WBAUnofficial
Ivan Toney - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: Ivan Toney (/showthread.php?tid=10724)

Pages: 1 2 3


Ivan Toney - SW4Baggie - 06-12-2020

Being linked with a £15m (LOL!) move to us should we win promotion... Celtic also said to be interested.

Given most League One clubs wont have a pot to piss in,  there is absolutely NO chance of anyone going near that kind of money bidding for someone at that level.... £1.5m maybe.


RE: Ivan Toney - Lightnin - 06-12-2020

(06-12-2020, 08:12 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote: Being linked with a £15m (LOL!) move to us should we win promotion... Celtic also said to be interested.

Given most League One clubs wont have a pot to piss in,  there is absolutely NO chance of anyone going near that kind of money bidding for someone at that level.... £1.5m maybe.

It’s one of a few reasons that Peterborough are so annoyed at finishing the season early and not getting in the play offs. They were hoping that promotion to the Championship would give an automatic rise to his value so they could try to get £15m for him. They know he’s too good for them and clubs will come in but know they may only get £6m tops now.


RE: Ivan Toney - Sliced - 06-12-2020

The textbook definition of a Championship level striker. He'll be fine in that league, but no higher


RE: Ivan Toney - Peachy - 06-12-2020

(06-12-2020, 09:05 PM)Sliced Wrote: The textbook definition of a Championship level striker. He'll be fine in that league, but no higher

This. 

From what I've seen he looks just that. Lower level Champ. If we are spending £15m on a striker then I'd hope we could get more bang for our buck. A fucking truck load more!

I have a feeling there will be some decently priced deals out there this summer window and if, and it's still an if, we get promoted we could well capatalise on the current situation. 

Who knows we could even offer Villa £3m for McGinn if they ask nicely ......


RE: Ivan Toney - Gzbaggy - 06-13-2020

How would you have defined Vardy when Leicester bought him from non-league?

McGinn came from the Scottish second tier (whatever it is these days)

We bought a Premiership strike in Lambert, would we have been better buying the League One or League Two version?


RE: Ivan Toney - Fulham Fallout - 06-13-2020

(06-12-2020, 09:11 PM)Peachy Wrote:
(06-12-2020, 09:05 PM)Sliced Wrote: The textbook definition of a Championship level striker. He'll be fine in that league, but no higher

This. 

From what I've seen he looks just that. Lower level Champ. If we are spending £15m on a striker then I'd hope we could get more bang for our buck. A fucking truck load more!

I have a feeling there will be some decently priced deals out there this summer window and if, and it's still an if, we get promoted we could well capatalise on the current situation.

Who knows we could even offer Villa £3m for McGinn if they ask nicely ......

True

But on the flip side, we won’t get as much for the players we sell.


RE: Ivan Toney - Peachy - 06-13-2020

(06-13-2020, 05:27 AM)Gzbaggy Wrote: How would you have defined Vardy when Leicester bought him from non-league?

McGinn came from the Scottish second tier (whatever it is these days)

We bought a Premiership strike in Lambert, would we have been better buying the League One or League Two version?

Don't get me wrong there is plenty of merit in buying lower league players if they are good enough. I just don't happen to think that Toney is good enough. Especially at £15 million.

How much did Leicester pay for Vardy? £1m. Villa bought McGinn for £2m. Both great value for money.

Paying £15m for a league one striker is ridiculous. That is my point. It's not about buying from lower leagues it's about how much you pay.

If you offered me Toney for £2m I might be tempted to take a punt.


RE: Ivan Toney - Fulham Fallout - 06-13-2020

Let’s not forget who has come up with the £15m price tag. Mr wheeler & dealer, Del Boy.


RE: Ivan Toney - Dumbo - 06-13-2020

I’d take a punt on Toney for £5/6M. Lots of potential and pace.

A gamble for sure.


RE: Ivan Toney - Sliced - 06-13-2020

(06-13-2020, 05:27 AM)Gzbaggy Wrote: How would you have defined Vardy when Leicester bought him from non-league?

McGinn came from the Scottish second tier (whatever it is these days)

We bought a Premiership strike in Lambert, would we have been better buying the League One or League Two version?

That's not the point though. Vardy and McGinn cost 1m and 2m respectively for teams that could afford much more than that at the time.

15m is a massive chunk of our budget in a player that is unproven at Champ level, nevermind premier league if we get there. 

6m is fine, but 15m, not a chance.

If you want to compare Lambert and Vardy, then where does Ollie Burke fit in?