WBAUnofficial
Budget 2026 - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: Politics (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=5)
+--- Thread: Budget 2026 (/showthread.php?tid=43165)

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5 6 7


RE: Budget 2026 - Protheroe - 11-03-2026

(11-03-2026, 09:32 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: The wealthy don’t plough money back into the economy they hoard it. They take it out of circulation to off shore accounts etc.

And you're about to lay the evidence in front of me for that contention?

(11-03-2026, 08:47 AM)Pontificator Wrote: The abject lack of leadership since John Major and Tony Blair, who showed what could be achieved in the EU (think Ireland and peace). Instead, we've had moronic British exceptionalism (Jacko style), no leadership on defence or the protection of our democracies and a reliance on the US when it was stark staring obvious, well before Crimea, that its interests lay more in the South China Sea than in Europe. Putin has been watching and exploiting the divisions sown over 26 years by Farage, the Tory bastards and some hard-left Labour tossers. Our interests have always been aligned with the EU, economically, socially and defensively. Anyone who can't see that, or still can't accept it, has a deep-seated problem. To me, they're on the same level as the Yanks who put Trump in the White House.
Mr P, why do you think the pissing contestants on here don't understand that when you start talking about something else, you're talking about something else?

I agree our interests are aligned with Europe. But not with the EU.


RE: Budget 2026 - Derek Hardballs - 11-03-2026

(11-03-2026, 08:47 AM)Pontificator Wrote: The abject lack of leadership since John Major and Tony Blair, who showed what could be achieved in the EU (think Ireland and peace). Instead, we've had moronic British exceptionalism (Jacko style), no leadership on defence or the protection of our democracies and a reliance on the US when it was stark staring obvious, well before Crimea, that its interests lay more in the South China Sea than in Europe. Putin has been watching and exploiting the divisions sown over 26 years by Farage, the Tory bastards and some hard-left Labour tossers. Our interests have always been aligned with the EU, economically, socially and defensively. Anyone who can't see that, or still can't accept it, has a deep-seated problem. To me, they're on the same level as the Yanks who put Trump in the White House.
Mr P, why do you think the pissing contestants on here don't understand that when you start talking about something else, you're talking about something else?

(11-03-2026, 10:04 AM)Protheroe Wrote:
(11-03-2026, 09:32 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: The wealthy don’t plough money back into the economy they hoard it. They take it out of circulation to off shore accounts etc.

And you're about to lay the evidence in front of me for that contention?

(11-03-2026, 08:47 AM)Pontificator Wrote: The abject lack of leadership since John Major and Tony Blair, who showed what could be achieved in the EU (think Ireland and peace). Instead, we've had moronic British exceptionalism (Jacko style), no leadership on defence or the protection of our democracies and a reliance on the US when it was stark staring obvious, well before Crimea, that its interests lay more in the South China Sea than in Europe. Putin has been watching and exploiting the divisions sown over 26 years by Farage, the Tory bastards and some hard-left Labour tossers. Our interests have always been aligned with the EU, economically, socially and defensively. Anyone who can't see that, or still can't accept it, has a deep-seated problem. To me, they're on the same level as the Yanks who put Trump in the White House.
Mr P, why do you think the pissing contestants on here don't understand that when you start talking about something else, you're talking about something else?

I agree our interests are aligned with Europe. But not with the EU.

So profits, dividends and wealth of the well off and their companies have gone up and yet prices for the ordinary person have gone through the roof in terms of food, fuel and general day to day costs. I think we are all awaiting the trickle down economics that we will now see from the very rich bestowing their wealth on us all by purchasing goods, raising people’s salaries etc. 

I noticed you avoided the difficult political and ethical issues I raised in my previous post. Let me put it this way do you want to cut support and financial security from Beryl and her disabled older son? How will this help the country?

I’m just taking your bean counter arguments away from the abstract into real world problems faced by thousand if not more people across the U.K.


RE: Budget 2026 - Protheroe - 11-04-2026

(11-03-2026, 10:26 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: So profits, dividends and wealth of the well off and their companies have gone up and yet prices for the ordinary person have gone through the roof in terms of food, fuel and general day to day costs. I think we are all awaiting the trickle down economics that we will now see from the very rich bestowing their wealth on us all by purchasing goods, raising people’s salaries etc. 

I noticed you avoided the difficult political and ethical issues I raised in my previous post. Let me put it this way do you want to cut support and financial security from Beryl and her disabled older son? How will this help the country?

I’m just taking your bean counter arguments away from the abstract into real world problems faced by thousand if not more people across the U.K.

Another meaningless post. Can you point out the link between profits, dividends and wealth increases and prices?  I can. Price increases have everything to do with over inflationary minimum wage increases, employers NI, energy prices, interest on government debt, over regulation etc. This is a direct result of the Trickle Up economics pursued by Sunak and Labour - much of it paid for by taxation on profits, dividends and wealth increases.

Why are you asking me about welfare cuts for disabled people? When have I ever suggested welfare cuts for disabled people?


RE: Budget 2026 - Derek Hardballs - 11-04-2026

(11-04-2026, 08:23 AM)Protheroe Wrote:
(11-03-2026, 10:26 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: So profits, dividends and wealth of the well off and their companies have gone up and yet prices for the ordinary person have gone through the roof in terms of food, fuel and general day to day costs. I think we are all awaiting the trickle down economics that we will now see from the very rich bestowing their wealth on us all by purchasing goods, raising people’s salaries etc. 

I noticed you avoided the difficult political and ethical issues I raised in my previous post. Let me put it this way do you want to cut support and financial security from Beryl and her disabled older son? How will this help the country?

I’m just taking your bean counter arguments away from the abstract into real world problems faced by thousand if not more people across the U.K.

Another meaningless post. Can you point out the link between profits, dividends and wealth increases and prices?  I can. Price increases have everything to do with over inflationary minimum wage increases, employers NI, energy prices, interest on government debt, over regulation etc. This is a direct result of the Trickle Up economics pursued by Sunak and Labour - much of it paid for by taxation on profits, dividends and wealth increases.

Why are you asking me about welfare cuts for disabled people? When have I ever suggested welfare cuts for disabled people?

The well off are not seeing their standard of life deteriorate, quite the contrary the rest of the population is. Your solution or at least the opinion piece you posted suggests we should make it even easier for the well off to make more money, with the wishy washy hope it will eventually find itself in the pockets of the middle and working class. If this were the case then it would have by now found itself into people’s pockets but it hasn’t given nothing really has changed in the last 15 years to make the rich poorer.

The problems across the West economically, socially and politically have been created by the wealthy and powerful, and yet you’re still arguing that by giving them more freedom it’ll make things better for everyone. It won’t it’ll continue to help them feather their own nest as we see only too well in the US under Trump. 

If you’re not for cutting welfare to the disabled then where are these welfare cuts you or the opinion piece you posted seem keen on coming from? Someone loses out when you start wanting to shrink the state and it’s usually the most vulnerable and weakest.


RE: Budget 2026 - Protheroe - 11-04-2026

Inflation makes the poorest people poorer. That's just a fact of life. It is not the wealthy causing inflation.

It wasn't the wealthy who nationalised private debt and stuck it on the governments balance sheet - it was the Labour Party. It wasn't the wealthy who spunked untold £billions on Covid relief and Energy Price relief to those who didn't need it - it was the Tory Party, backed by every other party in Parliament.

It wasn't the wealthy who invaded Iran. It wasn't the wealthy that fucked up our energy policy. It wasn't the wealthy that loaded kids with debt for getting an education. It wasn't the wealthy who persistently opposed building on any scrubby field anywhere. It wasn't the wealthy who've literally told benefit-dependent applicants that they'll never be able to rent a house from a private landlord again. It wasn't the wealthy who designed a tax code so byzantine and riddled with disincentives.

I think you're looking in the wrong direction again.

As for welfare cuts, no one capable of work ought to be signed off indefinitely. The Triple Lock has done its job and pensions should rise with inflation. Motability should be heavily restricted to those who actually need it. And if you have the means you need to cover the cost of your own social care. Not a cut for the disabled in sight.


RE: Budget 2026 - man in the corner shop - 11-04-2026

(11-04-2026, 10:01 AM)Protheroe Wrote: Inflation makes the poorest people poorer. That's just a fact of life. It is not the wealthy causing inflation.

It wasn't the wealthy who nationalised private debt and stuck it on the governments balance sheet - it was the Labour Party. It wasn't the wealthy who spunked untold £billions on Covid relief and Energy Price relief to those who didn't need it - it was the Tory Party, backed by every other party in Parliament.

It wasn't the wealthy who invaded Iran. It wasn't the wealthy that fucked up our energy policy. It wasn't the wealthy that loaded kids with debt for getting an education. It wasn't the wealthy who persistently opposed building on any scrubby field anywhere. It wasn't the wealthy who've literally told benefit-dependent applicants that they'll never be able to rent a house from a private landlord again. It wasn't the wealthy who designed a tax code so byzantine and riddled with disincentives.


I think you're looking in the wrong direction again.

As for welfare cuts, no one capable of work ought to be signed off indefinitely. The Triple Lock has done its job and pensions should rise with inflation. Motability should be heavily restricted to those who actually need it. And if you have the means you need to cover the cost of your own social care. Not a cut for the disabled in sight.

And in whose interests do you think that all of these decisions were made?

The interests of capital. Decisions by parties that represent capitalism. A different shade perhaps but parties that aren't really going to change the status quo.


RE: Budget 2026 - Protheroe - 11-04-2026

I'm a capitalist. None of those decisions are in the interests of capital.