WBAUnofficial
Wildsmith in goal - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: Wildsmith in goal (/showthread.php?tid=39579)

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10


RE: Wildsmith in goal - Birdman1811 - 12-06-2025

No idea if it was ever possible, but I'd have honestly tried to get Carson for a season, experienced head for Griffiths to learn from and wouldn't be a disaster if he needed to play.


RE: Wildsmith in goal - Even Flow 2.0 - 12-06-2025

Dropping Griffiths was just utterly bizarre. Yes he didn't have the best of games last week (TBF I might be in the minority in thinking the first wasn't his fault) but he has done more than enough this season to have some credit in the bank.


RE: Wildsmith in goal - Stillclem4england - 12-06-2025

It’s shit management: from JG’s perspective he is being blamed for recent results and the manager has lost confidence in him. He now has to give a run to the worst keeper in the league which will lead to some tonkings. I can see Sheff U getting five against us.


RE: Wildsmith in goal - Wednesburybaggie - 12-06-2025

(12-06-2025, 05:27 PM)Stillclem4england Wrote: It’s shit management: from JG’s perspective he is being blamed for recent results and the manager has lost confidence in him. He now has to give a run to the worst keeper in the league which will lead to some tonkings. I can see Sheff U getting five against us.

Not forgetting Saints midweek. Hopefully Tom can take pity on us with an own goal or two.


RE: Wildsmith in goal - Borin' Baggie - 12-06-2025

The worst thing from Wildsmith today was whatever the fuck he was doing when he gave them an open goal, if you're a defender and you can't even be confident that your keeper knows how the sweep what the fuck are you supposed to do?


RE: Wildsmith in goal - Cheshire East Baggie - 12-06-2025

I don't rate Wildsmith at all, and he was as wobbly as usual, but he didn't cost us the game.

Both Bielik and Mepham were flat-footed for the first goal and Mepham had every chance to hoof the ball in the run up to the second, but chose to play tippy-tappy and put his team mates under pressure. The third goal is down to Campbell's lapse and Wildsmith's block going into a danger area, but again I'd say that Mepham wasn't sharp enough to get near the scorer.

I still think Bielik, Phillips and Mepham are a class above any of the defenders who left in the summer (except Heggem of course), but defences need to be coached. What do they work on all week? Tippy-tappy playing out from the back, I imagine.

Oh yes, that breakaway where Wildsmith nearly lost possession on the edge of the box. As a goalie, what can you do when your centreback decides the ball can carry to you , so just tries (and fails) to hold the centre forward off? Run out and chest the ball? Where might the rebound go? Again it was Mepham's poor decision making as much as Wildsmith's uncertainty.


RE: Wildsmith in goal - baggie93 - 12-06-2025

I just find them a bunch of collectively idiotic fuckwits


RE: Wildsmith in goal - TartanRug - 12-06-2025

(12-06-2025, 05:33 PM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: I don't rate Wildsmith at all, and he was as wobbly as usual, but he didn't cost us the game.

Both Bielik and Mepham were flat-footed for the first goal and Mepham had every chance to hoof the ball in the run up to the second, but chose to play tippy-tappy and put his team mates under pressure. The third goal is down to Campbell's lapse and Wildsmith's block going into a danger area, but again I'd say that Mepham wasn't sharp enough to get near the scorer.

I still think Bielik, Phillips and Mepham are a class above any of the defenders who left in the summer (except Heggem of course), but defences need to be coached. What do they work on all week? Tippy-tappy playing out from the back, I imagine.

Oh yes, that breakaway where Wildsmith nearly lost possession on the edge of the box. As a goalie, what can you do when your centreback decides the ball can carry to you , so just tries (and fails) to hold the centre forward off? Run out and chest the ball?  Where might the rebound go? Again it was Mepham's poor decision making as much as Wildsmith's uncertainty.

Mepham is another problem IMHO. Is his attitude right? He should be more than good enough but is playing nothing like it


RE: Wildsmith in goal - Bob Fossil - 12-06-2025

(12-06-2025, 05:52 PM)TartanRug Wrote:
(12-06-2025, 05:33 PM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: I don't rate Wildsmith at all, and he was as wobbly as usual, but he didn't cost us the game.

Both Bielik and Mepham were flat-footed for the first goal and Mepham had every chance to hoof the ball in the run up to the second, but chose to play tippy-tappy and put his team mates under pressure. The third goal is down to Campbell's lapse and Wildsmith's block going into a danger area, but again I'd say that Mepham wasn't sharp enough to get near the scorer.

I still think Bielik, Phillips and Mepham are a class above any of the defenders who left in the summer (except Heggem of course), but defences need to be coached. What do they work on all week? Tippy-tappy playing out from the back, I imagine.

Oh yes, that breakaway where Wildsmith nearly lost possession on the edge of the box. As a goalie, what can you do when your centreback decides the ball can carry to you , so just tries (and fails) to hold the centre forward off? Run out and chest the ball?  Where might the rebound go? Again it was Mepham's poor decision making as much as Wildsmith's uncertainty.

Mepham is another problem IMHO. Is his attitude right? He should be more than good enough but is playing nothing like it
He’s pretty bad, lets too many balls bounce and his clearances are gash. Awful defending for the missed sitter, but he does it often it wasn’t a one off. Far more to blame than Wildsmith in that instance because he had chance to take control, the ball was never reaching the keeper.
Campbell same with the third, could have put it out for a throw or, at worst, bought him down, instead just got bullied. It was then Mepham who allowed the ball into the box and Wildshit palmed it with his Marigold hands.
3 fatal errors in o e passage of play. Shit players or shit coaching, or both?


RE: Wildsmith in goal - Peachofacross - 12-06-2025

(12-06-2025, 05:52 PM)TartanRug Wrote:
(12-06-2025, 05:33 PM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: I don't rate Wildsmith at all, and he was as wobbly as usual, but he didn't cost us the game.

Both Bielik and Mepham were flat-footed for the first goal and Mepham had every chance to hoof the ball in the run up to the second, but chose to play tippy-tappy and put his team mates under pressure. The third goal is down to Campbell's lapse and Wildsmith's block going into a danger area, but again I'd say that Mepham wasn't sharp enough to get near the scorer.

I still think Bielik, Phillips and Mepham are a class above any of the defenders who left in the summer (except Heggem of course), but defences need to be coached. What do they work on all week? Tippy-tappy playing out from the back, I imagine.

Oh yes, that breakaway where Wildsmith nearly lost possession on the edge of the box. As a goalie, what can you do when your centreback decides the ball can carry to you , so just tries (and fails) to hold the centre forward off? Run out and chest the ball?  Where might the rebound go? Again it was Mepham's poor decision making as much as Wildsmith's uncertainty.

Mepham is another problem IMHO. Is his attitude right? He should be more than good enough but is playing nothing like it

Said it for the last four or five weeks Tartan. He's had a very poor season yet seems to be a Mason favourite. Campbell was head and shoulders a better centre half in our opening games than Mepham has ever been.