WBAUnofficial
Reform Conference - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: Politics (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=5)
+--- Thread: Reform Conference (/showthread.php?tid=38626)

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16


RE: Reform Conference - Protheroe - 04-02-2026

(04-02-2026, 09:16 AM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: Would you pay a senior engineering manager in the energy sector with a head of policy portfolio more than £65k, yes or no? Because that's what Ofgem and DESNZ pay. I know the same level of expertise nets you £150k minimum at Exxon.

In the job I took immediately after leaving the public sector I extracted OFGEM from a mess of their own making on Hagley Road for the princely sum of several £million, and saved the public purse several million more on the initial Landlord offer their senior managers had recommended for acceptance.

High paid senior public sector positions make up a tiny proportion of overall public sector roles. Comparing the role of a state employee with an Exxon executive is rather bizarre. My dead uncle was a nuclear physicist, I'm sure he could have earned far more in say, Iran - but he chose to become a physics teacher after a decade working on building nuclear power stations.


RE: Reform Conference - Borin' Baggie - 04-02-2026

Thanks for avoiding the question with an irrelevant anecdote nobody but you gives two shits about. I'll repeat it for you though so you can answer it this time:

Would you pay a senior engineering manager in the energy sector with a head of policy portfolio more than £65k, yes or no?

And comparing winding down later in your career to going to fucking Iran in a comparison between two London-based office jobs in the same sector with flexible working arrangements is hilariously obtuse and disingenuous. And I'm not on about an executive, I'm on about a senior engineering manager with a head of policy portfolio at Ofgem or DESNZ vs Exxon. Two equivalent and directly transferable roles.


RE: Reform Conference - Gzbaggy - 04-02-2026

You implied his Teacher Pension (TP) constituted the great majority of his 65K per annum pension, with a 12K state pension you imply over 50K. If he was a Physics Teacher this is highly unlikely/impossible, you also say he worked for ten years before entering teaching. Assumedly he had other pensions


RE: Reform Conference - Protheroe - 04-02-2026

(04-02-2026, 09:49 AM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: Thanks for avoiding the question with an irrelevant anecdote nobody but you gives two shits about. I'll repeat it for you though so you can answer it this time:

Would you pay a senior engineering manager in the energy sector with a head of policy portfolio more than £65k, yes or no?

And comparing winding down later in your career to going to fucking Iran in a comparison between two London-based office jobs in the same sector with flexible working arrangements is hilariously obtuse and disingenuous. And I'm not on about an executive, I'm on about a senior engineering manager with a head of policy portfolio at Ofgem or DESNZ vs Exxon. Two equivalent and directly transferable roles.

Did you "wind down" at 35? Do your think teaching is "winding down"? Fuck me, did you go to a school in East London in the 70s and 80s?

The anecdote is not unrelated. The twat who got OFGEM into that mess was paid (at that time) two and a half times what I was, which illustrates the well renumerated and excessively pensioned useless fuckers that populate much of regulator sector.


RE: Reform Conference - Borin' Baggie - 04-02-2026

(04-02-2026, 10:43 AM)Protheroe Wrote:
(04-02-2026, 09:49 AM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: Thanks for avoiding the question with an irrelevant anecdote nobody but you gives two shits about. I'll repeat it for you though so you can answer it this time:

Would you pay a senior engineering manager in the energy sector with a head of policy portfolio more than £65k, yes or no?

And comparing winding down later in your career to going to fucking Iran in a comparison between two London-based office jobs in the same sector with flexible working arrangements is hilariously obtuse and disingenuous. And I'm not on about an executive, I'm on about a senior engineering manager with a head of policy portfolio at Ofgem or DESNZ vs Exxon. Two equivalent and directly transferable roles.

Did you "wind down" at 35? Do your think teaching is "winding down"? Fuck me, did you go to a school in East London in the 70s and 80s?

The anecdote is not unrelated. The twat who got OFGEM into that mess was paid (at that time) two and a half times what I was, which illustrates the well renumerated and excessively pensioned useless fuckers that populate much of regulator sector.

Being deliberately obtuse again, the anecdote has fuck all relevance. You're flailing to avoid answering the question by talking about something that is specifically not an engineering management and energy policy role that is transferable between the public and private sector. Answer the question, do you think a senior engineering manager with a head of policy portfolio is worth £65k or not, yes or no.

And bloody hell, put a sock in it. You framed it as though he stood back from a research position to teaching later in his career, I've seen that aplenty especially with regards to sixth-form teaching and lecturing. It's still an irrelevant and disingenuous comparison as I'm referring to two directly comparable and transferable positions.


RE: Reform Conference - Protheroe - 04-02-2026

And I'm talking about the civil service as a whole. We can all find outliers Dear.

In direct answer to the question, it illustrates how truly fucked up the public sector actually is if you're suggesting it's an important enough role not being paid enough, when I know the guy who saw out his time as "Head Of Station Development" for HS2 when he'd never developed anything in his life, let alone a station - on £135K plus benefits. Riddle me that.


RE: Reform Conference - Borin' Baggie - 04-02-2026

Are you labouring under the impression that I'm enamoured at the competency of the Civil Service or something? I work with the Civil Service, I am currently bashing my head against a brick wall trying to find out why some mid-career Civil Servant with no background in energy but has moved sideways from a different, non-technical department thinks that an at best £50 annual cut in energy bills via a right-wing Westminster bubble policy is better than something that is projected to offset bills by at least a magnitude more than that.

Government is crucial in setting the direction for the energy sector both through regulatory framework and general policy and industrial strategy. Numerous utilities, large critical infrastructure, critical natural resources and geopolitical constraints fall under it. If you don't have the best people internally you're reliant on expensive contractors and secondments from industry, currently those two departments function primarily as a business you join for two to three years to pad out your CV by working on a huge cross-sectional policy area before going back into industry for the same job at much higher pay yet with most of the flexible working benefits retained because it's 2026 and the private sector is generally quite pragmatic in attracting and retaining talent.

If you want the best and brightest to join the Civil Servant you need the Civil Service to recruit more like the private sector especially for management roles and that not only means being more ruthless with job security to incentivise hard work but also pay and benefits because why the fuck anyone with any ambition would bother with the pay in the civil service with benefits that aren't much if any better than can be managed in the private sector these days is beyond me.


RE: Reform Conference - Protheroe - 04-02-2026

I was with you until you wrote "anyone with any ambition"...


RE: Reform Conference - Borin' Baggie - 04-02-2026

You don't think the Civil Service should try to recruit people with ambition? You think that they should just focus on people using them as a CV bolster or to coast?


RE: Reform Conference - Protheroe - 04-02-2026

I don't think many ambitious people gravitate towards the blob as a long term gig in the first place BB, unless they're using it as a stepping stone as you described.

Culturally my interactions with let's say the HMRC and any decent Tax Consultant have been like chalk and cheese. I wouldn't have so much of a problem with the Civil Service pensions had the majority of civil servants spent their time actually enabling the public good, rather than doing their level best to frustrate it.