WBAUnofficial
SB transfer vision.... - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: SB transfer vision.... (/showthread.php?tid=25058)

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10


RE: SB transfer vision.... - GunsOfNavarone - 04-26-2022

(04-26-2022, 07:51 AM)BoingBoing2022 Wrote: Bruce has been in management since 1998 and only given 12 kids their debuts in that time.....He doesnt care

What were their names, did any of them play for England and do they all come from lovely families?


RE: SB transfer vision.... - Bob Fossil - 04-26-2022

(04-26-2022, 07:51 AM)BoingBoing2022 Wrote: Bruce has been in management since 1998 and only given 12 kids their debuts in that time.....He doesnt care
That is indeed a damning statistic, if true, especially given our need for a rebuild.
This team is crying out for youth, but I fear, with Bruce, we will see a Pulisesque, reliance on (not very) "good old pros"


RE: SB transfer vision.... - Gzbaggy - 04-26-2022

a "jobs for the boys" approach, WBA is one good last pay day...again


RE: SB transfer vision.... - Ministry Of Silly Signings - 04-26-2022

(04-26-2022, 08:10 AM)ericlegrisly Wrote: I think there were three of us in the 'not Bruce' camp on that thread.

It was an error appointing him in February, as has been proven. It will be an even bigger one giving him the job for longer.

I don't hate the bloke like a couple on here do, I just think he is limited in ideas, past his sell-by date, and just not very good at his job any more.  Happens to us all I guess....

My sentiments also. I don`t have any hatred of Bruce and thought the abuse he got on social media from fans at Newcastle was vile. But, like you, I feel we shouldn`t have rushed to appoint him. After we lost against Preston, it was already being rumoured that Val probably only had the Millwall game to save his job. On that basis, I would think it had been decided by 8PM on the Saturday that he was gone. They didn`t announce it until Tuesday, as Val had gone to visit his family, but in that time, surely a few calls could have been made ,to sound out any other interest, rather than just go straight for Bruce. I don`t know, maybe calls were made and nobody else wanted the job.

(04-26-2022, 08:18 AM)Bob Fossil Wrote:
(04-26-2022, 07:51 AM)BoingBoing2022 Wrote: Bruce has been in management since 1998 and only given 12 kids their debuts in that time.....He doesnt care
That is indeed a damning statistic, if true, especially given our need for a rebuild.
This team is crying out for youth, but I fear, with Bruce, we will see a Pulisesque, reliance on (not very) "good old pros"

This is my fear, talking to a Geordie fan last week who said Ciaran Clarke, Isaac Hayden, Phil Jones etc will be his type of player.


RE: SB transfer vision.... - Gzbaggy - 04-26-2022

Old, injury prone and expensive in terms of wages absolutely ideal

Elliott Anderson who is on loan at Bristol Rovers from Newcastle looks a really promising player (based on EFL highlights show on Quest) but I assume we will have no interest in him


RE: SB transfer vision.... - Spandaubaggie - 04-26-2022

(04-25-2022, 08:35 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(04-25-2022, 07:51 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(04-25-2022, 03:34 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Bruce is getting stick because he’s not exciting enough for some fans, they want this mythical young, hungry manager full of new ground breaking ideas just waiting to be plucked from footballing backwaters. Personally I just want a manager who can turn the club around and three months without one transfer or window or preseason isn’t enough time to judge a manager with a proven CV. Allardyce suffered from the same Guardian Football Supplement issues of fans clamouring for managers who will be the next Klopp or similar. We might roll the dice and find one but we might roll the dice and find ourselves with a one season wonder in charge of the biggest rebuild / restructuring job for the past decade at least.


Bruce is getting stick because under him we've gone from having an outside chance of finishing in the top 2 and certainly looking to push into the top 6 to wondering whether we'll finish in the top half, on top of bizarre team selections, poor to nonexistent tactics or structure, failing to freshen things up and not even trying to play some kids when we have nothing to play for and someone is suspended. How long did it take him to play TGH and O'Shea?

If he puts out the same shit team on Saturday with zero imagination with a bunch of players who have barely looked bothered I am going to boo the shit out of him, and I didn't even boo us after spending my time and money to watch a shit game under Pulis at Huddersfield. I don't give a shit about what he did 5 years ago for Hull, he's been worse than mediocre for us. I've criticised the squad for not being as good as you have been saying but it's not a bottom half squad even with the lack of balance and stinking attitudes of the players.

Val had us nosediving playing crap football and not one player had improved under him. We haven’t got better but let’s not pretend the trajectory has changed. Who knows if Bruce is the answer I’m certainly not going to wave a flag in ott support but I’m willing to see if he can sort things out given a preseason and his own players.

This is where I'm at.

I haven't spent enough time analysing Bruce's record at other clubs to condemn him. I'm also not listening to occasional Newcastle and Villa fans either.
Bruce, after all, as do all managers, inherit teams in a different state.

We are in an appalling mess with what has gone on beforehand and the inability by Bruce to get us into the play-offs is no surprise to me.

I'm just fed up of the whining, because like it or not he will be here next season and then we can judge better.

Sacking him now would only serve to show us as a club any aspiring serious manager would avoid.

Reluctantly, we have to give him time and hope he's better than he's started and proves most of us wrong. However, I don't expect this call for patience to penetrate the consciences of the ones who have him in their sights.


RE: SB transfer vision.... - Ministry Of Silly Signings - 04-26-2022

(04-26-2022, 09:03 AM)Spandaubaggie Wrote:
(04-25-2022, 08:35 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(04-25-2022, 07:51 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(04-25-2022, 03:34 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Bruce is getting stick because he’s not exciting enough for some fans, they want this mythical young, hungry manager full of new ground breaking ideas just waiting to be plucked from footballing backwaters. Personally I just want a manager who can turn the club around and three months without one transfer or window or preseason isn’t enough time to judge a manager with a proven CV. Allardyce suffered from the same Guardian Football Supplement issues of fans clamouring for managers who will be the next Klopp or similar. We might roll the dice and find one but we might roll the dice and find ourselves with a one season wonder in charge of the biggest rebuild / restructuring job for the past decade at least.


Bruce is getting stick because under him we've gone from having an outside chance of finishing in the top 2 and certainly looking to push into the top 6 to wondering whether we'll finish in the top half, on top of bizarre team selections, poor to nonexistent tactics or structure, failing to freshen things up and not even trying to play some kids when we have nothing to play for and someone is suspended. How long did it take him to play TGH and O'Shea?

If he puts out the same shit team on Saturday with zero imagination with a bunch of players who have barely looked bothered I am going to boo the shit out of him, and I didn't even boo us after spending my time and money to watch a shit game under Pulis at Huddersfield. I don't give a shit about what he did 5 years ago for Hull, he's been worse than mediocre for us. I've criticised the squad for not being as good as you have been saying but it's not a bottom half squad even with the lack of balance and stinking attitudes of the players.

Val had us nosediving playing crap football and not one player had improved under him. We haven’t got better but let’s not pretend the trajectory has changed. Who knows if Bruce is the answer I’m certainly not going to wave a flag in ott support but I’m willing to see if he can sort things out given a preseason and his own players.

This is where I'm at.

I haven't spent enough time analysing Bruce's record at other clubs to condemn him. I'm also not listening to occasional Newcastle and Villa fans either.
Bruce, after all, as do all managers, inherit teams in a different state.

We are in an appalling mess with what has gone on beforehand and the inability by Bruce to get us into the play-offs is no surprise to me.

I'm just fed up of the whining, because like it or not he will be here next season and then we can judge better.

Sacking him now would only serve to show us as a club any aspiring serious manager would avoid.

Reluctantly, we have to give him time and hope he's better than he's started and proves most of us wrong. However, I don't expect this call for patience to penetrate the consciences of the ones who have him in their sights.
He is going to be here next season, so we will see what happens, I hope he can refresh things, bring in some decent players etc.  My concern was when appointed, Gourlay was saying things like `Steve is the ideal man`, `It was a shortlist of one, a no brainer` etc. Did we really not consider anyone else,or as I said earlier, did no one else want the job.


RE: SB transfer vision.... - Duffers - 04-26-2022

(04-26-2022, 08:57 AM)Gzbaggy Wrote: Old, injury prone and expensive in terms of wages absolutely ideal

Or “good solid pros” as Steve likes to call them.


RE: SB transfer vision.... - Big Daddy Cool - 04-26-2022

I'd hope he'd sign better players than the likes of Mowatt, Reach. Molomby. We got rid of two better midfielders in Sawyers and Snodgrass.

We've been terrible in the transfer market for years which is why we are where we are. To criticise Bruce for signings he hasn't made is unfair and seems like shifting blame instead of blaming the people who actually got us in this mess.

Will Bruce sign some experienced old pros? Maybe, let's face it this squad is lacking leadership so it might not be a bad thing. It's not like we haven't got down that route before. The likes of Steven Reid and Gareth McAuley didn't turn out too bad. Bruce has also signed some good young players at clubs too. He picked up Andy Robertson from Dundee United while at Hull, I heard he's doing alright now.


RE: SB transfer vision.... - Ministry Of Silly Signings - 04-26-2022

(04-26-2022, 11:28 AM)Big Daddy Cool Wrote: I'd hope he'd sign better players than the likes of Mowatt, Reach. Molomby. We got rid of two better midfielders in Sawyers and Snodgrass.

We've been terrible in the transfer market for years which is why we are where we are. To criticise Bruce for signings he hasn't made is unfair and seems like shifting blame instead of blaming the people who actually got us in this mess.

Will Bruce sign some experienced old pros? Maybe, let's face it this squad is lacking leadership so it might not be a bad thing. It's not like we haven't got down that route before. The likes of Steven Reid and Gareth McAuley didn't turn out too bad. Bruce has also signed some good young players at clubs too. He picked up Andy Robertson from Dundee United while at Hull, I heard he's doing alright now.

We have signed some `Old Pros` who turned out ok, the ones you mention, Paddy Mulligan, Des Lyttle etc, but don`t think we can just rely on that. We need to look at young players in League 1, in Europe or wherever.