WBAUnofficial
Your view on Bruce-y: The Poll - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: Your view on Bruce-y: The Poll (/showthread.php?tid=25925)

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18


RE: Your view on Bruce-y: The Poll - MrFizz - 08-01-2022

(08-01-2022, 06:12 PM)Duffers Wrote:
(08-01-2022, 06:04 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(08-01-2022, 05:58 PM)Duffers Wrote:
(08-01-2022, 05:45 PM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote:
(08-01-2022, 04:19 PM)Duffers Wrote: Managers do come into squads half way through a season and make a difference (and often they do not), Bruce most certainly did not.

You can argue that the squad may not have had the required quality to challenge, but under Bruce it did not possess the necessary mentality either. Too many of those “experienced pros” went missing when they were needed most last season. How many times did we find ourselves in a situation where a decent result would have put us back into contention only for that spineless bunch to choke? Forest, Stoke, Preston, Blues just off the top of my head…

That’s why it bothers me seeing the likes of Phillips and Livermore in the squad, not only are they no longer good enough for what we need (IMO) but they have also demonstrated repeatedly that they lack the mental strength too (again IMO).

New season. Same failures.

Duffers, you're making these statements as though it was the first time, not the third time, these players had failed to settle under a new regime. As I asked on a thread somewhere, was Bruce given the option to discard Phillips, Livermore, Zohore and Bartley? I rather doubt it. I'd have made it a condition of staying on - which is probably what Sam Allardyce did. Whilst I'm happy to point the finger fairly and squarely at Sawyers as the chief troublemaker (his admission that he refused to do the running that Val demanded surprised me not at all), Livermore and Phillips have failed repeatedly to improve effort or morale when the going got tough. Bruce is stuck with them. If Livermore stays in the side once Okay is fit, if Phillips' feeble performance defensively on Saturday goes unnoticed, then I'll join you in calling Bruce out for picking them. One game in, it's too soon.

All the club can do is make them available for transfer, they have contracts so if nobody wants them there’s little we can do. Doesn’t mean they should be starting though.

Ok what have Diangana and Mowatt done since their respective injuries to warrant them walking into the team?

Conversely what have Livermore and Phillips done in the last 24 months to merit repeated selection? I’m willing to bet your favourite manager in the last five years was Allardyce and yet he bundled him out at the first opportunity. It speaks volumes to the mismanagement of the club in recent years that he’s still starting as captain.

Diangana was arguably our best player in pre-season, now I’m sure you will scoff at how little that means but he has been providing a damn sight more than Phillips recently.

Diangana's abscence was a surprise to me i have to admit. Especially after he looked so lively against Bertha Herlin. I was surprised about Jake being in as i was under the impression he had the tom-tits. But i would pick Jake over Mowatt anyway.


RE: Your view on Bruce-y: The Poll - Derek Hardballs - 08-01-2022

(08-01-2022, 06:12 PM)Duffers Wrote:
(08-01-2022, 06:04 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(08-01-2022, 05:58 PM)Duffers Wrote:
(08-01-2022, 05:45 PM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote:
(08-01-2022, 04:19 PM)Duffers Wrote: Managers do come into squads half way through a season and make a difference (and often they do not), Bruce most certainly did not.

You can argue that the squad may not have had the required quality to challenge, but under Bruce it did not possess the necessary mentality either. Too many of those “experienced pros” went missing when they were needed most last season. How many times did we find ourselves in a situation where a decent result would have put us back into contention only for that spineless bunch to choke? Forest, Stoke, Preston, Blues just off the top of my head…

That’s why it bothers me seeing the likes of Phillips and Livermore in the squad, not only are they no longer good enough for what we need (IMO) but they have also demonstrated repeatedly that they lack the mental strength too (again IMO).

New season. Same failures.

Duffers, you're making these statements as though it was the first time, not the third time, these players had failed to settle under a new regime. As I asked on a thread somewhere, was Bruce given the option to discard Phillips, Livermore, Zohore and Bartley? I rather doubt it. I'd have made it a condition of staying on - which is probably what Sam Allardyce did. Whilst I'm happy to point the finger fairly and squarely at Sawyers as the chief troublemaker (his admission that he refused to do the running that Val demanded surprised me not at all), Livermore and Phillips have failed repeatedly to improve effort or morale when the going got tough. Bruce is stuck with them. If Livermore stays in the side once Okay is fit, if Phillips' feeble performance defensively on Saturday goes unnoticed, then I'll join you in calling Bruce out for picking them. One game in, it's too soon.

All the club can do is make them available for transfer, they have contracts so if nobody wants them there’s little we can do. Doesn’t mean they should be starting though.

Ok what have Diangana and Mowatt done since their respective injuries to warrant them walking into the team?

Conversely what have Livermore and Phillips done in the last 24 months to merit repeated selection? I’m willing to bet your favourite manager in the last five years was Allardyce and yet he bundled him out at the first opportunity. It speaks volumes to the mismanagement of the club in recent years that he’s still starting as captain.

Diangana was arguably our best player in pre-season, now I’m sure you will scoff at how little that means but he has been providing a damn sight more than Phillips recently.

Mowatt isn’t a holding midfielder, I’m hoping his injury was the reason for some very poor performances last season. Currently I don’t know what he adds to a team? Not creative, not great at passing, not particularly good at defending but scores a decent / world class goal every now and then is all I saw of him last season, seems a perfect fit for Val ball but not sure where he will fit in when Okay is fit. 

You can’t judge a player on pre-season games. Also if Phillips offered nothing last season so did Grady. Frankly if we had an opportunity to sell him and bring in a more rounded winger / wide player than either Phillips or Diangana I would. Grady has talent but it’s a massive season for him to prove his early form for us wasn’t a purple patch. Also worth remembering that many of Grady’s best moments happened when he came off the bench.


RE: Your view on Bruce-y: The Poll - Sliced - 08-01-2022

Genuine question DH. Last season you were adamant that we had a top 2 squad and that anything outside of the top 2 was a failure.

Given that we're undoubtedly stronger than last year and that the league is arguably weaker with no "Fulham" esque team that should run away with it, do you still hold the opinion that anything other than top 2 is a failure?


RE: Your view on Bruce-y: The Poll - Cunninghamismagic - 08-01-2022

Blimey. One game in and we have this poll.


RE: Your view on Bruce-y: The Poll - Derek Hardballs - 08-01-2022

(08-01-2022, 07:17 PM)Sliced Wrote: Genuine question DH. Last season you were adamant that we had a top 2 squad and that anything outside of the top 2 was a failure.

Given that we're undoubtedly stronger than last year and that the league is arguably weaker with no "Fulham" esque team that should run away with it, do you still hold the opinion that anything other than top 2 is a failure?

I expect promotion yes but apart from Fulham I don’t think the league is weaker, stronger imo.


RE: Your view on Bruce-y: The Poll - Remi_Moses - 08-01-2022

Athens sits on the fence shocker!!


RE: Your view on Bruce-y: The Poll - Derek Hardballs - 08-01-2022

(08-01-2022, 07:38 PM)Remi_Moses Wrote: Athens sits on the fence shocker!!

Eh?


RE: Your view on Bruce-y: The Poll - HawkingsHalfpint - 08-01-2022

Wow, this grew legs!

The way I see it, we don't often get it right mid-season anyway. And often our decision has little bearing on the outcome afterwards...

Mel = brought in and we survived. Some would have (why I don't know, when it was mainly down to the seniors we survived), but we didn't keep him anyway.
Pardew = failed. Got rid.
Shan = didn't quite make it. We didn't keep him.
Allardyce = failed. Opinion split on whether we would have kept him, wasn't our choice to make anyway.
Bruce = failed.

So it seems to me that the players (or more likely a million other associated reasons such as their condition, confidence, attitude... even who the hell they even are) have the biggest bearing when we replace mid-season. Not necessarily the chump in charge.

So whether or not Bruce failed or succeeded in his objective last year, he's still in a job. And whatever the objectives are of that job, then yes of course he only has a limited time to achieve them. I would totally agree that it's more than fair that if his season goes the same way Val's does, so does his tenure. Just a little early to start talking about that after one away draw so far this season.


RE: Your view on Bruce-y: The Poll - Duffers - 08-01-2022

(08-01-2022, 07:38 PM)Remi_Moses Wrote: Athens sits on the fence shocker!!

Remi talks bollocks shocker!


RE: Your view on Bruce-y: The Poll - Moore Than - 08-01-2022

(08-01-2022, 10:45 AM)Sliced Wrote: I'm none of the above. I was happy when Bruce came in because of his previous Championship record. On the pitch I don't think there's been anything to write home about but I'm happy with the transfer business.

There's maybe 3-4 posters who will pretend that everything Bruce has done has been wonderful and he's been held back by the previous regime because they can't stand Val; but I think other than that select group most people probably feel the same as me.

Bruce now has a stronger squad than last year. He's been allowed to bring in not only another midfielder which Val wasn't given the luxury of, but 3, all of which improve our starting 11 massively. The league is also weaker. With that team Bruce should be comfortably looking at playoffs, challenging for the top 2 and I think we probably will be at least there.

"Val wasn't given the luxury of".

Haha. Val didn't see the need for midfielders. Let's not rewrite history here. Appalling manager.