![]() |
|
Motd - Printable Version +- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk) +-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3) +--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4) +--- Thread: Motd (/showthread.php?tid=29197) |
RE: Motd - Borin' Baggie - 03-13-2023 (03-13-2023, 03:54 PM)Squid Wrote:(03-13-2023, 02:45 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:(03-13-2023, 02:40 PM)Squid Wrote:(03-13-2023, 02:33 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:(03-13-2023, 02:25 PM)Squid Wrote: ...despite the very best effort of some. I've made perfectly clear before that I think rapists should be kept in isolation in prison, to you. I'm perfectly supportive of third spaces for changing rooms for transgender people to use. I do not support indecent exposure. None of that has anything to do with sex education or provisions of support for transgender teenagers. Care to put any more words in my mouth? Or is this going to end up with you calling me a misogynist and accusing me of only supported my mate's transition because he was transitioning as a female as some "men are better" superiority again? RE: Motd - Birdman1811 - 03-13-2023 Ah the good old slippery slope logical fallacy. If you accept this then you accept this will happen as it's a slippery slope etc... I don't debate with those using logical fallacies, it's a sign of dishonest debating. RE: Motd - Squid - 03-13-2023 (03-13-2023, 04:20 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: Ah the good old slippery slope logical fallacy. You are shifting the goalposts. It's not a fallacy if it is already taking place. As I have already evidenced upthread. So tell me exactly where I have been dishonest? Borin - whenever these issues are discussed, you always bring your friend into it. Last time you said Gender Self-ID needs to happen (despite the fact that it will lead to all the issues I've stated above), because your friend is distraught about not being able to change their birth certificate. Third spaces are great...but they need to be alongside single sex spaces. Those pushing for Self-ID as we have seen up in Scotland, do not believe in single-sex provision. This is the battle that women are facing. As for support for young people with gender dysphoria, contrary to what is happening in the US, the UK, Sweden, and now Norway have all found that the evidence base for youth transition is very poor and that more talking therapies are required. I recommend you read the Cass Review, if you haven't already done so. RE: Motd - Birdman1811 - 03-13-2023 (03-13-2023, 04:57 PM)Squid Wrote:(03-13-2023, 04:20 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: Ah the good old slippery slope logical fallacy. The problem with third spaces is simply that, space, do we actually need 4? Trans men, trans women? What about those who do and don't have bottom surgery, due to suitability (not all are) and so on.. A trans woman friend of mine is more feminine than some cis woman friends of mine, it's not safe for her to enter a man's changing room for sure, but she has not and won't have bottom surgery, where would you suggest she changes in a swimming pool for instance? ( To just say now, she will only use changing rooms with cubicles and won't ever be caught with no clothes on.) My point as said above is this is a very difficult subject to hit with black and white thinking and attitude, which sadly makes those more prone to such thinking get very angry, very quickly, on both sides, I've met plenty of black and while thinking on both sides. I'm not a fan of self ID by the way, actually because I think it's negative to trans rights, and is open to abuse, however I do fully believe in supporting people who are transitioning. As for youth transitioning since you bought it up, sadly the US have got it wrong, you are right, until close to adulthood, talking therapies are better, looking to transition if that is still required once adulthood hits. Puberty blockers can be used, but not as freely as they are in the US. They've gone off the deep end, and we all know why. RE: Motd - Borin' Baggie - 03-13-2023 (03-13-2023, 04:57 PM)Squid Wrote:(03-13-2023, 04:20 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: Ah the good old slippery slope logical fallacy. I never said that gender self-ID needs to happen I am pretty sure, when have I said that? I am very sympathetic to the people who want it as I have seen - via my friend - the flaws in the current process to change their legal identification, but my preference is to streamline the current process through better funding of the legal side of things and diversifying what medical checks. My friend is pissed off at a lot of things, he started the process ages ago because it "was only supposed to be a couple years", well it's been a lot longer than that and legally he's still a woman (despite this he's already started medically transitioning privately as he can thankfully afford it now, he's had top surgery, he's on testosterone etc.). But then again, I'm also very sympathetic to a lot of people for broad issues even if I don't agree with their solutions to those issues (which is an issue for the politics board). A third space is called a third space for a reason (generally as an extension to single-sex spaces), and I support the sex-based exclusions written into the equality act for things like women's refuges. There is no slippery slope. I bring my mate up because without actually being transgender it's the closest I have to a real world experience to someone going through that and by extension I have seen the flaws within the current process. As you can probably guess, that kind of has an effect and knowing full well the problems he experienced as a kid growing up (leading to him needing to get his stomach pumped - which is why he only came out in the first place) as well as the privilege of being able to bypass the NHS for the most part. Much the same as having your girlfriend break down at how she was taken advantage of at uni by a man or speaking to female friends who talk about getting groped or harrassed out in public makes you sympathetic to their experiences and makes you consciously change your own behaviour and take more care into how they're treated by others more broadly. I have read the Cass Review and I broadly agree with it, centralising healthcare on transgender issues has lead to poor standard of care at the major trust as well as reducing the levels of adequate scrutiny on decisions. But those issues need to be actually addressed alongside a narrative to provide better healthcare for transgender people on top of safeguards for other people who may be pushed into it - decentralisation of those provisions across England to more regional networks with more integration into local trusts, better mental healthcare provisions generally - which is fucking shit in this country, better education and better safeguarding processes. But there isn't a slippery slope and I really don't appreciate people telling me that if I support this or that then I must by extension be excusing this when I am not. (03-13-2023, 05:08 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: The problem with third spaces is simply that, space, do we actually need 4? Third spaces are generally "gender-neutral" single person spaces, e.g. at a gym or swimming pool. A disabled toilet is a third space. Your mate would have a single-occupancy changing room in that example, so she wouldn't need to go into the male changing room and be at risk of sexual assault as well as not make any women in the female changing room uncomfortable and by extension probably make her uncomfortable. Having more of them improves quality of life for transgender people as well as people with disabilities. RE: Motd - Tom Joad - 03-13-2023 Duffers Wrote:That's a real first on this bored...….Squid Wrote:Duffers Wrote:I have absolutely zero interest in getting into the Rowling argument.
RE: Motd - Bigp1968 - 03-13-2023 Is motd a word for all this that i wasnt aware of. I only started i this post because of the coverage of the football. RE: Motd - MassDebater - 03-13-2023 (03-13-2023, 09:50 PM)Bigp1968 Wrote: Is motd a word for all this that i wasnt aware of. I only started i this post because of the coverage of the football. Football on 'ere? You new?? Must admit I looked in on this, and was totally surprised by the turn it took. RE: Motd - Bigp1968 - 03-13-2023 Mass look i aint new RE: Motd - BaggieBaggieBromBrom - 03-14-2023 (03-13-2023, 10:42 PM)MassDebater Wrote:(03-13-2023, 09:50 PM)Bigp1968 Wrote: Is motd a word for all this that i wasnt aware of. I only started i this post because of the coverage of the football. The amount of posts on here that end up on the subject of trans rights is bizarre |