WBAUnofficial
Letter from Shilen - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: Letter from Shilen (/showthread.php?tid=41927)

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5 6 7


RE: Letter from Shilen - CarlosCorbewrong - 06-27-2026

Im not trying to insult him.

But:

  • Replacing a rookie with a rookie
  • Unbalanced squad
  • AI led recruitment/AI generated manager
  • Sacking your president halfway through a season
  • PSR breach 
Each one of those decisions/positions appeared ‘not unreasonable’ but every one of turned out bad.

With each of those problems compounding, I’m struggling to find another phrase tbh.


RE: Letter from Shilen - Josh1873 - 06-27-2026

(06-27-2026, 10:39 AM)tHEgLASSdOORS Wrote: Sailing close to the wind is what we had to do to have a realistic chance of survival. That’s fairly obvious.

I'm not so sure. Even when cutting our salary and having to make a net profit on transfer fees, our squad was still competitive and our budget still wealthy enough to be better than relegation contenders. 

Whilst we have made some good signings, the way the squad was assembled was so unbalanced. We also relied on Dike, Maja and Bany being fit, which was a massive gamble which didn't pay off. As well as signing another known sick note in Bielik, then you consider the poor loan signings. Particularly from Villa. We were left with a CB playing RB (Campbell) and a CM's playing wide (Molumby and Price), and running Heggebø into the ground as our only fit striker for much of the season. It was a shambles to be left with such an unblanced squad. We wasted so much of what little budget we did have. 

Whilst I accept the PSR restrictions made life difficult, it shouldn't be used as an excuse. There was ample opportunity and budget to build a competitive and balanced squad. Another failing of the board.


RE: Letter from Shilen - Tom Joad 25 - 06-27-2026

(06-27-2026, 10:48 AM)Josh1873 Wrote:
(06-27-2026, 10:39 AM)tHEgLASSdOORS Wrote: Sailing close to the wind is what we had to do to have a realistic chance of survival. That’s fairly obvious.

I'm not so sure. Even when cutting our salary and having to make a net profit on transfer fees, our squad was still competitive and our budget still wealthy enough to be better than relegation contenders. 

Whilst we have made some good signings, the way the squad was assembled was so unbalanced. We also relied on Dike, Maja and Bany being fit, which was a massive gamble which didn't pay off. As well as signing another known sick note in Bielik, then you consider the poor loan signings. Particularly from Villa. We were left with a CB playing RB (Campbell) and a CM's playing wide (Molumby and Price), and running Heggebø into the ground as our only fit striker for much of the season. It was a shambles to be left with such an unblanced squad. We wasted so much of what little budget we did have. 

Whilst I accept the PSR restrictions made life difficult, it shouldn't be used as an excuse. There was ample opportunity and budget to build a competitive and balanced squad. Another failing of the board.

Isn't the letter addressing those very points?


RE: Letter from Shilen - rsbaggy2 - 06-27-2026

(06-27-2026, 10:27 AM)Tom Joad 25 Wrote: Has Tom Brady built those chimneys yet? Are Wolves in the Champions League?
I'd sooner a guy walk in to our club and prevent almost certain administration. Even at the price of a very poor season - not just directly as a fault of managerial appointments- but surely equally due to having to sell our best players? We knew this. Patel could not simply come in Manchester City style and sign x,y and z for £ zillions. We all knew exactly where we stood, PSR and financially, 12 months ago yet are now bleating over something that was almost inevitably due to happen.
The actions people want to see have actually been put in place. It is detailed in the letter. It is the consequences of the actions that we are all interested in but they won't happen today, or next week. Patel HAS talked a good game but I'd sooner that than someone come in promising golden elephants and champions league games. I'll save any criticism for when I see how things pan out from here.

This 100%.

Let's not sell our higher value players which we can only replace with seemingly lesser value/quality ones. That way we could have survived mid table maybe. Then await the massive FFP penalty that would naturally come our way and lumbered us not just for last season but carried through for several more thereafter.

Some mind numbing opinions on here. Everything should be done in relevant order. The team suffered as a consequence with the reduction in quality. Shilen has steadied the financial aspect and now we hope to build. The one blot has been the managerial appointments, especially Ramsay and Mowbray. That has been put right hopefully, whether by luck or design. We survived relegation and a totally contrived points penalty. 

This coming season we do need a significant improvement, and his missive appears to show lessons have been learned and things are in place on and off the pitch to see us to a better future.


RE: Letter from Shilen - richbaggie - 06-27-2026

(06-27-2026, 10:48 AM)Josh1873 Wrote:
(06-27-2026, 10:39 AM)tHEgLASSdOORS Wrote: Sailing close to the wind is what we had to do to have a realistic chance of survival. That’s fairly obvious.

I'm not so sure. Even when cutting our salary and having to make a net profit on transfer fees, our squad was still competitive and our budget still wealthy enough to be better than relegation contenders. 

Whilst we have made some good signings, the way the squad was assembled was so unbalanced. We also relied on Dike, Maja and Bany being fit, which was a massive gamble which didn't pay off. As well as signing another known sick note in Bielik, then you consider the poor loan signings. Particularly from Villa. We were left with a CB playing RB (Campbell) and a CM's playing wide (Molumby and Price), and running Heggebø into the ground as our only fit striker for much of the season. It was a shambles to be left with such an unblanced squad. We wasted so much of what little budget we did have. 

Whilst I accept the PSR restrictions made life difficult, it shouldn't be used as an excuse. There was ample opportunity and budget to build a competitive and balanced squad. Another failing of the board.

Of course it can be used as a reason for having a poor season. We had to sell Fellows for less than expected, had to sell Taylor when we would have preferred to keep him to name but 2. We had to make decisions that weakened us because we had no choice.

Personally, under the circumstances, I think recruitment has been OK although loan usage has been very poor on the whole. The biggest issue has been the appointments of 2 managers who didn't get the best out of what they were given. However, we looked a good side under Mozza, players written off as poor signings now lauded as good signings.

Bilkul have made mistakes, some really poor ones. 2 bad manager appointments, giving Nestor too much control, not adding experience to the board, failing to get TD in which we've desperately needed for years. I am happy that Bilkul have gone a long way in correcting these mistakes. Actions came before these latest words.


RE: Letter from Shilen - Old Fart - 06-27-2026

Having worked in marketing for around 50 years I applaud the verbose narrative describing our journey to Avalon.  It's his job to do the vision thing and he does it well. 

But I am concerned about the number of chiefs and the inevitable dilution of responsibility and accountability.   There's lots of places to hide in what looks like a typical American corporate labyrinth. 

But only a few things really matter.

Is Mozza in charge of team selection?

Do  the players being bought have his approval and are the purchases being made at his request?

I assume Mozza has been given a target to achieve this season e.g. the playoffs, and if so, will there be sufficient funds to build the team he needs to achieve that objective? 

All else is commentary


RE: Letter from Shilen - man in the corner shop - 06-27-2026

(06-27-2026, 10:53 AM)rsbaggy2 Wrote:
(06-27-2026, 10:27 AM)Tom Joad 25 Wrote: Has Tom Brady built those chimneys yet? Are Wolves in the Champions League?
I'd sooner a guy walk in to our club and prevent almost certain administration. Even at the price of a very poor season - not just directly as a fault of managerial appointments- but surely equally due to having to sell our best players? We knew this. Patel could not simply come in Manchester City style and sign x,y and z for £ zillions. We all knew exactly where we stood, PSR and financially, 12 months ago yet are now bleating over something that was almost inevitably due to happen.
The actions people want to see have actually been put in place. It is detailed in the letter. It is the consequences of the actions that we are all interested in but they won't happen today, or next week. Patel HAS talked a good game but I'd sooner that than someone come in promising golden elephants and champions league games. I'll save any criticism for when I see how things pan out from here.

This 100%.

Let's not sell our higher value players which we can only replace with seemingly lesser value/quality ones. That way we could have survived mid table maybe. Then await the massive FFP penalty that would naturally come our way and lumbered us not just for last season but carried through for several more thereafter.

Some mind numbing opinions on here. Everything should be done in relevant order. The team suffered as a consequence with the reduction in quality. Shilen has steadied the financial aspect and now we hope to build. The one blot has been the managerial appointments, especially Ramsay and Mowbray. That has been put right hopefully, whether by luck or design. We survived relegation and a totally contrived points penalty. 

This coming season we do need a significant improvement, and his missive appears to show lessons have been learned and things are in place on and off the pitch to see us to a better future.

Well said rs
Umble charlatan appointment was insane. And Ramsay too.
If I fault shilen with anything it is that he allowed Nestor to stay far too long. Nestor should have been sacked when Mowbray was sacked.
Personally, if I had been Shilen, I would have sacked Nestor for coming to me with a list that had  Mowbray on it. As this would be evidence that he hadn't a fucking clue.


RE: Letter from Shilen - SausEggBaton - 06-27-2026

I didn't get a letter! He can fug off if he thinks he's having my membership monies this season.


RE: Letter from Shilen - Derek Hardballs - 06-27-2026

(06-27-2026, 11:02 AM)richbaggie Wrote:
(06-27-2026, 10:48 AM)Josh1873 Wrote:
(06-27-2026, 10:39 AM)tHEgLASSdOORS Wrote: Sailing close to the wind is what we had to do to have a realistic chance of survival. That’s fairly obvious.

I'm not so sure. Even when cutting our salary and having to make a net profit on transfer fees, our squad was still competitive and our budget still wealthy enough to be better than relegation contenders. 

Whilst we have made some good signings, the way the squad was assembled was so unbalanced. We also relied on Dike, Maja and Bany being fit, which was a massive gamble which didn't pay off. As well as signing another known sick note in Bielik, then you consider the poor loan signings. Particularly from Villa. We were left with a CB playing RB (Campbell) and a CM's playing wide (Molumby and Price), and running Heggebø into the ground as our only fit striker for much of the season. It was a shambles to be left with such an unblanced squad. We wasted so much of what little budget we did have. 

Whilst I accept the PSR restrictions made life difficult, it shouldn't be used as an excuse. There was ample opportunity and budget to build a competitive and balanced squad. Another failing of the board.

Of course it can be used as a reason for having a poor season. We had to sell Fellows for less than expected, had to sell Taylor when we would have preferred to keep him to name but 2. We had to make decisions that weakened us because we had no choice.

Personally, under the circumstances, I think recruitment has been OK although loan usage has been very poor on the whole. The biggest issue has been the appointments of 2 managers who didn't get the best out of what they were given. However, we looked a good side under Mozza, players written off as poor signings now lauded as good signings.

Bilkul have made mistakes, some really poor ones. 2 bad manager appointments, giving Nestor too much control, not adding experience to the board, failing to get TD in which we've desperately needed for years. I am happy that Bilkul have gone a long way in correcting these mistakes. Actions came before these latest words.

It was inevitable that we would see a drop in quality and league position but we got lucky with staying up, it wasn’t by design. Mowbray, Mason and Ramsay, what possible data were we looking at to suggest they should have been appointed in such a pivotal period in our history? I argued this as far back as Mowbray’s appointment, it isn’t hindsight to ask wtf?!. Morrison did exceptionally well but he fell into the position as the last possible throw of the dice. Selling Fellows was sadly inevitable but Taylor? We brought in an injury prone Bielik (spelling) for similar money, it made no sense. 

There seems a far better plan now in place now than when Nestor was in control. So we shall see what the season brings. I’m not suggesting the challenges the owners faced, weren’t significant, but they made things so much more difficult for themselves with completely avoidable mistakes.


RE: Letter from Shilen - HawkingsHalfpint - 06-27-2026

I’m glad that he took the time to write it (more than the last lot would have done) and addressed not only the misplaced pre-season optimism, the failures leading to it and (unlike that zero-watt bulb Nestor) overcook the ‘but, but, but we had the PSR situation’. I’m not so glad that he doesn’t much address the points CC makes atop this page.

But as Rich says, they acted when they needed to, ultimately it ‘worked’, and despite not being a Baggie at heart he seems to exhibit more passion in the identity of the club than JRP ever did. In fact I’d be tempted to liken him to a JRP who does care, only it’s too early to tell. Plus, he has less ice to cut and didn’t have the luxury of inheriting a Megson. And what he did inherit he didn’t seem to value a lot, but then again perhaps he saw through the fact that we were only going to be a stepping stone for someone of the character, work-rate and aptitude of Carlos.

Overall, a nice gesture, but if he balances us better over the summer, spends big on a decent, proven goalscorer (notwithstanding tieing down Styles and Diakite, both of which are great news) oh and signs Imray - who spoke very highly of us - he’ll go up considerably in my estimation.