WBAUnofficial
With the likely BTA suspension... - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: With the likely BTA suspension... (/showthread.php?tid=28317)

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10


RE: With the likely BTA suspension... - Bob Fossil - 01-11-2023

(01-11-2023, 12:13 PM)wbamitch Wrote: The problem I have with it is these bans aren't dished out consistently, the same kind of thing happens all of the time and often nothing is done retrospectively. I'm convinced the fact he went on to score moments after and prevented a big upset/story made it a bigger talking point hence why it was picked up on MOTD / why he has now got a ban. Like others have said, there would be no point appealing as he clearly throws his elbow back

Exactly, retro bans are as rare as hen's teeth, rogue elbows are not.
This would not have been a thing if not highlighted on TV and that's just plain wrong. We are big enough for them to make a big deal of it, especially against lower league opposition, yet not big enough to have it swept under the carpet.
If this had been a Man City player, against us at the same stage, there would have been no ban.
That's my onions anyway.


RE: With the likely BTA suspension... - MrFizz - 01-11-2023

(01-11-2023, 12:37 PM)Bob Fossil Wrote:
(01-11-2023, 12:13 PM)wbamitch Wrote: The problem I have with it is these bans aren't dished out consistently, the same kind of thing happens all of the time and often nothing is done retrospectively. I'm convinced the fact he went on to score moments after and prevented a big upset/story made it a bigger talking point hence why it was picked up on MOTD / why he has now got a ban. Like others have said, there would be no point appealing as he clearly throws his elbow back

Exactly, retro bans are as rare as hen's teeth, rogue elbows are not.
This would not have been a thing if not highlighted on TV and that's just plain wrong. We are big enough for them to make a big deal of it, especially against lower league opposition, yet not big enough to have it swept under the carpet.
If this had been a Man City player, against us at the same stage, there would have been no ban.
That's my onions anyway.

And as i said earlier, if he'd have done it for Salford, with one camera on the halfway line and no real view of it, it wouldn't have got this far. These things will only seem to be picked up at games with multiple cameras, so where is the consistency? If you are going to issue retrospective bans in professional football, surely you should be able to do so for every game played, not just cherry-picked high profile ones.


RE: With the likely BTA suspension... - wbamitch - 01-11-2023

(01-11-2023, 12:54 PM)MrFizz Wrote:
(01-11-2023, 12:37 PM)Bob Fossil Wrote:
(01-11-2023, 12:13 PM)wbamitch Wrote: The problem I have with it is these bans aren't dished out consistently, the same kind of thing happens all of the time and often nothing is done retrospectively. I'm convinced the fact he went on to score moments after and prevented a big upset/story made it a bigger talking point hence why it was picked up on MOTD / why he has now got a ban. Like others have said, there would be no point appealing as he clearly throws his elbow back

Exactly, retro bans are as rare as hen's teeth, rogue elbows are not.
This would not have been a thing if not highlighted on TV and that's just plain wrong. We are big enough for them to make a big deal of it, especially against lower league opposition, yet not big enough to have it swept under the carpet.
If this had been a Man City player, against us at the same stage, there would have been no ban.
That's my onions anyway.

And as i said earlier, if he'd have done it for Salford, with one camera on the halfway line and no real view of it, it wouldn't have got this far. These things will only seem to be picked up at games with multiple cameras, so where is the consistency? If you are going to issue retrospective bans in professional football, surely you should be able to do so for every game played, not just cherry-picked high profile ones.

Martinez from Man Utd elbowed one of the Villa players twice recently, VAR did nothing and no retrospective action either


RE: With the likely BTA suspension... - Squid - 01-11-2023

(01-11-2023, 12:37 PM)Bob Fossil Wrote:
(01-11-2023, 12:13 PM)wbamitch Wrote: The problem I have with it is these bans aren't dished out consistently, the same kind of thing happens all of the time and often nothing is done retrospectively. I'm convinced the fact he went on to score moments after and prevented a big upset/story made it a bigger talking point hence why it was picked up on MOTD / why he has now got a ban. Like others have said, there would be no point appealing as he clearly throws his elbow back

Exactly, retro bans are as rare as hen's teeth, rogue elbows are not.
This would not have been a thing if not highlighted on TV and that's just plain wrong. We are big enough for them to make a big deal of it, especially against lower league opposition, yet not big enough to have it swept under the carpet.
If this had been a Man City player, against us at the same stage, there would have been no ban.
That's my onions anyway.

I agree with those onions. Why do people still believe the FA is fair? We know they are not.


RE: With the likely BTA suspension... - Hughie Reed 31 - 01-11-2023

I have never ever seen a player who have been dragged back from behind has never tried to shrug/ shake them off it’s a natural reaction. If it had been a player from one of the big clubs no action would have been taken
3 match ban is a fucking joke.


RE: With the likely BTA suspension... - Albionmad - 01-11-2023

(01-11-2023, 03:31 PM)Hughie Reed 31 Wrote: I have never ever seen a player who have been dragged back from behind has never tried to shrug/ shake them off it’s a natural reaction. If it had been a player from one of the big clubs no action would have been taken
3 match ban is a fucking joke.

They banned Gayle, now BTA. Who's next?


RE: With the likely BTA suspension... - Tom Joad - 01-11-2023

MrFizz Wrote:
Bob Fossil Wrote:
wbamitch Wrote:The problem I have with it is these bans aren't dished out consistently, the same kind of thing happens all of the time and often nothing is done retrospectively. I'm convinced the fact he went on to score moments after and prevented a big upset/story made it a bigger talking point hence why it was picked up on MOTD / why he has now got a ban. Like others have said, there would be no point appealing as he clearly throws his elbow back

Exactly, retro bans are as rare as hen's teeth, rogue elbows are not.
This would not have been a thing if not highlighted on TV and that's just plain wrong. We are big enough for them to make a big deal of it, especially against lower league opposition, yet not big enough to have it swept under the carpet.
If this had been a Man City player, against us at the same stage, there would have been no ban.
That's my onions anyway.

And as i said earlier, if he'd have done it for Salford, with one camera on the halfway line and no real view of it, it wouldn't have got this far. These things will only seem to be picked up at games with multiple cameras, so where is the consistency? If you are going to issue retrospective bans in professional football, surely you should be able to do so for every game played, not just cherry-picked high profile ones.
I agree with these. I know it sounds like paranoia but the Gayle ban? Who else has ever been done for diving? Now the BTA ban which has been purely brought about by the MOTD fuss. It is all part and parcel of the FA and the unconscious bias they have. It isn't just Albion, look at the ridiculous decisions the dings had at Liverpool last Saturday. Coincidently (or not), very similar to when we knocked Liverpool out in the same round and VAR tried it's best to remedy the result.
Call it whining if you like but I don't like it and it is the very reason I barely watch Premier League games but will watch Albion at any level, non league football,  and even any games that happen to be on the local pitches to me on a sunday morning. The FA is rotten at worst  or incompetent at best, or more likely,  a good smattering of both.


RE: With the likely BTA suspension... - Fulham Fallout - 01-11-2023

Just thinking….. what happens if Dike picks up an injury or catches the flu etc?


RE: With the likely BTA suspension... - Swanage Baggie - 01-11-2023

What irks me about the whole BTA thing is the first media report was from a local Chesterfield rag...how did they know to look at the Birmingham FA website to report this before any other outlet if (a) the B'ham FA reported it before they should have done (according to the E&D) and (b) unless someone from the FA tipped them off that it was there to look at?


RE: With the likely BTA suspension... - Borin' Baggie - 01-11-2023

(01-11-2023, 04:06 PM)Tom Joad Wrote:
MrFizz Wrote:
Bob Fossil Wrote:
wbamitch Wrote:The problem I have with it is these bans aren't dished out consistently, the same kind of thing happens all of the time and often nothing is done retrospectively. I'm convinced the fact he went on to score moments after and prevented a big upset/story made it a bigger talking point hence why it was picked up on MOTD / why he has now got a ban. Like others have said, there would be no point appealing as he clearly throws his elbow back

Exactly, retro bans are as rare as hen's teeth, rogue elbows are not.
This would not have been a thing if not highlighted on TV and that's just plain wrong. We are big enough for them to make a big deal of it, especially against lower league opposition, yet not big enough to have it swept under the carpet.
If this had been a Man City player, against us at the same stage, there would have been no ban.
That's my onions anyway.

And as i said earlier, if he'd have done it for Salford, with one camera on the halfway line and no real view of it, it wouldn't have got this far. These things will only seem to be picked up at games with multiple cameras, so where is the consistency? If you are going to issue retrospective bans in professional football, surely you should be able to do so for every game played, not just cherry-picked high profile ones.
I agree with these. I know it sounds like paranoia but the Gayle ban? Who else has ever been done for diving? Now the BTA ban which has been purely brought about by the MOTD fuss. It is all part and parcel of the FA and the unconscious bias they have. It isn't just Albion, look at the ridiculous decisions the dings had at Liverpool last Saturday. Coincidently (or not), very similar to when we knocked Liverpool out in the same round and VAR tried it's best to remedy the result.
Call it whining if you like but I don't like it and it is the very reason I barely watch Premier League games but will watch Albion at any level, non league football,  and even any games that happen to be on the local pitches to me on a sunday morning. The FA is rotten at worst  or incompetent at best, or more likely,  a good smattering of both.

The thing about the Gayle ban was that we played QPR shortly after (might have been the next game), one of their players dived to win a penalty, successfully deceived the referee and nary a peep. There was actually more contact in the Gayle incident than the QPR dive, yet nothing.