WBAUnofficial
Just in case you missed it - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: Politics (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=5)
+--- Thread: Just in case you missed it (/showthread.php?tid=29632)

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9


RE: Just in case you missed it - Derek Hardballs - 04-24-2023

(04-24-2023, 10:05 AM)Protheroe Wrote:
(04-24-2023, 09:19 AM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: Cop-out.

You actively campaigned for this mess. You ignored people like me pointing out that Brexit was always going to be the biggest act of British protectionism since the corn laws, you disregarded the impact of NTBs to trade, you don't get to shit on the ground and blame someone else.

I didn't ignore you. I just don't agree with you.

As I've said on the subject ad nauseum, if the EU was *just* about the Thatcherite prism of trade with a Western European club of countries - as we entered the EEC in 1973 - I'd have no problem whatsoever with our continued membership. It morphed into a vast, undemocratic political and monetary bloc at odds with my values, and in the long run I felt the opportunity cost of that was too high a price to pay which is why a campaigned to Leave and would do so again. 

I am happy to own the decision to Leave. I'm disappointed with the failure of the political class in the UK (and the EU) to deliver a Brexit with less friction. I still hold to the belief that a club that would punish you for leaving is not a club I'd wish to be part of.

Arf ‘it’s not my Brexit’ ffs!


RE: Just in case you missed it - Borin' Baggie - 04-24-2023

(04-24-2023, 10:05 AM)Protheroe Wrote:
(04-24-2023, 09:19 AM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: Cop-out.

You actively campaigned for this mess. You ignored people like me pointing out that Brexit was always going to be the biggest act of British protectionism since the corn laws, you disregarded the impact of NTBs to trade, you don't get to shit on the ground and blame someone else.

I didn't ignore you. I just don't agree with you.

As I've said on the subject ad nauseum, if the EU was *just* about the Thatcherite prism of trade with a Western European club of countries - as we entered the EEC in 1973 - I'd have no problem whatsoever with our continued membership. It morphed into a vast, undemocratic political and monetary bloc at odds with my values, and in the long run I felt the opportunity cost of that was too high a price to pay which is why a campaigned to Leave and would do so again. 

I am happy to own the decision to Leave. I'm disappointed with the failure of the political class in the UK (and the EU) to deliver a Brexit with less friction. I still hold to the belief that a club that would punish you for leaving is not a club I'd wish to be part of.

Let's break this response down shall we.

You don't agree with me that Brexit was a huge act of protectionism? What the fuck have we ended up with then, because it's certainly the opposite to open and free trade. NTBs are more restrictive to trade than tariffs, that's not an opinion but fact - 2/3rds the cost of trade relates to NTBs, and we put up a load of them. How is that not protectionism?

The EEC in 1973 was not "Thatcherite". Thatcher's single market reforms in the 1980s were Eurofederalist, Thatcher's intervention at the Delors Commission and the changes she and her government pushed in was successfully implemented as the Maastricht Treaty. Thatcher explicitly pushed for centralisation of powers to Brussels so the European Commission could properly enforce the rules of a common market across the common market as she recognised while she was still lucid that if you don't enforce the rules you never deliver the outcome. Lawson pegged the pound to the Deutschmark. The Thatcherite "Eurosceptics" at the IEA like Mark Littlewood wanted us to join the Euro. What is this Thatcherite "prism of trade" again?

You're happy with owning the "decision to leave" yet you're pawning off the consequences of that decision to how it was implemented to someone else.

As for "punishing us", the EU just fucking offered us a discount on rejoining Horizon. If they were punishing us why would they do that? But of course that discount "isn't enough", even for something we were and would be a huge net beneficiary of, for the Tories because Brexit is and always has been cakeism and any attempt to point this out is "punishment". See also: Erasmus and EHIC where we left for the sake of it and replaced them with something worse for no reason.

Do I need mention David Frost and Jacob Rees Mogg, self-professed Thatcherites who you wanted to be in government at the last election, in the Telegraph advocating for the American import of "National Conservatism" which when you look into it is about a centralised state with empowered state institutions. Those are the people who negotiated Brexit. But no it's not protectionist, it just walks like protectionism and quacks like a protectionism but it isn't actually protectionism.


RE: Just in case you missed it - Protheroe - 04-24-2023

Let me explain; Brexit from my perspective was not a protectionist pursuit. It stems from the rationally optimistic viewpoint that by eliminating most or all tariffs other countries would reciprocate. As a largely service and knowledge based economy the UK is better insulated than say Germany (industry) or France (agriculture) in pursuing this end without the job losses that would crucify any government.

If I am guilty of anything, and if I need to own anything then it's that optimism and the terrible timing of Brexit. Just as the world closes down for Covid, just as the Doha round of talks at the WTO turned mightily more protectionist, just as China began flexing its muscles and appearing even less benign. The landslide victory of the Tories in 2019 and the banal promises of levelling up make it impossible to countenance the rapid loss of low value manufacturing jobs or wholly uneconomic hill farming (for instance) in favour of those things we're actually good at - life sciences, law, finance and high value added manufacturing. We have protected the worst of our economy at the cost of the best, but of course that wouldn't be a popular narrative in West Bromwich, Mansfield or Bishop Auckland.

Even more disappointingly, the world's greatest protectionist now occupies the White House. He has no interest in liberalising trade with the UK or EU. In the UK from Carwyn Jones to Jacob Rees Mogg the protectionists are on the march.

I take your point on Horizon, Erasmus and the EHIC, but again I point to the increasing evidence that the Johnson government was an empty vessel.

And I accept that if the mantra you've largely lived by is for government to "empty the bins and leave us alone" then my faith in the UK's ability to negotiate a liberal Brexit was probably misplaced. Hindsight is a wonderful thing, however we've made our bed and I only hope there are some optimists left to help us lie more comfortably in it from a trade perspective. Perhaps in hindsight the largest economy in Europe might not have spent much of the last decade closing its nuclear power stations in favour of sucking off Putin. We all make mistakes.

Nevertheless, I have no regrets about being semi-detached from the rest of the EU project.


RE: Just in case you missed it - Borin' Baggie - 04-24-2023

I don't care whether you wanted a protectionist Brexit, I care about the fact that it was always the end result of us leaving the EU owing to the fact that the campaign was based on and it's the end result. And it is damaging the economy and hitting people's pockets. Your optimism was misplaced and the end result is stupid, leaving the EU is defined by the end result and the end result is illiberal neo-mercantilism.

France is a largely service based economy (the French service sector is actually bigger than the UK's both as a percentage and in nominal terms of GDP), German industry is also very well rooted into manufacturing services (the big players do most of their R&D in Germany and export their services or work with foreign-based multinationals) and their dominance is in high-tech niche areas instead of low-level manufacturing. It's also highly automated. The Dutch are one of the biggest agricultural producers in the world thanks to utilising their comparative advantage within the single market. Free trade is better the fewer the barriers and the larger the market, we've put up barriers and shrunk the market.

The UK managed to pull itself away from being the sick man of Europe by exploiting its global comparative advantages as barriers to trade were Europe were torn up in the 80s, 90s and 2000s. We've now closed that off, and we have a much smaller comparative advantage, if any, in those sectors than the American north east or Singapore where we're trying to muscle in on and in a worse position to exploit while having blocked off that advantage by leaving the single market. Life science investment is contingent on European cooperation, in terms of access, labour and finance but that's had barriers shoved up now to a huge proportion of that, same with HVM.

As for the world's greatest protectionist, no he isn't - there's far worse in that country. The US has always been deeply protectionist, just look at how it effectively compels multinationals to build there or the effect of DoD policy on trade between companies based in the US and even allied countries like the UK. That's why we need to work with the EU and EFTA on dealing with the Inflation Reduction Act as 520 million people across 32 countries has a better chance of dealing with that than one alone, but nope. There's a reason the EU's threats to mitigate any fallout had the Biden administration carve out concessions to the US market for EU member states, see also the US taking significantly longer to remove Trump-era tariffs on goods from the UK than the EU and EFTA member states.

I find it bizarre that you're also (irrelevantly) having a dig at Germany on energy policy when you just need to look over the English channel to the, consistently, most forward thinking energy policy in the world that even after being proven to be the way to go we still couldn't get our head around.