WBAUnofficial
Bruce out now!! - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: Bruce out now!! (/showthread.php?tid=24386)

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11


RE: Bruce out now!! - Peachy - 03-01-2022

For me 3-5-2 is the best way to utilise what we have imo. Going to a back 3 we at least know how that works. Clarke is our best centre half so quite why he's not playing is anyones guess. I'd also drop SJ now tbh. Nothing against him but his contract fuckery and hissy fit has led to a lot of the negativity in recent weeks and hasn't helped us. He also is fu king off next season and we ain't going up anyway so why play him? Give Palmer a go now.

Lack of options in centre mid means for me Livermore has to come back in and we simply must play someone in the number 10 role in the hole. We have very limited options in either Castro or Rico Richards. Maybe give it to Matty P if he ever gets fit again but we need a link between midfield and strikers.

Then get them all supporting Carroll and Dike. Those two should strike the fear of god into defenders with their physicality.

I'd line up with something like this

---------------------------Palmer---------------------
-------------Ajayi-------O'Shea--------Clarke-------------
TGH-----------Jake---------Molumby------------Townsend
------------------------Phillips/Castro/Richards------------------------------
------------------------Carroll------Dike-----------------------


RE: Bruce out now!! - SW4Baggie - 03-01-2022

So 23 points from 19 games - 1.2/game

Bruce has managed 1 from 5 - 0.2/game

Said at the time we will regret sacking Val.


RE: Bruce out now!! - Remi_Moses - 03-01-2022

(03-01-2022, 09:16 AM)Peachy Wrote: For me 3-5-2 is the best way to utilise what we have imo. Going to a back 3 we at least know how that works. Clarke is our best centre half so quite why he's not playing is anyones guess. I'd also drop SJ now tbh. Nothing against him but his contract fuckery and hissy fit has led to a lot of the negativity in recent weeks and hasn't helped us. He also is fu king off next season and we ain't going up anyway so why play him? Give Palmer a go now.

Lack of options in centre mid means for me Livermore has to come back in and we simply must play someone in the number 10 role in the hole. We have very limited options in either Castro or Rico Richards. Maybe give it to Matty P if he ever gets fit again but we need a link between midfield and strikers.

Then get them all supporting Carroll and Dike. Those two should strike the fear of god into defenders with their physicality.

I'd line up with something like this

---------------------------Palmer---------------------
-------------Ajayi-------O'Shea--------Clarke-------------
TGH-----------Jake---------Molumby------------Townsend
------------------------Phillips/Castro/Richards------------------------------
------------------------Carroll------Dike-----------------------

That's about as good as it gets.


RE: Bruce out now!! - TartanRug - 03-01-2022

(03-01-2022, 09:06 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(03-01-2022, 08:49 AM)Ted Maul Wrote:
(03-01-2022, 08:45 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(03-01-2022, 08:26 AM)Ted Maul Wrote:
(03-01-2022, 08:18 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: The problem is we have set the team up to play Val Ball. It completely limits the way you can play, notably our midfield. Look at our options in central midfield, they have no creativity but will run all day. That was a choice of the previous managers. We didn’t need to be creative in central midfield because we bypassed the middle of the park, playing the statistical percentages.

The wheels started to quickly come off that way of playing no matter where we were before Bruce took over. Bruce is clearly trying to get the team to play more expansive football in the hope we create and convert more chances but the problem is we don’t have the players in central midfield who can do that job. We have filled it with expensive Sean Flynn’s. We are now stuck trying to play a completely different way under Bruce because we can’t score goals and we increasingly can’t create chances.

That was always the risk of playing a very particular way under Val. It leaves little or no flexibility if you try and change the way you play. The seasons a write off and it’ll get harder rather than easier to win promotion from this point onwards but whoever manages next year has to be given the season but realises the urgency of trying to win promotion. Long term fixes will only work with investment (money) and we dint have that luxury.

You end a post criticising a manager who wasn't given enough time to turn the squad over by saying the next manager needs to be given at least a season. The investment in Val should have meant he was given at least a season. There are plenty of managers with one way of playing. It's not like he was given the best tools for the job either was it. 

Largely agree with you though. Bruce has been stupid in trying to change too much. 75% of the team under Val worked, now we create less and can't defend. Well done Steve.

I criticise Val for making the team / squad so limited to one way of playing. The fact it inevitably stopped working once coaches had seen us play for a few weeks was always going leave us in a mess. What did you expect Bruce to do? Try and play Val ball? 

I’ve said all season we are one dimensional and that our midfield lacked creativity. That was a choice Val made for a squad he said he was very happy with.

No. He's been quoted as saying this squad has been set up to play three at the back. He could have kept in place a shape that was at least, for the most part tough to beat. We've totally unravelled since he joined. 

Valball was certainly better than what we've seen the last five games. Still, it's done now. Four at the back and nice passing, just like everyone wanted.

Three / four at the back it makes no odds, it’s the complete lack of creativity and cutting edge that has been a problem all season that see’s us where we are.  I don’t care how we play football, I’m not a purist, heck I always chose to be Wimbledon in the playground because I like the idea of playing a style that annoyed purists. However Val ball was so one dimensional it was painful to watch when we weren’t getting results, which was happening week after week before he went. 

I’m all for settling on a style of play but it has to be something less one dimensional than Val ball offered.

How we were defending was good under Val apart from the last couple of games where the players, not for their first manager, decided they couldn't be bothered and downed tools. Up till then we were at least generally solid and didn't concede many. If we'd have backed him in the Summer and got a decent striker in, or even if Dike hadn't got injured in January, he'd probably still be here. The midfield is dreadful and Val can take some blame but you're not exactly overloaded with great options when your budget is £0


RE: Bruce out now!! - SW4Baggie - 03-01-2022

(03-01-2022, 09:16 AM)Peachy Wrote: For me 3-5-2 is the best way to utilise what we have imo. Going to a back 3 we at least know how that works. Clarke is our best centre half so quite why he's not playing is anyones guess. I'd also drop SJ now tbh. Nothing against him but his contract fuckery and hissy fit has led to a lot of the negativity in recent weeks and hasn't helped us. He also is fu king off next season and we ain't going up anyway so why play him? Give Palmer a go now.

Lack of options in centre mid means for me Livermore has to come back in and we simply must play someone in the number 10 role in the hole. We have very limited options in either Castro or Rico Richards. Maybe give it to Matty P if he ever gets fit again but we need a link between midfield and strikers.

Then get them all supporting Carroll and Dike. Those two should strike the fear of god into defenders with their physicality.

I'd line up with something like this

---------------------------Palmer---------------------
-------------Ajayi-------O'Shea--------Clarke-------------
TGH-----------Jake---------Molumby------------Townsend
------------------------Phillips/Castro/Richards------------------------------
------------------------Carroll------Dike-----------------------

Swap Kipré (who has done nothing to deserve being dropped!) for Ajayi and I’m inclined to agree.

I’d rather persevere with Mowatt as he’s only been shit for a couple months whereas Jake has been gash since 2017. I’d also be making O’Shea, Dike or Carroll captain. We need a fresh voice.


RE: Bruce out now!! - Spandaubaggie - 03-01-2022

(03-01-2022, 08:18 AM)Ted Maul Wrote:
(03-01-2022, 08:15 AM)Moore Than Wrote:
(02-28-2022, 10:00 PM)Shabby Russian Wrote: My gut instinct was to let Ismael have the full season.

If only to send a message to the players and to the fans that they can't get rid of the manager when they want.

Pretty certain Ismael wouldn't have turned it round, but not sure things would have been any worse than they are now.

They were. That's why he got sacked.

The last five games have been worse than final Val games both statistically and results wise. That is not up for debate.
Hey but we managed two shots that hit the woodwork last night compared to no shots on goal v the might of Preston.

You're rewriting Val's era in a way most find plainly weird.

Shit football, going backwards at a rate of knots, overseeing the worst midfield in 30 years. This is overlooked by you.

Can you give it a rest now and look to the future rather than your fantasy land of Vals' success, which looked like disaster to pretty-much 99 per cent of the fanbase.


RE: Bruce out now!! - Ted Maul - 03-01-2022

(03-01-2022, 09:55 AM)Spandaubaggie Wrote: Hey but we managed two shots that hit the woodwork last night compared to no shots on goal v the might of Preston.

You're rewriting Val's era in a way most find plainly weird.

Shit football, going backwards at a rate of knots, overseeing the worst midfield in 30 years. This is overlooked by you.

Can you give it a rest now and look to the future rather than your fantasy land of Vals' success, which looked like disaster to pretty-much 99 per cent of the fanbase.

Yeah I'll leave it now. It's looking good for the future.


RE: Bruce out now!! - WorcsWBA - 03-01-2022

(03-01-2022, 09:55 AM)Spandaubaggie Wrote: Can you give it a rest now and look to the future rather than your fantasy land of Vals' success, which looked like disaster to pretty-much 99 per cent of the fanbase.

If people didn't keep spouting mistruths as if they were objective fact then maybe it would happen.

What Ted's saying, and I agree with him, is that if 80-90+% of the fanbase regarded it as a disaster then that's part of our problem, as no manager ever at the club will get the tolerance and patience needed to build something unless he's a success from the very start. Even that's no enough for some, Ismael was getting brickbats when we were unbeaten and top of the league. It's always going to be about short-termism and we'll never build anything.


RE: Bruce out now!! - Cuzer - 03-01-2022

Anybody who has kicked a ball or managed a team at any level knows you play to your strengths, if we had 3 Pereira's in our squad you would play through the lines, on the deck, allow movement in behind etc

Our best players are our centre halves, we should be 3 at the back all season, Bruce tried to change this to gain popularity as clearly he was told the fans had enough of 3-4-3 when actually as we can now see 5 games in it's comfortably our best system. Clarke who I've stated has been our best defender by a distance this season, gets bombed and now under Bruce we've gone from the best defence in the league to one of the worse

Derek it's not rocked science fella, if you've got workers, grafters in the middle of the park playing thorugh midfield isn't a priority, Val was all about get the ball wide and get the ball in the box, as frustrated as I was at times with this and his stubbounress we did create, we were craving a number 9 and got Hugill and then Dike got injured, Val was desperate for a midfielder in Jan, the club didn't deliver

You play to your strengths, Val was doing this, Bruce hasn't a clue what our strengths are, season is gone, he should go after Saturday and let Mozza and Brunt finish the season and we start planning now for a summer of recruitment, change and a new manager

Absolute shitshow

Cuzer


RE: Bruce out now!! - Squid - 03-01-2022

(03-01-2022, 10:07 AM)Cuzer Wrote: Anybody who has kicked a ball or managed a team at any level knows you play to your strengths, if we had 3 Pereira's in our squad you would play through the lines, on the deck, allow movement in behind etc

Our best players are our centre halves, we should be 3 at the back all season, Bruce tried to change this to gain popularity as clearly he was told the fans had enough of 3-4-3 when actually as we can now see 5 games in it's comfortably our best system. Clarke who I've stated has been our best defender by a distance this season, gets bombed and now under Bruce we've gone from the best defence in the league to one of the worse

Derek it's not rocked science fella, if you've got workers, grafters in the middle of the park playing thorugh midfield isn't a priority, Val was all about get the ball wide and get the ball in the box, as frustrated as I was at times with this and his stubbounress we did create, we were craving a number 9 and got Hugill and then Dike got injured, Val was desperate for a midfielder in Jan, the club didn't deliver

You play to your strengths, Val was doing this, Bruce hasn't a clue what our strengths are, season is gone, he should go after Saturday and let Mozza and Brunt finish the season and we start planning now for a summer of recruitment, change and a new manager

Absolute shitshow

Cuzer

This really emphasises the lack of footballing brains possessed by the club. They (and Bruce, who should know better) honestly thought it was a matter of putting an arm around some players and giving the fans the formation they wanted. So they dismantled one of the best defences in the league. Ridiculous.