![]() |
|
Molomby - Printable Version +- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk) +-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3) +--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4) +--- Thread: Molomby (/showthread.php?tid=38959) |
RE: Molomby - Josh1873 - 10-09-2025 Nearly somehow clinched a play-off place in 2022/23 with Molumby as a regular, despite Bruce having us bottom of the Champion. Reaching the play-offs with Molumby in 2023/24 as a regular. Should have been a play-off position last season but for an inept manager with Molumby 2024/25. There's no reason why we can't have a play-off push this season with Molumby as a regular. Where has this narrative come from that a team containing Molumby can't make the play-offs or have success? It's without any evidence, and it's an unreasonable assumption. I am not saying he's a top quality player that suddenly elevates a team, however I'm really not sure what games people have been watching if they seriously believe he's as bad as they're making out. RE: Molomby - Squid - 10-09-2025 (10-09-2025, 09:57 PM)Josh1873 Wrote: Nearly somehow clinched a play-off place in 2022/23 with Molumby as a regular, despite Bruce having us bottom of the Champion. All facts. I get that Coventry look a cut above, but no other team does. This idea that we'll be lucky to finish 10th doesn't have much basis in fact. RE: Molomby - Lurker#3 - 10-10-2025 (10-09-2025, 09:57 PM)Josh1873 Wrote: . I won't reply to the others parts because SW4 has boxed them off. But this bit. It's not that a team with him couldn't finish in the top 6. It's the fact that our team, with it's current balance will not. Then you have to look at the options we have, and where do we make the adjustments we need to be more threatening? We don't have any attacking fullbacks, so we need to look after midfield. Mowatt is our best player at recycling possession and progressing us up the pitch. He also crosses the ball more than most CMs in the league, and crosses from those deeper central areas are more dangerous than those from wide quite often these days. So he take that role from the start over JM. In his brief stints, Collyer has won more tackles, challenges and made more interceptions than anyone else in our midfield and often in the team, per 90. So he's a better option defensively. With Diakite in second. I still believe we need to, especially against lesser teams, play Price deeper and will die on this hill till we try it, but in the absence of such ambition we need to get the balance right. Against stubborn teams: Griffiths Gilchrist Bielik Mepham Styles Price Mowatt SIJ Maja Johnston Heggebo Against comparative teams: Griffiths Gilchrist Phillips Mepham Styles Collyer Mowatt SIJ Price Johnston Maja/Heggebo Then to really up the ante, you can put SIJ at LB and add another attacking threat if you really need to open up in games. Then of course you can tighten things up from any of these sets ups without ever going more defensive than we have often set up from the start in games. RE: Molomby - SW4Baggie - 10-10-2025 (10-09-2025, 09:57 PM)Josh1873 Wrote: Nearly somehow clinched a play-off place in 2022/23 with Molumby as a regular, despite Bruce having us bottom of the Champion. So what you're saying is that Molumby has been with us for 3 seasons, and in the season where he made by far the fewest number of appearances we finished in the top 6 (he played half of our games), yet in the 2 seasons where he played 43 and 37 games, we didn't make the top 6. So there's no reason why we can't attempt the playoffs with him in the side, and as Lurker says, it's not impossible for a team containing JM to do so, but the stats suggest it's unlikely that one will. RE: Molomby - Josh1873 - 10-10-2025 "It's not that a team with him couldn't finish in the top 6. It's the fact that our team, with it's current balance will not." Lurker That's not Molumby's fault. I'm addressing the criticism of him as a player, which is ridiculously unfair - not the balance of the team. Ideally I'd love to see a midfield duo of Mowatt and a more creative player, but we don't have that luxury. If you were to send an anonymous survey to the 23 other teams in this league and ask whether they'd want Molumby in their squad, and whether he'd be a regular starter, I bet there would be a good deal of teams that would say "yes" to starter, and I'd be surprised if any team said "no" to him being a member of their squad. He has flaws, and he's far from perfect, and probably warrants some levels of criticism, I'm not denying that, but to be criticised to the extent he has, particularly by AJ21, is borderline disrespectful. RE: Molomby - Birdman1811 - 10-10-2025 Molumby is what he is. A shithouse in midfield that disrupts the opposition, gets under their skin and is generally a pain in the ass to play against. He isn't however a good footballer at this level, so he's neither a good defender nor attacker, he does the basics then acts as a disruptive influence on the opposition. Managers like having a player like that in the squad, our issue is that he's having to be a regular starter, rather than used to start in games we need him (Stoke etc) and a sub to disrupt a team later in the game if they're starting to overrun us. Thing is, Mowatt doesn't do enough to the opposition defensively to be our defensive midfielder and lacks fitness and energy to be that man all game, every game, like Molumby who has Duracell batteries stuck up his ass. If we could merge Mowatt and Molumby together we could have a great player. We have so few creative outlets, and no line up anyone has put on here gives us more that doesn't leave us ridiculously overrun, especially in central midfield, that's the issue with our squad. RE: Molomby - Derek Hardballs - 10-10-2025 (10-10-2025, 08:35 AM)Birdman1811 Wrote: Molumby is what he is. A shithouse in midfield that disrupts the opposition, gets under their skin and is generally a pain in the ass to play against. Exactly… for whatever reason we didn’t concentrate this window on central midfield, so we have very little choice in who we play there that will make a huge difference to us creatively. I am at a loss why given this knowledge fans are surprised he’s chosen or why he’s chosen for games. Until we have better he will be a regular in the team. RE: Molomby - Birdman1811 - 10-10-2025 Indeed Derek. I do believe we thought we'd get 20 million for Fellows, which would have allowed a more thorough rebuild, instead we rebuilt the defense and ran out of money, that was the issue. The argument becomes should we have split the rebuild version a few areas or convention one as we did and accept promotion is still a long way away? Neither is right or wrong tbh. RE: Molomby - SW4Baggie - 10-10-2025 (10-10-2025, 08:57 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:(10-10-2025, 08:35 AM)Birdman1811 Wrote: Molumby is what he is. A shithouse in midfield that disrupts the opposition, gets under their skin and is generally a pain in the ass to play against. Who is expressing surprise? Disappointment maybe, but most understand why he’s in the team. For the most part we are saying it’s frustrating we are still in a situation where we are having to select him, as the facts suggest we won’t make the playoffs if he continues to be on of the first names on the team sheet. RE: Molomby - Tom Joad 25 - 10-10-2025 (10-10-2025, 10:00 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote:Recent finishes suggest if we do keep selecting him we will be top 10 minimum. FWIW, I reckon we'll see more of Toby C as the season goes on. He seems to play at a faster pace to the others. As for not doing the rebuild of midfield, we've added TC to Bany and Price on top of signing Diakite last year. Most need to push for their place. It's a long season and I'll be amazed if we finish it with the team that started in August.(10-10-2025, 08:57 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:(10-10-2025, 08:35 AM)Birdman1811 Wrote: Molumby is what he is. A shithouse in midfield that disrupts the opposition, gets under their skin and is generally a pain in the ass to play against. |