![]() |
|
Citeh Guilty - Printable Version +- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk) +-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3) +--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4) +--- Thread: Citeh Guilty (/showthread.php?tid=42871) |
RE: Citeh Guilty - Merkinagogo - 09-26-2026 I just worry for Scott Carson, tbh RE: Citeh Guilty - Even Flow 2.0 - 09-26-2026 I don't see any meaningful punishment happening. Any compensation would be chump change for their Saudi overlords and any points deductions would just delay them winning the league for a season or two. RE: Citeh Guilty - Jerry - 09-26-2026 (09-26-2026, 05:46 PM)Even Flow 2.0 Wrote: I don't see any meaningful punishment happening. Any compensation would be chump change for their Saudi overlords and any points deductions would just delay them winning the league for a season or two. If they were relegated to the championship then it would be just a blip as they could keep all their players meaning instant promotion then back to normal. If they went two leagues down then that is a problem with keeping players and F F P. RE: Citeh Guilty - Jacko - 09-26-2026 They can't go 2 leagues down, they haven't broken any EFL rules, the shout seems to be titles stripped, big enough points deduction that they are certain to go down (or just expulsion), then lesser points deductions for the next 3 Premier League seasons they happen to compete in (whatever is the old FFP max). RE: Citeh Guilty - YamYam - 09-27-2026 (09-26-2026, 08:43 PM)Jacko Wrote: They can't go 2 leagues down, they haven't broken any EFL rules, the shout seems to be titles stripped, big enough points deduction that they are certain to go down (or just expulsion), then lesser points deductions for the next 3 Premier League seasons they happen to compete in (whatever is the old FFP max). I was thinking why can't they go down a few leagues like Rangers but forgot that was due to going into administration. BBC have also reported that there's no appetite to strip titles but their reporting is nothing more than click-bait nowadays (and overly American for some reason). They don't state who told them that and end with the complete contradiction that they could be reallocated to runners-up or left "blank"! RE: Citeh Guilty - chasetownbaggie - 09-27-2026 Everton had an 8 point deduction for 2 infringements. By that measure City should be deducted 456 points. Seems obvious to me. Alternatively, dock them a season's worth of points (114) and a fine, maybe a transfer embargo. RE: Citeh Guilty - MrBater - 09-27-2026 (09-26-2026, 08:43 PM)Jacko Wrote: They can't go 2 leagues down, they haven't broken any EFL rules, the shout seems to be titles stripped, big enough points deduction that they are certain to go down (or just expulsion), then lesser points deductions for the next 3 Premier League seasons they happen to compete in (whatever is the old FFP max). hang on, the EFL don't have rules against making dodgy payments and hiding them?? Are you sure!? (09-27-2026, 08:17 AM)chasetownbaggie Wrote: Everton had an 8 point deduction for 2 infringements. By that measure City should be deducted 456 points. Seems obvious to me. Alternatively, dock them a season's worth of points (114) and a fine, maybe a transfer embargo. I think an incoming transfer ban (5 years) has to be applied whatever the punishment. Allow outgoing, so that Haaland etc... can fuck off wherever... as long as they can't buy new players that'll weaken them enough... RE: Citeh Guilty - Josh1873 - 09-27-2026 Can't the EFL just retrospectively change the rules. I know it's something a governing body would never do, but surely they make an exception here. RE: Citeh Guilty - MrBater - 09-27-2026 (09-27-2026, 09:19 AM)Josh1873 Wrote: Can't the EFL just retrospectively change the rules. I know it's something a governing body would never do, but surely they make an exception here. Only if it's us. Am pretty sure they must have similar rules on faking payments to agents, players and managers etc... then again, it's the EFL so maybe they don't. Also, if the EPL kick City out, surely there are no rules that state the EFL have to automatically accept them, and surely they'd be forced to apply for membership?? Different if there's a relegation as that's covered in the current rules / agreements, but not so sure about an expulsion. RE: Citeh Guilty - Spandaubaggie - 09-27-2026 It’ll be interesting to see how this mess is managed. I’ve read quite a few articles about it and seems they massively inflated sponsorship deals totally out of context with their brand strength to hide dirty money from their owners. This fit and proper ownership malarkey looks in tatters. Surely the first thing is the dodgy regime in charge there have to sell the club. As for Man City they can never really be truly punished as they’ve now inherited multitudes of glory hunters, many who will stick to them. Knock them down a few divisions and they’ll be back in a few years, certainly as a competitive Prem side again. |