WBAUnofficial
The "it will take ages to undo the damage done by val" argument... - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: The "it will take ages to undo the damage done by val" argument... (/showthread.php?tid=24143)

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13


RE: The "it will take ages to undo the damage done by val" argument... - Sliced - 02-15-2022

(02-15-2022, 09:40 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote:
(02-15-2022, 09:25 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(02-15-2022, 09:17 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote:
(02-15-2022, 09:09 AM)cornishbaggie Wrote: So after 6 months of performances and results getting worse by the week and those screaming to give Val time to sort it out and it will come good, to two games under Bruce, one with ten men and the same suspects are shouting " see it wasn't Val " WOW

IT'S NOT THE MANAGER!  Wink

It runs deeper than that. What some of us are saying is we wiuld prefer to see a long term strategy for sustained success like we did in the early 2010s. 

The argument seems to have shifted from valxit, to whether you are 'Pro-Project' or not. Baffling.

The long term strategy was only successful due to TV money. You can’t ignore this, in pursuit of a football utopia.

Big but. SGM did take us to the Prem with a clear, unwavering identity. Yes we were shite when we went up, but as you say we got there and it funded the next 15 years. 

We are now in a completely different position. We have one of the best academies in the country, a training ground to rival most and a squad of experienced players who are probably midtabke in their ability. 

The philosophy and identity I want  doesn't involve huge investment in the playing squad. It is finally starting to utilise what we have built for 20 years but never had the chance to realise as we have been too busy protecting the value of the asset for the owner in the short term. 

Derek, we are not too far apart in most of our opinions, generally when I read your posts. But we are just seperate sides of the "short term"/"long term" divide I think on this one.

(02-15-2022, 09:32 AM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote:
(02-15-2022, 08:44 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: Not sure we can blame Ismael for the fact we've got worse in the two games since he left.

There's no way you can claim that we actually got worse in the two games Bruce has had. Sending off - par for the course, been doing it for a couple of seasons. Can't score - tick. Concede sloppy goal - tick. Concede again under pressure with ten men - tick.

Huge reduction in; touches in the oppositions box, huge decrease in shot number, huge decrease in the number of key passes. 

It shows we have just gone back to aimless, deep lying, square, passing. Now if you are in the group that believes all our stats were "not a true reflection" and/or you don't care about stats and passing shorter and changing formations is what you're after, you won't think we've got worse. For those of us who don't care that much about arbitrary formations and possession style, we can already see whats changed, and not like it. It doesn't mean I wlnt support the team or Bruce, though, and I really hope he stumbles upon a short term solution. Because, whilst I don't like it, I like seeing us win.

All good points. I remember when Hugill got destroyed for missing chance after chance, now we don't have chances to miss. I also find it bizarre that everyone is jumping on you for wanting to see a long term plan with football that you enjoy watching but the same people were moaning that "Val's style of football takes all skill out of the game" while we were sitting top 2 in the league.


RE: The "it will take ages to undo the damage done by val" argument... - CA Baggie - 02-15-2022

Can't be arsed to read it all so I'll say what I think and if it's a repeat of someone else's thoughts then i apologise.

It's not all Val's fault that cetain players have been handed over to Bruce that aren't quite good enough, however there should be enough to make the top 6 and I can't see anything in teams like Luton or Huddersfield that make them better than us other than management.

It is Val's fault that we've got Mowatt and Molumby poncing round midfield with no attacking midfielders to play the "10" role and it is Val's fault that we ended up with Hugill as our only forward for the first 1/2 of season.

The squad is now imbalanced for another manager to come in as it's been built towards Val's style of play and Val's style of play simply wasn't working, not only that it was getting progressively worse. Had his performances been in reverse he's probably still have a job. We'd have seen the system he wanted to install begin to take shape, instead the opposite happened.

So, yes, it might take a transfer window or 2 to undo Val's input into an already dysfunctional squad. A dysfunctional squad that should still be good enough for the top 6 and would have been with better summer recruitment.


RE: The "it will take ages to undo the damage done by val" argument... - Tom Joad - 02-15-2022

There are massive flaws on this thread.
The anti Val crusade that don't want a "project" because we need promotion now? Where is the guarantee of promotion now? It is not a straight choice with a given result.
The fact we don't look like scoring is because Val destroyed the players? The players are not very good, they decided they didn't want to put the hard miles in as the manager was under pressure and they knew they are harder to move on. We look even less like scoring now, Bruce (whom I have no beef with), bemoaned both our strikeforce and midfield after watching 2 games. They just are not very good.
The former manager alienated Johnston?  SJ got a stupid sending off, his replacement did fine so Sam was put on the bench for a game. A fair point made, I'd say. Sam stropped off yet we blame the manager?
I have little to say in defence of Val's intransigence other than maybe he thought he'd be given time to get his ideas working. After all, they appear to be fine at our other levels. But once more, our playing staff didn't like what they were being asked to do. My conclusion is simply that our problems run way deeper than the guy that is in the manager's seat.


RE: The "it will take ages to undo the damage done by val" argument... - Spandaubaggie - 02-15-2022

(02-15-2022, 10:16 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote:
(02-15-2022, 09:47 AM)Spandaubaggie Wrote: Wow there is some egos on here and bollocks galore being spouted on this thread.

This is just a moment in time in a season at the minute, which is 2 games after a new boss came in.

Let us see what Bruce has done after a few weeks and then after a pre season.

We will have O'Shea and Dike back for the run in and also Bruce will have sized up the players better.

By and large I think its been well levelled discussion.

Spandau, could I ask which bit of peoples thoughts is bollocks? Or is it anything that suggests that the manager isn't the be all and end all of how we are performing?
I think the black and white arguments some are trying to spout. It's the players fault- no it's the manager's.

Truth is in all organisations where things are going wrong it is generally a culture and also a lack of patience and some bad leaders. Val was the wrong man at the wrong time.

Also when things go wrong tweaks can be made that make things go right so long as there is a willingness to accept mistakes and work for the collective good. 

FWIW , back on the original subject, Ishmael's revolution was a disaster. It started well and got worse and worse to the point that we couldn't even get a shot on target v Preston, couldn't win away, and he clearly created a bad dressing room spirit.

Ish also oversaw the ins and outs of the summer, which means we have a limited midfield. However, recruitment at a higher level has its part in this too. 

So right now, we also have to undo the most radical style change I've ever known, where some composed players treated the ball like a hot potato for several months. 

Bruce's appointment, the new chairman is a chance to hopefully start steering the club back into calmer waters.

However, the fans have to realise that right now this is just a point in the season, 180 minutes into Bruce's reign, where we are still a team that can't score goals,  and have played like a bottom 6 team for 3 months- that can't be undone with the wave of a wand.


RE: The "it will take ages to undo the damage done by val" argument... - Cunninghamismagic - 02-15-2022

(02-15-2022, 08:44 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: Not sure we can blame Ismael for the fact we've got worse in the two games since he left.

Worse? While still underwhelming last night was a big improvement on what we saw in the final weeks under Ismael


RE: The "it will take ages to undo the damage done by val" argument... - WorcsWBA - 02-15-2022

(02-15-2022, 11:16 AM)Sliced Wrote:
(02-15-2022, 09:40 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote: Huge reduction in; touches in the oppositions box, huge decrease in shot number, huge decrease in the number of key passes. 

It shows we have just gone back to aimless, deep lying, square, passing. Now if you are in the group that believes all our stats were "not a true reflection" and/or you don't care about stats and passing shorter and changing formations is what you're after, you won't think we've got worse. For those of us who don't care that much about arbitrary formations and possession style, we can already see whats changed, and not like it. It doesn't mean I wlnt support the team or Bruce, though, and I really hope he stumbles upon a short term solution. Because, whilst I don't like it, I like seeing us win.

All good points. I remember when Hugill got destroyed for missing chance after chance, now we don't have chances to miss. I also find it bizarre that everyone is jumping on you for wanting to see a long term plan with football that you enjoy watching but the same people were moaning that "Val's style of football takes all skill out of the game" while we were sitting top 2 in the league.

Agreed. Even when we were doing well (right up until mid-December as I explained in the match thread for last night), people were giving Ismael pelters for the boring style of play, despite us having lots of shots (that were claimed as being all hit and hope from distance, despite the stats showing that they weren't). Now boring is suddenly fine with many, simply because it's a different manager.

We have to have a project at some point, and fans need to find some patience to go with it. We can't just keep stumbling aimlessly from one short term fix to another, as the current lack of quality in the squad is showing that these short term fixes don't work. It also doesn't help the development of the younger players, as short term fix managers always seem to err on the side of experienced players to the extent of bringing in older loan players and giving them precedence.

(02-15-2022, 11:26 AM)CA Baggie Wrote: It is Val's fault that we've got Mowatt and Molumby poncing round midfield with no attacking midfielders to play the "10" role and it is Val's fault that we ended up with Hugill as our only forward for the first 1/2 of season.

The squad is now imbalanced for another manager to come in as it's been built towards Val's style of play and Val's style of play simply wasn't working, not only that it was getting progressively worse.  Had his performances been in reverse he's probably still have a job.  We'd have seen the system he wanted to install begin to take shape, instead the opposite happened.

I recall thinking, from the comments that Val made at the time Molumby signed, that he wasn't his signing. Having said that, Molumby should have been a perfect player in Val's system and I was excited to see what he could do. Sadly he's proven to be a disappointment so far.

As for Hugill, I imagine the thought was that we need a target man-type forward and he could well have been the only experienced player that we could get of that type.

The style of play was working right up until mid-December (and even in the Peterborough home game after that), as we'd only lost 4 out of 23 games at that point, but then the players effectively downed tools, either in concert with or as a reaction to the increased levels of booing by fans who didn't like the style of play for whatever reason. Now those fans suddenly don't care about the style of play!


RE: The "it will take ages to undo the damage done by val" argument... - Big Daddy Cool - 02-15-2022

(02-15-2022, 08:44 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: Not sure we can blame Ismael for the fact we've got worse in the two games since he left.

Did the Preston and Millwall games not happen?


RE: The "it will take ages to undo the damage done by val" argument... - Bob Fossil - 02-15-2022

(02-15-2022, 12:10 PM)WorcsWBA Wrote:
(02-15-2022, 11:16 AM)Sliced Wrote:
(02-15-2022, 09:40 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote: Huge reduction in; touches in the oppositions box, huge decrease in shot number, huge decrease in the number of key passes. 

It shows we have just gone back to aimless, deep lying, square, passing. Now if you are in the group that believes all our stats were "not a true reflection" and/or you don't care about stats and passing shorter and changing formations is what you're after, you won't think we've got worse. For those of us who don't care that much about arbitrary formations and possession style, we can already see whats changed, and not like it. It doesn't mean I wlnt support the team or Bruce, though, and I really hope he stumbles upon a short term solution. Because, whilst I don't like it, I like seeing us win.

All good points. I remember when Hugill got destroyed for missing chance after chance, now we don't have chances to miss. I also find it bizarre that everyone is jumping on you for wanting to see a long term plan with football that you enjoy watching but the same people were moaning that "Val's style of football takes all skill out of the game" while we were sitting top 2 in the league.

Agreed. Even when we were doing well (right up until mid-December as I explained in the match thread for last night), people were giving Ismael pelters for the boring style of play, despite us having lots of shots (that were claimed as being all hit and hope from distance, despite the stats showing that they weren't). Now boring is suddenly fine with many, simply because it's a different manager.

We have to have a project at some point, and fans need to find some patience to go with it. We can't just keep stumbling aimlessly from one short term fix to another, as the current lack of quality in the squad is showing that these short term fixed don't work. It doesn't help the development of the younger players, as short term fix managers always seem to err on the side of experienced players.

Then let Bruce head up the "project" and rebuild, yes he's English and unfashionable but is 10 times the manager Val is, or ever will be. It's also a safer bet then taking another punt on a young upcoming, but unproven, manager.
If people genuinely want a long term plan then Bruce is the perfect fit. I can't think of anyone I would rather kick off next season in the Championship with. Yes the squad needs an overhaul, but, again, Bruce knows the division and the type of player required to get out of it. Shit or bust tilt at play offs for the rest of this season, albeit, it looks unlikely, then reset in summer with him still in charge.


RE: The "it will take ages to undo the damage done by val" argument... - WorcsWBA - 02-15-2022

(02-15-2022, 12:37 PM)Bob Fossil Wrote: Then let Bruce head up the "project" and rebuild, yes he's English and unfashionable but is 10 times the manager Val is, or ever will be. It's also a safer bet then taking another punt on a young upcoming, but unproven, manager.
If people genuinely want a long term plan then Bruce is the perfect fit. I can't think of anyone I would rather kick off next season in the Championship with. Yes the squad needs an overhaul, but, again, Bruce knows the division and the type of player required to get out of it. Shit or bust tilt at play offs for the rest of this season, albeit, it looks unlikely, then reset in summer with him still in charge.

In other words, give Bruce a level of fan tolerance that Val never came close to being afforded. Younger managers need that tolerance much more than experienced ones of course.

I'm not sure that Bruce is interested in a longer term project but, regardless of that, our project shouldn't be giving jobs to as many 60+ year-old managers as we can.


RE: The "it will take ages to undo the damage done by val" argument... - wbamitch - 02-15-2022

How I see it is that Val was an exciting appointment with the right intentions which just hasn’t worked. I had seen enough from him to be confident we weren’t getting any better, and whilst he didn’t have much money to spend, he decided to spend what we did have on very similar and limited footballers which is contributing now to a horrible lack of creativity. I blame the fact that we don’t have a number 10 to pick from on Val as he had no interest in signing one in the summer and didn’t rectify it in January either. The idea that Dike was going to solve everything was a huge gamble which has been highlighted with his injury. There was no room for Sawyers, but room for Molumby and Reach. Not everything is his fault of course, the performances of our so called better players have been pathetic which is on them, but unfortunately we can’t scrap the playing squad and start again. Added to that he rewarded Phillips, Bartley, Furlong and Towsend with new contracts and the awful deals sanctioned for Grady, Grant and Robinson left little wiggle room for this rebuild that he wanted. Bruce hasn’t had long enough in the role to compare yet, but if he throws Livermore straight back in and carries on selecting Reach in that role then my opinion on him will quickly be made.