![]() |
|
Cancelling Elections - Printable Version +- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk) +-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3) +--- Forum: Politics (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=5) +--- Thread: Cancelling Elections (/showthread.php?tid=40152) |
RE: Cancelling Elections - man in the corner shop - 02-20-2026 Yes that's the criticism of the "social care is free in Scotland" line lauded by SNP and Labour. Looks like anything from £700 to £1500 pw. So it's certainly not free. The capital threshold is £35k there though. Seems that the state pay a higher contribution to your fees there. Not much of a difference really. But more generous than England. (02-19-2026, 07:54 AM)Protheroe Wrote: It’s a minority of us that will need long term care. At the moment the majority of local government finance goes to a tiny minority of people, many of whom have substantial assets. When you are saving for your old age who are you saving for? I’m saving for me and Mrs P, whilst making provision for my kids where I can. The Brexit generation doing their thing. I see and hear so much argument that we shouldn't be playing generations off against one another but the baby boomers really did and do have it all. Start by abolishing the triple lock, make pensioners pay NI, national housebuilding programme. It's really no wonder. According to the Office for National Statistics, external, suicide was the leading cause of death among young people aged 20 to 34 in England and Wales in 2024. According to the Office for National Statistics, external, suicide was the leading cause of death among young people aged 20 to 34 in England and Wales in 2024. RE: Cancelling Elections - baggy1 - 02-20-2026 Do you ever read, and interpret properly, anything you post MICS. There is a reason why suicide is the leading cause of death amongst young people aged 20-34, and that is due to he lack of other causes of death in that age group - they're healthy! If you go to page 8 it shows you that suicides in general are about the same for the last 45 years, and that is taking into account that they are classified as suicides now based on 'balance of probabilities' as opposed to the pre-2018 classification by 'beyond reasonable doubt'. This means there is a good chance that using the same measure they are down. If you go to page 13 you'll see that it is more prevalent in the 50-60 age group than any other. If you are going to take on a serious subject such as this please do some reading around the subject. RE: Cancelling Elections - man in the corner shop - 02-20-2026 It seems it is you that needs to some reading and apply a bit of thinking. I am clearly talking about age 20-34 yet you use page 8 to quote all age statistics, in some piss poor petty attempt to create a needless argument. The same MO that you use with Derek. It must be a centrist dad chip and you just come on here to argue for the sake if it. Well done on finding the chart on p13 as that was the one I was looking at. And yes I know about the 2018 changes. Now, getting back to the issue. There is clearly some balance to be applied between the baby boomers and whatever today's kids are called. It's a national scandal. RE: Cancelling Elections - baggy1 - 02-20-2026 WTF are you talking about? Have you even followed the link that references the very stat you talk about. The reason that suicide is the leading cause of death amongst young people aged 20-34 is that there are few other types of death because that age group is healthier. The other two listed are Accidental poisoning at 14.3% and Land Transport Accidents at 5.7%. The total deaths in those 3 comes to 2,517. Whereas if you go to the 50-64 age group you get a whole range of ways to go including heart disease, cancer, cirrhosis of the liver, respiratory diseases etc - you know the things that come with age, so unsurprisingly suicide is not one of the leading causes in that age group.The total in this age group (of leading causes of death not all btw) is 26,135, ten times the number. And the lowest number, cerebrovascular disease comes in at 2,222, nearly as much as the top three in the 20-34 age group. Also if you look just a few paragraphs down it clearly says that 45-59 year olds are at higher risk. Edit, just looked a little bit further into the figures and can confirm that the number of males in the age group 50-64 that died of intentional self harm was 1,376. in the 20-34 age group the same figure for males is 985 and in both male and female it is 1,378, so safe to say that it is more prevalent in the older age group. This is the point you say fair enough, I misunderstood the document. And btw this is a subject close to my heart so no glib comments either please. RE: Cancelling Elections - Protheroe - 02-21-2026 (02-20-2026, 04:38 PM)baggy1 Wrote: And btw this is a subject close to my heart so no glib comments either please. #MeToo RE: Cancelling Elections - baggy1 - 02-21-2026 Hard to understand what you mean by that comment are you saying that as a comment about me being a 'victim', or are you saying you also have been impacted? RE: Cancelling Elections - Protheroe - 02-21-2026 (02-21-2026, 10:15 AM)baggy1 Wrote: Hard to understand what you mean by that comment are you saying that as a comment about me being a 'victim', or are you saying you also have been impacted? the latter RE: Cancelling Elections - baggy1 - 02-21-2026 Sorry to hear about that. Sometimes I can read too much into a simple comment on here, apologies for even considering that. RE: Cancelling Elections - Derek Hardballs - 02-21-2026 There are also posters who have lived or worked experiences on other equally serious subjects whose opinions should not be readily dismissed glibly because they are at odds with others. This isn’t a post to cause an argument but rather asking all of us to extend the same courtesy when it comes to some subjects that are discussed. RE: Cancelling Elections - baggy1 - 02-21-2026 Good call Dekka. The reason for the focus on this point was how a fact was being used completely out of context and this is what I try and pick up on here. MICS read a fact ‘the biggest cause of death in the 20-34 age group is suicide’ and then misinterpreted it as meaning that it impacted that age group more than before, and also impacted that age group more than any other age group to support a point about how that age group is suffering. Both of those points were wrong but it doesn’t diminish the point that the younger generation is suffering and using suicide as a way to get a point across can be a bit sharp for some of us. |