WBAUnofficial
Gary's Economics - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: Politics (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=5)
+--- Thread: Gary's Economics (/showthread.php?tid=42041)

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12


RE: Gary's Economics - Derek Hardballs - 08-06-2026

(08-06-2026, 04:46 PM)Shabby Russian Wrote:
(08-06-2026, 12:20 PM)baggy1 Wrote: 'Wealth tax' is the new Brexit. No-one can define it or what the benefits will be but they just want it.

There is a massive misunderstanding in how wealth actually materialises here - taking the most well known one, Elon Musk, for example. His wealth is created by the value of his shares going up and, if he were in the UK, he would pay a tax on that if he ever realised them. That is a wealth tax. If he owned two houses and sold his second home, he would pay tax on that. That is a wealth tax. When he dies and he passes his wealth onto other individuals there is a tax at that point. All of these are taxes on wealth.

I would imagine that a wealth tax can easily be defined as a number of countries employ one.

For example one of the richest countries in the world...if you sue the measurement of gdp per population. Switzerland has a wealth tax, or more accurately it has a number of wealth taxes, as each individual canton has its own wealth tax . These wealth taxes haven't stopped Switzerland being seen as a bit of a poster boy for liberal economies.

But despite that a handful of the richest individuals in the world have a combined wealth greater than the total GDP of a country of nearly 10 million people and widely seen as one of the most successful economies in the world.

My real concern is that the most wealthy in the world will use their wealth in a negative way. Gaining political power, protecting their wealth by supporting authoritarian, perhaps totalitarian regimes, with little regard to human rights, the economic well being of most of the world's citizens etc.

Doing nothing about this seems to me to be the really stupid thing to do.

Exactly, and lsts be honest this is already happening across the globe. But the experts on here have already said we just need to carry on doing the same as we have for the last 40-50yrs and it’ll be fine!


RE: Gary's Economics - tHEgLASSdOORS - 08-06-2026

Agree with the above. We live in truly volatile times and have 3 geriatrics in the 3 most powerful seats (traditional power, at least) utterly divorced from the volatile and changing dynamics that most impact where the real power sits.

It’s hard not to believe that at some point AI will drop a massive unforeseen bollock that sends everything spinning.


RE: Gary's Economics - Øssian - 08-06-2026

Things could be worse, and soon enough they will be: give it ‘til the middle of this century and climate migration will be vying with economic resettlement for which is causing the bigger movement of the people.


RE: Gary's Economics - tHEgLASSdOORS - 08-06-2026

I’d be astonished if we get to 2030 in once piece never mind 2050


RE: Gary's Economics - Shabby Russian - 08-07-2026

(08-06-2026, 08:18 PM)Øssian Wrote: Things could be worse, and soon enough they will be: give it ‘til the middle of this century and climate migration will be vying with economic resettlement for which is causing the bigger movement of the people.

Agree with this.

The issue of migration is very serious, but very few people take it seriously enough.

Too many people in this country are obsessed by so called pull factors driving migration but totally ignore the more pertinent (and more to difficult to solve) push factors.


RE: Gary's Economics - Squid - 08-07-2026

(08-07-2026, 07:57 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote:
(08-06-2026, 08:18 PM)Øssian Wrote: Things could be worse, and soon enough they will be: give it ‘til the middle of this century and climate migration will be vying with economic resettlement for which is causing the bigger movement of the people.

Agree with this.

The issue of migration is very serious, but very few people take it seriously enough.

Too many people in this country are obsessed by so called pull factors driving migration but totally ignore the more pertinent (and more to difficult to solve) push factors.

There is that. I actually think there are some similarities with the supposed War On Drugs. There is no drug more potent than hope and in particular, the hope of a better life. Hence why people trafficking is now a multi million pound business.


RE: Gary's Economics - HawkingsHalfpint - 08-07-2026

(08-07-2026, 10:24 AM)Squid Wrote:
(08-07-2026, 07:57 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote:
(08-06-2026, 08:18 PM)Øssian Wrote: Things could be worse, and soon enough they will be: give it ‘til the middle of this century and climate migration will be vying with economic resettlement for which is causing the bigger movement of the people.

Agree with this.

The issue of migration is very serious, but very few people take it seriously enough.

Too many people in this country are obsessed by so called pull factors driving migration but totally ignore the more pertinent (and more to difficult to solve) push factors.

There is that. I actually think there are some similarities with the supposed War On Drugs. There is no drug more potent than hope and in particular, the hope of a better life. Hence why people trafficking is now a multi million pound business.

Correct. As I keep saying to my right-wing, boomer parents ‘would you get on one of those boats? How desperate would you have to be?’ 

So then you get the token ‘but but but it’s always the young men’ reply, to which I simply reply ‘Dad, would you let Mom, or one of your kids/grandkids take that massive risk, or shoulder it yourself?’ 

Their counter-argument isn’t even correct - plenty of women and children board them. It just doesn’t get printed in their right-wing source of daily hate, the Torygraph. 

And as I keep saying to them, they’re looking at it all wrong. It’s when people STOP wanting to come here we have serious problems. That they do demonstrates it is still a country worth living in. Where people see fairness, opportunity, diversity etc. I’m not arguing we can afford to let everyone in, but the boats argument is an over-exaggerated proportion of net inward migration.


RE: Gary's Economics - petty sniper - 08-10-2026

(08-06-2026, 10:02 AM)baggy1 Wrote: Don't feed the troll ps. For the record I have no argument against a wealth tax and think a workable one is welcome to most people. I also think it would raise some taxes although probably not as much as is being quoted for the reasons already stated.

A couple of points that your statement needs to be clear on. Your opening statement of 'Billionaire wealth has more than doubled in the last 10 years', can you get me a link to check that. I have no doubt that there are more Billionaires than there were 10 years ago but that doesn't mean that their wealth has doubled. If an individual has £900,000,000,000 in 2025 and £1Bn in 2026 there is 1 more Billionaire to measure that wasn't being measured before but that individual's wealth has not doubled. And also are we talking about UK Billionaires only here, I've never understood why there are different ways of measuring Bn between UK and US.

Secondly don't confuse solid assets (buildings, cars etc) which will make up some of their wealth, but I would guess at being a small part percentagewise, with the share type wealth that will make up the majority of their wealth. If they simply sell the latter type of assets then that won't be a redistributable asset and it will likely devalue the business or fund that they held it in.

And going back to the opening point, I am not arguing against a wealth tax I am asking for a workable one. Zucman has said that in order for this to work effectively there would need to be a coordinated global wealth tax and we are a billion miles off that at the moment. This is a good debating point but realistically wouldn't work in the UK at this point in time.

Point 1
Sunday Times rich list Top 10 total

2016 - 101B
2026 - 213B

Point 2
The sale of any assets is a start.  Linked to a LVT is may help with property

Point 3
Zucman proposes a 10 year exit tax and says it would be better if it was worldwide but that is no reason not to do it.  He also gives the example of income tax which was introduced at diffrent times in different countries.  My view is that everyone will have to do it eventually


RE: Gary's Economics - baggy1 - 08-10-2026

Thanks for those ps. You've convinced me of giving it a better look at it. I do believe that we would suffer initially in the hope that other countries bring it in but longer term and I'd like to understand more about the actual value of their properties that would be the benefit as you point out. However if that is the case wouldn't a LVT suffice?


RE: Gary's Economics - petty sniper - 08-10-2026

Watch Zucman on TRIP - he gets a real grilling from Stewart and holds his own. He is also excellent on the rest is money. The LVT promotes the active use of land and thus growth rather than land banking. The growth of the super rich needs to be address because as the wealth transfers to them it has to come from somewhere and that is the middle and upper classes - the young working class and the government have very little left.

As for Gary Stevenson - he deserves massive credit for bringing the issue to the fore and as he says he is not a tax expert but has recognised that the problem needs to be addressed