WBAUnofficial
The roar of a Merlin Engine..... - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: The roar of a Merlin Engine..... (/showthread.php?tid=10252)

Pages: 1 2


The roar of a Merlin Engine..... - baggpuss - 05-08-2020

Has there ever been a more stirring sound??

Enjoy!!



Happy VE day all!  Big Grin


RE: The roar of a Merlin Engine..... - TETLEY74 - 05-08-2020

Never get tired of listening to a merlin engine, Flying legends at Duxford is a delight for this as the "balbo" at the end when every aircraft that has displayed flys past in formation there is usually over 2 dozen merlin engined aircraft in the air at once, Hurricanes, Spitfires, Mustangs, it is a beautiful sight and an even better sound.


RE: The roar of a Merlin Engine..... - Solihull Throstle - 05-08-2020

One of the few things that ever brought a tear to the eye of my ex-RAF dad.

Funny how thinking of his response to that inimitable sound is bringing a tear to my eye.


RE: The roar of a Merlin Engine..... - Tom Joad - 05-08-2020

Ay it !!!


RE: The roar of a Merlin Engine..... - Cheshire East Baggie - 05-09-2020

Thinking about this today. Funny how the much-loved Lancaster is a key part of the Battle of Britain Flight - also Flying Fortress Sally B stooges around the country doing displays. But at the end of the war things were a little different.

The tactics of day- and night-time bombing over German towns and cities became a political issue. The Russians made great play of the bombing of Dresden to discredit British and American activities towards the end of the war. As the Cold War loomed, the bombing campaign became an embarrassment. Churchill immediately started blaming Butcher Harris for all of the key decisions. Aircrews were denied a campaign medal or even a clasp for the 1939-45 Star (unlike for example Battle of Britain veterans). The Bomber Command clasp was issued to the few survivors in 2013, a monument was unveiled in 2012, with as I recall quite a cacophony of opposition from pacifist groups.

So you're an ordinary Joe called up into the RAF. You could spend the war peeling potatoes or pumping up tyres at RAF Cosford, but you want to get at the enemy, pull your weight, do something useful. So you apply for aircrew, and end up as a Wireless Operator/Air Gunner, or maybe a Flight Engineer. Or maybe volunteer for pilot training and end up as a Pilot, Bomb Aimer or Navigator. If you survive training you get posted to an airfield where your neighbours are disappearing at an alarming rate. You go off on your first mission with very poor odds against returning unharmed (or at all). You have to complete a tour of 30 missions, and there's no backing out - if you can't handle the sheer terror of going out in the cold and dark, night after night, AA fire and exploding aircraft all around you, you will be hauled up for "Lack of Moral Fibre" and thrown into prison. No way back to pumping up tyres for you. If you get hit, can you get out (unlikely if you're the pilot), will your parachute open, will you get lynched by the first civilian to get hold of you, or handed over to the Gestapo who were no respecters of the Geneva Convention?

Of 125,000 Bomber Command aircrew, 55,500 were killed. Only 30% of those who started in Bomber Command came out without being killed, wounded or captured. Yes it was a nasty, dirty campaign with dubious justification (when viewed in hindsight). But these men were heroes like everyone else, the only choice they made was to get more involved in fighting for freedom. They didn't deserve to be forgotten for over 60 years.


RE: The roar of a Merlin Engine..... - baggpuss - 05-09-2020

(05-09-2020, 03:18 PM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: Thinking about this today. Funny how the much-loved Lancaster is a key part of the Battle of Britain Flight - also Flying Fortress Sally B stooges around the country doing displays. But at the end of the war things were a little different.

The tactics of day- and night-time bombing over German towns and cities became a political issue. The Russians made great play of the bombing of Dresden to discredit British and American activities towards the end of the war. As the Cold War loomed, the bombing campaign became an embarrassment. Churchill immediately started blaming Butcher Harris for all of the key decisions. Aircrews were denied a campaign medal or even a clasp for the 1939-45 Star (unlike for example Battle of Britain veterans). The Bomber Command clasp was issued to the few survivors in 2013, a monument was unveiled in 2012, with as I recall quite a cacophony of opposition from pacifist groups.

So you're an ordinary Joe called up into the RAF. You could spend the war peeling potatoes or pumping up tyres at RAF Cosford, but you want to get at the enemy, pull your weight, do something useful. So you apply for aircrew, and end up as a Wireless Operator/Air Gunner, or maybe a Flight Engineer. Or maybe volunteer for pilot training and end up as a Pilot, Bomb Aimer or Navigator. If you survive training you get posted to an airfield where your neighbours are disappearing at an alarming rate. You go off on your first mission with very poor odds against returning unharmed (or at all). You have to complete a tour of 30 missions, and there's no backing out - if you can't handle the sheer terror of going out in the cold and dark, night after night, AA fire and exploding aircraft all around you, you will be hauled up for "Lack of Moral Fibre" and thrown into prison. No way back to pumping up tyres for you. If you get hit, can you get out (unlikely if you're the pilot), will your parachute open, will you get lynched by the first civilian to get hold of you, or handed over to the Gestapo who were no respecters of the Geneva Convention?

Of 125,000 Bomber Command aircrew, 55,500 were killed. Only 30% of those who started in Bomber Command came out without being killed, wounded or captured. Yes it was a nasty, dirty campaign with dubious justification (when viewed in hindsight). But these men were heroes like everyone else, the only choice they made was to get more involved in fighting for freedom. They didn't deserve to be forgotten for over 60 years.

Don't you mean 'Bomber Harris'?
The only person I know of nicknamed 'Butcher' was Field Marshal Haig from WW1


RE: The roar of a Merlin Engine..... - Remi_Moses - 05-09-2020

For anyone interested, Wellesbourne has a Vulcan bomber XM655 based in a hanger and occasionally bring it onto the runway when they have a promotion or a scheduled show. Not as large I thought they were, but as noisy as fk?
Lookout for wings and wheels classic shows, etc - obviously when the lockdowns are removed.
https://www.facebook.com/avrovulcanxm655/


RE: The roar of a Merlin Engine..... - Cheshire East Baggie - 05-09-2020

(05-09-2020, 03:33 PM)baggpuss Wrote:
(05-09-2020, 03:18 PM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: Thinking about this today. Funny how the much-loved Lancaster is a key part of the Battle of Britain Flight - also Flying Fortress Sally B stooges around the country doing displays. But at the end of the war things were a little different.

The tactics of day- and night-time bombing over German towns and cities became a political issue. The Russians made great play of the bombing of Dresden to discredit British and American activities towards the end of the war. As the Cold War loomed, the bombing campaign became an embarrassment. Churchill immediately started blaming Butcher Harris for all of the key decisions. Aircrews were denied a campaign medal or even a clasp for the 1939-45 Star (unlike for example Battle of Britain veterans). The Bomber Command clasp was issued to the few survivors in 2013, a monument was unveiled in 2012, with as I recall quite a cacophony of opposition from pacifist groups.

So you're an ordinary Joe called up into the RAF. You could spend the war peeling potatoes or pumping up tyres at RAF Cosford, but you want to get at the enemy, pull your weight, do something useful. So you apply for aircrew, and end up as a Wireless Operator/Air Gunner, or maybe a Flight Engineer. Or maybe volunteer for pilot training and end up as a Pilot, Bomb Aimer or Navigator. If you survive training you get posted to an airfield where your neighbours are disappearing at an alarming rate. You go off on your first mission with very poor odds against returning unharmed (or at all). You have to complete a tour of 30 missions, and there's no backing out - if you can't handle the sheer terror of going out in the cold and dark, night after night, AA fire and exploding aircraft all around you, you will be hauled up for "Lack of Moral Fibre" and thrown into prison. No way back to pumping up tyres for you. If you get hit, can you get out (unlikely if you're the pilot), will your parachute open, will you get lynched by the first civilian to get hold of you, or handed over to the Gestapo who were no respecters of the Geneva Convention?

Of 125,000 Bomber Command aircrew, 55,500 were killed. Only 30% of those who started in Bomber Command came out without being killed, wounded or captured. Yes it was a nasty, dirty campaign with dubious justification (when viewed in hindsight). But these men were heroes like everyone else, the only choice they made was to get more involved in fighting for freedom. They didn't deserve to be forgotten for over 60 years.

Don't you mean 'Bomber Harris'?
The only person I know of nicknamed 'Butcher' was Field Marshal Haig from WW1

He was known by Bomber Command people as "Butch" or "Butcher". Similar reasons!


RE: The roar of a Merlin Engine..... - JOK - 05-09-2020

I must take slight issue with you Chesh. As far as I am aware the crews of Bomber Command gave Harris the epithet of ‘Butch’ to mean ; vigorous, forceful and tenacious. (Admittedly not as a term of endearment.)
This has been hi jacked in later years by those with softer sensibilities than those that pervaded in his day and adulterated it to butcher. It has been termed by cretins like Andrew Marr in his History ‘lite’ series for the terminally hard of reading and independent thought. He also used the term “Terror Bombing” infuriating those of Bomber Command still alive. 
The tit Peter Hitchens writing in the Mail on Sunday also used the term.
For a more rounded view I would suggest reading: 
Dam Busters, James Holland.
Bomber Boys, Patrick Bishop.
Bomber Boys, Mel Rolf.
Bomber Pilot, Leonard Cheshire. (If you want a pacifist’s view although he wasn’t one when originally written)
Enemy Coast Ahead, Guy Gibson. 
Air Crew, Bruce Lewis
Tail end Charlie’s, Nichol & Rennel. (Good for eyewitness accounts)
I may be misremembering but I don’t recall one instance in any of those books that refer to Harris as ‘Butcher’.
Disgracefully, Churchill and the War Cabinet hung Harris and his crews out to dry immediately the war ended even though the practice of area bombing was carried out with their full approval.

Churchill and Roosevelt also promised Stalin who insisted the Western allies continue their bombing campaign against eastern Germany to aid the advancing Soviet forces.


RE: The roar of a Merlin Engine..... - ColliersWoodBaggie - 05-09-2020

Quite a lot of civilians were killed (drowned) as a result of the Dambuster raids. 1,650, and over half were (mainly Soviet) POWs.