WBAUnofficial
Bruce set for a squad overhaul - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: Bruce set for a squad overhaul (/showthread.php?tid=24895)

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15


RE: Bruce set for a squad overhaul - Tom Joad - 04-12-2022

Offside Wrote:Over the years I've seen many  incidences of 11 competent,  but not spectacularly talented players,  each of whom knew their job precisely, organised into a method of playing to the manager's plan.

And as a result, this gives them an better than evens chance of winning games.  

Brian Clough was a master at this in his early career.  Alf Ramsey did the same with Ipswich and England,  as did Bobby Robson. And for those of you old enough to remember, Vic Buckingham did it with us in the 1950s, and that became the blue-print for  the Netherland's "Total Football" philosophy which revolutionised football tactics.  


I've been a keen student of Steve Bruce since he shat on Huddersfield when he was a manager there.  I always wondered what it was that convinced various boards of directors that this decent but very intellectually limited man,  was the person to take their club forward.   He certainly has mastered his interview technique.  Perhaps he should take interview coaching up as a profession? 

I don't dislike him.  But he is without a jot of inspiration in his footballing philosophy, because he doesn't have one. He appears to make no attempt to assess a player, work out what his strengths are, work out if he can improve him in order to slot him into his strategic plan for the the team, because he doesn't have one.   Hence he puts players into roles that they don't know, or understand or have never practised on the training ground.  Hence they don't know what they should be doing, and neither do the players around them.  

He fails to motivate players because there is no vision of what the team should play like, where they are going as a team, and importantly, no apparent desire from any individuals to buy into the team ethos.  Gary Megson had a bang-average bunch of players who would kill for each other because he created a collective cult who wanted to achieve more than they ever believed they could achieve individually.   As Derek McInnes said " there's something special happening here".    

Bruces' teams rarely show any evidence of a plan other than to hoof it in the general direction of the opponent's goal. He can't organise a defence because the players in mid-field, who are the first line of defence,  are usually ageing ( but "good pros") lacking in pace. And in the unlikely event that they win the ball back,  the shock of doing so is so overwhelming, they pass it back to the opposition. 

 Meanwhile the four behind them are clueless as to where they should be,  where the ball is likely to go, and where the final delivery will be delivered to, and who is likely to make the runs.  These things should be dealt with in the classroom,  or on the training pitch, and based on a thorough analysis of how the opposition play leading up to the game.  Because if the opposition  are any good, unlike us, they will have a plan. 

His teams lack creativity. The options from midfield are limited due to the lack of well-rehearsed movement from the front two.  They are usually a target man, who when the ball arrives at neck height, at 50 mph,  has no chance of controlling it,  and no colleague to lay it off to, because he hasn't a clue where he should be.  So we lose possession again. 

Have a look at how easily Harry Kane skimmed the ball off his head to Son vs the Villa on Sunday.  That's how easy it is if you know where your mate is and where he is going to be.  That has to be the simplest goal ever.  Total route one football,  brilliantly executed and obviously rehearsed ad infinitum on the training pitch.  The player who launched the ball knew where Kane was, Kane took a look at where Son was, Son knew where he was going and where Kane would put the ball for him to run on to.  A superb piece of football at its simplest. 

Bruce can't change a game in the second half with plan B, because there is no plan A.  And the players know it.  So they don't care, other than Andy Carroll and TGH. 

Bruce is a relic worthy of role in the next Mike Bassett film.   I wouldn't be surprised in the next film,  to find his character out in the town centre in the early hours,  throwing white plastic bar chairs at the opposition fans,  which is about the nearest he will ever come to organising an attack. 

The cabbage that landed on the pitch in his final days at Villa Park was cruel but well-deserved.   I think there's an Asian convenience store on Brasshouse Lane that stocks them. 



Drink has been taken. 



 
Really good post, Offside. I'm still for giving Bruce a chance but I can't argue with a single thing you wrote. I have always been bored watching Bruce sides, be it Blues, villa, Wigan, Hull and so on. My villa mates thought Bruce was clueless. I also have seen no discernible tactics, other than Fulham and Bournemouth, where we simply got stuck in among their tippy tappys. It worked, but we then don't do it next time out.  The Stoke game was a good example of lack of identity. Rigid lines of midfield and defence with close marking nullified any threat and left us absolutely no ideas. Right now the only reason I can find for wanting Bruce to stay is that I hope his experience has enabled him to know who to get rid of before we get someone else in that wants to 'take a look at the squad', and 'everyone has a clean slate'.


RE: Bruce set for a squad overhaul - Huggybear - 04-12-2022

(04-12-2022, 06:00 PM)Offside Wrote: Over the years I've seen many  incidences of 11 competent,  but not spectacularly talented players,  each of whom knew their job precisely, organised into a method of playing to the manager's plan.

And as a result, this gives them an better than evens chance of winning games.  

Brian Clough was a master at this in his early career.  Alf Ramsey did the same with Ipswich and England,  as did Bobby Robson. And for those of you old enough to remember, Vic Buckingham did it with us in the 1950s, and that became the blue-print for  the Netherland's "Total Football" philosophy which revolutionised football tactics.  


I've been a keen student of Steve Bruce since he shat on Huddersfield when he was a manager there.  I always wondered what it was that convinced various boards of directors that this decent but very intellectually limited man,  was the person to take their club forward.   He certainly has mastered his interview technique.  Perhaps he should take interview coaching up as a profession? 

I don't dislike him.  But he is without a jot of inspiration in his footballing philosophy, because he doesn't have one. He appears to make no attempt to assess a player, work out what his strengths are, work out if he can improve him in order to slot him into his strategic plan for the the team, because he doesn't have one.   Hence he puts players into roles that they don't know, or understand or have never practised on the training ground.  Hence they don't know what they should be doing, and neither do the players around them.  

He fails to motivate players because there is no vision of what the team should play like, where they are going as a team, and importantly, no apparent desire from any individuals to buy into the team ethos.  Gary Megson had a bang-average bunch of players who would kill for each other because he created a collective cult who wanted to achieve more than they ever believed they could achieve individually.   As Derek McInnes said " there's something special happening here".    

Bruces' teams rarely show any evidence of a plan other than to hoof it in the general direction of the opponent's goal. He can't organise a defence because the players in mid-field, who are the first line of defence,  are usually ageing ( but "good pros") lacking in pace. And in the unlikely event that they win the ball back,  the shock of doing so is so overwhelming, they pass it back to the opposition. 

 Meanwhile the four behind them are clueless as to where they should be,  where the ball is likely to go, and where the final delivery will be delivered to, and who is likely to make the runs.  These things should be dealt with in the classroom,  or on the training pitch, and based on a thorough analysis of how the opposition play leading up to the game.  Because if the opposition  are any good, unlike us, they will have a plan. 

His teams lack creativity. The options from midfield are limited due to the lack of well-rehearsed movement from the front two.  They are usually a target man, who when the ball arrives at neck height, at 50 mph,  has no chance of controlling it,  and no colleague to lay it off to, because he hasn't a clue where he should be.  So we lose possession again. 

Have a look at how easily Harry Kane skimmed the ball off his head to Son vs the Villa on Sunday.  That's how easy it is if you know where your mate is and where he is going to be.  That has to be the simplest goal ever.  Total route one football,  brilliantly executed and obviously rehearsed ad infinitum on the training pitch.  The player who launched the ball knew where Kane was, Kane took a look at where Son was, Son knew where he was going and where Kane would put the ball for him to run on to.  A superb piece of football at its simplest. 

Bruce can't change a game in the second half with plan B, because there is no plan A.  And the players know it.  So they don't care, other than Andy Carroll and TGH. 

Bruce is a relic worthy of role in the next Mike Bassett film.   I wouldn't be surprised in the next film,  to find his character out in the town centre in the early hours,  throwing white plastic bar chairs at the opposition fans,  which is about the nearest he will ever come to organising an attack. 

The cabbage that landed on the pitch in his final days at Villa Park was cruel but well-deserved.   I think there's an Asian convenience store on Brasshouse Lane that stocks them. 



Drink has been taken. 

I’m also one of the older supporters and I have to say this post is spot on.The players at the moment are going out very similar of when Pardew was here.If I remember rightly in the program Artist in Residence they interviewed, by memory Foster and Brunt and the simple question they asked was”How has training gone?”Both Brunt and Foster looked at one another ,laughed and avoided the question.There body language said everything about the training and I get the same thing is happening now under Bruce.

 



RE: Bruce set for a squad overhaul - wba13 - 04-12-2022

So you don’t dislike Bruce then you cruelly bring up the unwarranted cabbage thrown by utter wankers from Vile Park. Your entitled to your opinion. As for bringing up the Head on from Kane to Son now your talking about two of the worlds best players and I have not seen another side in the premier try that tactic as they nearly all play out from the back.
I seem to remember on Wednesday against Bournemouth our keeper put a though ball to Carroll to score,our keeper also put a long ball out to Furlong for which we scored the first goal. But of course these have nothing to do with tactics. I not advocating for Bruce but he deserves more credit and respect than a lot are willing to give him without any players he has purchased. Yes we have played crap but you cannot blame Bruce it’s the players fault as they have showed when the big hitters come to town we do well .


RE: Bruce set for a squad overhaul - Offside - 04-12-2022

(04-12-2022, 06:40 PM)wba13 Wrote: So you don’t dislike Bruce then you cruelly bring up the unwarranted cabbage thrown by utter wankers from Vile Park. Your entitled to your opinion. As for bringing up the Head on from Kane to Son now your talking about two of the worlds best players and I have not seen another side in the premier try that tactic as they nearly all play out from the back.
I seem to remember on Wednesday against Bournemouth our keeper put a though ball to Carroll to score,our keeper also put a long ball out to Furlong for which we scored the first goal. But of course these have nothing to do with tactics. I not advocating for Bruce but he deserves more credit and respect than a lot are willing to give him without any players he has purchased.  Yes we have played crap but you cannot blame Bruce it’s the players fault as they have showed when the big hitters come to town we do well .

Yes I am entitled to my opinion.

I draw your attention to the part where I mentioned assessment of players,  their strengths, the potential to educate and coach them to be better players, and the lack of it.  Most managers are the same. 

If I am paying Bruce probably a million quid a year,  I expect him to exert some effort in improving the tools he inherits. We simply can not go on and on changing 22 players with all of the associated costs every time a new manager arrives.  If you are a good coach,  which he obviously is not, his job is to alter the culture, the ethos and the tactics to make the most of what he has. This bollocks about " they are not his players" is,  well,  bollocks. 

As regards Kane and Son.   That was a plan brilliantly executed and rehearsed time and time and time again.


RE: Bruce set for a squad overhaul - SW4Baggie - 04-12-2022

(04-12-2022, 06:00 PM)Offside Wrote: Over the years I've seen many  incidences of 11 competent,  but not spectacularly talented players,  each of whom knew their job precisely, organised into a method of playing to the manager's plan.

And as a result, this gives them an better than evens chance of winning games.  

Brian Clough was a master at this in his early career.  Alf Ramsey did the same with Ipswich and England,  as did Bobby Robson. And for those of you old enough to remember, Vic Buckingham did it with us in the 1950s, and that became the blue-print for  the Netherland's "Total Football" philosophy which revolutionised football tactics.  


I've been a keen student of Steve Bruce since he shat on Huddersfield when he was a manager there.  I always wondered what it was that convinced various boards of directors that this decent but very intellectually limited man,  was the person to take their club forward.   He certainly has mastered his interview technique.  Perhaps he should take interview coaching up as a profession? 

I don't dislike him.  But he is without a jot of inspiration in his footballing philosophy, because he doesn't have one. He appears to make no attempt to assess a player, work out what his strengths are, work out if he can improve him in order to slot him into his strategic plan for the the team, because he doesn't have one.   Hence he puts players into roles that they don't know, or understand or have never practised on the training ground.  Hence they don't know what they should be doing, and neither do the players around them.  

He fails to motivate players because there is no vision of what the team should play like, where they are going as a team, and importantly, no apparent desire from any individuals to buy into the team ethos.  Gary Megson had a bang-average bunch of players who would kill for each other because he created a collective cult who wanted to achieve more than they ever believed they could achieve individually.   As Derek McInnes said " there's something special happening here".    

Bruces' teams rarely show any evidence of a plan other than to hoof it in the general direction of the opponent's goal. He can't organise a defence because the players in mid-field, who are the first line of defence,  are usually ageing ( but "good pros") lacking in pace. And in the unlikely event that they win the ball back,  the shock of doing so is so overwhelming, they pass it back to the opposition. 

 Meanwhile the four behind them are clueless as to where they should be,  where the ball is likely to go, and where the final delivery will be delivered to, and who is likely to make the runs.  These things should be dealt with in the classroom,  or on the training pitch, and based on a thorough analysis of how the opposition play leading up to the game.  Because if the opposition  are any good, unlike us, they will have a plan. 

His teams lack creativity. The options from midfield are limited due to the lack of well-rehearsed movement from the front two.  They are usually a target man, who when the ball arrives at neck height, at 50 mph,  has no chance of controlling it,  and no colleague to lay it off to, because he hasn't a clue where he should be.  So we lose possession again. 

Have a look at how easily Harry Kane skimmed the ball off his head to Son vs the Villa on Sunday.  That's how easy it is if you know where your mate is and where he is going to be.  That has to be the simplest goal ever.  Total route one football,  brilliantly executed and obviously rehearsed ad infinitum on the training pitch.  The player who launched the ball knew where Kane was, Kane took a look at where Son was, Son knew where he was going and where Kane would put the ball for him to run on to.  A superb piece of football at its simplest. 

Bruce can't change a game in the second half with plan B, because there is no plan A.  And the players know it.  So they don't care, other than Andy Carroll and TGH. 

Bruce is a relic worthy of role in the next Mike Bassett film.   I wouldn't be surprised in the next film,  to find his character out in the town centre in the early hours,  throwing white plastic bar chairs at the opposition fans,  which is about the nearest he will ever come to organising an attack. 

The cabbage that landed on the pitch in his final days at Villa Park was cruel but well-deserved.   I think there's an Asian convenience store on Brasshouse Lane that stocks them. 



Drink has been taken. 



 

Drink more often. Very good post.
One of my biggest concerns about Bruce going forward is that he’ll fill the squad with more “good pros” and leave us with another ageing squad of rapidly devaluing players in 2 years’ time.


RE: Bruce set for a squad overhaul - Spandaubaggie - 04-12-2022

(04-12-2022, 07:19 PM)Offside Wrote:
(04-12-2022, 06:40 PM)wba13 Wrote: So you don’t dislike Bruce then you cruelly bring up the unwarranted cabbage thrown by utter wankers from Vile Park. Your entitled to your opinion. As for bringing up the Head on from Kane to Son now your talking about two of the worlds best players and I have not seen another side in the premier try that tactic as they nearly all play out from the back.
I seem to remember on Wednesday against Bournemouth our keeper put a though ball to Carroll to score,our keeper also put a long ball out to Furlong for which we scored the first goal. But of course these have nothing to do with tactics. I not advocating for Bruce but he deserves more credit and respect than a lot are willing to give him without any players he has purchased.  Yes we have played crap but you cannot blame Bruce it’s the players fault as they have showed when the big hitters come to town we do well .

Yes I am entitled to my opinion.

I draw your attention to the part where I mentioned assessment of players,  their strengths, the potential to educate and coach them to be better players, and the lack of it.  Most managers are the same. 

If I am paying Bruce probably a million quid a year,  I expect him to exert some effort in improving the tools he inherits. We simply can not go on and on changing 22 players with all of the associated costs every time a new manager arrives.  If you are a good coach,  which he obviously is not, his job is to alter the culture, the ethos and the tactics to make the most of what he has. This bollocks about " they are not his players" is,  well,  bollocks. 

As regards Kane and Son.   That was a plan brilliantly executed and rehearsed time and time and time again.

There's an element of fans who when things don't go well just go and blame the manager. These characters are piping up here and choosing the bits of the Bruce CV that helps cement their opinion. 

However, in business as with anything when things aren't going well you have to examine what's going wrong from many angles and ask searching questions. Most here don't do this, because if they did they'd work out the most obvious thing is we've had 4 managers, 3 very experienced who haven't been able to get a tune out of these.

Most fans, myself included, weren't jumping for joy with Bruce's appointment, but we do need experience, someone who knows how football clubs are meant to operate. I'd put him in that category.

Bruce deserves a decent amount of time to see what he can do to refresh the squad, which will the opinion of the silent majority. 

If he's had a pre-season and 15 or so games and things are still shite then fair enough.

The opinions of those asking for him to be bombed out is astonishingly premature, when we put into perspective the last year of Bilic's team, Allardyce's tenure, where only loan players changed thing, Ismael's revolution which turned sour after 10 games and the wheels then came off, all before Bruce.

Someone has to weed out the weak links, but sacking Bruce expecting some conjurer to suddenly come in transform this messed up squad and make us a top team seems bewilderingly daft.


RE: Bruce set for a squad overhaul - wba13 - 04-12-2022

(04-12-2022, 07:19 PM)Offside Wrote:
(04-12-2022, 06:40 PM)wba13 Wrote: So you don’t dislike Bruce then you cruelly bring up the unwarranted cabbage thrown by utter wankers from Vile Park. Your entitled to your opinion. As for bringing up the Head on from Kane to Son now your talking about two of the worlds best players and I have not seen another side in the premier try that tactic as they nearly all play out from the back.
I seem to remember on Wednesday against Bournemouth our keeper put a though ball to Carroll to score,our keeper also put a long ball out to Furlong for which we scored the first goal. But of course these have nothing to do with tactics. I not advocating for Bruce but he deserves more credit and respect than a lot are willing to give him without any players he has purchased.  Yes we have played crap but you cannot blame Bruce it’s the players fault as they have showed when the big hitters come to town we do well .

Yes I am entitled to my opinion.

I draw your attention to the part where I mentioned assessment of players,  their strengths, the potential to educate and coach them to be better players, and the lack of it.  Most managers are the same. 

If I am paying Bruce probably a million quid a year,  I expect him to exert some effort in improving the tools he inherits. We simply can not go on and on changing 22 players with all of the associated costs every time a new manager arrives.  If you are a good coach,  which he obviously is not, his job is to alter the culture, the ethos and the tactics to make the most of what he has. This bollocks about " they are not his players" is,  well,  bollocks. 

As regards Kane and Son.   That was a plan brilliantly executed and rehearsed time and time and time again.

Did I hit a nerve. So now your defending a team of wasters who have failed under 3 managers yet your blaming Bruce who hasn’t been able to bring in anyone in. Sorry if I disagree and I not backing Bruce but he deserves at least one transfer window like the 3 managers before him.


RE: Bruce set for a squad overhaul - Derek Hardballs - 04-12-2022

Can’t be arsed to read the recent rather long posts, suffice to say I await this young hungry manager whose going to build our squad via our youth team, taking on all comers with swashbuckling football the likes of which we have never seen before. West Brazil Albion will be reborn and this time we shall stay up and be challenging for Europe in three seasons!











Nah, I didn’t think so either.


RE: Bruce set for a squad overhaul - Squid - 04-12-2022

(04-12-2022, 09:20 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Can’t be arsed to read the recent rather long posts, suffice to say I await this young hungry manager whose going to build our squad via our youth team, taking on all comers with swashbuckling football the likes of which we have never seen before. West Brazil Albion will be reborn and this time we shall stay up and be challenging for Europe in three seasons!











Nah, I didn’t think so either.

Someone who could organise us to not concede three goals to Stoke at home would be a start.


RE: Bruce set for a squad overhaul - Offside - 04-12-2022

(04-12-2022, 08:56 PM)wba13 Wrote:
(04-12-2022, 07:19 PM)Offside Wrote:
(04-12-2022, 06:40 PM)wba13 Wrote: So you don’t dislike Bruce then you cruelly bring up the unwarranted cabbage thrown by utter wankers from Vile Park. Your entitled to your opinion. As for bringing up the Head on from Kane to Son now your talking about two of the worlds best players and I have not seen another side in the premier try that tactic as they nearly all play out from the back.
I seem to remember on Wednesday against Bournemouth our keeper put a though ball to Carroll to score,our keeper also put a long ball out to Furlong for which we scored the first goal. But of course these have nothing to do with tactics. I not advocating for Bruce but he deserves more credit and respect than a lot are willing to give him without any players he has purchased.  Yes we have played crap but you cannot blame Bruce it’s the players fault as they have showed when the big hitters come to town we do well .

Yes I am entitled to my opinion.

I draw your attention to the part where I mentioned assessment of players,  their strengths, the potential to educate and coach them to be better players, and the lack of it.  Most managers are the same. 

If I am paying Bruce probably a million quid a year,  I expect him to exert some effort in improving the tools he inherits. We simply can not go on and on changing 22 players with all of the associated costs every time a new manager arrives.  If you are a good coach,  which he obviously is not, his job is to alter the culture, the ethos and the tactics to make the most of what he has. This bollocks about " they are not his players" is,  well,  bollocks. 

As regards Kane and Son.   That was a plan brilliantly executed and rehearsed time and time and time again.

Did I hit a nerve. So now your defending a team of wasters who have failed under 3 managers yet your blaming Bruce who hasn’t been able to bring in anyone in. Sorry if I disagree and I not backing Bruce but he deserves at least one transfer window like the 3 managers before him.

You overestimate the impact of your somewhat frantic critique of my post.  After  nearly 70 years of support,  any player, manager or fan's power to provoke anything greater than a mild interest in what is happening at the club,  has been diminished to the point,  where right now, the gout in my right knee and my 12th day of testing positive for covid concerns me a lot more than if I have been unfair to a man earning a million quid a year,  and failing to justify such benevolence from a board of directors who so obviously do not know their arse from their elbow.   I'll buy the cabbage if someone wants to throw it.

(04-12-2022, 09:54 PM)Squid Wrote:
(04-12-2022, 09:20 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Can’t be arsed to read the recent rather long posts, suffice to say I await this young hungry manager whose going to build our squad via our youth team, taking on all comers with swashbuckling football the likes of which we have never seen before. West Brazil Albion will be reborn and this time we shall stay up and be challenging for Europe in three seasons!











Nah, I didn’t think so either.

Someone who could organise us to not concede three goals to Stoke at home would be a start.

Thanks Squid.  That saved me thinking of an appropriate response.