WBAUnofficial
Francois Chesnais - been looking at training ground - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: Francois Chesnais - been looking at training ground (/showthread.php?tid=30788)

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21


RE: Francois Chesnais - been looking at training ground - MancBaggie - 08-10-2023

It does not particularly affect our sale prospects etc.  

Whoever ends up acquiring us will (as per the norm) buy the shares in Holdings from Yunyai/ Warmfront and therefore acquire the subsidiaries.  The Buyer will require the Sellers to discharge the secured loans from the sale proceeds on Completion.  The historical/ current security holders should therefore be removed. 

We are all guessing on whether a sale is currently proceeding and whether it’s the French guy. But the chances are we couldn’t do much worse than the current lot.


RE: Francois Chesnais - been looking at training ground - WorcsWBA - 08-10-2023

Sorry for the straight cross-post from .com, but this is better verbatim as it can't easily be paraphrased. The comments below were posted by someone who's a leading member of A4A:

"Just a couple of things. There is no default on the Warmfront loan, however that £2m loan is now due in February 2024 and will be over £4m as we agreed to terms of 5% interest per MONTH. 79% APR. What we were intimating is that a partial sale, be it a minority investment, or potentially to offset an outstanding loan would be disastrous as it makes it even more difficult to achieve what we need, which is a full sale. I will post a tweet we compiled earlier on here.

it’s very important that people read and understand why a partial sale is not good, let's break down what we see as the key points:

- Partial sale means current majority shareholder sells some shares, but retains control.
- Unlike Blues who had many different owners, we have one, Yunyi, controlled by Lai, owning 88%.

Questions arise regarding partial sale:

1. Who and why would anyone invest partially in Albion?
2. Is there a guarantee the club will receive the funds from a partial sale ?
3. Will potential buyers face a more complicated process? (yes, we think so)
4. Would funds from a partial sale create real impact? Yunyi considers 'market value offers' at £30m for full shares sale.

So, 10% (equivalent to £3m) from partial sale seems small, considering Yunyi's valuation.
A mere drop in the ocean.

A minority stake sale also means no fit and proper persons test is needed as it’s less than threshold required."

Obviously there's no guarantee that he's right about everything, but A4A do have their ears close to the ground.


RE: Francois Chesnais - been looking at training ground - CaptainFantastico - 08-10-2023

That’s about it with a couple of slight variations


RE: Francois Chesnais - been looking at training ground - MancBaggie - 08-10-2023

Unless it is some sort of publicity stunt, you will struggle to find a potential buyer who would want a minority shareholding. 

Commercially, it is very unlikely as not many investors would put money in without legal control (especially given the mess Yunyai have made to date)


RE: Francois Chesnais - been looking at training ground - CaptainFantastico - 08-10-2023

From what I can understand Manc this is more a potential attempt to acquire a portion more cheaply than it may be worth a short(ish) time later but that would be sufficient to be needed or preferable to a full buyer.

No doubt people like BB and Prag can make a better assessment of such things


RE: Francois Chesnais - been looking at training ground - Pragmatist - 08-10-2023

(08-10-2023, 09:27 PM)CaptainFantastico Wrote: The above is right but the situation with the 2.35% and how the debt is settled is more complicated than that because of the broadly shady nature of our owners

How does it differ from the loan security described in the Notes to the Accounts?


RE: Francois Chesnais - been looking at training ground - MancBaggie - 08-10-2023

(08-10-2023, 09:57 PM)CaptainFantastico Wrote: From what I can understand Manc this is more a potential attempt to acquire a portion more cheaply than it may be worth a short(ish) time later but that would be sufficient to be needed or preferable to a full buyer.

No doubt people like BB and Prag can make a better assessment of such things

Unless it’s a minority purchase with an option to acquire the majority within a certain option period. It’s unlikely though - an acquisition of the vast majority in one tranche is more usual and likely


RE: Francois Chesnais - been looking at training ground - CaptainFantastico - 08-10-2023

(08-10-2023, 10:07 PM)Pragmatist Wrote:
(08-10-2023, 09:27 PM)CaptainFantastico Wrote: The above is right but the situation with the 2.35% and how the debt is settled is more complicated than that because of the broadly shady nature of our owners

How does it differ from the loan security described in the Notes to the Accounts?

I doubt that it does - but the 2.35% isn’t the only portion here purportedly involved in what’s going on


RE: Francois Chesnais - been looking at training ground - Pragmatist - 08-10-2023

(08-10-2023, 09:44 PM)WorcsWBA Wrote: Sorry for the straight cross-post from .com, but this is better verbatim as it can't easily be paraphrased. The comments below were posted by someone who's a leading member of A4A:

"Just a couple of things. There is no default on the Warmfront loan, however that £2m loan is now due in February 2024 and will be over £4m as we agreed to terms of 5% interest per MONTH. 79% APR. What we were intimating is that a partial sale, be it a minority investment, or potentially to offset an outstanding loan would be disastrous as it makes it even more difficult to achieve what we need, which is a full sale. I will post a tweet we compiled earlier on here.

it’s very important that people read and understand why a partial sale is not good, let's break down what we see as the key points:

- Partial sale means current majority shareholder sells some shares, but retains control.
- Unlike Blues who had many different owners, we have one, Yunyi, controlled by Lai, owning 88%.

Questions arise regarding partial sale:

1. Who and why would anyone invest partially in Albion?
2. Is there a guarantee the club will receive the funds from a partial sale ?
3. Will potential buyers face a more complicated process? (yes, we think so)
4. Would funds from a partial sale create real impact? Yunyi considers 'market value offers' at £30m for full shares sale.

So, 10% (equivalent to £3m) from partial sale seems small, considering Yunyi's valuation.
A mere drop in the ocean.

A minority stake sale also means no fit and proper persons test is needed as it’s less than threshold required."

Obviously there's no guarantee that he's right about everything, but A4A do have their ears close to the ground.

I don’t get this “WE agreed to terms of 5% interest per month”.  No “we” didn’t.  “We” are not Holdings!  Holdings is Yunyai’s own company.  I’ve pointed this out multiple times on this board.  People are fooled by the name of Holdings.  Think of it as “Yunyai (UK) Holdings Limited” and it is easier to grasp. 

Point 2 is also incorrect.  When shares in a company are sold, it is the vendor who receives the share sale proceeds, not the company whose shares are being sold.


RE: Francois Chesnais - been looking at training ground - CaptainFantastico - 08-10-2023

Point 2, as you outline it, is very relevant