![]() |
|
When will the lockdown get more strict?? - Printable Version +- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk) +-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3) +--- Forum: Politics (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=5) +--- Thread: When will the lockdown get more strict?? (/showthread.php?tid=9860) |
RE: When will the lockdown get more strict?? - Remi_Moses - 04-11-2020 (04-11-2020, 10:40 PM)TETLEY74 Wrote:(04-11-2020, 10:12 PM)Swagbaggie Wrote:(04-11-2020, 05:09 PM)strawman Wrote: Interesting (if you are interested in this kind of thing, or if you are bored enough to find this kind of thing) stats comparing the current year provisional registered deaths against the last 5 year averageYes but the reason that they are comparable and hopefully will remain so, is because of the measures taken. They are not a direct comparison. In all those previous years people were just living. If they were doing that now we would be dieing. The only figure that will compare this year with a previous year is number of deaths from CV19 last year was zero. And CV19 is the same as the flu tbh only stronger and more infectious. Any other comparison is pointless. RE: When will the lockdown get more strict?? - Derek Hardballs - 04-12-2020 (04-11-2020, 08:02 PM)fuzzbox Wrote:(04-11-2020, 04:48 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: The figure of 250,000 was modelled by Imperial College London if we did not follow what other countries had done to flatten the curve. If we relax the rules anytime soon I cannot see without adequate testing of the public how it’ll stop the virus spiking again. The idea of opening schools for example before September will only put more people at risk. Fir example how do you keep a vulnerable member of a family safe if their siblings are told to go back to school? The study is valid it is the reason we are in lockdown. The only thing we know more about now is the fact the virus is more deadly to the wider population than we thought at the time... well what was reported and what the government said. If you want to lift lock down then you test the general public to see who has and hasn’t had it on a mass scale that way there is at least some certainty that we can map and isolate outbreaks and deal with the properly. Just telling people to go back to work is going to throw thousands of people of ALL ages under the bus. There of course is a balancing act to be had with the economy but We won’t be taking our kids back to school before September regardless of what anybody else says. All you will do is make the virus peak yet again. (04-11-2020, 08:02 PM)fuzzbox Wrote:(04-11-2020, 04:48 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: The figure of 250,000 was modelled by Imperial College London if we did not follow what other countries had done to flatten the curve. If we relax the rules anytime soon I cannot see without adequate testing of the public how it’ll stop the virus spiking again. The idea of opening schools for example before September will only put more people at risk. Fir example how do you keep a vulnerable member of a family safe if their siblings are told to go back to school? The study is valid it is the reason we are in lockdown. The only thing we know more about now is the fact the virus is more deadly to the wider population than we thought at the time... well what was reported and what the government said. If you want to lift lock down then you test the general public to see who has and hasn’t had it on a mass scale that way there is at least some certainty that we can map and isolate outbreaks and deal with the properly. Just telling people to go back to work is going to throw thousands of people of ALL ages under the bus. There of course is a balancing act to be had with the economy but We won’t be taking our kids back to school before September regardless of what anybody else says. All you will do is make the virus peak yet again. RE: When will the lockdown get more strict?? - fuzzbox - 04-12-2020 (04-12-2020, 12:32 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: The study is valid it is the reason we are in lockdown. The only thing we know more about now is the fact the virus is more deadly to the wider population than we thought at the time... well what was reported and what the government said. The 100 000 relates to herd without short term lockdowns. I wasn't advocating that. I'm not sure anybody is anymore. So the premise of the model in this context isn't valid. I'm not sure we do know for sure that the virus is more deadly than we thought then. Some experts say it is, some don't. We don't even know how many people have been infected and how many are asymptomatic. Without knowing this, how can we be sure? The raw figures from Northern Italy make it look more deadly, those from Germany make it look less so. We probably won't know until it's all over. Do you mean you won't be taking your kids back before September or the country as a whole? I'd be amazed if the kids and by extension their parents would be staying home until late July. That would bankrupt the government. I reckon it'll be more likely they'll extend terms into August than that. But ultimately, who knows? I suppose we'll wait and see. RE: When will the lockdown get more strict?? - Fulham Fallout - 04-12-2020 (04-12-2020, 02:25 AM)fuzzbox Wrote:(04-12-2020, 12:32 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: The study is valid it is the reason we are in lockdown. The only thing we know more about now is the fact the virus is more deadly to the wider population than we thought at the time... well what was reported and what the government said. Germany has been extensively testing and their total number of cases include those who do not require hospital treatment and are therefore a truer representation of the risk of fatality on catching the virus. 2871/125452 =2% As pointed out by Cornwall on the “pandemic, what pandemic thread”, Belarus are adopting an ignorant approach to the virus and their death rate to number of cases is 1% at present (23/2226) As we know, there is a delay between being tested positive and dying and therefore the percentages above will be slightly understated when attempting to calculate the risk of fatality. RE: When will the lockdown get more strict?? - Derek Hardballs - 04-12-2020 (04-12-2020, 02:25 AM)fuzzbox Wrote:(04-12-2020, 12:32 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: The study is valid it is the reason we are in lockdown. The only thing we know more about now is the fact the virus is more deadly to the wider population than we thought at the time... well what was reported and what the government said. We do know that deaths attributed to the virus in hospital numbers. We don’t have a very accurate picture of who has died in their own houses and care homes as those cases aren’t counted in the figures announced at the briefings. We know that 28 at least NHS Dr’s and Nurses have died. We know that 11 bus drivers have died. How many Carers have died? These deaths would not have occurred if it wasn’t for Covid 19 so what price our lives or those of our families? Currently the the Passport office is telling its staff to go back to work and quite rightly many are scared for themselves and those they are shielding for example. They are also questioning the contradictory message of stay at home if something isn’t essential and frankly Mr Jones passport renewal so he can’t go on holiday to Benidorm isn’t a priority currently. Then you have have the deputy scientific advisor saying they should go back because we are all going to get it. This is going to cause huge resentment, political fall out should those working there lose their life or those of a loved one as a direct consequence. We already have significant tensions betweentransport bosses, the unions and workers where they have been forced to work without protection and are now being advised not to work if they feel they are not safe. It’s not an easy situation but we already have a very relaxed lockdown compared to most European countries and until this is under control nothing including the economy will be back to normal. RE: When will the lockdown get more strict?? - fuzzbox - 04-12-2020 (04-12-2020, 08:45 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: We do know that deaths attributed to the virus in hospital numbers. We don’t have a very accurate picture of who has died in their own houses and care homes as those cases aren’t counted in the figures announced at the briefings. We know that 28 at least NHS Dr’s and Nurses have died. We know that 11 bus drivers have died. How many Carers have died? These deaths would not have occurred if it wasn’t for Covid 19 so what price our lives or those of our families? I don't think that's the case. Of course, that's not to say that everything's okay and we should go on as normal. Just to show that statistics can be used to backup anything (Something I know you know!) an internal model for the government has put deaths 'caused' as a result of lockdown at 150 000! I'm not saying that's accurate, but it does show the problem with statistics. Do you think that maybe this will be the way of the world now and like flu, we have to accept we can't 'solve' it? We are maybe used to living in a society where nothing touches us. Maybe this is a wake up call? Lockdown or not, is it possible that in some form or another, it's here to stay?. Perhaps blaming deaths on policy and assuming there's a way we can 'win the war' is sticking your head in the sand and not accepting the reality of the situation? RE: When will the lockdown get more strict?? - Derek Hardballs - 04-12-2020 (04-12-2020, 12:14 PM)fuzzbox Wrote:(04-12-2020, 08:45 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: We do know that deaths attributed to the virus in hospital numbers. We don’t have a very accurate picture of who has died in their own houses and care homes as those cases aren’t counted in the figures announced at the briefings. We know that 28 at least NHS Dr’s and Nurses have died. We know that 11 bus drivers have died. How many Carers have died? These deaths would not have occurred if it wasn’t for Covid 19 so what price our lives or those of our families? You don’t think that the deaths of those NHS workers, transport workers etc was a direct result of Covid 19 and their over exposure to it? No I don’t accept that there is nothing we could / can do to minimise the deaths, if this was attitude throughout history measles, small pox, Ebola would have just been allowed to fester and kill unimpeded. Where is the testing to get us out of lock down? Why were we so poorly prepared, why did we allow huge get togetherness like Cheltenham to go ahead! Why are people still being allowed to fly into the country unchecked? RE: When will the lockdown get more strict?? - strawman - 04-12-2020 (04-12-2020, 01:10 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:(04-12-2020, 12:14 PM)fuzzbox Wrote:(04-12-2020, 08:45 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: We do know that deaths attributed to the virus in hospital numbers. We don’t have a very accurate picture of who has died in their own houses and care homes as those cases aren’t counted in the figures announced at the briefings. We know that 28 at least NHS Dr’s and Nurses have died. We know that 11 bus drivers have died. How many Carers have died? These deaths would not have occurred if it wasn’t for Covid 19 so what price our lives or those of our families? Throughout history those have killed people until a cure / vaccination was created. Do you not think they are working on this - Even some cancer research scientists have been diverted to looking for a cure / vaccination against it. How long do you think it takes? - It took 7 years for an antiviral to be developed to treat aids. There is still no validated antibody test - the USA reckon another week, but we have been hearing another week for a month now. A self testing antibody test could be a game changer, but it is still not sure that immunity is created by recovering from the virus. RE: When will the lockdown get more strict?? - baggiebloke - 04-12-2020 There is always more that any government could do, and indeed do things differently. But all we can do is be sensible and adapt as things evolve. For all we know the virus could mutate and we'll all be dead in 12 months time. Time will tell. RE: When will the lockdown get more strict?? - Remi_Moses - 04-12-2020 (04-12-2020, 01:35 PM)baggiebloke Wrote: There is always more that any government could do, and indeed do things differently. Bloody hell, does this mean I won't have to buy you that pint I owe you
|