WBAUnofficial
This Labour Ad attack against Sunak - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: Politics (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=5)
+--- Thread: This Labour Ad attack against Sunak (/showthread.php?tid=29487)

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12


RE: This Labour Ad attack against Sunak - Protheroe - 04-14-2023

Like I said. Weasel words.

Mmmkay....


RE: This Labour Ad attack against Sunak - baggy1 - 04-14-2023

(04-14-2023, 12:37 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(04-14-2023, 12:35 PM)baggy1 Wrote: And yet up until this point you have voted for a party that has done exactly that, and pro-actively trumpeted a cause that was always going to make you worse off.

I'm not worse off due to Brexit. I'd be potentially worse off due the post-GE 2019 (complete) abandonment of sound money, fiscal discipline, support for small business, support for long term investment etc ad nauseum. Thankfully my business did recover post Covid and I've launched two more since in an attempt to maintain where we were.

We're all clearly worse off following Brexit, if you can't see that then you are deluded. Hiding behind other reasons for us being worse off doesn't negate the negative impact of Brexit on all of us.


RE: This Labour Ad attack against Sunak - Borin' Baggie - 04-14-2023

(04-14-2023, 12:49 PM)Protheroe Wrote: Like I said. Weasel words.

Which body decides minimum and maximum sentences for crimes?

Which body has the capacity to introduce legislation on sentencing?

Which body is responsible for prisons?

Which body is responsible for funding the court system?

Do you think the sentencing council is a magical body that can affect things and influence things through the power of will or something?


RE: This Labour Ad attack against Sunak - Protheroe - 04-14-2023

The fact remains that it is the Sentencing Council's role to issue guidelines on sentencing, which the courts must follow unless it is in the interests of justice not to do so.

If the sentencing of child molesters was such a problem for Labour then why has it taken them 13 years to raise it?

It's sewer level statistical opportunism.

Get back to your bar charts FFS. They won't mislead themselves.

(04-14-2023, 12:51 PM)baggy1 Wrote: We're all clearly worse off following Brexit

We're all clearly worse off than we might otherwise have been due to inflation. A small part of which may be Brexit related, but if you really want to understand why we're worse off than we might otherwise have been I could bang on about economic policy since 2008, but I'm sure I might have mentioned that before.


RE: This Labour Ad attack against Sunak - baggy1 - 04-14-2023

(04-14-2023, 02:20 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(04-14-2023, 12:51 PM)baggy1 Wrote: We're all clearly worse off following Brexit

We're all clearly worse off than we might otherwise have been due to inflation. A small part of which may be Brexit related, but if you really want to understand why we're worse off than we might otherwise have been I could bang on about economic policy since 2008, but I'm sure I might have mentioned that before.

Brexit is impacting us in two ways, one is as part of the problems that we are facing through, as you say, many other factors; and secondly, and probably more importantly, it is impacting on our ability to recover through trading our way out of the mess we are in. Brexit might have had some merits in idealistic terms but the basic tenant of impacting on trade with our biggest market was always going to be an exercise in unnecessary self harm.


RE: This Labour Ad attack against Sunak - Protheroe - 04-14-2023

(04-14-2023, 02:38 PM)baggy1 Wrote:
(04-14-2023, 02:20 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(04-14-2023, 12:51 PM)baggy1 Wrote: We're all clearly worse off following Brexit

We're all clearly worse off than we might otherwise have been due to inflation. A small part of which may be Brexit related, but if you really want to understand why we're worse off than we might otherwise have been I could bang on about economic policy since 2008, but I'm sure I might have mentioned that before.

Brexit is impacting us in two ways, one is as part of the problems that we are facing through, as you say, many other factors; and secondly, and probably more importantly, it is impacting on our ability to recover through trading our way out of the mess we are in. Brexit might have had some merits in idealistic terms but the basic tenant of impacting on trade with our biggest market was always going to be an exercise in unnecessary self harm.

I might also add that without the GFC we'd never have had Brexit. My greatest regret since the Referendum is that the UK did not seek to breakaway from the group think policies that have crushed wages, growth and investment since 2008 - until Truss and Kwarteng's hamfisted approach at quite possibly the worst moment (and as I stated on here before his mini budget - you do not borrow to cut taxes).


RE: This Labour Ad attack against Sunak - Borin' Baggie - 04-14-2023

(04-14-2023, 02:20 PM)Protheroe Wrote: The fact remains that it is the Sentencing Council's role to issue guidelines on sentencing, which the courts must follow unless it is in the interests of justice not to do so.

If the sentencing of child molesters was such a problem for Labour then why has it taken them 13 years to raise it?

It's sewer level statistical opportunism.

Get back to your bar charts FFS. They won't mislead themselves.

The fact remains that the Sentencing Council can only operate within the boundaries of the circumstances provided to them and the only body that has the power to affect said circumstances is the government.

You (via Paul Staines bullshit blog I imagine) trying to deflect this onto Starmer makes zero logical sense because the critical factors in which the sentencing guidelines are determined are constrained (not influenced but constrained) by legislation. The Sentencing Council does not have the capacity to dictate legislation, that is reserved for the government. If the government changed the legislation to be harsher then the guidelines would follow suit. If the government expanded the amount of prison spaces the guidelines would follow suit. If the government cleared the courts backlog then the guidelines would follow suit. Cause and effect. I also find it highly ironic that the likes of Paul Staines' blog trying to take the moral high ground seeing as they are campaigning journalists who have gone well below that in the past.

As for statistical opportunism, it certainly is that. I wouldn't call it sewer level though as the mode of attack is not novel, it's the exact same mode of attack that has been prevalent in British politics for centuries, there's a perceived government failing and the opposition are trying to tie that to the Prime Minister. And the fact is that you do not win elections by being nice, you do not win elections by taking the moral high ground. Look at 2015, Labour tried to play things nice and the Tories ended up attacking Miliband for being in the pocket of the SNP (he wasn't) eating a bacon sandwich and that his dad was a Britain-hating communist. Do I need to remind you of the anti-AV campaign saying we couldn't "afford" AV and maternity wards or bulletproof vests? The personal attack ads on Gordon Brown during the "vote for me" campaign? New Labour, New Danger? This isn't new, neither is the right feigning moral outrage when the left and centre employ the same tactics e.g. Major having a whinge when New Labour personally attacked him in 1997 (which worked). The Lib Dems making out that Prescott was just Ann Widdecombe also worked. I'm personally fine with that stuff, it's part and parcel. I have more gripes with imitating newspapers, funding targeted ads via a middleman that you don't need to declare, renaming your political accounts to pretend your a fact check, using dodgy foreign data companies to target online attack ads and farm data without consent and, as a data analyst by trade or target pensioners with bullshit postal vote sign ups that add them to the Tory mailing list. That's what is sewer level.

Also, further to add: people like Ian Blackford trying to take the moral high ground for political campaigning over this.

https://twitter.com/AlexofBrown/status/1646512053295939587

This is wrong, but personally attacking Charles Kennedy over something that has nothing to do with politics and sending your local party goons round to intimidate and assault Lib Dem staffers is fine though obviously.


RE: This Labour Ad attack against Sunak - CaptainFantastico - 04-14-2023

Excellent post BB


RE: This Labour Ad attack against Sunak - Protheroe - 04-14-2023

(04-14-2023, 02:52 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(04-14-2023, 02:20 PM)Protheroe Wrote: The fact remains that it is the Sentencing Council's role to issue guidelines on sentencing, which the courts must follow unless it is in the interests of justice not to do so.

If the sentencing of child molesters was such a problem for Labour then why has it taken them 13 years to raise it?

It's sewer level statistical opportunism.

Get back to your bar charts FFS. They won't mislead themselves.

The fact remains that the Sentencing Council can only operate within the boundaries of the circumstances provided to them and the only body that has the power to affect said circumstances is the government.

You (via Paul Staines bullshit blog I imagine) trying to deflect this onto Starmer makes zero logical sense because the critical factors in which the sentencing guidelines are determined are constrained (not influenced but constrained) by legislation. The Sentencing Council does not have the capacity to dictate legislation, that is reserved for the government. If the government changed the legislation to be harsher then the guidelines would follow suit. If the government expanded the amount of prison spaces the guidelines would follow suit. If the government cleared the courts backlog then the guidelines would follow suit. Cause and effect. I also find it highly ironic that the likes of Paul Staines' blog trying to take the moral high ground seeing as they are campaigning journalists who have gone well below that in the past.

As for statistical opportunism, it certainly is that. I wouldn't call it sewer level though as the mode of attack is not novel, it's the exact same mode of attack that has been prevalent in British politics for centuries, there's a perceived government failing and the opposition are trying to tie that to the Prime Minister. And the fact is that you do not win elections by being nice, you do not win elections by taking the moral high ground. Look at 2015, Labour tried to play things nice and the Tories ended up attacking Miliband for being in the pocket of the SNP (he wasn't) eating a bacon sandwich and that his dad was a Britain-hating communist. Do I need to remind you of the anti-AV campaign saying we couldn't "afford" AV and maternity wards or bulletproof vests? The personal attack ads on Gordon Brown during the "vote for me" campaign? New Labour, New Danger? This isn't new, neither is the right feigning moral outrage when the left and centre employ the same tactics e.g. Major having a whinge when New Labour personally attacked him in 1997 (which worked). The Lib Dems making out that Prescott was just Ann Widdecombe also worked. I'm personally fine with that stuff, it's part and parcel. I have more gripes with imitating newspapers, funding targeted ads via a middleman that you don't need to declare, renaming your political accounts to pretend your a fact check, using dodgy foreign data companies to target online attack ads and farm data without consent and, as a data analyst by trade or target pensioners with bullshit postal vote sign ups that add them to the Tory mailing list. That's what is sewer level.

Also, further to add: people like Ian Blackford trying to take the moral high ground for political campaigning over this.

https://twitter.com/AlexofBrown/status/1646512053295939587

This is wrong, but personally attacking Charles Kennedy over something that has nothing to do with politics and sending your local party goons round to intimidate and assault Lib Dem staffers is fine though obviously.

To be fair BB I haven't read Guido for months as he finally disappeared up his own sphincter some time ago so you're pretty much shouting at a cloud there. I read the same paper as you and it was mentioned in there.

And as I've already said on this thread Sunak IS collectively responsible and WAS in the room for most of the worst decisions made by this government (exc Truss) since 2019. It's not just sewer level to make such an attack - it's to miss the bigger target. I suppose the problem actually is that most of those terrible decisions in the last few years would have also been made by a Starmer administration and I suppose the Kiddy Fiddler attack is some vain attempt to get a Rizla between them on policy.

I also agree with you on Blackford. You might also recall Hugh McCallion's attacks on Gary Sambrook back in the day in Kingstanding which started with jibes about his youth and weight and ended up with outright homophobia on the doorstep. If anything local politics can be filthier.

And no party is beyond reproach.


RE: This Labour Ad attack against Sunak - Borin' Baggie - 04-14-2023

Fair enough on Staines. I brought him up as that's the blog where it was dug up first with the print outlets cottoning on. Wheeler's own "exclusive" on Sunday was after the bullshit blog had brought it up.

The reasoning behind this is obvious, Labour are going after socially conservative swing voters as that is where the greatest potential for them is to win seats is and painting Sunak as well as the Tories as being weak on law and order is a very valuable attack. It's the same reason the Lib Dems are going all-in on sewage (trust me, in the national context that might be meh and it's well down the list of pressing issues but living in a Tory constituency it has come up a lot apparently, it's also come up a lot when speaking to other dog walkers in a non-political context). If you're someone who voted Tory in 2017 and 2019 but liked Blair and live in the new West Brom constituency and have personally experienced failures in justice I'd imagine making out as though Sunak is weak on crime will cut through.