RE: Annus horribilis - Big Daddy Cool - 05-27-2019
So if we appointed a different assistant we would have gone up? Moore was the manager FFS. If he wasn't good enough without relying heavily on an assistant he shouldn't have agreed to the bloody job ffs.
As soon as I saw Jones do the team talk at extra time against Brighton while Moore stood there listening in like one of the players I knew we were in trouble. What an utter shambles this season was.
I honestly believe even Shan would have got us promoted if appointed at the start of the season.
(05-27-2019, 08:08 PM)Remi_Moses Wrote: (05-27-2019, 07:56 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote: (05-27-2019, 07:39 PM)Remi_Moses Wrote: (05-27-2019, 07:19 PM)Statto Wrote: (05-27-2019, 07:14 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: I'm simply asking why he'd have got us up, I see 0 evidence for saying he would have done.
What I do think would have got us up is Moore getting us to play like the end of last season, like Shan had us playing. We'd have gone up in automatic imo had that happened.
We are not, and without a massive overhaul, an attacking, possession dominating team.
+1
Firmly believe we’d have gone up with Moore and Shan. For all the wailing and gnashing of teeth in the board’s direction, the worst decision of the season wasn’t from Lai, Jenkins or Dowling, it was Moore bringing in Jones to make us something we weren’t designed to be.
Darren's misguided loyalty to a friend was reflected in his sacking - he paid the ultimate price.
Lai - Jenkins - Dowling employed them? and set the parameters they worked in, if the foundations are dodgy whatever is built will always fall apart.
If Dowling/Jenkins/Lai had told Moore he couldn’t appoint Jones, and insisted on Shan there would have been an absolute meltdown. The general opinion on here was that we’d pulled off an absolute coup in luring Jones in also...
Jenkins provided Moore with the kind of budget that should have seen a serious promotion tilt, and Dowling provided excellent players for this level in Holgate, Johansen, Murphy (admittedly his heart wasn’t in it), and also did the deals that brought us Gayle and Barnes amongst competition from other sides in this league.
Ultimately we appointed the wrong man in Moore, and he brought the wrong man in to support him.
Had Moore picked someone like Shakespeare or Reid, or as has been said, Shan, we’d have probably made it up.
Dowling had nothing to do with Gayle & Barnes coming I believe that was credited to Darren tbf.
Yes Gayle and Barnes only come to play for Darren Moore. Get a grip.
RE: Annus horribilis - Mancbaggies - 05-27-2019
Shan would certainly have won more points and had us closer to automatic
RE: Annus horribilis - Birdman1811 - 05-27-2019
(05-27-2019, 08:35 PM)Big Daddy Cool Wrote: So if we appointed a different assistant we would have gone up? Moore was the manager FFS. If he wasn't good enough without relying heavily on an assistant he shouldn't have agreed to the bloody job ffs.
As soon as I saw Jones do the team talk at extra time against Brighton while Moore stood there listening in like one of the players I knew we were in trouble. What an utter shambles this season was.
I honestly believe even Shan would have got us promoted if appointed at the start of the season.
(05-27-2019, 08:08 PM)Remi_Moses Wrote: (05-27-2019, 07:56 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote: (05-27-2019, 07:39 PM)Remi_Moses Wrote: (05-27-2019, 07:19 PM)Statto Wrote: +1
Firmly believe we’d have gone up with Moore and Shan. For all the wailing and gnashing of teeth in the board’s direction, the worst decision of the season wasn’t from Lai, Jenkins or Dowling, it was Moore bringing in Jones to make us something we weren’t designed to be.
Darren's misguided loyalty to a friend was reflected in his sacking - he paid the ultimate price.
Lai - Jenkins - Dowling employed them? and set the parameters they worked in, if the foundations are dodgy whatever is built will always fall apart.
If Dowling/Jenkins/Lai had told Moore he couldn’t appoint Jones, and insisted on Shan there would have been an absolute meltdown. The general opinion on here was that we’d pulled off an absolute coup in luring Jones in also...
Jenkins provided Moore with the kind of budget that should have seen a serious promotion tilt, and Dowling provided excellent players for this level in Holgate, Johansen, Murphy (admittedly his heart wasn’t in it), and also did the deals that brought us Gayle and Barnes amongst competition from other sides in this league.
Ultimately we appointed the wrong man in Moore, and he brought the wrong man in to support him.
Had Moore picked someone like Shakespeare or Reid, or as has been said, Shan, we’d have probably made it up.
Dowling had nothing to do with Gayle & Barnes coming I believe that was credited to Darren tbf.
Yes Gayle and Barnes only come to play for Darren Moore. Get a grip.
Gayle did actually, he had said no to playing at this level until Moore went to speak to him.
Barnes was heavily wanted, and pushed for by Moore.
RE: Annus horribilis - SW4Baggie - 05-27-2019
I’m sure Moore was a big part in both Gayle and Barnes joining, however he isn’t the one who convinced Rondon and his people to extend his deal, and he isn’t the one who structured a deal to get Gayle over the line with Newcastle funding a large part of his wages despite interest from other, more monied, sides.
The time to judge Dowling is from now, as he’s had a year to prepare for this outcome, until now he’s done what can be expected. Jenkins made a mistake with the level of faith that was put in Moore, bit rectified it rather brutally as soon as the axe needed to fall.
RE: Annus horribilis - Statto - 05-27-2019
(05-27-2019, 10:49 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote: I’m sure Moore was a big part in both Gayle and Barnes joining, however he isn’t the one who convinced Rondon and his people to extend his deal, and he isn’t the one who structured a deal to get Gayle over the line with Newcastle funding a large part of his wages despite interest from other, more monied, sides.
The time to judge Dowling is from now, as he’s had a year to prepare for this outcome, until now he’s done what can be expected. Jenkins made a mistake with the level of faith that was put in Moore, bit rectified it rather brutally as soon as the axe needed to fall.
Do we know whether it was Jenkins or Dowling who sacked Moore?
|