forward nothing like enough

Semi 5 Poor tonight, should have done better with goal and sloppy in possession 

Hegazi 8* Was excellent throughout, also played well v Blues, solid with good distribution 

Sawyers 4 All our problems tonight, way too labored in possession, no forward passes and Brentford crowded him out perfectly, also offers nothing when we don’t have the ball, too lazy. My MOM v Blues but way off tonight

Livermore 4 Also very poor, doesn’t look fit and looks to me like he’s bulked up too much again

Pereira 7 Still our most likely but guilty of over complicating things at times

Diangana 6 Rusty, some flashes but not up to speed yet

Phillips 4 Good work rate but offered no threat tonight, surely has to sit out Sheff Wed 

HRK 4 Poor again but in his defense totally isolated first half, Pereira nowhere near him

Subs

Krovinovic 5 Quiet and didn’t enjoy playing so wide

Zahore 6 Started well but then slipped back into slumber mode

Harper 4 Worked hard but nothing worked for him

Robinson 4 No impact

Edwards no time 

Slav got some work to do with them after this

Cuzer
you can say that again - simply not good enough against a good Brentford side - I don't like to single out players so I'll give the whole team 5 

Thought Hegazi should have done better for the goal - we had one shot I can remember zahore who hit the bar apart from that did we create anything of note? 

lack of creativity - Krov apart from one shit corner (our only one iirc?) did seem to inject a bit of life after he came on Pereira had his worst game for a while and as for diang - miles off the pace - did philips touch the ball?

Is the correct answer. He was slow to react and could have got to the ball first. I therefore don’t agree with Hegazi being given such a high rating on this thread and the other ratings thread.


RE: Ratings - TETLEY74 - 06-27-2020

(06-27-2020, 07:33 AM)Fulham Fallout Wrote:
(06-26-2020, 09:33 PM)igorbalis Wrote:
(06-26-2020, 09:10 PM)Cuzer Wrote: SJ 7 Good handling and kicking, little to do but one of the few he’s come back strong

Furlong 6 Poor touch tonight, great energy and good in the air but not good enough tonight

Gibbs 6 Tidy first half but not getting forward nothing like enough

Semi 5 Poor tonight, should have done better with goal and sloppy in possession 

Hegazi 8* Was excellent throughout, also played well v Blues, solid with good distribution 

Sawyers 4 All our problems tonight, way too labored in possession, no forward passes and Brentford crowded him out perfectly, also offers nothing when we don’t have the ball, too lazy. My MOM v Blues but way off tonight

Livermore 4 Also very poor, doesn’t look fit and looks to me like he’s bulked up too much again

Pereira 7 Still our most likely but guilty of over complicating things at times

Diangana 6 Rusty, some flashes but not up to speed yet

Phillips 4 Good work rate but offered no threat tonight, surely has to sit out Sheff Wed 

HRK 4 Poor again but in his defense totally isolated first half, Pereira nowhere near him

Subs

Krovinovic 5 Quiet and didn’t enjoy playing so wide

Zahore 6 Started well but then slipped back into slumber mode

Harper 4 Worked hard but nothing worked for him

Robinson 4 No impact

Edwards no time 

Slav got some work to do with them after this

Cuzer
you can say that again - simply not good enough against a good Brentford side - I don't like to single out players so I'll give the whole team 5 

Thought Hegazi should have done better for the goal - we had one shot I can remember zahore who hit the bar apart from that did we create anything of note? 

lack of creativity - Krov apart from one shit corner (our only one iirc?) did seem to inject a bit of life after he came on Pereira had his worst game for a while and as for diang - miles off the pace - did philips touch the ball?

Is the correct answer. He was slow to react and could have got to the ball first. I therefore don’t agree with Hegazi being given such a high rating on this thread and the other ratings thread.
Hegazi was wrong side of his man for the goal so dosnt deserve an 8 imho having said that the ball traveled past 2 other defenders and the keeper  who should  cleared before it got to Watkins, also how with 2 defenders supposedly closing him down was Benehrama allowed to get a cross in from that position(ball went between the 2 off them) should have been closed down sooner and push out to the touchline or corner flag imho.


RE: Ratings - CA Baggie - 06-27-2020

Semi should have cut the cross out, awful defending. He gaze should have never have been beaten to the ball, again awful defending. Aside from the goal we didn’t defend too bad, how many other chances did they create?

Sawyers and Livermore were terrible as were the 2 wide players Diangana & Phillips. Yet as bad as Livermore was Harper seemed to make us worse! Emperor’s New Clothesfor me is Sawyers. Neat and tidy and ticks over but we need so much more from him. Great passing stats when they’re all sideways, doesn’t score and simply doesn’t cover the back 4 defensively at all.

Periera seemed to be the only player putting the effort in. The less said about Phillips and Diangana the better. Krov was ok, nothing more and forgot Robinson even came on.

HRK fits the old saying “form is temporary and class is permanent”. He was very much on form earlier in the season. Didn’t win his battle at all. Zohore for 15 minutes looked like the player he could be and then quickly became the player we know he is.

Poor all round and I’d give Periera MoM just for trying as I suspect a few others didn’t or couldn’t for some reason.


RE: Ratings - Jack Halford - 06-27-2020

(06-27-2020, 07:33 AM)Fulham Fallout Wrote:
(06-26-2020, 09:33 PM)igorbalis Wrote:
(06-26-2020, 09:10 PM)Cuzer Wrote: SJ 7 Good handling and kicking, little to do but one of the few he’s come back strong

Furlong 6 Poor touch tonight, great energy and good in the air but not good enough tonight

Gibbs 6 Tidy first half but not getting forward nothing like enough

Semi 5 Poor tonight, should have done better with goal and sloppy in possession 

Hegazi 8* Was excellent throughout, also played well v Blues, solid with good distribution 

Sawyers 4 All our problems tonight, way too labored in possession, no forward passes and Brentford crowded him out perfectly, also offers nothing when we don’t have the ball, too lazy. My MOM v Blues but way off tonight

Livermore 4 Also very poor, doesn’t look fit and looks to me like he’s bulked up too much again

Pereira 7 Still our most likely but guilty of over complicating things at times

Diangana 6 Rusty, some flashes but not up to speed yet

Phillips 4 Good work rate but offered no threat tonight, surely has to sit out Sheff Wed 

HRK 4 Poor again but in his defense totally isolated first half, Pereira nowhere near him

Subs

Krovinovic 5 Quiet and didn’t enjoy playing so wide

Zahore 6 Started well but then slipped back into slumber mode

Harper 4 Worked hard but nothing worked for him

Robinson 4 No impact

Edwards no time 

Slav got some work to do with them after this

Cuzer
you can say that again - simply not good enough against a good Brentford side - I don't like to single out players so I'll give the whole team 5 

Thought Hegazi should have done better for the goal - we had one shot I can remember zahore who hit the bar apart from that did we create anything of note? 

lack of creativity - Krov apart from one shit corner (our only one iirc?) did seem to inject a bit of life after he came on Pereira had his worst game for a while and as for diang - miles off the pace - did philips touch the ball?

Is the correct answer. He was slow to react and could have got to the ball first. I therefore don’t agree with Hegazi being given such a high rating on this thread and the other ratings thread.
If you watch the goal Semi should have cut the cross out. The ball went under his foot. They had an identical cross in the second half which he put out for a corner.

If the rest of the team put the effort and graft Hegazi put in we may have won

(06-27-2020, 07:33 AM)Fulham Fallout Wrote:
(06-26-2020, 09:33 PM)igorbalis Wrote:
(06-26-2020, 09:10 PM)Cuzer Wrote: SJ 7 Good handling and kicking, little to do but one of the few he’s come back strong

Furlong 6 Poor touch tonight, great energy and good in the air but not good enough tonight

Gibbs 6 Tidy first half but not getting forward nothing like enough

Semi 5 Poor tonight, should have done better with goal and sloppy in possession 

Hegazi 8* Was excellent throughout, also played well v Blues, solid with good distribution 

Sawyers 4 All our problems tonight, way too labored in possession, no forward passes and Brentford crowded him out perfectly, also offers nothing when we don’t have the ball, too lazy. My MOM v Blues but way off tonight

Livermore 4 Also very poor, doesn’t look fit and looks to me like he’s bulked up too much again

Pereira 7 Still our most likely but guilty of over complicating things at times

Diangana 6 Rusty, some flashes but not up to speed yet

Phillips 4 Good work rate but offered no threat tonight, surely has to sit out Sheff Wed 

HRK 4 Poor again but in his defense totally isolated first half, Pereira nowhere near him

Subs

Krovinovic 5 Quiet and didn’t enjoy playing so wide

Zahore 6 Started well but then slipped back into slumber mode

Harper 4 Worked hard but nothing worked for him

Robinson 4 No impact

Edwards no time 

Slav got some work to do with them after this

Cuzer
you can say that again - simply not good enough against a good Brentford side - I don't like to single out players so I'll give the whole team 5 

Thought Hegazi should have done better for the goal - we had one shot I can remember zahore who hit the bar apart from that did we create anything of note? 

lack of creativity - Krov apart from one shit corner (our only one iirc?) did seem to inject a bit of life after he came on Pereira had his worst game for a while and as for diang - miles off the pace - did philips touch the ball?

Is the correct answer. He was slow to react and could have got to the ball first. I therefore don’t agree with Hegazi being given such a high rating on this thread and the other ratings thread.
If you watch the goal Semi should have cut the cross out. The ball went under his foot. They had an identical cross in the second half which he put out for a corner.

If the rest of the team put the effort and graft Hegazi put in we may have won


RE: Ratings - billybassett - 06-27-2020

You can over analyse the goal I guess. Phillips chugging back too late. Sawyers going to double up instead of covering, Ajayi and Hegazi slow to react. A deflection into attacker.

But apart from that Brentford only threatened in our box once more , that in the second half.

Defence wasn't the problem . They did a job on our wide men forced us back and our passing to get round their press was woeful.


RE: Ratings - Faggits - 06-27-2020

(06-27-2020, 08:15 AM)billybassett Wrote: You can over analyse the goal I guess. Phillips chugging back too late. Sawyers going to double up instead of covering, Ajayi and Hegazi slow to react. A deflection into attacker.

But apart from that Brentford only threatened in our box once more , that in the second half.

Defence wasn't the problem . They did a job on our wide men forced us back and our passing to get round their press was woeful.

For all his plaudits and the continued love in for him Sawyers offers nothing defensively he doesn’t understand that side of the game , he cannot track runners and when he does get himself into a position to close someone down he is easily beaten . 
As for Philips he always seems to be blowing out of his backside .