WBAUnofficial
Fair Play to Callum Robinson - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: Fair Play to Callum Robinson (/showthread.php?tid=21847)

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14


RE: Fair Play to Callum Robinson - Dumbo - 10-06-2021

(10-06-2021, 11:14 AM)wba13 Wrote:
(10-06-2021, 10:44 AM)backsidebaggie Wrote:
(10-06-2021, 10:37 AM)wba13 Wrote: My opinion is he is totally wrong not to have the vaccine, perhaps I’m being selfish but as I’m vulnerable I’m glad I’m not in his list of friends or relatives who go close by him. For all we know he could be a carrier and with his skin tone I think I’m right in saying he is more vulnerable to catching it. Another thing from a selfish point is having caught it twice he has missed matches so and put others at risk. For me it’s wrong when it’s proved the vaccine does a job why not take it instead of putting yourself, your family and anyone you come in contact with at risk.

Anyone can be a carrier. Vaxed or not. Had it previously or not. Literally anyone.

The vaccine severely limits bad cases of the disease.

Yes I know. But would rather be next to someone who’s been vaccinated and a carrier than next to someone not vaccinated and a carrier.

Eh?


RE: Fair Play to Callum Robinson - Remi_Moses - 10-06-2021

Missing common sense arguement.
If CR7 has caught Covid twice already, that shows his immune system isn't brilliant at providing antibodies.
I would have applied Reminomics and got double jabbed as soon as possible.
A help protect himself
B help protect those around him


RE: Fair Play to Callum Robinson - Sliced - 10-06-2021

(10-06-2021, 01:16 PM)baggy1 Wrote:
(10-06-2021, 01:05 PM)Sliced Wrote: There’s not conclusive evidence that you’re more protected by the vaccine than if you’ve had Covid in the past.

There’s not evidence that you’re less likely to transmit after having had the vaccine than if you’ve had Covid in the past.

It’s not the same as an unvaccinated person whos never had Covid, if you've had it twice then in theory you should be protected in the instance that you're unlucky enough to get it a third time and the chances of transmission will be lower.

Honestly the main story here is that Robinson has been racially abused, almost certainly as a result of his statement today, but it’s hardly been mentioned.

However there is conclusive proof logically that if you have had covid and are vaccinated then you will definitely be less likely to transmit the virus. Belt and braces as my old man used to say - very true in this situation. This shouldn't be an either / or discussion.

almost definitely*

But again, only as much proof as for having a 3rd and then 4th jab in quick succession, so why are we settling for only two jabs in a short space of time?

The answer is because they've decided that the costs which include the running these trials, and includes assessing the risks of having multiple jabs in a short space of time, isn't worth it.

Write to your Mp's, why settle only for 2 jabs if you're under 50 or 3 if you're over 50? If enough people do it then maybe collectively we can have more doses in a short space of time to reduce transmission further.

Robinson has decided that he doesn't want the vaccine as he's already had COVID and is less likely to transmit it. The backlash against him is real pitchfork stuff unfortunately. You should see the things people are writing on twitter. I've genuinely seen comments saying that they hope he dies. How wonderfully progressive.


RE: Fair Play to Callum Robinson - baggy1 - 10-06-2021

One of the reasons I've come off twitter tbh Sliced, an absolute scumfest on there at times.

I like to keep it simple, we've needed two jabs in quick succession to provide some immunity, we will also get it from catching the virus. Going forward less jabs will be needed because we will be more exposed to it naturally without as much risk (because of the existing jabs) and an annual booster for us old gets should be enough.


RE: Fair Play to Callum Robinson - backsidebaggie - 10-06-2021

(10-06-2021, 01:24 PM)Sliced Wrote:
(10-06-2021, 01:16 PM)baggy1 Wrote:
(10-06-2021, 01:05 PM)Sliced Wrote: There’s not conclusive evidence that you’re more protected by the vaccine than if you’ve had Covid in the past.

There’s not evidence that you’re less likely to transmit after having had the vaccine than if you’ve had Covid in the past.

It’s not the same as an unvaccinated person whos never had Covid, if you've had it twice then in theory you should be protected in the instance that you're unlucky enough to get it a third time and the chances of transmission will be lower.

Honestly the main story here is that Robinson has been racially abused, almost certainly as a result of his statement today, but it’s hardly been mentioned.

However there is conclusive proof logically that if you have had covid and are vaccinated then you will definitely be less likely to transmit the virus. Belt and braces as my old man used to say - very true in this situation. This shouldn't be an either / or discussion.

almost definitely*

But again, only as much proof as for having a 3rd and then 4th jab in quick succession, so why are we settling for only two jabs in a short space of time?

The answer is because they've decided that the costs which include the running these trials, and includes assessing the risks of having multiple jabs in a short space of time, isn't worth it.

Write to your Mp's, why settle only for 2 jabs if you're under 50 or 3 if you're over 50? If enough people do it then maybe collectively we can have more doses in a short space of time to reduce transmission further.

Robinson has decided that he doesn't want the vaccine as he's already had COVID and is less likely to transmit it. The backlash against him is real pitchfork stuff unfortunately. You should see the things people are writing on twitter.

Correct Slice. Pitchfork indeed. And this is being encouraged by the media, social media, the government, by labelling people and putting them into two categories. It’s not that simple. Then you have the “virtuous” like DH doing exactly that, increasing the division in society, sewing further seeds of division,  while claiming he’s caring about others. It’s gross.

I’m just thankful that people I come across in life, my friends and family aren’t like that. I’ve not heard any judgment from any of them on either having the vaccine or not. They have it for them, or don’t have it.


RE: Fair Play to Callum Robinson - Bob Fossil - 10-06-2021

(10-06-2021, 01:37 PM)backsidebaggie Wrote:
(10-06-2021, 01:24 PM)Sliced Wrote:
(10-06-2021, 01:16 PM)baggy1 Wrote:
(10-06-2021, 01:05 PM)Sliced Wrote: There’s not conclusive evidence that you’re more protected by the vaccine than if you’ve had Covid in the past.

There’s not evidence that you’re less likely to transmit after having had the vaccine than if you’ve had Covid in the past.

It’s not the same as an unvaccinated person whos never had Covid, if you've had it twice then in theory you should be protected in the instance that you're unlucky enough to get it a third time and the chances of transmission will be lower.

Honestly the main story here is that Robinson has been racially abused, almost certainly as a result of his statement today, but it’s hardly been mentioned.

However there is conclusive proof logically that if you have had covid and are vaccinated then you will definitely be less likely to transmit the virus. Belt and braces as my old man used to say - very true in this situation. This shouldn't be an either / or discussion.

almost definitely*

But again, only as much proof as for having a 3rd and then 4th jab in quick succession, so why are we settling for only two jabs in a short space of time?

The answer is because they've decided that the costs which include the running these trials, and includes assessing the risks of having multiple jabs in a short space of time, isn't worth it.

Write to your Mp's, why settle only for 2 jabs if you're under 50 or 3 if you're over 50? If enough people do it then maybe collectively we can have more doses in a short space of time to reduce transmission further.

Robinson has decided that he doesn't want the vaccine as he's already had COVID and is less likely to transmit it. The backlash against him is real pitchfork stuff unfortunately. You should see the things people are writing on twitter.

Correct Slice. Pitchfork indeed. And this is being encouraged by the media, social media, the government, by labelling people and putting them into two categories. It’s not that simple. Then you have the “virtuous” like DH doing exactly that, increasing the division in society, sewing further seeds of division,  while claiming he’s caring about others. It’s gross.

I’m just thankful that people I come across in life, my friends and family aren’t like that. I’ve not heard any judgment from any of them on either having the vaccine or not. They have it for them, or don’t have it.
You can't complain about labelling people and then label people.

You also label the media, social media and government as if they are single entities when they are not, there will be differing opinions across all of these bodies.

This is indeed a divisive issue, with differing opinions, you just seem to believe that you are 100% right, as do all the others.


RE: Fair Play to Callum Robinson - baggiebuckster - 10-06-2021

(10-06-2021, 10:43 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(10-06-2021, 09:28 AM)backsidebaggie Wrote: Most people don’t give a shit either way. Have it or don’t have it, most don’t care and accept it’s personal. Like all medical decisions.

There’s a few morons on either side who gleefully jump on negative stories about the other side. But I hated typing that because there should be no sides. It’s personal choice. I’d bet 95% of people dont give other people’s choices a single seconds thought. That’s called being normal.

There is no logic whatsoever to this argument. If your choices impact on others then of course you will care. People who refuse to get vaccinated are putting others, mostly the vulnerable at greater risk than they would be if they have had the vaccine. We can quibble about the percentages but this not just about the individual it’s about society as a whole.

(10-06-2021, 01:15 PM)boingingjim Wrote:
(10-06-2021, 12:41 PM)wba13 Wrote: My biggest concern would not be Calum as he possibly could not get Covid seriously but he could pass it on to someone who could get Covid seriously or die. For me it’s totally selfish not to get vaccinated unless there are underlying issues to prevent you.

As could a vaccinated person.  Round and round we go.  His body is his life and slight deviation in performance could seriously damage his earning potential.  Post vaccine I was rough for days and had an increased heart rate of around 10-15 BPM for a week or so after.  I can totally understand why a professional sportsperson would not risk this after knowing they are heavily protected with antibodies from prior infection.

Imagine a scenario where he does get some kind of heart inflammation, is that for the greater good?
  The vulnerable in society are protected as best as they can be with some now having had 3 shots of a vaccine.  We can't live life based on what ifs.  Personal risk is for each individual to weigh up and decide. 

It's like me demanding that dairy is banned from all commercial kitchens because I have a severe allergy to it.  I just have to look and make a judgement call based on the menu in front of me (or choose not to eat out).

I notice this statement has been ignored. Exactly this - and that is the position of many parents with teenage boys who are clearly at greater risk of this occurring from the jab. All these people who have ongoing adverse reactions appear to be considered as collateral damage by a few on here.

And as I finished typing this I see that Sweden has now paused the Moderna jab for under 30's due to heart inflammation issues.


RE: Fair Play to Callum Robinson - backsidebaggie - 10-06-2021

(10-06-2021, 02:00 PM)Bob Fossil Wrote:
(10-06-2021, 01:37 PM)backsidebaggie Wrote:
(10-06-2021, 01:24 PM)Sliced Wrote:
(10-06-2021, 01:16 PM)baggy1 Wrote:
(10-06-2021, 01:05 PM)Sliced Wrote: There’s not conclusive evidence that you’re more protected by the vaccine than if you’ve had Covid in the past.

There’s not evidence that you’re less likely to transmit after having had the vaccine than if you’ve had Covid in the past.

It’s not the same as an unvaccinated person whos never had Covid, if you've had it twice then in theory you should be protected in the instance that you're unlucky enough to get it a third time and the chances of transmission will be lower.

Honestly the main story here is that Robinson has been racially abused, almost certainly as a result of his statement today, but it’s hardly been mentioned.

However there is conclusive proof logically that if you have had covid and are vaccinated then you will definitely be less likely to transmit the virus. Belt and braces as my old man used to say - very true in this situation. This shouldn't be an either / or discussion.

almost definitely*

But again, only as much proof as for having a 3rd and then 4th jab in quick succession, so why are we settling for only two jabs in a short space of time?

The answer is because they've decided that the costs which include the running these trials, and includes assessing the risks of having multiple jabs in a short space of time, isn't worth it.

Write to your Mp's, why settle only for 2 jabs if you're under 50 or 3 if you're over 50? If enough people do it then maybe collectively we can have more doses in a short space of time to reduce transmission further.

Robinson has decided that he doesn't want the vaccine as he's already had COVID and is less likely to transmit it. The backlash against him is real pitchfork stuff unfortunately. You should see the things people are writing on twitter.

Correct Slice. Pitchfork indeed. And this is being encouraged by the media, social media, the government, by labelling people and putting them into two categories. It’s not that simple. Then you have the “virtuous” like DH doing exactly that, increasing the division in society, sewing further seeds of division,  while claiming he’s caring about others. It’s gross.

I’m just thankful that people I come across in life, my friends and family aren’t like that. I’ve not heard any judgment from any of them on either having the vaccine or not. They have it for them, or don’t have it.
You can't complain about labelling people and then label people.

You also label the media, social media and government as if they are single entities when they are not, there will be differing opinions across all of these bodies.

This is indeed a divisive issue, with differing opinions, you just seem to believe that you are 100% right, as do all the others.

My point is labelling into two distinct categories. Vax and unvax.

I don’t think it’s right or wrong to be vaccinated or not. It’s totally right for the individual to do exactly as they wish. Both choices are fine. But the labelling that goes on is not correct. The labelling of people automatically being 5G conspiracy theorists if they don’t have the vaccine. Or being an anti vaxxer even if they’ve had tons of vaccines before. That’s the labelling im talking about. Silly generalisations that cause greater division, rather than acknowledging the nuances.

My labelling of DH isn’t labelling in that way, its not pigeonholing him into a type, it’s an accurate description of what he does. 

I think social media and government and media have largely ignored the nuance and joined in with this all or nothing, vax or anti vax approach.

There is no right or wrong. What’s right for Callum Robinson may not be right for Bob fossil or backsidebaggie. But I sure as hell know it’s way more nuanced than just lumping people into vax or anti vax.

(10-06-2021, 02:00 PM)baggiebuckster Wrote:
(10-06-2021, 10:43 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(10-06-2021, 09:28 AM)backsidebaggie Wrote: Most people don’t give a shit either way. Have it or don’t have it, most don’t care and accept it’s personal. Like all medical decisions.

There’s a few morons on either side who gleefully jump on negative stories about the other side. But I hated typing that because there should be no sides. It’s personal choice. I’d bet 95% of people dont give other people’s choices a single seconds thought. That’s called being normal.

There is no logic whatsoever to this argument. If your choices impact on others then of course you will care. People who refuse to get vaccinated are putting others, mostly the vulnerable at greater risk than they would be if they have had the vaccine. We can quibble about the percentages but this not just about the individual it’s about society as a whole.

(10-06-2021, 01:15 PM)boingingjim Wrote:
(10-06-2021, 12:41 PM)wba13 Wrote: My biggest concern would not be Calum as he possibly could not get Covid seriously but he could pass it on to someone who could get Covid seriously or die. For me it’s totally selfish not to get vaccinated unless there are underlying issues to prevent you.

As could a vaccinated person.  Round and round we go.  His body is his life and slight deviation in performance could seriously damage his earning potential.  Post vaccine I was rough for days and had an increased heart rate of around 10-15 BPM for a week or so after.  I can totally understand why a professional sportsperson would not risk this after knowing they are heavily protected with antibodies from prior infection.

Imagine a scenario where he does get some kind of heart inflammation, is that for the greater good?
  The vulnerable in society are protected as best as they can be with some now having had 3 shots of a vaccine.  We can't live life based on what ifs.  Personal risk is for each individual to weigh up and decide. 

It's like me demanding that dairy is banned from all commercial kitchens because I have a severe allergy to it.  I just have to look and make a judgement call based on the menu in front of me (or choose not to eat out).

I notice this statement has been ignored. Exactly this - and that is the position of many parents with teenage boys who are clearly at greater risk of this occurring from the jab. All these people who have ongoing adverse reactions appear to be considered as collateral damage by a few on here.

And as I finished typing this I see that Sweden has now paused the Moderna jab for under 30's due to heart inflammation issues.

Indeed. Yet many will tell us there’s “no good reason” not be have the vaccine. It’s unbelievable blind faith. Especially for young folks who have such small chances of dying from covid. There are good reasons. Not everyone will agree with their reasons, but there are good reasons.


RE: Fair Play to Callum Robinson - wba13 - 10-06-2021

(10-06-2021, 02:11 PM)backsidebaggie Wrote:
(10-06-2021, 02:00 PM)Bob Fossil Wrote:
(10-06-2021, 01:37 PM)backsidebaggie Wrote:
(10-06-2021, 01:24 PM)Sliced Wrote:
(10-06-2021, 01:16 PM)baggy1 Wrote: However there is conclusive proof logically that if you have had covid and are vaccinated then you will definitely be less likely to transmit the virus. Belt and braces as my old man used to say - very true in this situation. This shouldn't be an either / or discussion.

almost definitely*

But again, only as much proof as for having a 3rd and then 4th jab in quick succession, so why are we settling for only two jabs in a short space of time?

The answer is because they've decided that the costs which include the running these trials, and includes assessing the risks of having multiple jabs in a short space of time, isn't worth it.

Write to your Mp's, why settle only for 2 jabs if you're under 50 or 3 if you're over 50? If enough people do it then maybe collectively we can have more doses in a short space of time to reduce transmission further.

Robinson has decided that he doesn't want the vaccine as he's already had COVID and is less likely to transmit it. The backlash against him is real pitchfork stuff unfortunately. You should see the things people are writing on twitter.

Correct Slice. Pitchfork indeed. And this is being encouraged by the media, social media, the government, by labelling people and putting them into two categories. It’s not that simple. Then you have the “virtuous” like DH doing exactly that, increasing the division in society, sewing further seeds of division,  while claiming he’s caring about others. It’s gross.

I’m just thankful that people I come across in life, my friends and family aren’t like that. I’ve not heard any judgment from any of them on either having the vaccine or not. They have it for them, or don’t have it.
You can't complain about labelling people and then label people.

You also label the media, social media and government as if they are single entities when they are not, there will be differing opinions across all of these bodies.

This is indeed a divisive issue, with differing opinions, you just seem to believe that you are 100% right, as do all the others.

My point is labelling into two distinct categories. Vax and unvax.

I don’t think it’s right or wrong to be vaccinated or not. It’s totally right for the individual to do exactly as they wish. Both choices are fine. But the labelling that goes on is not correct. The labelling of people automatically being 5G conspiracy theorists if they don’t have the vaccine. Or being an anti vaxxer even if they’ve had tons of vaccines before. That’s the labelling im talking about. Silly generalisations that cause greater division, rather than acknowledging the nuances.

My labelling of DH isn’t labelling in that way, its not pigeonholing him into a type, it’s an accurate description of what he does. 

I think social media and government and media have largely ignored the nuance and joined in with this all or nothing, vax or anti vax approach.

There is no right or wrong. What’s right for Callum Robinson may not be right for Bob fossil or backsidebaggie. But I sure as hell know it’s way more nuanced than just lumping people into vax or anti vax.

(10-06-2021, 02:00 PM)baggiebuckster Wrote:
(10-06-2021, 10:43 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(10-06-2021, 09:28 AM)backsidebaggie Wrote: Most people don’t give a shit either way. Have it or don’t have it, most don’t care and accept it’s personal. Like all medical decisions.

There’s a few morons on either side who gleefully jump on negative stories about the other side. But I hated typing that because there should be no sides. It’s personal choice. I’d bet 95% of people dont give other people’s choices a single seconds thought. That’s called being normal.

There is no logic whatsoever to this argument. If your choices impact on others then of course you will care. People who refuse to get vaccinated are putting others, mostly the vulnerable at greater risk than they would be if they have had the vaccine. We can quibble about the percentages but this not just about the individual it’s about society as a whole.

(10-06-2021, 01:15 PM)boingingjim Wrote:
(10-06-2021, 12:41 PM)wba13 Wrote: My biggest concern would not be Calum as he possibly could not get Covid seriously but he could pass it on to someone who could get Covid seriously or die. For me it’s totally selfish not to get vaccinated unless there are underlying issues to prevent you.

As could a vaccinated person.  Round and round we go.  His body is his life and slight deviation in performance could seriously damage his earning potential.  Post vaccine I was rough for days and had an increased heart rate of around 10-15 BPM for a week or so after.  I can totally understand why a professional sportsperson would not risk this after knowing they are heavily protected with antibodies from prior infection.

Imagine a scenario where he does get some kind of heart inflammation, is that for the greater good?
  The vulnerable in society are protected as best as they can be with some now having had 3 shots of a vaccine.  We can't live life based on what ifs.  Personal risk is for each individual to weigh up and decide. 

It's like me demanding that dairy is banned from all commercial kitchens because I have a severe allergy to it.  I just have to look and make a judgement call based on the menu in front of me (or choose not to eat out).

I notice this statement has been ignored. Exactly this - and that is the position of many parents with teenage boys who are clearly at greater risk of this occurring from the jab. All these people who have ongoing adverse reactions appear to be considered as collateral damage by a few on here.

And as I finished typing this I see that Sweden has now paused the Moderna jab for under 30's due to heart inflammation issues.

Indeed. Yet many will tell us there’s “no good reason” not be have the vaccine. It’s unbelievable blind faith. Especially for young folks who have such small chances of dying from covid. There are good reasons. Not everyone will agree with their reasons, but there are good reasons.

I will end here, I think he’s wrong not to be vaccinated, I’m glad I’m not in his circle of friends but it’s his choice. All of my family and friends have had at least 2 doses where eligible so we all feel safe in each other’s company.


RE: Fair Play to Callum Robinson - Derek Hardballs - 10-06-2021

(10-06-2021, 01:37 PM)backsidebaggie Wrote:
(10-06-2021, 01:24 PM)Sliced Wrote:
(10-06-2021, 01:16 PM)baggy1 Wrote:
(10-06-2021, 01:05 PM)Sliced Wrote: There’s not conclusive evidence that you’re more protected by the vaccine than if you’ve had Covid in the past.

There’s not evidence that you’re less likely to transmit after having had the vaccine than if you’ve had Covid in the past.

It’s not the same as an unvaccinated person whos never had Covid, if you've had it twice then in theory you should be protected in the instance that you're unlucky enough to get it a third time and the chances of transmission will be lower.

Honestly the main story here is that Robinson has been racially abused, almost certainly as a result of his statement today, but it’s hardly been mentioned.

However there is conclusive proof logically that if you have had covid and are vaccinated then you will definitely be less likely to transmit the virus. Belt and braces as my old man used to say - very true in this situation. This shouldn't be an either / or discussion.

almost definitely*

But again, only as much proof as for having a 3rd and then 4th jab in quick succession, so why are we settling for only two jabs in a short space of time?

The answer is because they've decided that the costs which include the running these trials, and includes assessing the risks of having multiple jabs in a short space of time, isn't worth it.

Write to your Mp's, why settle only for 2 jabs if you're under 50 or 3 if you're over 50? If enough people do it then maybe collectively we can have more doses in a short space of time to reduce transmission further.

Robinson has decided that he doesn't want the vaccine as he's already had COVID and is less likely to transmit it. The backlash against him is real pitchfork stuff unfortunately. You should see the things people are writing on twitter.

Correct Slice. Pitchfork indeed. And this is being encouraged by the media, social media, the government, by labelling people and putting them into two categories. It’s not that simple. Then you have the “virtuous” like DH doing exactly that, increasing the division in society, sewing further seeds of division,  while claiming he’s caring about others. It’s gross.

I’m just thankful that people I come across in life, my friends and family aren’t like that. I’ve not heard any judgment from any of them on either having the vaccine or not. They have it for them, or don’t have it.

Hang on a minute before you drag me into every post on this subject. Let's get this clear I am defending the most vulnerable people's right to live as normal a life as possible. People I might add who would dearly love / give anything for the vaccine to keep them as safe as they can be from getting seriously ill or dying, but for a number of reasons can't have it. They and their families lives have shrank to what others endured for a few months under lockdown, even more so now there are little or no restrictions. Currently there is still no light at the end of the tunnel for them whilst the rest of the population now goes about its normal life to a lesser or greater extent. 

You are making out that people who choose to not have the vaccine are victims but hardly ever mention those whose lives are made more difficult by their decisions, just a throwaway line or two about having to shield / be careful. Cast your mind back to when there was no vaccine for elderly relatives and when people in the 50's, 60, 70's were dying from Covid at a much greater rate, those left behind through no choice of their own by the vaccine roll out are still at that point. They haven't had an opportunity to move on since the pandemic has started. What would make their live easier is for those that can have the jab to have it. If me questioning the choice of those who refuse to have the vaccine and coming to the conclusion I completely disagree with them is wrong and stating as such is gross then so be it. I haven't taken their rights away from making that choice but some have no choice it's worth remembering in all of this. For someone who is all about defending people's rights, it does seem you wish to put the rights of some as greater than others. We all have a responsibility for each other, society falls apart if we do not uphold both rights and responsibilities.