WBAUnofficial
This season tells me one thing… - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: This season tells me one thing… (/showthread.php?tid=39299)

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9


RE: This season tells me one thing… - Derek Hardballs - 11-10-2025

(11-10-2025, 01:55 PM)CA Baggie Wrote: Dekka, you allowed the fact you don’t like/rate him to want rid at the first opportunity.  No leeway at all, you just wanted to be right.

And in this very thread you’re accusing people of not wanting this manager because he wasn’t their choice and not giving anyway just so they can be proven right.

Because one manger has over twenty year career to be judged upon and the other 14 games. One had far better resources at his disposal when he had his best spell in his career with us and the other is having to piece together a squad on I would imagine the lowest budget we’ve had relatively speaking since Megson performed a miracle. 

Which manager is in more need of patience? TM or a rookie Mason?


RE: This season tells me one thing… - Jacko - 11-10-2025

(11-10-2025, 02:10 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(11-10-2025, 01:55 PM)CA Baggie Wrote: Dekka, you allowed the fact you don’t like/rate him to want rid at the first opportunity.  No leeway at all, you just wanted to be right.

And in this very thread you’re accusing people of not wanting this manager because he wasn’t their choice and not giving anyway just so they can be proven right.

Because one manger has over twenty year career to be judged upon and the other 14 games. One had far better resources at his disposal when he had his best spell in his career with us and the other is having to piece together a squad on I would imagine the lowest budget we’ve had relatively speaking since Megson performed a miracle. 

Which manager is in more need of patience? TM or a rookie Mason?

Both.

Edit. Sorry I meant neither.


RE: This season tells me one thing… - CA Baggie - 11-10-2025

(11-10-2025, 02:10 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(11-10-2025, 01:55 PM)CA Baggie Wrote: Dekka, you allowed the fact you don’t like/rate him to want rid at the first opportunity.  No leeway at all, you just wanted to be right.

And in this very thread you’re accusing people of not wanting this manager because he wasn’t their choice and not giving anyway just so they can be proven right.

Because one manger has over twenty year career to be judged upon and the other 14 games. One had far better resources at his disposal when he had his best spell in his career with us and the other is having to piece together a squad on I would imagine the lowest budget we’ve had relatively speaking since Megson performed a miracle. 

Which manager is in more need of patience? TM or a rookie Mason?

All I'm reading is you trying to justify why you wouldn't provide an Albion manager with any patience, because you didn't want him, yet slagging other people off for not giving any patience to a manager you're claiming they didn't want.

The hypocrisy is something to behold.


RE: This season tells me one thing… - Derek Hardballs - 11-10-2025

(11-10-2025, 02:34 PM)CA Baggie Wrote:
(11-10-2025, 02:10 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(11-10-2025, 01:55 PM)CA Baggie Wrote: Dekka, you allowed the fact you don’t like/rate him to want rid at the first opportunity.  No leeway at all, you just wanted to be right.

And in this very thread you’re accusing people of not wanting this manager because he wasn’t their choice and not giving anyway just so they can be proven right.

Because one manger has over twenty year career to be judged upon and the other 14 games. One had far better resources at his disposal when he had his best spell in his career with us and the other is having to piece together a squad on I would imagine the lowest budget we’ve had relatively speaking since Megson performed a miracle. 

Which manager is in more need of patience? TM or a rookie Mason?

All I'm reading is you trying to justify why you wouldn't provide an Albion manager with any patience, because you didn't want him, yet slagging other people off for not giving any patience to a manager you're claiming they didn't want.

The hypocrisy is something to behold.

I have always owned my bias against TM, it is based on rational criticism and always has been. Never shied away from it or been embarrassed by it. 

Mason is a rookie manager, with less resources than any manager since Megson. He’s not a manager with 30 odd years in management with a record we can all judge one way or the other. I’m happy with the distinction and due to where the club is currently and where the manager is in his career I’m happy to give more time to the latter than the former. 

Btw I don’t recall me starting Mowbray out threads, or polls on his next successor or even commenting on his after game thoughts. Just to point out some of the OTT criticism Mason has received for a handful of games managed during a period of readjustment for the club.


RE: This season tells me one thing… - SW4Baggie - 11-10-2025

(11-10-2025, 11:26 AM)richbaggie Wrote:
(11-10-2025, 11:05 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(11-10-2025, 08:49 AM)richbaggie Wrote: There's a really good comparison that could be made between Mason and Kieran McKenna at Ipswich. Both retired young due to injury and went down the coaching route and achieved the highest coaching badges available. Both picked up first jobs at relatively big clubs albeit Ipswich a division below but both rebooting with new owners.

I took a look at his start earlier. After a flying start in his first few games, they then struggled and tailed off in 2021. They had an awful start the season after and they wanted him out but they stuck with and they finished 11th. They then went on an incredible run as we know.

Now, I'm not saying Mason is as good as him. I genuinely don't know yet. I would imagine that he's had so many ideas flowing through his head these past few years of how he wants teams to play and how he would manage people. Hes now finding out which ideas work and what don't. He has and will continue to make mistakes because of his inexperience. At the moment, I am more relaxed than most in letting it play out, seeing if he can develop. Who knows, he may go the same way as Kieran McKenna or he might not have it in him to be a no.1. Give him time to find out....within reason.

Not sure this is entirely true Rich.... McKenna came in during the 21/22 season when Ipswich were struggling in League One - they went on a fantastic run almost immediately after he arrived but it wasn't enough for them to get close to the playoffs, and their form petered out in the final month or so when they were 10+ points adrift of the top 6. The following season they won promotion to the Championship and then to the PL the year after.

The difference here is that McKenna had an immediate impact at Ipswich - he turned round a struggling team and improved individuals to the point where many of the squad that was in the bottom half of League One were playing in the PL less than 3 years later. 

I'm not sure he's ever been under any pressure from their fans other than a couple of weeks ago when they were struggling to find their feet in the Championship. 

Whilst it's fair to compare McKenna and Mason from a playing career cut short and coaching perspective, I think they're poles apart in how they have adapted to management.

I got the follow up season wrong having looked again but his first season was mixed. He won 6 of his first 8 but then only 5 of the last 15 which saw them fall away badly. So I think the point still stands. Early impact followed by a drop off. They stuck with him despite that and reaped the rewards the following year as he grew into the role.

I’d imagine the reviews were relatively positive still, Ipswich had been struggling in that division for a while and he was the first manager they’d had that delivered an impact.

Mason hasn’t really improved on the last couple seasons, hence the criticism.