RE: Your view on Bruce-y: The Poll - Fulham Fallout - 08-01-2022
(08-01-2022, 09:31 AM)Duffers Wrote: (08-01-2022, 09:15 AM)Fulham Fallout Wrote: Can’t believe this thread after one game. This is like building the gallows before the court hearing.
It’s not one game though, is it?
We were fifth when he took over and his brief was to get us back into the automatic promotion fight.
We finished 10th.
With the players used to playing val ball and a totally unbalanced squad.
RE: Your view on Bruce-y: The Poll - Derek Hardballs - 08-01-2022
(08-01-2022, 01:04 PM)Duffers Wrote: (08-01-2022, 12:59 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Hysterical nonsense again from the same posters who overreacted about the team sheet on the first day of the season ffs!
Val ball left the squad in position it could only really play one way. It was formulaic drivel, football designed exclusively around stats with zero creativity. Players were going backwards in terms of performance under his management. As were results and it’s disingenuous to suggest we were 5th when he left, when we all know the trajectory of our results and pts tally meant we were going down the table rather than up. The same people who disagree with this point would have happily seen Irvine remain as coach because we weren’t in the relegation zone when he was sacked I presume?
Bruce tried to change things too quickly arguably given the formulaic approach the players had drilled into them. It didn’t work but by the end of the season there were signs that things were improving. To say he’s got a handful of games is harsh but understandable if the same posters had shown anywhere near such harshness towards Val. I’m old enough to remember the same posters saying Val deserved three / four transfer windows and it was going to be a two, three, four year ‘project’.
Hawks is right if Bruce was Esteban Brucio and spoke about his philosophy and his project this ludicrous poll wouldn’t even have been posted.
Bruce was brought in with the key requirement to arrest that slide though. Something he failed abjectly at.
It all depends how damaging / restrictive you think Valball was for any manager to turn things around. I think his way of playing makes it very difficult for any manager to change anything positively halfway through a season in hindsight.
Also and this isn’t directly to you Duffers but fans are staying as fact it was the wrong team selection. That isn’t a fact it is an opinion and completely subjective. Then to compound their weak argument they point out we played better in the second half but for 70mins ish we played with the same team Bruce chose in the first place and who knows how much joy Dike and Grady would have had if they had started given Boro’s players wouldn’t have been so tired as they were in the second half. As I pointed out the game is 90 odd minutes long and what’s the point in making subs if they cannot make an impact off the bench?
RE: Your view on Bruce-y: The Poll - CA Baggie - 08-01-2022
I think there's one or two posters from the team selection\Game thread and this one that need to FODTV with their attitudes.
Bruce wasn't many peoples pick but he's here now and has managed, like BFS, to see the weaknesses in the squad and bring in the players we need. I'm sure there will be a few more to come and go yet. He's clearly working on a zero spend budget as Lai has run of with the piggy bank.
We were actually 6th on the day he was appointed, I assume someone played that evening and jumped above us, however 4 teams had games in hand to go above us. He didn't succeed last season, no surprise given the trajectory and the quality he had to work with in midfield. He's address that and should be given enough games to show what he can or can't do with a more balanced squad of players he wants.
It shouldn't be a question until at least 10 games post transfer window closing.
RE: Your view on Bruce-y: The Poll - Huggybear - 08-01-2022
Everyone knows my view on Bruce but the fact he was allowed to build his own team through pre season,I think he deserves a chance.I have never had a problem that he could build a squad of players capable of a promotion challenge but my reservation comes with his coaching ability.
Bruce certainly can’t afford the start of season Sheffield United had last season and looking at the squad of players ,I would expect a top six position this season.As a club we certainly can’t dither if things aren’t going well but like I say it’s early days and he has to be given a reasonable crack at it,with his team now.
RE: Your view on Bruce-y: The Poll - GunsOfNavarone - 08-01-2022
(08-01-2022, 03:50 PM)Huggybear Wrote: Everyone knows my view on Bruce but the fact he was allowed to build his own team through pre season,I think he deserves a chance.I have never had a problem that he could build a squad of players capable of a promotion challenge but my reservation comes with his coaching ability.
Bruce certainly can’t afford the start of season Sheffield United had last season and looking at the squad of players ,I would expect a top six position this season.As a club we certainly can’t dither if things aren’t going well but like I say it’s early days and he has to be given a reasonable crack at it,with his team now.
That seems like a perfectly reasonable and well balanced post to me. Fuck knows what you're playing at. Careful Birdy doesn't ban you. And if you're still here when Rowley logs on either sit down or stand with your back to a solid brick wall. Just saying.
RE: Your view on Bruce-y: The Poll - Duffers - 08-01-2022
(08-01-2022, 03:19 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (08-01-2022, 01:04 PM)Duffers Wrote: (08-01-2022, 12:59 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Hysterical nonsense again from the same posters who overreacted about the team sheet on the first day of the season ffs!
Val ball left the squad in position it could only really play one way. It was formulaic drivel, football designed exclusively around stats with zero creativity. Players were going backwards in terms of performance under his management. As were results and it’s disingenuous to suggest we were 5th when he left, when we all know the trajectory of our results and pts tally meant we were going down the table rather than up. The same people who disagree with this point would have happily seen Irvine remain as coach because we weren’t in the relegation zone when he was sacked I presume?
Bruce tried to change things too quickly arguably given the formulaic approach the players had drilled into them. It didn’t work but by the end of the season there were signs that things were improving. To say he’s got a handful of games is harsh but understandable if the same posters had shown anywhere near such harshness towards Val. I’m old enough to remember the same posters saying Val deserved three / four transfer windows and it was going to be a two, three, four year ‘project’.
Hawks is right if Bruce was Esteban Brucio and spoke about his philosophy and his project this ludicrous poll wouldn’t even have been posted.
Bruce was brought in with the key requirement to arrest that slide though. Something he failed abjectly at.
It all depends how damaging / restrictive you think Valball was for any manager to turn things around. I think his way of playing makes it very difficult for any manager to change anything positively halfway through a season in hindsight.
Also and this isn’t directly to you Duffers but fans are staying as fact it was the wrong team selection. That isn’t a fact it is an opinion and completely subjective. Then to compound their weak argument they point out we played better in the second half but for 70mins ish we played with the same team Bruce chose in the first place and who knows how much joy Dike and Grady would have had if they had started given Boro’s players wouldn’t have been so tired as they were in the second half. As I pointed out the game is 90 odd minutes long and what’s the point in making subs if they cannot make an impact off the bench?
Managers do come into squads half way through a season and make a difference (and often they do not), Bruce most certainly did not.
You can argue that the squad may not have had the required quality to challenge, but under Bruce it did not possess the necessary mentality either. Too many of those “experienced pros” went missing when they were needed most last season. How many times did we find ourselves in a situation where a decent result would have put us back into contention only for that spineless bunch to choke? Forest, Stoke, Preston, Blues just off the top of my head…
That’s why it bothers me seeing the likes of Phillips and Livermore in the squad, not only are they no longer good enough for what we need (IMO) but they have also demonstrated repeatedly that they lack the mental strength too (again IMO).
New season. Same failures.
RE: Your view on Bruce-y: The Poll - Cheshire East Baggie - 08-01-2022
(08-01-2022, 04:19 PM)Duffers Wrote: (08-01-2022, 03:19 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (08-01-2022, 01:04 PM)Duffers Wrote: (08-01-2022, 12:59 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Hysterical nonsense again from the same posters who overreacted about the team sheet on the first day of the season ffs!
Val ball left the squad in position it could only really play one way. It was formulaic drivel, football designed exclusively around stats with zero creativity. Players were going backwards in terms of performance under his management. As were results and it’s disingenuous to suggest we were 5th when he left, when we all know the trajectory of our results and pts tally meant we were going down the table rather than up. The same people who disagree with this point would have happily seen Irvine remain as coach because we weren’t in the relegation zone when he was sacked I presume?
Bruce tried to change things too quickly arguably given the formulaic approach the players had drilled into them. It didn’t work but by the end of the season there were signs that things were improving. To say he’s got a handful of games is harsh but understandable if the same posters had shown anywhere near such harshness towards Val. I’m old enough to remember the same posters saying Val deserved three / four transfer windows and it was going to be a two, three, four year ‘project’.
Hawks is right if Bruce was Esteban Brucio and spoke about his philosophy and his project this ludicrous poll wouldn’t even have been posted.
Bruce was brought in with the key requirement to arrest that slide though. Something he failed abjectly at.
It all depends how damaging / restrictive you think Valball was for any manager to turn things around. I think his way of playing makes it very difficult for any manager to change anything positively halfway through a season in hindsight.
Also and this isn’t directly to you Duffers but fans are staying as fact it was the wrong team selection. That isn’t a fact it is an opinion and completely subjective. Then to compound their weak argument they point out we played better in the second half but for 70mins ish we played with the same team Bruce chose in the first place and who knows how much joy Dike and Grady would have had if they had started given Boro’s players wouldn’t have been so tired as they were in the second half. As I pointed out the game is 90 odd minutes long and what’s the point in making subs if they cannot make an impact off the bench?
Managers do come into squads half way through a season and make a difference (and often they do not), Bruce most certainly did not.
You can argue that the squad may not have had the required quality to challenge, but under Bruce it did not possess the necessary mentality either. Too many of those “experienced pros” went missing when they were needed most last season. How many times did we find ourselves in a situation where a decent result would have put us back into contention only for that spineless bunch to choke? Forest, Stoke, Preston, Blues just off the top of my head…
That’s why it bothers me seeing the likes of Phillips and Livermore in the squad, not only are they no longer good enough for what we need (IMO) but they have also demonstrated repeatedly that they lack the mental strength too (again IMO).
New season. Same failures.
Duffers, you're making these statements as though it was the first time, not the third time, these players had failed to settle under a new regime. As I asked on a thread somewhere, was Bruce given the option to discard Phillips, Livermore, Zohore and Bartley? I rather doubt it. I'd have made it a condition of staying on - which is probably what Sam Allardyce did. Whilst I'm happy to point the finger fairly and squarely at Sawyers as the chief troublemaker (his admission that he refused to do the running that Val demanded surprised me not at all), Livermore and Phillips have failed repeatedly to improve effort or morale when the going got tough. Bruce is stuck with them. If Livermore stays in the side once Okay is fit, if Phillips' feeble performance defensively on Saturday goes unnoticed, then I'll join you in calling Bruce out for picking them. One game in, it's too soon.
RE: Your view on Bruce-y: The Poll - Duffers - 08-01-2022
(08-01-2022, 05:45 PM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: (08-01-2022, 04:19 PM)Duffers Wrote: (08-01-2022, 03:19 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (08-01-2022, 01:04 PM)Duffers Wrote: (08-01-2022, 12:59 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Hysterical nonsense again from the same posters who overreacted about the team sheet on the first day of the season ffs!
Val ball left the squad in position it could only really play one way. It was formulaic drivel, football designed exclusively around stats with zero creativity. Players were going backwards in terms of performance under his management. As were results and it’s disingenuous to suggest we were 5th when he left, when we all know the trajectory of our results and pts tally meant we were going down the table rather than up. The same people who disagree with this point would have happily seen Irvine remain as coach because we weren’t in the relegation zone when he was sacked I presume?
Bruce tried to change things too quickly arguably given the formulaic approach the players had drilled into them. It didn’t work but by the end of the season there were signs that things were improving. To say he’s got a handful of games is harsh but understandable if the same posters had shown anywhere near such harshness towards Val. I’m old enough to remember the same posters saying Val deserved three / four transfer windows and it was going to be a two, three, four year ‘project’.
Hawks is right if Bruce was Esteban Brucio and spoke about his philosophy and his project this ludicrous poll wouldn’t even have been posted.
Bruce was brought in with the key requirement to arrest that slide though. Something he failed abjectly at.
It all depends how damaging / restrictive you think Valball was for any manager to turn things around. I think his way of playing makes it very difficult for any manager to change anything positively halfway through a season in hindsight.
Also and this isn’t directly to you Duffers but fans are staying as fact it was the wrong team selection. That isn’t a fact it is an opinion and completely subjective. Then to compound their weak argument they point out we played better in the second half but for 70mins ish we played with the same team Bruce chose in the first place and who knows how much joy Dike and Grady would have had if they had started given Boro’s players wouldn’t have been so tired as they were in the second half. As I pointed out the game is 90 odd minutes long and what’s the point in making subs if they cannot make an impact off the bench?
Managers do come into squads half way through a season and make a difference (and often they do not), Bruce most certainly did not.
You can argue that the squad may not have had the required quality to challenge, but under Bruce it did not possess the necessary mentality either. Too many of those “experienced pros” went missing when they were needed most last season. How many times did we find ourselves in a situation where a decent result would have put us back into contention only for that spineless bunch to choke? Forest, Stoke, Preston, Blues just off the top of my head…
That’s why it bothers me seeing the likes of Phillips and Livermore in the squad, not only are they no longer good enough for what we need (IMO) but they have also demonstrated repeatedly that they lack the mental strength too (again IMO).
New season. Same failures.
Duffers, you're making these statements as though it was the first time, not the third time, these players had failed to settle under a new regime. As I asked on a thread somewhere, was Bruce given the option to discard Phillips, Livermore, Zohore and Bartley? I rather doubt it. I'd have made it a condition of staying on - which is probably what Sam Allardyce did. Whilst I'm happy to point the finger fairly and squarely at Sawyers as the chief troublemaker (his admission that he refused to do the running that Val demanded surprised me not at all), Livermore and Phillips have failed repeatedly to improve effort or morale when the going got tough. Bruce is stuck with them. If Livermore stays in the side once Okay is fit, if Phillips' feeble performance defensively on Saturday goes unnoticed, then I'll join you in calling Bruce out for picking them. One game in, it's too soon.
All the club can do is make them available for transfer, they have contracts so if nobody wants them there’s little we can do. Doesn’t mean they should be starting though.
RE: Your view on Bruce-y: The Poll - Derek Hardballs - 08-01-2022
(08-01-2022, 05:58 PM)Duffers Wrote: (08-01-2022, 05:45 PM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: (08-01-2022, 04:19 PM)Duffers Wrote: (08-01-2022, 03:19 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (08-01-2022, 01:04 PM)Duffers Wrote: Bruce was brought in with the key requirement to arrest that slide though. Something he failed abjectly at.
It all depends how damaging / restrictive you think Valball was for any manager to turn things around. I think his way of playing makes it very difficult for any manager to change anything positively halfway through a season in hindsight.
Also and this isn’t directly to you Duffers but fans are staying as fact it was the wrong team selection. That isn’t a fact it is an opinion and completely subjective. Then to compound their weak argument they point out we played better in the second half but for 70mins ish we played with the same team Bruce chose in the first place and who knows how much joy Dike and Grady would have had if they had started given Boro’s players wouldn’t have been so tired as they were in the second half. As I pointed out the game is 90 odd minutes long and what’s the point in making subs if they cannot make an impact off the bench?
Managers do come into squads half way through a season and make a difference (and often they do not), Bruce most certainly did not.
You can argue that the squad may not have had the required quality to challenge, but under Bruce it did not possess the necessary mentality either. Too many of those “experienced pros” went missing when they were needed most last season. How many times did we find ourselves in a situation where a decent result would have put us back into contention only for that spineless bunch to choke? Forest, Stoke, Preston, Blues just off the top of my head…
That’s why it bothers me seeing the likes of Phillips and Livermore in the squad, not only are they no longer good enough for what we need (IMO) but they have also demonstrated repeatedly that they lack the mental strength too (again IMO).
New season. Same failures.
Duffers, you're making these statements as though it was the first time, not the third time, these players had failed to settle under a new regime. As I asked on a thread somewhere, was Bruce given the option to discard Phillips, Livermore, Zohore and Bartley? I rather doubt it. I'd have made it a condition of staying on - which is probably what Sam Allardyce did. Whilst I'm happy to point the finger fairly and squarely at Sawyers as the chief troublemaker (his admission that he refused to do the running that Val demanded surprised me not at all), Livermore and Phillips have failed repeatedly to improve effort or morale when the going got tough. Bruce is stuck with them. If Livermore stays in the side once Okay is fit, if Phillips' feeble performance defensively on Saturday goes unnoticed, then I'll join you in calling Bruce out for picking them. One game in, it's too soon.
All the club can do is make them available for transfer, they have contracts so if nobody wants them there’s little we can do. Doesn’t mean they should be starting though.
Ok what have Diangana and Mowatt done since their respective injuries to warrant them walking into the team?
RE: Your view on Bruce-y: The Poll - Duffers - 08-01-2022
(08-01-2022, 06:04 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (08-01-2022, 05:58 PM)Duffers Wrote: (08-01-2022, 05:45 PM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: (08-01-2022, 04:19 PM)Duffers Wrote: (08-01-2022, 03:19 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: It all depends how damaging / restrictive you think Valball was for any manager to turn things around. I think his way of playing makes it very difficult for any manager to change anything positively halfway through a season in hindsight.
Also and this isn’t directly to you Duffers but fans are staying as fact it was the wrong team selection. That isn’t a fact it is an opinion and completely subjective. Then to compound their weak argument they point out we played better in the second half but for 70mins ish we played with the same team Bruce chose in the first place and who knows how much joy Dike and Grady would have had if they had started given Boro’s players wouldn’t have been so tired as they were in the second half. As I pointed out the game is 90 odd minutes long and what’s the point in making subs if they cannot make an impact off the bench?
Managers do come into squads half way through a season and make a difference (and often they do not), Bruce most certainly did not.
You can argue that the squad may not have had the required quality to challenge, but under Bruce it did not possess the necessary mentality either. Too many of those “experienced pros” went missing when they were needed most last season. How many times did we find ourselves in a situation where a decent result would have put us back into contention only for that spineless bunch to choke? Forest, Stoke, Preston, Blues just off the top of my head…
That’s why it bothers me seeing the likes of Phillips and Livermore in the squad, not only are they no longer good enough for what we need (IMO) but they have also demonstrated repeatedly that they lack the mental strength too (again IMO).
New season. Same failures.
Duffers, you're making these statements as though it was the first time, not the third time, these players had failed to settle under a new regime. As I asked on a thread somewhere, was Bruce given the option to discard Phillips, Livermore, Zohore and Bartley? I rather doubt it. I'd have made it a condition of staying on - which is probably what Sam Allardyce did. Whilst I'm happy to point the finger fairly and squarely at Sawyers as the chief troublemaker (his admission that he refused to do the running that Val demanded surprised me not at all), Livermore and Phillips have failed repeatedly to improve effort or morale when the going got tough. Bruce is stuck with them. If Livermore stays in the side once Okay is fit, if Phillips' feeble performance defensively on Saturday goes unnoticed, then I'll join you in calling Bruce out for picking them. One game in, it's too soon.
All the club can do is make them available for transfer, they have contracts so if nobody wants them there’s little we can do. Doesn’t mean they should be starting though.
Ok what have Diangana and Mowatt done since their respective injuries to warrant them walking into the team?
Conversely what have Livermore and Phillips done in the last 24 months to merit repeated selection? I’m willing to bet your favourite manager in the last five years was Allardyce and yet he bundled him out at the first opportunity. It speaks volumes to the mismanagement of the club in recent years that he’s still starting as captain.
Diangana was arguably our best player in pre-season, now I’m sure you will scoff at how little that means but he has been providing a damn sight more than Phillips recently.
|