WBAUnofficial
Corberan - messiah or overrated or somewhere in between? - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: Corberan - messiah or overrated or somewhere in between? (/showthread.php?tid=33824)

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10


RE: Corberan - messiah or overrated or somewhere in between? - johntoewba - 05-21-2024

(05-21-2024, 10:16 AM)Woodman scoreboard Wrote:
(05-21-2024, 10:10 AM)richbaggie Wrote: The Corberan discussion on the Brighton thread seems to match what I see on social media. There is a growing, albeit still mainly a minority of fans, who are questioning his ability. Whilst questioning is fine, some of the criticism feels harsh given what he's done in a relatively short time under extremely difficult circumstances.

He's not the messiah, but we have a good un who will improve with more experience. His work ethic is astonishing, players buy in to him, he connects with fans and staff. He gets it.

Ultimately it's about results and overall he's in the positive category. Taking us from bottom to 5th in less than 2 years with an unbalanced squad and players that most had written off as not being good enough is a good achievement. Not a miracle, but still a good achievement. 

I think the best judge of any coach is have the players improved under him and who have stagnated or regressed.

I'd say only a couple, 3 at most have stagnated or regressed. The rest have either improved or dramatically improved. When was the last manager you could say did that for us? Roy?

He does get things wrong. I think he overthinks things sometimes. But overall he's doing a bloody good job, he's the perfect fit for us, and I think we are lucky to have him.

I like him but he frustrates me more than he should.
Love the bloke and he’s done a fantastic job but Friday really disappointed me. Far too defensive for my liking


RE: Corberan - messiah or overrated or somewhere in between? - SW4Baggie - 05-21-2024

(05-21-2024, 04:46 PM)MancBaggie Wrote:
(05-21-2024, 04:37 PM)Shabby Russian Wrote:
(05-21-2024, 04:30 PM)MancBaggie Wrote: Roy's early days were excellent - we scored a lot of goals and played an attacking 4231 in the last few months of that 10/11 season.  We bagged some great home wins too including v Liverpool, Villa and a good Everton side

In his full season - the home form was largely turgid and his flat 442 didnt work that well.  However, the counter attack style away from home reaped dividends and we smashed a load of top flight away hoodoos including Vile, Blackburn Newcastle Wolves and Liverpool

Always felt his full season in charge was hampered by the start we had.

Chelsea and Man U both good  performances no points, then the compulsory home defeat to Stoke.

Playing catch up thereafter and made Roy ultra pragmatic.

Someone will now tell I have mixed up seasons and I will put it down to age.

Youre spot on Shabb.  

2 good early performances and then 2 dreadful ones at home to Stoke and Fulham  0-1 and 0-0

The 0-1 at home to Everton on a very hungover New Years Day with the obligatory late Anichebe goal possibly the lowest point of Hodgson’s time here. That was truly woeful.


RE: Corberan - messiah or overrated or somewhere in between? - Midget In A Pinstripe Suit - 05-21-2024

Fugg me that Everton game was horrendous, raging hangover, early KO, cold wet and miserable. A rare day I sat in the SME.


RE: Corberan - messiah or overrated or somewhere in between? - man in the corner shop - 05-21-2024

I think that he has done as well as he could do with the resources he has had. I have been very bored quite often watching the team as he sets them up to play. I will accept any old shite if results go our way - i put up with Pulis, for example. So he still has a lot of credit with me and we are lucky to have him. But he is not beyond criticism and fair play to people who want to criticise - as long as it is rational.

I think that the squad isnt good enough. They appear to be a collection of mentally weak blokes and do not seem fit enough to me, also clueless at set pieces (Carlos's problems to sort)

Also they dont seem to do the basics of passing to another Albion player and a lot cant trap a pig in an entry. Carlos doesnt send them out with these failings and thats on them.

Overall, 5th with not a great team and no striker is brilliant. Well done Carlos. Bravo.


RE: Corberan - messiah or overrated or somewhere in between? - Wotty - 05-21-2024

We’re lucky to have him. Simple. He’s intelligent, articulate and results driven.
Long may he reign as our manager.


RE: Corberan - messiah or overrated or somewhere in between? - Sliced - 05-21-2024

Clarkes first season was the best football I’ve ever seen us play. We had a few matches under Bilic that were spectacular but under Clarke we had about 4 months in a row of just looking like a top quality side


RE: Corberan - messiah or overrated or somewhere in between? - MancBaggie - 05-21-2024

(05-21-2024, 05:40 PM)Midget In A Pinstripe Suit Wrote: Fugg me that Everton game was horrendous, raging hangover, early KO, cold wet and miserable. A rare day I sat in the SME.

Everton Swansea Wigan and Stoke at home were all dreadful performances


RE: Corberan - messiah or overrated or somewhere in between? - baggy1 - 05-21-2024

Don't think there's any serious push for people to get him replaced, he's done a fantastic job with the resources provided and considering the strength of the 3 that came down he worked miracles to get us to being 2nd best of the rest. One area of concern is his recruitment, Chalobah and M'vila don'e fill me with confidence but at the same time he hasn't exactly been given the combination to the safe to blow.

Earned another year and in this game that's all that anyone can expect.


RE: Corberan - messiah or overrated or somewhere in between? - SW4Baggie - 05-21-2024

(05-21-2024, 06:35 PM)baggy1 Wrote: Don't think there's any serious push for people to get him replaced, he's done a fantastic job with the resources provided and considering the strength of the 3 that came down he worked miracles to get us to being 2nd best of the rest. One area of concern is his recruitment, Chalobah and M'vila don'e fill me with confidence but at the same time he hasn't exactly been given the combination to the safe to blow.

Earned another year and in this game that's all that anyone can expect.

The Chalobah signing was utterly bizarre but had all the hallmarks of being a Gourlay one - think he may have been at Chelsea at the same time as Big Ron, and by his own admission he focused on signing players he or Bruce knew during their time together so doubt that changed when CC arrived.

M’Vila was a last minute replacement for Molumby… doubt he cost us much and he was someone CC knew


RE: Corberan - messiah or overrated or somewhere in between? - Duffers - 05-21-2024

(05-21-2024, 09:14 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(05-21-2024, 06:35 PM)baggy1 Wrote: Don't think there's any serious push for people to get him replaced, he's done a fantastic job with the resources provided and considering the strength of the 3 that came down he worked miracles to get us to being 2nd best of the rest. One area of concern is his recruitment, Chalobah and M'vila don'e fill me with confidence but at the same time he hasn't exactly been given the combination to the safe to blow.

Earned another year and in this game that's all that anyone can expect.

The Chalobah signing was utterly bizarre but had all the hallmarks of being a Gourlay one - think he may have been at Chelsea at the same time as Big Ron, and by his own admission he focused on signing players he or Bruce knew during their time together so doubt that changed when CC arrived.

M’Vila was a last minute replacement for Molumby… doubt he cost us much and he was someone CC knew

Most of the players we have brought in over the last 12 months or so have been reactive. They’ve been replacements for injured players or those who have left and were basically bodies brought in when we desperately needed some.

When the need is that dire there isn’t really any time for detailed scouting or negotiation, it’s a case of bringing in bodies the manager or staff know and can afford.

For thise reasons I don’t judge our transfer business of the last year too harshly.

That West Ham kid though is a future quiz tie breaker.